Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Top Latin American Prospects

Featured Replies

Well Swifty, when you're forced to do one and not the other it's easy to choose one even if you're not guaranteed anything in either. Since they don't have the money (or claim to, anyways) then I guess it's just us throwing around philosophical questions if we're talking Marlins.

 

 

And that's all my point has been, but somehow I'm an idiot and a racist.

 

Plus, maybe it's me, but I think you're guaranteed more with the draft. At least in the draft you are guaranteed (based on positioning) the right to select no worse than the best player you feel is available and he has no say in the matter, with the international world, there are far more intangiables, like the guys in pinstripes swooping in.

Well Swifty, when you're forced to do one and not the other it's easy to choose one even if you're not guaranteed anything in either. Since they don't have the money (or claim to, anyways) then I guess it's just us throwing around philosophical questions if we're talking Marlins.

And that's all my point has been, but somehow I'm an idiot and a racist.

 

Plus, maybe it's me, but I think you're guaranteed more with the draft. At least in the draft you are guaranteed (based on positioning) the right to select no worse than the best player you feel is available and he has no say in the matter, with the international world, there are far more intangiables, like the guys in pinstripes swooping in.Possibly.....but I think that though the quantity is greater in the amateur draft, the quality is far more prevailing in the international field. If you can indeed fend off the evil empire (and they specifically have yet to show any sort of significant prowess in Asia or Latin America) you have a much higher chance of nailing a Vlad or Miguelito.

Well Swifty, when you're forced to do one and not the other it's easy to choose one even if you're not guaranteed anything in either. Since they don't have the money (or claim to, anyways) then I guess it's just us throwing around philosophical questions if we're talking Marlins.

And that's all my point has been, but somehow I'm an idiot and a racist.

 

Plus, maybe it's me, but I think you're guaranteed more with the draft. At least in the draft you are guaranteed (based on positioning) the right to select no worse than the best player you feel is available and he has no say in the matter, with the international world, there are far more intangiables, like the guys in pinstripes swooping in.Possibly.....but I think that though the quantity is greater in the amateur draft, the quality is far more prevailing in the international field. If you can indeed fend off the evil empire (and they specifically have yet to show any sort of significant prowess in Asia or Latin America) you have a much higher chance of nailing a Vlad or Miguelito.

 

I agree, but not completely.

 

There isn't a high chance of nailing a Vlad or Miguel because, by my count, only 8 teams (us, the Mets, Washington, Boston, the Tigers, Angels, Twins and Mariners) can say their best player is the product of international scouting.

 

What the international field holds is a great chance to get very productive years out of a player because of the non-requirement for college or even highschool involvement, thus letting the Renteria's and Andruw Jones of the world debut before their 20th birthday.

 

What I think would make for an interesting argument is what effect a universal age of 18 would have on the international world...or, letting super-prospects from America go pro at 16 or whatever the international minimum age is.

 

I mean, I think that the Upton's, Delmon Young, etc could have hung at 16 and 17 too...

Well Swifty, when you're forced to do one and not the other it's easy to choose one even if you're not guaranteed anything in either. Since they don't have the money (or claim to, anyways) then I guess it's just us throwing around philosophical questions if we're talking Marlins.

 

 

And that's all my point has been, but somehow I'm an idiot and a racist.

 

Plus, maybe it's me, but I think you're guaranteed more with the draft. At least in the draft you are guaranteed (based on positioning) the right to select no worse than the best player you feel is available and he has no say in the matter, with the international world, there are far more intangiables, like the guys in pinstripes swooping in.

 

You don't get the point it is a whole market left untapped by the organization just because Loria is allergic to touching his wallet...it would greatly bring this team to a whole new level just by looking at 15 and 16 y/o players in Columbia, Dominican Republic, Venezuela, Korea, Japan and Australia...yes it takes more resources! but the rewards are worth it

Well, Fred Ferreira will have his work cut out for him in the future.

 

Oh, wait. No he won't. We got rid of him.

 

For all the resources given to him: a team unafraid to hand out bonuses to legitimate top prospects, camps in atleast 5 countries (Florida, Holland, DR, Venezuela, (joint) Japan), [up until 2004] full control of international scouting, and his pick of the best of the Henry/Huizenga Marlins and Expos scouting staffs.

 

And for all that, Jose Campusano has been the best player developed.

 

Damn right he deserved to be canned. You can't live off Vlad forever.

 

 

Also, to be fair to TSwift, prin, you have made it known in the past that your attention is on the latin population. It's not exactly a huge leap to assume that this thread comes as a result of your unhappiness with the latin concentration of players on the Marlins and /or its minor league affiliates. Not clarifying yourself lead to the introduction of race into the discussion.

  • Author

I don't know what you're talking about, rferry. What I have said a few times is that the Marlins need to do a better job of marketing the team to the Hispanics of South Florida because 1) they are the majority in Dade County and 2) they love baseball and would therefore be an important part of a growing fan base in South Florida. And I do think that ownership that was mostly composed of Latin investors (like Cisneros) would know how to reach into this potential fan base that the Marlins have struggled to attract thus far. Or, alternatively, If Loria & Co. hired the right people, i.e. people that are familiar with the community and how to market to them, they could attract more fans from this demographic group.

 

For me, it's about the bottom line. Signing and developing the best players and filling the stands with fans. Loria and Co. have failed at this.

Why isn't it a concern?

 

because a prospect's a prospect..latin american or not. no offense.

I can just see where one might have assumed the thinking behind your post.

 

 

Stop being an "idiot." ;)

Mike Lowell was not born in Cuba. His heritage is Cuban though.

 

Morales hasn't done anything in the majors yet.

 

Palmeiro's career has been horribly tainted by steroids.

 

Otsuka is promising, but he's a reliever.

Why isn't it a concern?

 

because a prospect's a prospect..latin american or not. no offense.

 

:banana

Why isn't it a concern?

 

because a prospect's a prospect..latin american or not. no offense.

 

:banana

It is a concern because we should be looking at getting the best prospects not only in the draft but from other countries as well.

Why isn't it a concern?

 

because a prospect's a prospect..latin american or not. no offense.

 

:banana

It is a concern because we should be looking at getting the best prospects not only in the draft but from other countries as well.

 

http://www.marlinbaseball.com/forums/index...dpost&p=1130432

 

and then for your inevitable response to that:

 

 

http://www.marlinbaseball.com/forums/index...dpost&p=1130508

http://www.marlinbaseball.com/forums/index...dpost&p=1130524

and

http://www.marlinbaseball.com/forums/index...dpost&p=1130547

Why isn't it a concern?

because a prospect's a prospect..latin american or not. no offense.Miguel Cabrera = Eric Reed?

Why isn't it a concern?

because a prospect's a prospect..latin american or not. no offense.Miguel Cabrera = Eric Reed?

 

Now you're just putting words in his mouth.

 

That's not what he meant and you know it.

Why isn't it a concern?

because a prospect's a prospect..latin american or not. no offense.Miguel Cabrera = Eric Reed?Now you're just putting words in his mouth.

 

That's not what he meant and you know it.I don't see how that's an unreasonable assumption from his statement at face value.

 

I have an underlying point. But I like being sneaky about it first. Let's let this unravel.

Why isn't it a concern?

because a prospect's a prospect..latin american or not. no offense.Miguel Cabrera = Eric Reed?Now you're just putting words in his mouth.

 

That's not what he meant and you know it.I don't see how that's an unreasonable assumption from his statement at face value.

 

I have an underlying point. But I like being sneaky about it first. Let's let this unravel.

 

It's completely unreasonable. Luis Castillo=Hank Aaron? Juan Encarnacion = Roberto Clemente? You're better than that.

 

Who cares if he's anglo, hispanic, oriental or martian. If he can hit, he can hit, and who cares how we got him? Draft, amateur free-agent, trade, waiver claim, rule 5 or some other manner I'm sure I've forgotten.

 

That's all his point is, that's all the point of this discussion is and to make it anything more is fallacious and simply serving to make this more of a misguided argument that some have already made it.

  • Author

My main argument is that we're potentially missing out on many talented players in Latin America and that will have negative consequences for the team's farm system for several years to come. We can potentially overcome this weakness by being exceptionally good at identifying, drafting, and signing players in the US, but that is harder to do. It's better to have a well-rounded scouting system that can net us the best American and Latin American prospects. (We should also be involved in Korea and Japan, although the rules with dealing with those players is significantly different than the rules with dealing with Latin American players.) Doing this is good baseball.

My main argument is that we're potentially missing out on many talented players in Latin America and that will have negative consequences for the team's farm system for several years to come. We can potentially overcome this weakness by being exceptionally good at identifying, drafting, and signing players in the US, but that is harder to do. It's better to have a well-rounded scouting system that can net us the best American and Latin American prospects. (We should also be involved in Korea and Japan, although the rules with dealing with those players is significantly different than the rules with dealing with Latin American players.) Doing this is good baseball.

 

 

They both cost money. Doing one well costs a lot of money, doing both of them well costs a lot more money.

 

You're not forced to sign international players. You are forced to draft players.

 

The Marlins have chosen not to do both, but so far I can't complain with their domestic scouting. I may take issue with their draft strategy, but not the identification of talent.

  • Author

My main argument is that we're potentially missing out on many talented players in Latin America and that will have negative consequences for the team's farm system for several years to come. We can potentially overcome this weakness by being exceptionally good at identifying, drafting, and signing players in the US, but that is harder to do. It's better to have a well-rounded scouting system that can net us the best American and Latin American prospects. (We should also be involved in Korea and Japan, although the rules with dealing with those players is significantly different than the rules with dealing with Latin American players.) Doing this is good baseball.

 

 

They both cost money. Doing one well costs a lot of money, doing both of them well costs a lot more money.

 

You're not forced to sign international players. You are forced to draft players.

 

The Marlins have chosen not to do both, but so far I can't complain with their domestic scouting. I may take issue with their draft strategy, but not the identification of talent.

 

We've done a decent job through the draft, but we're missing out on some great players in Latin America. It costs money, but it is money well-spent. We should do it.

This could become a major problem.

 

Especially when 27.4% of major leaguers and 45.1% of minor leaguers are foreign born. Cutting off from a group that makes up a fourth of the major leagues doesn't make sense at all.

It's completely unreasonable. Luis Castillo=Hank Aaron? Juan Encarnacion = Roberto Clemente? You're better than that.

 

They could have been. If the teams made an attempt to develop their skills. If the team went out of their way to focus on these players and develop them into similar major leaguers as the ones you mentioned. Isn't that, right, prin, by placing attention on a certain individual (segment of the population) you can develop (market) them into something special (strong fan base), no matter if they lack the power (disposable income), speed (transportation), batting eye (interest) of certain other individuals (markets)?

 

 

My main argument is that we're potentially missing out on many talented players in Latin America and that will have negative consequences for the team's farm system for several years to come. We can potentially overcome this weakness by being exceptionally good at identifying, drafting, and signing players in the US, but that is harder to do. It's better to have a well-rounded scouting system that can net us the best American and Latin American prospects. (We should also be involved in Korea and Japan, although the rules with dealing with those players is significantly different than the rules with dealing with Latin American players.) Doing this is good baseball.

 

This runs counter to the models of success for te Braves and Athletics, which have reduced their focus to specific areas or levels of players. It would be nice to do everything perfectly, but it's really a question of doing everything poorly or a few things well.

 

 

It costs money, but it is money well-spent. We should do it.

 

You're not the one that's writing checks. You're not the one that has to reconcile the investment. How do you know the expense is worth it? And just who are you to make that decision?

  • Author

I've never seen you criticize anything this organization does, rferry. You just defend them to the death. I'm not saying that their decision is way off, but I am saying that they could take a better approach. This thread was supposed to create a genuine debate about our approach to developing players. No one has the right answer, including you.

 

Oh, and who are you to say the expense is not worth it? You ask who am I to make the decision, but we can say that about anything this organization does. Just because we're not in a position to make a decision on this doesn't mean we can't criticize what they do or don't do or have good debates about how we should go about doing things. The point of this forum is to discuss the Marlins and, at times, to question the wiseness of some of their decisions. Nothing wrong with that. There is no reason to suppress debate.

You haven't been around here during draft time, have you?

 

I believe the team has the full right to decide what they consider the right course of action. I may disagree. I may have my concerns. I may even have my pet issues. But I'm not going to pretend I know more than they do. I'm not going to make ridiculous claims such as the expense is worth it despite not being aware of the costs or assume the club is amortizing 50% of the entire franchise purchase or they're pocketing any profit, etc. Unlike some I realize and accept my ignorance on certain matters.

 

That said, there's a very good reason to reduce, not expand, your focus of available talent beyond the supposed evidence of the Marlins' decision assumed as a result of the poorly acquired international talent in recent years.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.