Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Do you want Girardi back next year?

Featured Replies

Fire him. I don't think he deserves much of the credit for our team's success. I don't want to keep a sub-par manager because it will avoid a PR nightmare for our team (and our owner). Everyone already thinks we are a mickey mouse organization and we have el diablo as our owner. The only way to change perceptions is to win, and I think we'll be fine (in fact...better actually) if we had a more qualified manager.

Yes, Joe Girardi should be the manager next year. Jeffrey Loria needs to swallow his pride and make his peace with Girardi for the sake of the club. The players respect Girardi, he has done a great job coaching the rookies and he has done a fine job coming up with winning lineups and managing the starting rotation. Bring back Girardi, Loria.

Here's the way I look at it. Most may not understand the point I'm trying to make, even less will agree with me, but this is, to me, what defines this argument:

 

At the start of the season, I felt (and still feel) that we were a substantially better team than the media was giving us credit for. I thought that the talent was there for a 70-75 win season, that would still give us around 90 losses, but I thought those that were predicting over 100 were way off base. My predictions, of course, factored in zero when considering coaching/management and focused solely on the players' talent.

 

With that in mind, I'm not "overwhelmed" with the team's success as we're still on pace for about 80 wins, or roughly in the area I had us initially forcast.

 

HOWEVER, that does not mean I expected this, far from it, and after seeing the way the season started out, I felt as if I had extremely overrated the readiness of much of the team. That is where this becomes very important in talent/management. Girardi still got these guys to play, and play hard despite looking overwhelmed and confused. Most teams can and have quit after stretches like our April and part of May, but guess what, since then, we've been the best (that's right, the best in terms of W/L) team in the National League. A lot of that has to do with the maturation of players, sure, but Girardi also commanded the respect enough of these guys to the point that they went out and played hard for him and for themselves.

 

That's where this whole thing comes into play with Girardi; he's a hell of a motivator and the players love the guy, and they respect him.

 

Letting go of Girardi would send a bad message to the players, other prospective players and prospective coaches. You don't take a good thing and send it packing, even if there is a difference of opinion. Loria hand-picked the guy and negotiated a multi-year contract, and in every sense of the word, Girardi has lived up to his contract.

 

It's embarassing enough to be a fan of this team (there, I said it) with the way it's been mismanaged into baseball purgatory, and this is the last thing this organization needs. Any argument to the contrary is simply based on the assumption that people don't have emotions and would completely ignore the active efforts to undermine progress made by this organization since 2003. Since that champagne has dried, Jeffrey Loria has done nothing but shovel dirt on the grave of baseball in South Florida, and the scalding orange seats today were visible proof. Firing Girardi wouldn't just be a mistake, it'd be downright sabotage.

Here's the way I look at it. Most may not understand the point I'm trying to make, even less will agree with me, but this is, to me, what defines this argument:

 

At the start of the season, I felt (and still feel) that we were a substantially better team than the media was giving us credit for. I thought that the talent was there for a 70-75 win season, that would still give us around 90 losses, but I thought those that were predicting over 100 were way off base. My predictions, of course, factored in zero when considering coaching/management and focused solely on the players' talent.

 

With that in mind, I'm not "overwhelmed" with the team's success as we're still on pace for about 80 wins, or roughly in the area I had us initially forcast.

 

HOWEVER, that does not mean I expected this, far from it, and after seeing the way the season started out, I felt as if I had extremely overrated the readiness of much of the team. That is where this becomes very important in talent/management. Girardi still got these guys to play, and play hard despite looking overwhelmed and confused. Most teams can and have quit after stretches like our April and part of May, but guess what, since then, we've been the best (that's right, the best in terms of W/L) team in the National League. A lot of that has to do with the maturation of players, sure, but Girardi also commanded the respect enough of these guys to the point that they went out and played hard for him and for themselves.

 

That's where this whole thing comes into play with Girardi; he's a hell of a motivator and the players love the guy, and they respect him.

 

Letting go of Girardi would send a bad message to the players, other prospective players and prospective coaches. You don't take a good thing and send it packing, even if there is a difference of opinion. Loria hand-picked the guy and negotiated a multi-year contract, and in every sense of the word, Girardi has lived up to his contract.

 

It's embarassing enough to be a fan of this team (there, I said it) with the way it's been mismanaged into baseball purgatory, and this is the last thing this organization needs. Any argument to the contrary is simply based on the assumption that people don't have emotions and would completely ignore the active efforts to undermine progress made by this organization since 2003. Since that champagne has dried, Jeffrey Loria has done nothing but shovel dirt on the grave of baseball in South Florida, and the scalding orange seats today were visible proof. Firing Girardi wouldn't just be a mistake, it'd be downright sabotage.

 

 

Minus the last paragraph, I agree with everything you wrote TSwift. Loria has had to deal with an array of people working against his interests since he became the owner of the Marlins that have contributed to the situation the Marlins find themselves in. But that is for another thread. Loria needs to use his business sense and baseball sense and realize that while the Beinfest and the FO did a great job putting together this team, Girardi has done a great job managing this team and deserves to be the Marlins manager for the remainder of his contract if not longer.

Here's the way I look at it. Most may not understand the point I'm trying to make, even less will agree with me, but this is, to me, what defines this argument:

 

At the start of the season, I felt (and still feel) that we were a substantially better team than the media was giving us credit for. I thought that the talent was there for a 70-75 win season, that would still give us around 90 losses, but I thought those that were predicting over 100 were way off base. My predictions, of course, factored in zero when considering coaching/management and focused solely on the players' talent.

 

With that in mind, I'm not "overwhelmed" with the team's success as we're still on pace for about 80 wins, or roughly in the area I had us initially forcast.

 

HOWEVER, that does not mean I expected this, far from it, and after seeing the way the season started out, I felt as if I had extremely overrated the readiness of much of the team. That is where this becomes very important in talent/management. Girardi still got these guys to play, and play hard despite looking overwhelmed and confused. Most teams can and have quit after stretches like our April and part of May, but guess what, since then, we've been the best (that's right, the best in terms of W/L) team in the National League. A lot of that has to do with the maturation of players, sure, but Girardi also commanded the respect enough of these guys to the point that they went out and played hard for him and for themselves.

 

That's where this whole thing comes into play with Girardi; he's a hell of a motivator and the players love the guy, and they respect him.

 

Letting go of Girardi would send a bad message to the players, other prospective players and prospective coaches. You don't take a good thing and send it packing, even if there is a difference of opinion. Loria hand-picked the guy and negotiated a multi-year contract, and in every sense of the word, Girardi has lived up to his contract.

 

It's embarassing enough to be a fan of this team (there, I said it) with the way it's been mismanaged into baseball purgatory, and this is the last thing this organization needs. Any argument to the contrary is simply based on the assumption that people don't have emotions and would completely ignore the active efforts to undermine progress made by this organization since 2003. Since that champagne has dried, Jeffrey Loria has done nothing but shovel dirt on the grave of baseball in South Florida, and the scalding orange seats today were visible proof. Firing Girardi wouldn't just be a mistake, it'd be downright sabotage.

 

 

:thumbup I say keep him.

It's embarassing enough to be a fan of this team (there, I said it) with the way it's been mismanaged into baseball purgatory, and this is the last thing this organization needs. Any argument to the contrary is simply based on the assumption that people don't have emotions and would completely ignore the active efforts to undermine progress made by this organization since 2003. Since that champagne has dried, Jeffrey Loria has done nothing but shovel dirt on the grave of baseball in South Florida, and the scalding orange seats today were visible proof. Firing Girardi wouldn't just be a mistake, it'd be downright sabotage.

 

When I visit opposing stadiums and talk about Loria and the second firesale I say nothing but positives to fans of other teams. But that's me.

 

Yeah, it's just you. :whistle

 

No, seriously, I look at the first fire-sale as ending with the day we traded Livan, and I view the second one as beginning with the Lee trade and ending this past offseason.

 

Loria had a damn dynasty handed to him with the '03 team and he screwed that up...that rotation would've put the Atlanta run to shame (Beckett, Burnett, Penny, Willis, Pavano) and the lineup was so damn deadly it was crazy. He could have picked one or the other and just built around it for the next decade and have been fine, instead he decided he could afford neither (buh bye Pudge, Lee, Pavano, Penny).

 

Anyway, it's not the time to play the looking back game as it's not relevant to the Girardi discussion and I'd hate to get off topic on that, but seriously, Loria does not deserve to have a single positive thing about him said, ever.

he started molding this team, it's only for the better that he continues next year what he started this year. It may also result in a winning season since he knows his pieces better than any new manager would. Keep Girardi, he's what this young ball club needed, and all we fans hoped for.

Keep Joe of course. The guy has brought this team together to play together and learn through their mistakes. This team is so fun to watch and with a guy like Giradi that can relate to players you just gotta love it.

 

I would love to see Giradi come back next year.

I put I really don't care.

 

 

My problem has always been with how the situation is being handled. Everything has been handled so unprofessionally it makes me sick.

 

 

Even though I voted to keep him, this too is what makes me so damn mad. The organization is looking worse than ever, and is getting trashed. Does this affect the ability to sign FA's and a respectable manager for next year in the case that Girardi is gone ? Do any FA's want to come to a team with an owner that causes this much drama ? And I'm not talking multi-million dollar type guys that are FA's but the tyoes that have contributed so much this year to the team's good character like Wes Helms, Brian Moehler and Matt Herges. Many times its those kind of guys are just as valuable to winning as those guys that start everyday.

Fire Him......

 

Am not saying he's a bad Coach but he's really lucky that the rookies have developed alot faster than we thought..... All the pitchers and most hitters have over acheived and are putting up incredible numbers...

 

I just notice alot of the times in close games and key situations it looks like Joe G. doesn't make the right moves......

 

Call me an idiot if ya want but thats my 2 cents...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.