August 27, 200620 yr See poll. Please vote. Sorry for another Joe topic but I was just wondering where everyone stands on this Joe thing.
August 27, 200620 yr Yes I do. I think that despite some oversights and mishaps in management throughout the season, Joe has done an excellent job getting this team to play the way they have been playing. I don't care what name you pull out there, but there is not one first time manager that could have done a better job getting this team of rookies playing as well as they have like Joe Girardi has. Besides, Nick Saban is a pain in the @$$ as well and you would never dream of firing him, would you?
August 27, 200620 yr Author Joe needs to come back. He has done an amazing job with the boys. Nobody knows what would have happened with a different manager. So what happens if we fire him and the next manager comes in and totally stinks?... Just keep him Loria. Maybe we can send Loria a 1 way plane ticket to Alaska.
August 27, 200620 yr Absolutely Yeah. It might be a smart idea to keep a guy who is in contention for Manager of the Year.
August 27, 200620 yr Author Joe needs to come back. He has done an amazing job with the boys. Nobody knows what would have happened with a different manager. So what happens if we fire him and the next manager comes in and totally stinks?... Just keep him Loria. Maybe we can send Loria a 1 way plane ticket to Alaska. What if another manager helped the team be over .500 right now and in greater position to claim the wild card? Then it would be a good move but I think if it aint broken dont fix it.
August 27, 200620 yr I put I really don't care. My problem has always been with how the situation is being handled. Everything has been handled so unprofessionally it makes me sick.
August 27, 200620 yr Joe needs to come back. He has done an amazing job with the boys. Nobody knows what would have happened with a different manager. So what happens if we fire him and the next manager comes in and totally stinks?... Just keep him Loria. Maybe we can send Loria a 1 way plane ticket to Alaska. What if another manager helped the team be over .500 right now and in greater position to claim the wild card? If? If my aunt had **** she would be my uncle.
August 27, 200620 yr Yes. People already don't take this team seriously, getting rid of him would simply be the final nail in the coffin as far as credibility goes. No one would want to play here, no one would want to stay here and no one would ever take this team seriously if the manager of the year is let go. Plus, he hasn't exactly done a bad job with this team... :whistle
August 27, 200620 yr yes, i do want him back. but i think hes getting to much credit for this whole turnaround. the players are a big part of this you know.
August 27, 200620 yr I say keep him. No one else could have done what he has done for this team. He has that Yankees winning spirit in him and is truely a leader.
August 27, 200620 yr Not at the cost of beinfest of course It really depends on if we could get Ozzie. But I think he will be back. Really I dont care, it is the talent around that matters.
August 28, 200620 yr I want him back but if he does get fired and Loria hires Gonalez I really wont be to disgusted.
August 28, 200620 yr Keep him, but not because he is the key piece that makes this team what it is or that they couldn't have done it without him. Just keep him because it works. If you subtract the first month and half of the season and look at the team that has developed, you see that there is very little (CF) that needs any work at all.
August 28, 200620 yr Whoever thinks that Girardi should be fired is by far the stupidest people I've ever been associated with. Do you guys really understand how bad this team was supposed to be? And yes who knows someone could come in and be over .500 but who in their right minds actually believe that? I love how everyone was expecting this team to be horrible and then when we actually play well people want him fired. Seriously for some reason you guys have a personal vendetta against Girardi which I really dont understand all this guy does is win. Well if the Marlins need to fire Girardi after one year then the Tigers definitely need to fire Leyland and the White Sox shouldve fired Guillen because who knows maybe another guy wouldve gotten them over 100 wins last season. I just really cant believe it.
August 28, 200620 yr Whoever thinks that Girardi should be fired is by far the stupidest people I've ever been associated with. Do you guys really understand how bad this team was supposed to be? And yes who knows someone could come in and be over .500 but who in their right minds actually believe that? I love how everyone was expecting this team to be horrible and then when we actually play well people want him fired. Seriously for some reason you guys have a personal vendetta against Girardi which I really dont understand all this guy does is win. Well if the Marlins need to fire Girardi after one year then the Tigers definitely need to fire Leyland and the White Sox shouldve fired Guillen because who knows maybe another guy wouldve gotten them over 100 wins last season. I just really cant believe it. Not the biggest fan of Joe, but I want him back. I just don't agree with this mentality that Joe deserves all the credit for the teams success.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.