Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Yet another CF idea

Featured Replies

I just had to laugh at this Wilkerson/Church comparison, little of which is accurate if you believe ESPN and MLB stats/splits are correct.

 

How are they different, in relevant ways? How about BA, OBP, OPS, SLG, Hr/AB, SO, SB, BB, when adjusted for equal at bats they're aren't even close. How about Fielding percentage? Be my guest.

 

I realize it's convenient to make stuff up because no one (hopefully) will check them, these two shouldn't even be mentioned in the same sentence.

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...cator=wilkerson

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...&statSet1=2

 

Wilkerson ESPN page : http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=4612

 

Church ESPN page : http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=6078

 

 

 

Both ESPN pages are set to main "profile" page. Check splits, more splits, , you guys know how to do it.

 

BTW, Wilkerson's time in centerfield last season? One at bat.

First of all, no need for the condescending tone(I realize I probably butchered the word)

 

Second of all, not everyone needs stats to decide if they are similar players. From what I have seen of the two, they are very similar at the plate, on the basepaths, and in the outfield.

 

Career lines in the majors:

Wilkerson- .252/.358/.448/.806

Church- .269/.347/.461/.808

 

By golly, they have almost the exact numbers! LIKE OMG!!!!11... The best part is that I didnt even have to look up their numbers to know they were similar. Maybe I'm just that damn good. I'd like to thank the numbers for providing me some good backup. Big shout out to the numbers 2, 4 and 9. 9 played a big role in this piece.

 

I also like the fact that Wilkerson has... ya know... been in the league and actually put these numbers up in a little more than a sample size. And this is coming from someone who likes Ryan Church too.

 

BTW, why would Wilkerson play CF for the Rangers when that Gary Mathews guy was there? Come on.

 

No further questions, your honor.

I just had to laugh at this Wilkerson/Church comparison, little of which is accurate if you believe ESPN and MLB stats/splits are correct.

 

How are they different, in relevant ways? How about BA, OBP, OPS, SLG, Hr/AB, SO, SB, BB, when adjusted for equal at bats they're aren't even close. How about Fielding percentage? Be my guest.

 

I realize it's convenient to make stuff up because no one (hopefully) will check them, these two shouldn't even be mentioned in the same sentence.

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...cator=wilkerson

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...&statSet1=2

 

Wilkerson ESPN page : http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=4612

 

Church ESPN page : http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=6078

 

 

 

Both ESPN pages are set to main "profile" page. Check splits, more splits, , you guys know how to do it.

 

BTW, Wilkerson's time in centerfield last season? One at bat.

First of all, no need for the condescending tone(I realize I probably butchered the word)

 

Second of all, not everyone needs stats to decide if they are similar players. From what I have seen of the two, they are very similar at the plate, on the basepaths, and in the outfield.

 

Career lines in the majors:

Wilkerson- .252/.358/.448/.806

Church- .269/.347/.461/.808

 

By golly, they have almost the exact numbers! LIKE OMG!!!!11... The best part is that I didnt even have to look up their numbers to know they were similar. Maybe I'm just that damn good. I'd like to thank the numbers for providing me some good backup. Big shout out to the numbers 2, 4 and 9. 9 played a big role in this piece.

 

I also like the fact that Wilkerson has... ya know... been in the league and actually put these numbers up in a little more than a sample size. And this is coming from someone who likes Ryan Church too.

 

BTW, why would Wilkerson play CF for the Rangers when that Gary Mathews guy was there? Come on.

 

No further questions, your honor.

 

But are you weighted them for at bats? If you do you get a completely different POV. You can't legitimately compare two players, one with a couple of years of playing time to someone with five times as many.

 

Ignore the facts at your own peril.

 

You compare the last two years. Anything else is invalid.

 

As for Matthews, last season was his break-out year, he took over CF in 2006 because Wilkerson could no longer play there, had a great season, left and put Texas in the position to go get a new CFer because they knew Wilkerson could no long play there.

 

Perhaps you have a better reason for the Rangers acquiring Lofton?

 

And BTW, I'm not taking anything away from Wilkerson's career.I'm comparing the last two seasons of two players, because it's alot more relevant than whatone of them did in 2001.

As for Matthews, last season was his break-out year, he took over CF in 2006 because Wilkerson could no longer play there, had a great season, left and put Texas in the position to go get a new CFer because they knew Wilkerson could no long play there.

 

That's flawed logic. Does every team who signs a free agent with an incumbent know that the incumbent "can no longer play there."?

 

Does every player buried on a depth chart have no ability? Hell no (a champion cause of your own, I believe).

 

Is it slightly possible that Texas this offseason, like every offseason before, is misguidedly spending their money on glitzy free agents or marginal upgrades?

 

I'm done.

As for Matthews, last season was his break-out year, he took over CF in 2006 because Wilkerson could no longer play there, had a great season, left and put Texas in the position to go get a new CFer because they knew Wilkerson could no long play there.

 

That's flawed logic. Does every team who signs a free agent with an incumbent know that the incumbent "can no longer play there."?

 

Does every player buried on a depth chart have no ability? Hell no (a champion cause of your own, I believe).

 

Is it slightly possible that Texas this offseason, like every offseason before, is misguidedly spending their money on glitzy free agents or marginal upgrades?

 

I'm done.

 

The only flawed logic is your own. Not surprising and nothing new. The numbers over the last two seasons speak for themselves. It's your choice to ignore them. Offensively and defensively going forward, Church will be the better player, which is all that matters. What someone did in 2001 is irrelevant at this point when Wilkerson was brought up in as the subject of this thread in the context of 2007.

You say Church will be the better player but can not even keep his starting job in washington.

 

Also if you guys look even deeper into the stats you will realize that he struggled once being moved into the leadoff role.

Also He played through a nagging wrist and shoulder injury all last season and should be 100% come this season

 

Those things do have an effect on your performance.

I just had to laugh at this Wilkerson/Church comparison, little of which is accurate if you believe ESPN and MLB stats/splits are correct.

 

How are they different, in relevant ways? How about BA, OBP, OPS, SLG, Hr/AB, SO, SB, BB, when adjusted for equal at bats they're aren't even close. How about Fielding percentage? Be my guest.

 

I realize it's convenient to make stuff up because no one (hopefully) will check them, these two shouldn't even be mentioned in the same sentence.

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...cator=wilkerson

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...&statSet1=2

 

Wilkerson ESPN page : http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=4612

 

Church ESPN page : http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=6078

 

 

 

Both ESPN pages are set to main "profile" page. Check splits, more splits, , you guys know how to do it.

 

BTW, Wilkerson's time in centerfield last season? One at bat.

First of all, no need for the condescending tone(I realize I probably butchered the word)

 

Second of all, not everyone needs stats to decide if they are similar players. From what I have seen of the two, they are very similar at the plate, on the basepaths, and in the outfield.

 

Career lines in the majors:

Wilkerson- .252/.358/.448/.806

Church- .269/.347/.461/.808

 

By golly, they have almost the exact numbers! LIKE OMG!!!!11... The best part is that I didnt even have to look up their numbers to know they were similar. Maybe I'm just that damn good. I'd like to thank the numbers for providing me some good backup. Big shout out to the numbers 2, 4 and 9. 9 played a big role in this piece.

 

I also like the fact that Wilkerson has... ya know... been in the league and actually put these numbers up in a little more than a sample size. And this is coming from someone who likes Ryan Church too.

 

BTW, why would Wilkerson play CF for the Rangers when that Gary Mathews guy was there? Come on.

 

No further questions, your honor.

 

But are you weighted them for at bats? If you do you get a completely different POV. You can't legitimately compare two players, one with a couple of years of playing time to someone with five times as many.

 

Ignore the facts at your own peril.

 

You compare the last two years. Anything else is invalid.

 

As for Matthews, last season was his break-out year, he took over CF in 2006 because Wilkerson could no longer play there, had a great season, left and put Texas in the position to go get a new CFer because they knew Wilkerson could no long play there.

 

Perhaps you have a better reason for the Rangers acquiring Lofton?

 

And BTW, I'm not taking anything away from Wilkerson's career.I'm comparing the last two seasons of two players, because it's alot more relevant than whatone of them did in 2001.

I dont need to see facts. I have seen them play with my 2 eyes. They are very VERY similar players. It just so happens that their career numbers in the majors are pretty close too.

 

Numbers can only tell you so much. Google up some video of the two. They are pretty darn close to watch.

They seem basically similar to me, although Wilk has a solid history of injury. And I dont understand the stats over ABs argument as Wilk has put up about equal #s over a much longer period.

I just had to laugh at this Wilkerson/Church comparison, little of which is accurate if you believe ESPN and MLB stats/splits are correct.

 

How are they different, in relevant ways? How about BA, OBP, OPS, SLG, Hr/AB, SO, SB, BB, when adjusted for equal at bats they're aren't even close. How about Fielding percentage? Be my guest.

 

I realize it's convenient to make stuff up because no one (hopefully) will check them, these two shouldn't even be mentioned in the same sentence.

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...cator=wilkerson

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...&statSet1=2

 

Wilkerson ESPN page : http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=4612

 

Church ESPN page : http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=6078

 

 

 

Both ESPN pages are set to main "profile" page. Check splits, more splits, , you guys know how to do it.

 

BTW, Wilkerson's time in centerfield last season? One at bat.

First of all, no need for the condescending tone(I realize I probably butchered the word)

 

Second of all, not everyone needs stats to decide if they are similar players. From what I have seen of the two, they are very similar at the plate, on the basepaths, and in the outfield.

 

Career lines in the majors:

Wilkerson- .252/.358/.448/.806

Church- .269/.347/.461/.808

 

By golly, they have almost the exact numbers! LIKE OMG!!!!11... The best part is that I didnt even have to look up their numbers to know they were similar. Maybe I'm just that damn good. I'd like to thank the numbers for providing me some good backup. Big shout out to the numbers 2, 4 and 9. 9 played a big role in this piece.

 

I also like the fact that Wilkerson has... ya know... been in the league and actually put these numbers up in a little more than a sample size. And this is coming from someone who likes Ryan Church too.

 

BTW, why would Wilkerson play CF for the Rangers when that Gary Mathews guy was there? Come on.

 

No further questions, your honor.

 

But are you weighted them for at bats? If you do you get a completely different POV. You can't legitimately compare two players, one with a couple of years of playing time to someone with five times as many.

 

Ignore the facts at your own peril.

 

You compare the last two years. Anything else is invalid.

 

As for Matthews, last season was his break-out year, he took over CF in 2006 because Wilkerson could no longer play there, had a great season, left and put Texas in the position to go get a new CFer because they knew Wilkerson could no long play there.

 

Perhaps you have a better reason for the Rangers acquiring Lofton?

 

And BTW, I'm not taking anything away from Wilkerson's career.I'm comparing the last two seasons of two players, because it's alot more relevant than whatone of them did in 2001.

I dont need to see facts. I have seen them play with my 2 eyes. They are very VERY similar players. It just so happens that their career numbers in the majors are pretty close too.

 

Numbers can only tell you so much. Google up some video of the two. They are pretty darn close to watch.

 

 

They seem basically similar to me, although Wilk has a solid history of injury. And I dont understand the stats over ABs argument as Wilk has put up about equal #s over a much longer period.

 

I agree!

 

DBL UNITE! :lol

As for Matthews, last season was his break-out year, he took over CF in 2006 because Wilkerson could no longer play there, had a great season, left and put Texas in the position to go get a new CFer because they knew Wilkerson could no long play there.

 

That's flawed logic. Does every team who signs a free agent with an incumbent know that the incumbent "can no longer play there."?

 

Does every player buried on a depth chart have no ability? Hell no (a champion cause of your own, I believe).

 

Is it slightly possible that Texas this offseason, like every offseason before, is misguidedly spending their money on glitzy free agents or marginal upgrades?

 

I'm done.

 

The only flawed logic is your own. Not surprising and nothing new. The numbers over the last two seasons speak for themselves. It's your choice to ignore them. Offensively and defensively going forward, Church will be the better player, which is all that matters. What someone did in 2001 is irrelevant at this point when Wilkerson was brought up in as the subject of this thread in the context of 2007.

That's not all that matters. Going forward, Carl Crawford will be the better player so I guess we can cross Church off our lists. I've been pushing for extraordinary talent to come in as our new CFer, but there's plenty of middle-tier guys like Church and Wilkerson that would help us win a championship. It's the mid to low-end guys who are only marginally better than our current options that I object to. What matters is if the player we bring in can help the team take the next step. Which player is better is not.

 

So let us hear your argument on why Wilkerson is not a good player or will not be one with the Marlins.

Bob Dutton in the Kansas City Star thinks unless the Royals can trade off Brown or Sanders that either Costa or Gathright will lose their roster spot because of the crunch to find room for all their new acquisitions.

 

I'm not posting the link because going directly there usually (but not always) won't let you see the story without signing up.

 

Here's the story, without a link for the reason stated above:

 

THE ROYALS

Buddy breaks down his team

After a flurry of winter acquisitions, manager Bell analyzes how the roster of his 2007 club is taking shape.

By BOB DUTTON

The Kansas City Star

 

Buddy Bell was already well on the way to recovery from throat surgery even before the Royals overhauled their pitching staff. Now, he can?t wait for February to start piecing together a new roster.

 

?What we?ve done,? he said, ?creates a lot more competition ? and we haven?t had a lot of that here before. We might not be finished, either.?

 

The Royals added five pitchers and deleted four others in a frenetic rush over the last week that remains ongoing. They now seem unlikely to land free-agent Miguel Batista, who is close to signing a three-year deal with Seattle, but they continue to shop for a veteran starter. The possibilities include ex-Royal Jeff Suppan.

 

?We want to make sure that we give our players the best opportunity to win,? Moore said, ?and give our fans something they can be proud of. That?s where your sense of urgency comes from.?

 

So the countdown is on: It?s just 66 days until pitchers and catchers report for duty at the club?s spring home in Surprise, Ariz. The first full-squad workout is Feb. 22.

 

?I know the fans are excited,? designated hitter Mike Sweeney said, ?and that?s great. You need that. But the players are also excited, and that?s a tribute to what Dayton Moore and the Glass family have done this winter.?

 

Projected roster

Position players (13 or 14)

 

Catcher: Jason LaRue/John Buck

 

First base: Ryan Shealy

 

Second base: Mark Grudzielanek

 

Shortstop: Angel Berroa

 

Third base: Alex Gordon

 

Left field: Emil Brown/Reggie Sanders

 

Center field: David DeJesus

 

Right field: Mark Teahen

 

Designated hitter: Mike Sweeney

 

Reserves: Utilityman Esteban German, outfielder Shane Costa or outfielder Joey Gathright and probably one other utility player.

Rotation (5 plus 1)

 

RHP Gil Meche

 

LHP Odalis Perez

 

RHP Luke Hudson

 

Two of the following plus one as long reliever: LHP Jorge De La Rosa, RHP Zack Greinke, RHP Brian Bannister and RHP Todd Wellemeyer.

Bullpen (5 or 6)

 

RHP Octavio Dotel

 

LHP John Bale

 

LHP Jimmy Gobble

 

RHP Ken Ray

 

One or two of the following: RHP Joel Peralta, RHP Joe Nelson, RHP Joakim Soria, LHP Andrew Sisco, RHP Ryan Braun and LHP Neal Musser.

 

the Rotation

 

It starts, of course, with right-hander Gil Meche, the new $55 million man. The Royals ponied up for that five-year deal because they see Meche, 28, developing into a reliable staff leader.

 

?Everybody in our organization thinks he has a great arm,? Bell said. ?He was also, basically, the youngest guy coming out (in the free-agent market).?

 

Veteran lefty Odalis Perez projects as the No. 2 starter. He was just 6-8 last season with a 6.20 ERA while splitting time with the Royals and Dodgers. But he?s in the final year of his contract and figures to be motivated.

 

Right-hander Luke Hudson would have to pitch his way out of the rotation after blossoming last year into a dependable performer.

 

The Royals remain hopeful of adding another veteran before spring training. Failing that, they will select their final two starters from a youthful group that includes Jorge De La Rosa, Zack Greinke and just-acquired Brian Bannister.

 

Greinke made three relief appearances last season after joining the club in September but will enter spring as a candidate for the rotation.

 

?That doesn?t mean he can?t make our club while pitching out of the bullpen,? Bell said, ?because we feel pretty confident that Zack?s development can be done at the big-league level.?

 

the Bullpen

 

The signing of veteran Octavio Dotel fills the gaping need for a proven closer and allows the Royals to shift other pitchers into roles that better fit their capabilities.

 

?He?s done it before,? Bell said, ?and he has the stuff to do it.?

 

Lefty John Bale seems a lock after signing a two-year deal. The Royals outbid the Yankees for Bale, who spent the last three seasons in Japan after bouncing among three big-league teams during 1999-2003.

 

Lefty Jimmy Gobble and right-hander Ken Ray also figure to claim jobs. The Royals claimed Ray off waivers in October from Atlanta. He got off to a great start last year before fading badly after the All-Star break.

 

Rule 5 draft pick Joakim Soria will also get a long look. He pitched a perfect game Saturday for Obregon in the Mexican Pacific League but projects as a middle reliever.

 

?Heck, he might be a candidate for the setup role,? Bell said, ?because he can throw strikes. That?s something we just couldn?t do enough last year.?

 

That leaves just one or two openings for a returning group that includes Joel Peralta, Joe Nelson, Andrew Sisco, Ryan Braun and Arizona Fall League standout Neal Musser.

 

?We?ve got a lot of guys who can pitch in the setup role,? Bell said. ?You?ve got to look at Nelson. You?ve got to look at Gobble. You?ve got to look at Bale.

 

?With Sisco, we?d probably prefer not to pitch him as closely to the end (of games), but Peralta is in the mix.?

 

the Infield

 

Moore remains unwilling, at this point, to commit to Alex Gordon as the club?s starting third baseman despite a terrific first professional season that resulted in his selection as Baseball America?s minor-league player of the year.

 

?We?re still not ready to say that Gordon is on our team,? Moore said. ?We want him to continue to force our hand.?

 

Even so, it would be a stunning development if Gordon isn?t the starting third baseman when the Royals open the season April 2 against Boston at Kauffman Stadium.

 

Putting Gordon at third would force Mark Teahen to shift to the outfield ? something he has already been told to prepare for as he undergoes rehabilitation following surgery on his right shoulder.

 

The rest of the infield appears set with Ryan Shealy at first base, Gold Glove winner Mark Grudzielanek at second base and, for better or worse, Angel Berroa at shortstop.

 

?Angel has to play better, period,? Bell said, ?but first, he?s got to play better defensively.?

 

Sweeney will be the full-time DH, and Esteban German is a lock for a utility job.

 

the Outfield

 

Bell said David DeJesus will return to center field on a full-time basis and continue to bat leadoff. Everything else is in flux.

 

Teahen seems certain to play one of the corner spots unless something happens that forces his return to third base. Which corner will depend on what happens between now and opening day.

 

The Royals are trying to trade either Reggie Sanders or Emil Brown. If they fail, and both stay, a platoon seems likely in left field with Teahen getting regular duty in right. Sanders can play right, but the Royals seem to want to keep Brown in left and prefer not to shift Teahen around.

 

The backup candidates are Shane Costa and Joey Gathright. Both are left-handed hitters, and the Royals figure to keep only one if Sanders and Brown are both around. If so, Gathright probably gets the edge because of his speed and his ability to play center field.

 

Catcher

 

The acquisition of veteran catcher Jason LaRue last month from Cincinnati effectively puts John Buck on notice and probably means a pink slip for Paul Phillips, who is out of options.

 

LaRue and Buck will battle next spring for the starting job.

 

?I would hope that somebody emerges as the No. 1 guy,? Bell said. ?I mean, that?s what I would prefer. I like LaRue, and I like Buck. It could work out differently, but I?m hoping it is one way or the other.?

 

Bell also dismissed the suggestion the two are similar players.

 

?Makeup is a little different,? he said. ?I think that might be the biggest difference whether John wins it or Jason wins it.?

David DeJesus will return to center field next season and bat leadoff for the Royals, manager Buddy Bell said.

 

Not a surprise. DeJesus was pushed to left when Joey Gathright arrived last season, but if Gathright is on next year's squad, he'll be a reserve.

Source: Kansas City Star

 

If we can grab him cheap, Gathright is an otion we liked last season...just not for Scott Olsen at the time :)

One of the most interesting transformations in baseball this season is KC and with the veteran pitchers they acquired, it allows their pitching prospects to not be rushed through the system and may make it more advantageous for them to trade a reserve player like Costa or Gathright for a prospect (or prospects depending on how highly ranked they are) knowing they can spend a year or two in the minors learning to pitch.

We can put this thread to bed and allow Marlins2003 to save face due to the report that the Rangers are going to tender Wilk a contract.

 

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dw...e.1b2ceed6.html

 

I think it's great he gets to stay in the American League where he can DH and play a little left field. He was just the wrong guy at the wrong time for the Marlins.

 

He was never going to take a 70-80% cut in pay to play here and he can't play CF anymore so it was just people arguing for argument sake. Church may or may not be the answer and certainly the fact that not a single report links the Fish to acquiring the player speaks volumes about the team's interest in him, but financially and in some other ways he fit the Marlins profile (older but still youngish, some MLB experience and making close to the minimum) better than a guy coming off shoulder surgery making $4 million in '06. And I guess we'll never solve the riddle of how to compare one player to the other. I see it as comparing similar years of playing time as valid, others don't. To me it's like in algebra when you have to simplify both sides of the equation, and you accomplish that finding something both sides share, equal years or equal ABs, something they both have in common.

 

It appears neither player winds up here so it's all academic. NBD.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.