December 28, 200619 yr There really isn't alot still available on this left on the web. There appears not to be an actual written column by Rosenthal, rather this sprung up from a short piece he did during a Fox broadcast MLB game. The video was up on the foxsports.com website for a while but is now gone. My sense in reading the stuff still available on the web is that Ken Rosenthal was the sole source, and all others references were borne from him. As for Granderson and Verlander, the genesis of that pairing appears to be a rumor that the Marlins asked for those two when moving/auctioning off Beckett/Lowell. I can't find anything from a credible source (other than KR and I'll leave to each of you to decide for yourself if you consider him credible) that directly reports the Marlins affirmatively attempting to trade Willis for the pair. By the time Rosenthal reported this rumor both Detroit players had blossomed into bonafide major leaguers who were well on their way to successful ML seasons, as opposed to late fall/early winter 2005 (Beckett/Lowell) when the they were for all intents super-prospects with just a small amount of ML time. I suspect Rosenthal reached back to conjure up this rumor theorizing that if they wanted the pair the winter previous they'd still want them. And probably it had as much to do with everyone else having a Willis trade rumor du jour and Kenny needed to have one of his own (because by then both Detroit players had proven their worth and were virtually untradeable).
December 28, 200619 yr Glad that Beckett trade with Detroit didn't go through. Hanley&Sanchez >>>>>>>> Granderson and Verlander. I really like Verlander too.
December 28, 200619 yr ^ I thought about that too. I think a lot of people (like me at first) invisioned if we had done that trade we'd have granderson and verlander, but forgot that hanley and anibal wouldn't be here. I think I'm happy w/ the bosox trade, I think it's better than the tigers. hanley is better than granderson, verlander is a better than anibal. So we went with the trade that offers us the best position player, not the better pitcher. We already had (or were going to have) a ton of great pitchers, so we didn't NEED a good pitcher as much as we NEED a good position player, in this case the 2006 NL ROY.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.