Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Iran and Pakistan

Featured Replies

I wonder how most of the Persian Jews feel about how the CIA got Mossadeq out of power and ended anything like secular democracy in Iran.

 

If you think that Mossadeq was going to install democracy you don't know anything about his ties to the movers and shakers of the eventual theocratic government that took over 12 years after his death.

I wonder how most of the Persian Jews feel about how the CIA got Mossadeq out of power and ended anything like secular democracy in Iran.

 

If you think that Mossadeq was going to install democracy you don't know anything about his ties to the movers and shakers of the eventual theocratic government that took over 12 years after his death.

Mossadeq was a legitimate official in the government of a foreign independent nation. We helped get rid of him and built an autocrat, the Shah, and we both know damn well it had nothing to do with protecting religious freedom in Iran. Mossadeq enforced the Oil Nationalization act, and the CIA did what it did for the same reason we still prop up the Saudi royal family. What we did to Mossadeq had much more to do with the subsequent revolution than Mossadeq itself, and we will never have moral high ground when dealing with Iran.

I wonder how most of the Persian Jews feel about how the CIA got Mossadeq out of power and ended anything like secular democracy in Iran.

 

If you think that Mossadeq was going to install democracy you don't know anything about his ties to the movers and shakers of the eventual theocratic government that took over 12 years after his death.

Mossadeq was a legitimate official in the government of a foreign independent nation. We helped get rid of him and built an autocrat, the Shah, and we both know damn well it had nothing to do with protecting religious freedom in Iran. Mossadeq enforced the Oil Nationalization act, and the CIA did what it did for the same reason we still prop up the Saudi royal family. What we did to Mossadeq had much more to do with the subsequent revolution than Mossadeq itself, and we will never have moral high ground when dealing with Iran.

 

You must think Chavez is legitimate then. There is no doubt that the US and the UK helped the coup that removed Mossadeq was largely in response to the nationalization (read: theft) of the oil industry, but that does not change the fact that Mossadeq gave himself additional power and suspended Parliment. He also put Ayatollah Kashani in a position of power and tied himself to the Soviet-backed Tudeh party.

 

Dictators are bad, but if there is going to be a dictator anyhow, we are much better off with a pro-US one.

I wonder how most of the Persian Jews feel about how the CIA got Mossadeq out of power and ended anything like secular democracy in Iran.

 

If you think that Mossadeq was going to install democracy you don't know anything about his ties to the movers and shakers of the eventual theocratic government that took over 12 years after his death.

Mossadeq was a legitimate official in the government of a foreign independent nation. We helped get rid of him and built an autocrat, the Shah, and we both know damn well it had nothing to do with protecting religious freedom in Iran. Mossadeq enforced the Oil Nationalization act, and the CIA did what it did for the same reason we still prop up the Saudi royal family. What we did to Mossadeq had much more to do with the subsequent revolution than Mossadeq itself, and we will never have moral high ground when dealing with Iran.

 

You must think Chavez is legitimate then. There is no doubt that the US and the UK helped the coup that removed Mossadeq was largely in response to the nationalization (read: theft) of the oil industry, but that does not change the fact that Mossadeq gave himself additional power and suspended Parliment. He also put Ayatollah Kashani in a position of power and tied himself to the Soviet-backed Tudeh party.

 

Dictators are bad, but if there is going to be a dictator anyhow, we are much better off with a pro-US one.

I'm no fan of Chavez, but (unlike Castro) he has actually won elections (that included more than one candidate). So yes, he is legitimate. Just because I vehemently disagree with everything he has done since being elected makes no difference. Like him or not, we have no business deposing him. Is it really that strange a notion that we don't have the right to topple governments just because we don't like them? If Iran, Venezuela, or anyone else wants to elect socialists into power that is their right. They will end up much more screwed over than anyone else.

 

Nationalization may be theft (I agree that it is), but if that's what the Iranians wanted (and it was, despite the problems that followed), our government has no business interfereing with it. The aftermath of doing so has adversely affected our national interests in the region for almost 30 years now. I don't suggest that there are not times when toppling a foreign government is justified, but I think doing it for the sake of a private interest (such as a wealthy oil company) is flat out wrong. If a huge international company wants to do business in a country utilize its resources for profit then they should have to abide by the laws of that country, no matter how fair or unfair.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.