Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Iran and Pakistan

Featured Replies

Pakistan:

-Military dictatorship

-Has at least 50 nuclear weapons

-Unstable political situation

-Military keeps the order

-Signed a truce with Al Qaeda and the Taliban

-Will not allow US to go after terrorists hiding in Waziristan (Afghani/Pakistani border province)

-Pakistani ISI frequently worked with the Taliban before the 2001 US invasion

-General population is very anti-US

 

Iran:

-Semi-democracy that is controlled by a group of mullahs

-Does not currently have nuclear weapons

-Actively seeking nuclear technology

-Political situation relatively stable

-Worked with US against Al Qaeda in 2001 and 2002

-In the past, Iranian funded groups like Hezbollah have directly attacked American and Western interests

-Has the ability to launch massive retaliatory terrorist strikes throughout the Middle East and possibly the continental US if attacked

-Has generally cooperated in the 'war on terror'

-General population is very pro-Western

-Country's population is mostly under 30

-Younger generation opposes the rule of the mullahs

-Radical President Ahmedinejad has little real power

-Ahmedinejad's party suffered a defeat in recent midterm elections

 

As I have made clear in the past, there is no reason to launch strikes against suspected Iranian nuclear facilities. Certainly the costs are really high. A major worldwide economic disruption is invitable from an Iranian blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, along with possible attacks against oil platforms throughout the Middle East and Persian Gulf. Then there is the likelihood that Iran will send Hezbollah to attack targets in this country, by possibly activating sleeper cells that we are presently unaware of. They could also get operatives into this country through normal means if they don't have a cell in place. Even if they fail in attacking the US, they could go after Europe or, more likely, Israel.

That is disgusting. Pakistan is an awful place but the fact that you're trying to paint Iran as a much rosier place than it is, renders you the credibility of Jimmy the Greek at a black cultural event.

We're still giving aid to Pakistan. We may disagree with the policy that their government put in place. That doesn't make us enemies or a threat to our nation.

 

If they were to collapse (which would be extremely difficult as the U.S. and other countries would likely get involved), then there would be a need for this thread.

  • Author

I think that it is important to recognize that Iran is not as big of a threat as it is currently being painted. It's only a major threat if we provoke them through bombing.

 

Pakistan is a potential threat, considering that there is a radical Islamic presence already in that country, and they already have nukes. Pervez Musharraf is the only thing keeping that country from going radical, however brutal that might be for the common people.

Frontline on PBS recently aired a piece entitled Showdown With Iran. It explores the severity of the threat, and how U.S. and Iranian actions have each served to fuel the conflict. It's an hour long, but it's worth watching. Here's the link:

 

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/showdown/view/

How about responses that don't take personal shots at people with differing opinions?

 

 

As for Iran as a threat, Ahmedinejad is controlled by the Mullahs who are really entrenched in powers. I wouldn't characterize Iran too much as a democracy. I don't think they would attack us, but if they truely want nukes, it seems to be a affirmtive act of provocation in some ways. That makes them an enormous threat to Israel which makes them a threat to us, depending on how you see it.

 

Both countries seem to be going in the opposite direction. One country is lead by a shaky ally with question marks but with an undercurrent of possible radical leadership rising(Pakistan). The other country is lead by a person who is certainly acting like a threat if not a legit threat, but has an undercurrent of possible moderate movements.

 

I don't think we should engage in immediate war preperation with Iran which is just plain stupid but also not treat them with kid gloves. I also think Pakistan is a much bigger problem than we are willing to admit.

Iran is the greater threat to the US because Ahmedinejad actually intends to use nuclear weapons if he gets them.

If Benazir Bhutto is not arrested and elections are held, the two situations are not even close.

 

Pakistan's problems are internal, they aren't going to attack the US.

Pakistan:

-Military dictatorship

-Has at least 50 nuclear weapons

-Unstable political situation

-Military keeps the order

-Signed a truce with Al Qaeda and the Taliban

-Will not allow US to go after terrorists hiding in Waziristan (Afghani/Pakistani border province)

-Pakistani ISI frequently worked with the Taliban before the 2001 US invasion

-General population is very anti-US

 

Iran:

-Semi-democracy that is controlled by a group of mullahs

-Does not currently have nuclear weapons

-Actively seeking nuclear technology

-Political situation relatively stable

-Worked with US against Al Qaeda in 2001 and 2002

-In the past, Iranian funded groups like Hezbollah have directly attacked American and Western interests

-Has the ability to launch massive retaliatory terrorist strikes throughout the Middle East and possibly the continental US if attacked

-Has generally cooperated in the 'war on terror'

-General population is very pro-Western

-Country's population is mostly under 30

-Younger generation opposes the rule of the mullahs

-Radical President Ahmedinejad has little real power

-Ahmedinejad's party suffered a defeat in recent midterm elections

 

As I have made clear in the past, there is no reason to launch strikes against suspected Iranian nuclear facilities. Certainly the costs are really high. A major worldwide economic disruption is invitable from an Iranian blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, along with possible attacks against oil platforms throughout the Middle East and Persian Gulf. Then there is the likelihood that Iran will send Hezbollah to attack targets in this country, by possibly activating sleeper cells that we are presently unaware of. They could also get operatives into this country through normal means if they don't have a cell in place. Even if they fail in attacking the US, they could go after Europe or, more likely, Israel.

Just how paranoid are you?

Pakistan is an enormous problem. However, they aren't a threat to the U.S. in their current state.

 

If Pakistani radical opposition takes power, then it will become a serious problem, starting with the fact that they may start some sort of conflict with India.

I took pakistan as I believe the problems with Iraq can be bridged for the time being but for pakistan we need to see where they go with their instability because being certain of the full situation.

 

Of course both can be dangerous and no we should not be going to war over there at all and should gtfo of the region fully.

  • Author

Iran is the greater threat to the US because Ahmedinejad actually intends to use nuclear weapons if he gets them.

And what proof do you have of that? Even Kim Jong Il isn't that stupid.

How about responses that don't take personal shots at people with differing opinions?

 

 

As for Iran as a threat, Ahmedinejad is controlled by the Mullahs who are really entrenched in powers. I wouldn't characterize Iran too much as a democracy. I don't think they would attack us, but if they truely want nukes, it seems to be a affirmtive act of provocation in some ways. That makes them an enormous threat to Israel which makes them a threat to us, depending on how you see it.

 

Both countries seem to be going in the opposite direction. One country is lead by a shaky ally with question marks but with an undercurrent of possible radical leadership rising(Pakistan). The other country is lead by a person who is certainly acting like a threat if not a legit threat, but has an undercurrent of possible moderate movements.

 

I don't think we should engage in immediate war preperation with Iran which is just plain stupid but also not treat them with kid gloves. I also think Pakistan is a much bigger problem than we are willing to admit.

Because it's hard to take it as a serious discussion when it's so obviously skewed. I'm sorry, I was under the ridiculous assumption that this thread was taken from Future's left leaning prespective.

How about responses that don't take personal shots at people with differing opinions?

 

 

As for Iran as a threat, Ahmedinejad is controlled by the Mullahs who are really entrenched in powers. I wouldn't characterize Iran too much as a democracy. I don't think they would attack us, but if they truely want nukes, it seems to be a affirmtive act of provocation in some ways. That makes them an enormous threat to Israel which makes them a threat to us, depending on how you see it.

 

Both countries seem to be going in the opposite direction. One country is lead by a shaky ally with question marks but with an undercurrent of possible radical leadership rising(Pakistan). The other country is lead by a person who is certainly acting like a threat if not a legit threat, but has an undercurrent of possible moderate movements.

 

I don't think we should engage in immediate war preperation with Iran which is just plain stupid but also not treat them with kid gloves. I also think Pakistan is a much bigger problem than we are willing to admit.

Because it's hard to take it as a serious discussion when it's so obviously skewed. I'm sorry, I was under the ridiculous assumption that this thread was taken from Future's left leaning prespective.

 

 

Instead of merely attacking the individual that added the thread for discussion of the masses of the website why not simply add facts to balance out the statements made? Not opinions?

  • Author

Instead of merely attacking the individual that added the thread for discussion of the masses of the website why not simply add facts to balance out the statements made? Not opinions?

That would be nice, but I don't expect it.

 

For those who think I'm paranoid about Iran having cells inside this country, it has already happened. Check out this article below for information on a Charlotte, NC cell of Hezbollah that was discovered several years ago.

 

Charlotte Hezbollah Cell

Iran is the greater threat to the US because Ahmedinejad actually intends to use nuclear weapons if he gets them.

And what proof do you have of that? Even Kim Jong Il isn't that stupid.

 

It seemed pretty clear why Kim Jong Il wanted the nukes. It gave his nation more bargaining power. With Ahmadinejad its extremely unclear why they want the nukes. He himself has stated whether directly or indirectly that he intends to use the nuclear weapons on Israel.

Elements within Iran have aided Hezbollah with weapons and expertise and have some sway with them but for the most part Hezbollah is autonomous and thier main objective is to resist Israeli interests not American ones, it is distinctly Lebanese in nature and doesn't brook any of its power with any other nation even at times Lebanon. Al-Quds is another story.

 

I attended a lecture by Gary Sick (he was on theNational Security Council for Ford, Carter, and Reagan and expert on Iran par excellence) and he said historically speaking when a nation declares that they want nukes they usually develop them in 5-7 years, Iran declared they wanted nukes in 1985, its been 22 years and still haven't been able to develop nukes. Iran is still very far away from being able to develop and deliver nuclear weapons and even if they had them why would they use them immediately? What will they gain strategically aside from massive nuclear relations from Israel and the U.S? I think Iran's quest for nukes is spurned on by being strategically surrounded on all sides by the U.S., Israel, and distrustful Arab nations with having no effective conventional forces to deter an attempted invasion. Aside from being large and having alot of people they have no means of deterrence.

 

Pakistan I think is the bigger potential threat by default as they actually have nuclear weapons, have a strong radical undercurrent sweeping the countryside and seeping into the major cities, and face civil unrest as well as grumblings in the military against Musharaf.

  • Author

If Benazir Bhutto is not arrested and elections are held, the two situations are not even close.

 

 

hold that thought...

Seriously...

 

there's also the statement by Musharraf that he is placing security above democracy in his country.

How about responses that don't take personal shots at people with differing opinions?

 

 

As for Iran as a threat, Ahmedinejad is controlled by the Mullahs who are really entrenched in powers. I wouldn't characterize Iran too much as a democracy. I don't think they would attack us, but if they truely want nukes, it seems to be a affirmtive act of provocation in some ways. That makes them an enormous threat to Israel which makes them a threat to us, depending on how you see it.

 

Both countries seem to be going in the opposite direction. One country is lead by a shaky ally with question marks but with an undercurrent of possible radical leadership rising(Pakistan). The other country is lead by a person who is certainly acting like a threat if not a legit threat, but has an undercurrent of possible moderate movements.

 

I don't think we should engage in immediate war preperation with Iran which is just plain stupid but also not treat them with kid gloves. I also think Pakistan is a much bigger problem than we are willing to admit.

 

And yet the Iranian opposition isn't that much better. There's an Argentinian bench warrant issued for Hashemi Rafsanjani's arrest should he ever step foot in Argentina.

Instead of merely attacking the individual that added the thread for discussion of the masses of the website why not simply add facts to balance out the statements made? Not opinions?

That would be nice, but I don't expect it.

 

For those who think I'm paranoid about Iran having cells inside this country, it has already happened. Check out this article below for information on a Charlotte, NC cell of Hezbollah that was discovered several years ago.

 

Charlotte Hezbollah Cell

 

And let's not forget the bombings of the Israeli Embassy in Argentina in 1992 and AMIA building (Buenos Aires's JCC) in 1994. As I said in a previous post, there's a warrant for former president and current opposition leader Hashemi Rafsanjani's arrest in connection to the two attacks.

Iran is the greater threat to the US because Ahmedinejad actually intends to use nuclear weapons if he gets them.

#1 Ahmadinejad doesn't have that power within his government.

#2 In the 28 years since the Islamic Revolution, the only war Iran has participated in was when it was invaded by Saddam Hussein's Iraq (whom we were backing if I recall). Overall their representative government has shown itself to be very pragmatic and realistic and very much not fanatical.

#3 Ahmadinejad is an elected leader who is accountable to his people, not a dictator as many neocons like to imply.

#4 Iran has not invaded or attacked another country in the last 100 years.

#5 Propaganda is propaganda. He talks big against the US because Iran remembers Mossadeq & the Shah. He talks big against Israel because they are hated throughout the Middle East. But the reality is that the 30,000+ Jews in Iran haven't been thrown into concentration camps. There is even a seat in the Iranian Parlaiment reserved for a representative of the Jewish community in Iran.

 

Unless the US attacks Iran there will be no war. The Iranians are intelligent enough to realize that an attack against the US (or nuclear armed Israel) would be suicide, and leaders don't become suicide bombers.

#5 Propaganda is propaganda. He talks big against the US because Iran remembers Mossadeq & the Shah. He talks big against Israel because they are hated throughout the Middle East. But the reality is that the 30,000+ Jews in Iran haven't been thrown into concentration camps. There is even a seat in the Iranian Parlaiment reserved for a representative of the Jewish community in Iran.

 

People don't need to be thrown into concentration camps to be debased, as using the threat of the state to control the populace through terror is threat enough.

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsourc...m/iranjews.html

Also, there are restrictions on Jewish education: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persian_Jews#...ucation_in_Iran

Furthermore, the Iranian government forces Jews to break the Sabbath (see link above).

 

Oh, and one more thing: just because the Iranian parliament has a Jewish representative doesn't mean he isn't a token or pawn. Just look at the Judenraten of the ghettoes. The were, de jure, representatives of the Jews inside the ghettoes, but, de facto, pawns of the Nazis. MP Maurice Motamed has been called a pawn by a lot of people.

 

Oh, and another thing: an acquaintance of mine who is from LA tells me that a large majority of Persian Jews there hate the Iranian government and were the main force behind a divest-from-Iran movement at UCLA.

#5 Propaganda is propaganda. He talks big against the US because Iran remembers Mossadeq & the Shah. He talks big against Israel because they are hated throughout the Middle East. But the reality is that the 30,000+ Jews in Iran haven't been thrown into concentration camps. There is even a seat in the Iranian Parlaiment reserved for a representative of the Jewish community in Iran.

 

People don't need to be thrown into concentration camps to be debased, as using the threat of the state to control the populace through terror is threat enough.

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsourc...m/iranjews.html

Also, there are restrictions on Jewish education: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persian_Jews#...ucation_in_Iran

Furthermore, the Iranian government forces Jews to break the Sabbath (see link above).

 

Oh, and one more thing: just because the Iranian parliament has a Jewish representative doesn't mean he isn't a token or pawn. Just look at the Judenraten of the ghettoes. The were, de jure, representatives of the Jews inside the ghettoes, but, de facto, pawns of the Nazis. MP Maurice Motamed has been called a pawn by a lot of people.

 

Oh, and another thing: an acquaintance of mine who is from LA tells me that a large majority of Persian Jews there hate the Iranian government and were the main force behind a divest-from-Iran movement at UCLA.

I'm sure most Persian Jews oppose the current Iranian government, and that there is plenty of bigotry from that government against them. But there is a difference between being a bigot and being a (suicidal) fanatic. Only the latter would ever seriously engage in open conflict with Israel or the US, and the Iranians have never shown themselves to be such. I'm not saying they are good and nice people, but I am saying that you need to be realistic about how far they will go.

 

I wonder how most of the Persian Jews feel about how the CIA got Mossadeq out of power and ended anything like secular democracy in Iran.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.