Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Shaq vs. Ilgauskas

Featured Replies

Why Not?

 

 

Because the whole conversation was about Big Z being better than Shaq so far this season, not in his entire career.

 

 

Would it help if i put this seasons stats

Shaq

 

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

PHX 22 222 8.80.5930.0000 .589 2.7 5.8 8.5 1.8 0.4 1.3 1.95 3.50 16.1

 

Z

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

CLE 24 24 26.1 0.526 0.462 0.845 2.4 4.9 7.3 1.60 .4 1.1 1.79 2.30 14.7

 

SHaq has a better FG%, more total rebounds, more assists per game, more blocks per game and more PPG

 

Shaq in 2008 still > Soft Z

But he's not better than Shaq this year.

 

Would it help if i put this seasons stats

Shaq

 

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

PHX 22 222 8.80.5930.0000 .589 2.7 5.8 8.5 1.8 0.4 1.3 1.95 3.50 16.1

 

Z

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

CLE 24 24 26.1 0.526 0.462 0.845 2.4 4.9 7.3 1.60 .4 1.1 1.79 2.30 14.7

 

SHaq has a better FG%, more total rebounds, more assists per game, more blocks per game and more PPG

 

Shaq in 2008 still > Soft Z

 

 

Read posts 201-269, then you will both understand.

But he's not better than Shaq this year.

 

Would it help if i put this seasons stats

Shaq

 

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

PHX 22 222 8.80.5930.0000 .589 2.7 5.8 8.5 1.8 0.4 1.3 1.95 3.50 16.1

 

Z

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

CLE 24 24 26.1 0.526 0.462 0.845 2.4 4.9 7.3 1.60 .4 1.1 1.79 2.30 14.7

 

SHaq has a better FG%, more total rebounds, more assists per game, more blocks per game and more PPG

 

Shaq in 2008 still > Soft Z

 

 

Read posts 201-269, then you will both understand.

 

All i see is that you say Z is better because he is "more atletic" and can shot 3's when he has less then 20 3's made.

Ok then if Z is a better shoter, is taller, and more athletic why does he have less PPG, RBP, BPG and and a lower FG% then Shaq?

But he's not better than Shaq this year.

 

Would it help if i put this seasons stats

Shaq

 

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

PHX 22 222 8.80.5930.0000 .589 2.7 5.8 8.5 1.8 0.4 1.3 1.95 3.50 16.1

 

Z

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

CLE 24 24 26.1 0.526 0.462 0.845 2.4 4.9 7.3 1.60 .4 1.1 1.79 2.30 14.7

 

SHaq has a better FG%, more total rebounds, more assists per game, more blocks per game and more PPG

 

Shaq in 2008 still > Soft Z

 

 

Read posts 201-269, then you will both understand.

 

All i see is that you say Z is better because he is "more atletic" and can shot 3's when he has less then 20 3's made.

Ok then if Z is a better shoter, is taller, and more athletic why does he have less PPG, RBP, BPG and and a lower FG% then Shaq?

 

 

I explained all of that. Read the whole thing.

But he's not better than Shaq this year.

 

Would it help if i put this seasons stats

Shaq

 

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

PHX 22 222 8.80.5930.0000 .589 2.7 5.8 8.5 1.8 0.4 1.3 1.95 3.50 16.1

 

Z

Team G GS MPG FG% 3p% FT% OFF DEF RPG APG SPG BPG TO PF PPG

CLE 24 24 26.1 0.526 0.462 0.845 2.4 4.9 7.3 1.60 .4 1.1 1.79 2.30 14.7

 

SHaq has a better FG%, more total rebounds, more assists per game, more blocks per game and more PPG

 

Shaq in 2008 still > Soft Z

 

 

Read posts 201-269, then you will both understand.

 

All i see is that you say Z is better because he is "more atletic" and can shot 3's when he has less then 20 3's made.

Ok then if Z is a better shoter, is taller, and more athletic why does he have less PPG, RBP, BPG and and a lower FG% then Shaq?

 

 

I explained all of that. Read the whole thing.

 

bro stop telling people to read stuff. Stats show Shaq has always been, and CURRENTLY is better than Big Z. Admit that in your opinion he is better, but thats not a fact according to stats.

bro stop telling people to read stuff. Stats show Shaq has always been, and CURRENTLY is better than Big Z. Admit that in your opinion he is better, but thats not a fact according to stats.

 

Why, do you have a problem with reading? Instead of looking for an explanation, you would rather just say incorrect information?

 

Excuse me for not wanting to repeat myself. :rolleyes:

 

According to the unbalanced, biased stats, yes, Shaq is better. :thumbup

bro stop telling people to read stuff. Stats show Shaq has always been, and CURRENTLY is better than Big Z. Admit that in your opinion he is better, but thats not a fact according to stats.

 

Why, do you have a problem with reading? Instead of looking for an explanation, you would rather just say incorrect information?

 

Excuse me for not wanting to repeat myself. :rolleyes:

 

According to the unbalanced, biased stats, yes, Shaq is better. :thumbup

 

 

VICTORY :happydance

bro stop telling people to read stuff. Stats show Shaq has always been, and CURRENTLY is better than Big Z. Admit that in your opinion he is better, but thats not a fact according to stats.

 

Why, do you have a problem with reading? Instead of looking for an explanation, you would rather just say incorrect information?

 

Excuse me for not wanting to repeat myself. :rolleyes:

 

According to the unbalanced, biased stats, yes, Shaq is better. :thumbup

 

 

VICTORY :notworthy

 

 

How is that "victory"?

  • Author

bro stop telling people to read stuff. Stats show Shaq has always been, and CURRENTLY is better than Big Z. Admit that in your opinion he is better, but thats not a fact according to stats.

 

Why, do you have a problem with reading? Instead of looking for an explanation, you would rather just say incorrect information?

 

Excuse me for not wanting to repeat myself. :rolleyes:

 

According to the unbalanced, biased stats, yes, Shaq is better. :thumbup

 

:lol

Dude, stop it. Shaq is better than Soft Z.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

 

Just tell me in one big summarization why do you think Z is better then Shaq or do you mean Z is better than Shaq THIS SEASON?

Dude, stop it. Shaq is better than Soft Z.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

 

Just tell me in one big summarization why do you think Z is better then Shaq or do you mean Z is better than Shaq THIS SEASON?

 

 

One word: Versatility.

 

That's why he has been better so far this season.

  • Author

Dude, stop it. Shaq is better than Soft Z.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

 

Just tell me in one big summarization why do you think Z is better then Shaq or do you mean Z is better than Shaq THIS SEASON?

 

 

One word: Versatility.

 

That's why he has been better so far this season.

 

 

Y'know...if you keep on posting on this thread...you might actually be right one time. Aside from his whopping 6 three pointers, what is so versatile about Ilgauskus?

Dude, stop it. Shaq is better than Soft Z.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

 

Just tell me in one big summarization why do you think Z is better then Shaq or do you mean Z is better than Shaq THIS SEASON?

 

 

One word: Versatility.

 

That's why he has been better so far this season.

 

 

Y'know...if you keep on posting on this thread...you might actually be right one time. Aside from his whopping 6 three pointers, what is so versatile about Ilgauskus?

 

 

Don't forget, we are comparing his versatility with Shaq's, so it's not that hard.

 

But, Dim is right, this is a Heat thread, so I'm not arguing this anymore.

  • Author

Don't forget, we are comparing his versatility with Shaq's, so it's not that hard.

 

But, Dim is right, this is a Heat thread, so I'm not arguing this anymore.

 

How is Shaq not versatile? Puts up points, gets rebounds...both he & Ilgauskus (to be fair) are amongst the best big men, in terms of passing the ball. Shaq is also a good shot blocker...I don't get it. He's not exactly a dumb, fat man making a living off purely strength. The guy has skill.

Dude, stop it. Shaq is better than Soft Z.

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

 

Just tell me in one big summarization why do you think Z is better then Shaq or do you mean Z is better than Shaq THIS SEASON?

 

 

One word: Versatility.

 

That's why he has been better so far this season.

 

 

What? That's why you think he's better than Shaq? Who gives a F*ck about versatility. If i wanted a big man on my team, i want him to be a force down low. A beast on the boards. Not a 7+ foot soft ass center thats "versatile".

Im gonna preface this by saying I really don't like the NBA to begin with and have no allegiances to any teams, but I do have a great understanding of game theory and have been around basketball coaches my whole life, so here's my 2 cents:

 

Ilgauskas vs Shaq isn't an easy debate, but at this point... I think most GMs would take Ilgauskas over Shaq, sans those needing to sell tickets.

 

You need to consider the following when comparing the players right now:

 

A) Shaq was brought in primarily to be a rebounder. PHX routinely got killed on the boards and in the inside, so by having Amare and Shaq, they hoped to fix that. Whereas, like the Pro-Zydrunas poster mentioned, the numbers are more spread out in Cleveland. Ilgauskas doesn't have to be that big rebounder, such is life with LeBron on your team.

 

B) The offenses that are being run. If you run a more finesse offense, you need a shooting big man that can not only take it to the post to open up for other shooters, but can create his own shot from mid-range if everything else is covered. Again, having LeBron James (who cannot be defended) makes this hard for Ilgauskas, but he CAN create a shot better than Shaq can. You know Shaq's going to have to go into the paint to create... Zydrunas can step back... and with 6 three pointers, that IS something that needs to be accounted for... Basically, Shaq can really only run one kind of offense, Ilgauskas can be run in multiple styles

 

C) Free Throw Shooting - This is probably undeservedly important, but Hack-A-Shaq is a big deal... and late in games... an 85% shooter is a huge deal compared to Shaq.

 

D) Age - I'd rather have that guy that's 3 years younger, with limited (to no, I haven't followed him his whole career, so I don't know) injury history and better fitness.

 

E) Contract - Again, another one I shouldn't probably count but... Shaq's contract is egregious and he's not worth that contract right now.

 

3 years ago, this is Shaq, no contest... right now... Ilgauskas gets the nod over Shaq

How is Shaq not versatile? Puts up points, gets rebounds...both he & Ilgauskus (to be fair) are amongst the best big men, in terms of passing the ball. Shaq is also a good shot blocker...I don't get it. He's not exactly a dumb, fat man making a living off purely strength. The guy has skill.

 

 

Actually, he is. If it weren't for all of his muscle and bulk, he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is. He can't shoot, he can't jump, and he can't run. He is not an athletic person.

  • Author

How is Shaq not versatile? Puts up points, gets rebounds...both he & Ilgauskus (to be fair) are amongst the best big men, in terms of passing the ball. Shaq is also a good shot blocker...I don't get it. He's not exactly a dumb, fat man making a living off purely strength. The guy has skill.

 

 

Actually, he is. If it weren't for all of his muscle and bulk, he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is. He can't shoot, he can't jump, and he can't run. He is not an athletic person.

 

 

Obviously.

If it wasn't for the fact that Ilgauskus is 7'3" he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is, either.

 

It really all depends what you'd rather have...a post presence or a guy that can go to the perimeter and knock down an occasional shot.

I'd rather have a post presence from my center. Come playoff time, toughness becomes important.

How is Shaq not versatile? Puts up points, gets rebounds...both he & Ilgauskus (to be fair) are amongst the best big men, in terms of passing the ball. Shaq is also a good shot blocker...I don't get it. He's not exactly a dumb, fat man making a living off purely strength. The guy has skill.

 

 

Actually, he is. If it weren't for all of his muscle and bulk, he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is. He can't shoot, he can't jump, and he can't run. He is not an athletic person.

 

 

Obviously.

If it wasn't for the fact that Ilgauskus is 7'3" he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is, either.

 

It really all depends what you'd rather have...a post presence or a guy that can go to the perimeter and knock down an occasional shot.

I'd rather have a post presence from my center. Come playoff time, toughness becomes important.

 

 

Wrong. If Ilgauskas were only six feet, he would still be in the NBA because of his ability to shoot the ball.

 

I think you're missing the concept though. Shaq is a great post presence. Ilgauskas is also a good post presence, just not as good as Shaq. Ilgauskas is one of the best, if not the best all-around shooter for a center. Shaq probably is the worst all-around shooter out of all of the centers in the NBA.

 

Shaq's post presence is slightly better than Big Z's, but Big Z's shooting ability is far greater than Shaq's. If you combine the two, Big Z is the overall better player.

  • Author

How is Shaq not versatile? Puts up points, gets rebounds...both he & Ilgauskus (to be fair) are amongst the best big men, in terms of passing the ball. Shaq is also a good shot blocker...I don't get it. He's not exactly a dumb, fat man making a living off purely strength. The guy has skill.

 

 

Actually, he is. If it weren't for all of his muscle and bulk, he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is. He can't shoot, he can't jump, and he can't run. He is not an athletic person.

 

 

Obviously.

If it wasn't for the fact that Ilgauskus is 7'3" he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is, either.

 

It really all depends what you'd rather have...a post presence or a guy that can go to the perimeter and knock down an occasional shot.

I'd rather have a post presence from my center. Come playoff time, toughness becomes important.

 

 

Wrong. If Ilgauskas were only six feet, he would still be in the NBA because of his ability to shoot the ball.

 

I think you're missing the concept though. Shaq is a great post presence. Ilgauskas is also a good post presence, just not as good as Shaq. Ilgauskas is one of the best, if not the best all-around shooter for a center. Shaq probably is the worst all-around shooter out of all of the centers in the NBA.

 

Shaq's post presence is slightly better than Big Z's, but Big Z's shooting ability is far greater than Shaq's. If you combine the two, Big Z is the overall better player.

 

Yeahno.

How is Shaq not versatile? Puts up points, gets rebounds...both he & Ilgauskus (to be fair) are amongst the best big men, in terms of passing the ball. Shaq is also a good shot blocker...I don't get it. He's not exactly a dumb, fat man making a living off purely strength. The guy has skill.

 

 

Actually, he is. If it weren't for all of his muscle and bulk, he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is. He can't shoot, he can't jump, and he can't run. He is not an athletic person.

 

 

Obviously.

If it wasn't for the fact that Ilgauskus is 7'3" he wouldn't be nearly as good as he is, either.

 

It really all depends what you'd rather have...a post presence or a guy that can go to the perimeter and knock down an occasional shot.

I'd rather have a post presence from my center. Come playoff time, toughness becomes important.

 

 

Wrong. If Ilgauskas were only six feet, he would still be in the NBA because of his ability to shoot the ball.

 

I think you're missing the concept though. Shaq is a great post presence. Ilgauskas is also a good post presence, just not as good as Shaq. Ilgauskas is one of the best, if not the best all-around shooter for a center. Shaq probably is the worst all-around shooter out of all of the centers in the NBA.

 

Shaq's post presence is slightly better than Big Z's, but Big Z's shooting ability is far greater than Shaq's. If you combine the two, Big Z is the overall better player.

 

Yeahno.

 

 

I think you're forgetting the fact that anyone has the ability to foul him and there's a good chance that Shaq will end up with no points, unlike Big Z, who shoots 85% from the line. That is why Shaq's post presence is only slightly better than Big Z's.

Wrong. If Ilgauskas were only six feet, he would still be in the NBA because of his ability to shoot the ball.

 

I think you're missing the concept though. Shaq is a great post presence. Ilgauskas is also a good post presence, just not as good as Shaq. Ilgauskas is one of the best, if not the best all-around shooter for a center. Shaq probably is the worst all-around shooter out of all of the centers in the NBA.

 

Shaq's post presence is slightly better than Big Z's, but Big Z's shooting ability is far greater than Shaq's. If you combine the two, Big Z is the overall better player.

 

Yeahno.

 

 

I think you're forgetting the fact that anyone has the ability to foul him and there's a good chance that Shaq will end up with no points, unlike Big Z, who shoots 85% from the line. That is why Shaq's post presence is only slightly better than Big Z's.

 

So you're gonna foul Shaq all game to send him to the foul line? By halftime, all the opposing team's players will be out of the game.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.