August 20, 201016 yr That doesn't really make sense. If the Marlins had kept guys like Calero, Donnelly, and Lindstrom, they would have been probably a worse team in those "two months" you mention. And they would have been out a lot of money. The Marlins kept Meyer, which is consistent with the strategy you seem to advocate, and that was a disaster. Paying the super replaceable Veras in the range of $1 million isn't a smart move, considering the risk that he might blow up next season. You're reading the absolute wrong thing into what I'm saying. It's not necessarily specific guys that should have been held over, its just that year after year we are ending up with a bullpen consisting of guys who will not be hold overs. It seems like 2/3 of the effective relievers are gone the next year. The problem is simply that we haven't cared to get guys either deemed worth holding over, or that we are capable of holding over. The strategy I'm advocating is not keeping guys who won't be able to keep it up. We need to find more guys that are worth keeping for more than one year. What good has it done to finally get a solid bullpen established in July when we were already out of it by then? That's what happens every year. We need to find a bullpen before then. Honestly, if we aren't keeping Veras next year then why don't we just throw all of our young promising arms into the fire and have them take their lumps now so maybe we can find one guy besides Hensley (because for all I know Leo will be gone) who can actually pitch the late innings come opening day. Here's the issue: From what resource do you take away to add to the bullpen? With payroll being what it's been, there's going to be holes. We can have holes offensively, we can have holes defensively, we can have holes in the rotation, we can have holes in the bullpen, ect. To improve in one area means taking away from the other. I don't think anybody agrees that the "throw sh*t against the wall, see what sticks" strategy is the best. People only advocate it because, when it comes to resources, you can normally build an average to better bullpen using less resources, than you can build a line up/rotation. This isn't something to blame on the FO. It's something to blame on the payroll, and whatever you believe causes the payroll to be so low. And it's something that, with payroll going up and a lot of guys being cost controlled, will hopefully change in the future. But when it comes to next year, unless we push a 60m payroll, we just don't have the money to go out and sign a Saito, Rauch, ect for 5m to shore up the back of the bullpen.
August 20, 201016 yr That doesn't really make sense. If the Marlins had kept guys like Calero, Donnelly, and Lindstrom, they would have been probably a worse team in those "two months" you mention. And they would have been out a lot of money. The Marlins kept Meyer, which is consistent with the strategy you seem to advocate, and that was a disaster. Paying the super replaceable Veras in the range of $1 million isn't a smart move, considering the risk that he might blow up next season. You're reading the absolute wrong thing into what I'm saying. It's not necessarily specific guys that should have been held over, its just that year after year we are ending up with a bullpen consisting of guys who will not be hold overs. It seems like 2/3 of the effective relievers are gone the next year. The problem is simply that we haven't cared to get guys either deemed worth holding over, or that we are capable of holding over. The strategy I'm advocating is not keeping guys who won't be able to keep it up. We need to find more guys that are worth keeping for more than one year. What good has it done to finally get a solid bullpen established in July when we were already out of it by then? That's what happens every year. We need to find a bullpen before then. Honestly, if we aren't keeping Veras next year then why don't we just throw all of our young promising arms into the fire and have them take their lumps now so maybe we can find one guy besides Hensley (because for all I know Leo will be gone) who can actually pitch the late innings come opening day. How am I to interpret your previously statement where you said that Veras should retained and you defended this by saying the Marlins can't succeed without continuity in the bullpen? It sounds like to me is that you are saying that Veras is effective this year and should be retained next year to preserve continuity because you presume he'll be effective. I disagree with this this, because I have severe doubts that he will be effective next season. Continuity doesn't mean a damn thing if he turns out to be another Dan Meyer. Right now I would say that Veras is just as much of a question mark for 2011 as most of the guys Beinfest will be acquiring under the hopes that some will step it up and fulfill certain roles. And Veras will likely cost $1 million.
August 20, 201016 yr I'm with The Penguin here, I'm completely confused about what your point and position actually is.
August 20, 201016 yr he is definitely worth keeping. he has been great and he has great stuff. there is no reason not to give him another shot. but the pen does for sure need some work. Sure, he's been good since being called back up as Erick pointed out but it's 23.2 innings vs 133 innings of career mediocrity. He's pitching way over his head right now and it's unlikely to continue. Rab said it: we've done that before (counted on guys that pitched over their heads for a year to come back and do the same next year) and it hasn't had good results. Veras is no different than Dan Meyer right now.
August 20, 201016 yr All about the asking price. He shouldn't be making over about 900 K per season is all I have to say.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.