Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dannyvalentine13

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  1. I wouldnt mind if Arod and Lowell signed in NYY. The yankees said they would be interested in him at first base. That would leave all the other teams without an option at 3rd and hopefully get them into a bidding war. Why would Mike Lowell sign with the Yankees as a 1B? A big part of his value is that he is a solid defensive 3B. On top of that, Lowell's numbers have been helped out a lot by the friendly dimensions at Fenway. He has been a doubles machine because of that ballpark. Yankee Stadium is not ideal for Mike Lowell. His numbers would take a hit and his value as a defensive player would diminish. Why sign a guy like Lowell to a big contract at 1B when there are other cheap options at 1B who can produce decent numbers. If Lowell doesn't sign with Boston, the only other team I could seriously see him playing for is Philly, but they don't have much left to spend and have stated they need pitching above any sort of position player. Look for Lowell to stay in Boston. The other teams who were rumored to be in the Lowell race were the Braves (ridiculous rumor) and the Cardinals. The Cards have denied interest and I don't believe they would be interested anyway. Miguel Cabrera's market is the LA teams. The Tigers have some nice pieces to move but the question is, will they (probably not since they already made one pretty big move this offseason). The Giants have Lincecum and Cain, and not much more beyond that worthy of Cabrera. It's between the LA teams. Hopefully the Dodgers do offer the 4 players the Marlins would be asking for (Kemp, Loney, Billingsly, Meloan). Otherwise a Kendrick, Mathis, Adenhart, Santana or Saunders deal has been talked about as the asking price from the Angels. The Yankees weren't a true option I believe because they are unwilling to relent Joba, Ian or Phil for a position player. Peavy or Santana would be the only guys they would surrender one of their young guns for. The Sox were most likely unwilling to deal Ellsbury or Clay after their debuts this year. I believe Lowell will stay with the Sox, and A-Rod is clearly returning to the Yanks. So, I don't think these moves will afftect Miguel's market too much, except for the fact that it may heat up the LA battle for him. Other teams may just decide to explore options like Crede, Rolen or maybe Glaus and Blalock.
  2. Now that you guys mentioned bullpen arms JC Romero got a 3 year deal worth 12 mill (stupid phillies). Time to sell high on guys like Pinto and Gregg. Not sure why Pinto is in that group but Miller, Gardner and Gregg should be I agree Ramp. Dealing a guy like Lee Gardner right now would be a smart move. He should have some value, seeing as how he had a great year and is under 35. He doesn't have the best stuff, but he was effective this year. Matt Herges was effective this year as well, and if he could find a suitor this offseason after the season he had, I'm sure the Marlins will take that into consideration and see if they could find a taker for a guy like Gardner. Plus, you don't know if a guy with his kind of stuff could even come close to repeating his numbers from this past season. Which I'm sure most teams will be thinking the same thing, but I'm sure there would be at least a few teams that would be interested. Same goes for Justin Miller. Kevin Gregg is a bit of a different story. He is under 30 and has good stuff. I'm sure there are plenty of teams who would be interested in Kevin Gregg for the late innings. Maybe Houston, or Chicago. Houston just lost Lidge and Chicago has moved Dempster into the rotation. If the Cubs can't sign Fransisco Cordero, resign Kerry Wood or if they decide not to put him in that closer role...maybe Gregg could be a nice option for them. The Reds are another team who need an actual closer...Dave Weathers is not the answer there. There are plenty of teams who could use a solid, versatile pitcher like Kevin Gregg. If we held onto Gregg though, I wouldn't complain. Besides, with guys like Chris Volstad, Brett Sinkbell and Gaby Hernandez on the way up into the rotation, and Vandenhurk hoping to earn a rotation spot guys like Nolasco and Mitre may need to be placed in the pen. Pinto is a guy we should hold on to. I agree on that. Guys like Owens, Lindstrom, Pinto, Nolasco, Mitre, Logan Kensing and Gregg should we hold onto him could really make for a strong bullpen (should they remain healthy). I especially am a big fan of Henry Owens. The bullpen was the strength of the team and it will be cheap again in 2008 even if the Marlins keep everyone. No need to move anyone. I'm not saying that there is a need to move anyone, but Gardner doesn't have great stuff and while he put up some solid numbers, he may be very hard pressed to even come close to repeating his 2007 performance. Same with Miller, though he does have better stuff than Gardner. Plus, with a healthy Owens, Matt Lindstrom, Taylor Tankersly, Renyel Pinto, a healthy Logan Kensing, Ricky Nolasco, Kevin Gregg and others like Harvey Garcia, and Carlos Martinez. Plus with Vandenhurk and Gaby Hernandez both ready to join the rotation, and Anibal Sanchez joining the staff again hopefully sometime in the early part of the season, more guys may be moved into the bullpen. While it doesn't hurt to have these guys in the organization, they may not be up with the club if the Owens' and Kensings can stay healthy, so it wouldn't hurt to see what kind of value they have.
  3. Now I could live with Barrett at catcher Would take him over Tore. anyday! If Barrett were to sign a deal worth 1 million, then yeah...I would take him over Yorvit, since we could get the same production (and potentially much more offensively) with and he could come much cheaper. The only issue is whether or not the Padres offer him arbitration. If they do, I don't think he would be worth a 1st or 2nd rd pick. Mike Maroth...I really really hope we stay as far away from this guy as possible. Kris Benson, Matt Clement, Josh Fogg, Joe Kennedy, Chin-Hui Tsao, Byung-Hyuun Kim, Eric Milton, Brett Tomko, Randy Wolf, Tony Armas, Shawn Chacon...anyone but Maroth. Hell I would prefer Kip Wells, who also had a dismal season...but has been much better than Mike Maroth in his career. Anyone but Mike Maroth. If we want quality pitching, we won't find it in Mike Maroth. If you want a lefty, try Joe Kennedy, or Randy Wolf. Just not Mike Maroth.
  4. Now that you guys mentioned bullpen arms JC Romero got a 3 year deal worth 12 mill (stupid phillies). Time to sell high on guys like Pinto and Gregg. Not sure why Pinto is in that group but Miller, Gardner and Gregg should be I agree Ramp. Dealing a guy like Lee Gardner right now would be a smart move. He should have some value, seeing as how he had a great year and is under 35. He doesn't have the best stuff, but he was effective this year. Matt Herges was effective this year as well, and if he could find a suitor this offseason after the season he had, I'm sure the Marlins will take that into consideration and see if they could find a taker for a guy like Gardner. Plus, you don't know if a guy with his kind of stuff could even come close to repeating his numbers from this past season. Which I'm sure most teams will be thinking the same thing, but I'm sure there would be at least a few teams that would be interested. Same goes for Justin Miller. Kevin Gregg is a bit of a different story. He is under 30 and has good stuff. I'm sure there are plenty of teams who would be interested in Kevin Gregg for the late innings. Maybe Houston, or Chicago. Houston just lost Lidge and Chicago has moved Dempster into the rotation. If the Cubs can't sign Fransisco Cordero, resign Kerry Wood or if they decide not to put him in that closer role...maybe Gregg could be a nice option for them. The Reds are another team who need an actual closer...Dave Weathers is not the answer there. There are plenty of teams who could use a solid, versatile pitcher like Kevin Gregg. If we held onto Gregg though, I wouldn't complain. Besides, with guys like Chris Volstad, Brett Sinkbell and Gaby Hernandez on the way up into the rotation, and Vandenhurk hoping to earn a rotation spot guys like Nolasco and Mitre may need to be placed in the pen. Pinto is a guy we should hold on to. I agree on that. Guys like Owens, Lindstrom, Pinto, Nolasco, Mitre, Logan Kensing and Gregg should we hold onto him could really make for a strong bullpen (should they remain healthy). I especially am a big fan of Henry Owens.
  5. Miggy losing out to Wright here is another bit of a surprise???? no???? Could easily make an arguement Wright was better than Miggy. Harder to make an arguement for Migz over Wright than Wright over Migz. But as much as I hate him, Admin should have won it. Hanley not getting the award over Jimmy Rollins is ridiculous. Though Rollins had a solid year, Hanley's was better. And on top of that Rollins plays in a ballpark which is the epitome of hitter friendly. Hanley plays in the polar opposite of Citizen's Bank. Also, a lot of people would argue that the 3rd base award belonged to Chipper (or Admin as Nny called him). Wright didn't have a better offensive year than Cabrera but they were fairly even in most categories.
  6. As of now, Willis is probably only worth a mid-level prospect or two. he's worth much more than that not much more, no. If the Braves were able to rape the M's and take Rafael Soriano for a pitcher like Haracio Ramirez who has never been anything more than average to below average...The Marlins can surely get something more than a B level prospect for a guy who is not only a proven winner...but is only 26, and has the stuff to be a top notch number 2 starter and even an ace on certain teams. The Rockies got Jason Hirsh, Taylor Buccholz and Willy Taveras in the Jason Jennings deal. Are you seriously going to tell me Dontrelle Willis' value is lower than a Horacio Ramirez or a Jason Jennings? A lefty who has won 18 games in a season and is 26 is worth a lot more than you think in a free agent market where Carlos Silva could get a 4 year 40something million dollar deal. Dontrelle Willis is worth more than Carlos Silva, Kyle Lohse, Jason Jennings, Matt Clement, Bartolo Colon, and Livan Hernandez. So a team who is desperately seeking solid starting pitching will most certainly prefer giving up some decent prospects for Dontrelle instead of taking a guy like Silva at a much heftier salary right now. "But the starting pitching market is thin enough that Carlos Silva, who has allowed 1,122 hits in 945 career innings, might be looking at a four-year deal worth more than $40 million. And Tom Glavine, 41, is an attractive commodity because he's reliable and won't require a long-term commitment." That was from Buster Olney. So Willingham you can keep taking shots at me, and LPUMA you can continue to believe that Dontrelle Willis can only bring in a b level prospect....But just examine the overall market for quality starting pitching and the fact that 28 or 29 GMs stated that starting pitching was among their top needs during the roundtable discussion at the GM meetings this week. While I will agree with Beef that Dontrelle won't bring in the best prospect on a team such as Balentien or Adam Jones in Seattle, Nick Adenhart or Brandon Wood from the Angels or Max Scherzer from Arizona...It is not out of realistic thought to believe that a team like Seattle who has a solid catcher in Jojima wouldn't be willing to part with Clement for Dontrelle. All I'm saying is remember the bleak free agent market for pitchers.
  7. Have to wait for Cabrera to get traded first as he is obviously the bigger ticket, which will get larger talent. Once we see what holes that fills/creates, then it'll be time to figure out what to do with Dontrelle, whether trading him now or praying to god he is "fixed" by July to trade him at the deadline. But houston? They have junk. Willis to Colorado, Arizona, Cleveland or Seattle makes more sense. They all need pitching and have lots and lots of fun stuff in their advanced minors or just breaking into the bigs that make sense here. I would like a Willis to Seattle trade. Of course, any deal with seattle would have to include Jeff Clement. I don't see them giving up Wladimier Balentien, or Brandon Morrow. Maybe Eric O'Flaherty and Jeff Clement.
  8. :lol No way in HELL are the 'Stros going to give up Pence for Willis. Thats no reason for us not to discuss it and insert him into fake lineups. ...where Scott Podsednik is leading off Ok...seriously? We're going to keep going with this stupid crap? Can you let it go already? We all get it, you don't like Podsednik. I simply wanted to see what people thought of an Astros/Marlins deal involving Willis. I never said that the Marlins would be able to pull that trade off. I said I would love to deal Willis for Pence straight up. A lot of people would, but its so unrealistic that its not worth posting. I didn't post the thread just to say that...I posted the thread because I saw the report on rotoworld and wanted to post it here. Hell, people post threads about Torrealba possibly coming over, and any other piece of news or rumors regarding the Marlins, so I decided to post one myself. The possible deal could include Towles or Flores and Patton. I just added a little comment on how I would love to have Pence. Seriously is it that big a deal that I added that side note?
  9. :lol No way in HELL are the 'Stros going to give up Pence for Willis. Thats no reason for us not to discuss it and insert him into fake lineups. ...where Scott Podsednik is leading off Ok...seriously? We're going to keep going with this stupid crap? Can you let it go already? We all get it, you don't like Podsednik. I simply wanted to see what people thought of an Astros/Marlins deal involving Willis. I never said that the Marlins would be able to pull that trade off. I said I would love to deal Willis for Pence straight up.
  10. According to rotoworld.... "The Astros have inquired about what it would take to get Dontrelle Willis from the Marlins. Without a lot of other minor league talent to sell off, the Astros would likely have to include probable 2008 catcher J.R. Towles in a deal for Willis. The Marlins should also be interested in left-hander Troy Patton and center fielder Josh Flores. A deal is pretty unlikely." Patton and Towles or Pence for Willis....would anyone find that deal appealing? Maybe Pence for Willis straight up? Maybe Pence, Towles and Patton for Willis and Gregg (the Stros may be looking for another option at closer other than Qualls, but that price may be too high for the Astros to pay). I would like to see Hunter Pence playing CF here. Houston just acquired Michael Bourn, who is another Willy Taveras, so maybe they would be willing to part with Pence to improve their woeful staff from last year. If this deal went down, it could drastically change any deal with Cabrera since we wouldn't need a CF anymore. Personally I would go Willis for Pence straight up. Anyone wanna weigh in on a deal with Houston?
  11. The problem with acquiring a "catcher of the future," is that most likely, when we do, he'll be young. And, because of that, calling a game and handling a young pitching staff will probably not be his strong suit. I agree with this comment completely. You can't expect a Jeff Mathis or Jeff Clement to be able to come in and handle our staff the way Pudge did, or even the way LoDuca did and Treanor has. If the Marlins were strictly out for a defensive catcher, they could go with a cheaper option. While Torrealba did have a better defensive year than Olivo, he isn't a huge step up defensively. If they are just looking for a defensive upgrade, then old man Lieberthal or Rod Barajas could be given a shot in the spring. Or you could just make the argument that a young catcher like Mathis, Spollach or Jeff Clement could learn what it takes to handle a big league staff under Matt Treanor. Of course, I realize a lot of people on this forum would love to have Paul LoDuca back, but I think, considering his age, his off year and his nack for wasting away in the second half....he should be taking a pay cut this year. If the price is right then LoDuca could be a temporary solution.
  12. I put up some weight since Cabrera came to the Big Leagues as well. Everybody has. Hes still in a developing body, plus a lot of this weight is muscle weight. If youre in a developing body, of course your weight is gonna increase . totally dude :lol Are you kidding me? Miguel Cabrera came in weighing 185. It is absolutely not muscle weight. He has gained a lot of weight and that needs to be a big issue he deals with this offseason. His offense hasn't been affected but his defense has absolutely gone from mediocre/passable to truly awful. He has no mobility. If anyone actually sat down to watch the Marlins this year, you would know that our hitting was solid: Hanley was sensational, Dan Uggla put up big power numbers and produced a lot of runs, Miguel Cabrera was in his usual form, Josh Willingham put up nice numbers...and Jeremy Hermida came into his own in the second half. None of that great hitting could make up for truly piss poor defense, and injury riddled, inconsistent starting pitching. Miguel was a big contributer to that...as was Hanley, but Hanley is in a place where he can improve because he is the most athletic guy on the field on any given day. Miguel Cabrera on the other hand, may very well come into camp weighing 270-280...as a 3B. That just simply can't happen. For a team that won 2 championships on pitching and defense.....Miguel Cabrera really needs to step it up and lose that weight, get his mobility back, his quickness back and use that cannon of his, instead of wasting it as a 280 lbs 1B or DH because that's where he is headed. He is a great hitter, but an overall great game, hitting, and defense....is better.
  13. Taking a look back at the trade rumors that have been swirling around regarding Johan Santana, Dontrelle Willis, and Miguel Cabrera, I believe that I may have come up with a blockbuster trade idea that would involve the Marlins, Twins, and Dodgers. Here is my proposal. Los Angeles Dodgers Get: 3B Miguel Cabrera SP Johan Santana Minnesota Twins Get: SP Dontrelle Willis 3B Andy LaRoche Florida Marlins Get: C Russell Martin SP Brad Penny OF Matt Kemp RP Jonathan Broxton SP Chad Billingsley RP Jesse Crain The Dodgers would gain two young superstars that would give them a great chance at winning a championship, the Twins would gain a cheaper, younger pitcher who could become an ace for the Twins and could help Liriano as well as a top third base prospect, and the Marlins would gain an All-Star starting pitcher (Penny) who will make the same money as Dontrelle will next season, a top notch starting catcher who is only 24, and some signifcant pitching help both in the starting rotation and the bullpen with two potential future closers. Once that takes place, the deal would actually save us money that we could use to replace Cabrera with A-Rod at third base. How does this trade sound? Why would the Twins do this? Willis didn't fair to well int he NL and you want to throw him into the AL Central? While I agree that this trade is never going to happen, for so many reasons, I don't agree that Dontrelle Willis didn't fair too well in the NL. He had a bad year, yes...we all saw that. But Dontrelle is still 68-54, making him the winningest pitcher in Marlins history. Last year was a bad year for him, and the year before his record was 12-12, but his ERA was still 3.87 which is a solid major league ERA, and the year before that he was 22-10 with a 2.63 which is absolutely phenomenal. I will say that his numbers have been on a decline ever since Rick Kranitz took over, given the right situation (a pitching coach who knows how to coach a pitcher like Dontrelle and a catcher who knows how to manage a pitching staff), Dontrelle can bounce back and have a solid year. That's why I believe he should not be traded this off season. Bring Mark Wiley back, and sign a catcher like Mike Lieberthal or Paul LoDuca, maybe even Jason Kendall. You can't sell D-Train when his stock is so low. He will bounce back next year given a better catcher and better defense. Our offense was solid, but Miguel Olivo is not the answer. He is not the guy to manage the staff and he commits too many errors. He was a pass ball machine this year. If you are going to trade someone, it is obviously going to be Miguel Cabrera, who will bring in the most value. And yes I know, it's sad to think we would have to trade yet another great player, especially our very own Albert Pujols, but if you think about it, even if we get the stadium deal Miguel will command a contract very similar to the deal A-Rod received from Texas when his contract is up. Will Loria give that to Miguel? Even if we have our stadium deal done already, signed and sealed...will the Marlins shell out a 10 year, 250 million dollar deal? I would love to say yes, but I am just not sure that they would. The Red Sox will, the Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, Angels and Giants may. Maybe even the Rangers or Mariners...but the Marlins? That is doubtful. Like someone said yesterday, top notch pitching is much harder to come by than top notch offense. If we can acquire top notch pitching in exchange for Miguel Cabrera, we have to take it. Either that, or sign Miguel to a 5 year, 80 million dollar extension right now (though that won't happen). lol
  14. Give me Bruney and we're set, take Miggs. You guys are ridiculous. I hate forums because most of the time when you try to discuss and debate people get stupid and nasty. Honestly, is there any reason for you guys to go ahead and make those stupid comments? I get attacked by a mob because I recognize that no one hitter is worth 3 top of the line potential aces and a 25 year, 2 time all star, who in his 3 big league seasons has been a stand out hitter with good speed and solid defense. Saying that in order to get Miguel Cabrera the Yankees would have to hand us their entire pool of prospects is just as bad as someone (hypothetically) in 2001 going on an Expos forum upon hearing rumors of the Marlins' interest in Vlad Guerrero, and demanding that the Marlins give up Josh Beckett, Brad Penny, A.J. Burnett and on top of that....Derrek Lee or Mike Lowell. And for those of you who would be insane enough to say yes...you would have taken that deal...the Marlins would never have won the World Series in 2003 without Beckett, Penny, Lowell and Lee. So if you think the Yankees are going to give those guys and either Melky or Cano, you're insane. And yes I agree that it is a waste to put a guy with such a great arm like Miguel Cabrera at 1B but when you have a 3B weighing over 250...he is going to be a huge liability. If the Marlins, or Yankees or whoever put Cabrera on some sort of plan to get him down to 230...then you can see his defense improve. Even Peter Gammons said he finds it unlikely that the Yankees would give up Phil Hughes. If the Marlins get offered both Kennedy and Chamberlain on top of Cano and whoever else you guys want them to add in there (Tabata, Gardner, Edwar Ramirez, Tyler Clippard, Ross Ohlendorf), then they have made a very generous offer. Great pitchers will always be more valuable to a team than great hitters. The Yankees problem has never been their hitting. When they were winning their championships, they had Scott Brosius at 3B. It was their pitching...a young Andy Pettite, David Cone, El Duque, Roger Clemens, and Mariano Rivera at his most dominant. The Red Sox won this year because of great pitching from Beckett, Schilling, Lester, and Papelbon's dominance. It's always pitching, not hitting that wins the championships. The Yankees have not been lacking in hitting. A-Rod had a more productive year, way more productive than Miguel and they didn't go anywhere. Jeter, A-Rod, Abreu, Damon, Cano, Cabrera, Posada....they do not lack offense. Even without A-Rod they still don't lack offense. Why would they give up the thing that clearly can get them over their World Series drought? A team like the Dodgers? Yeah, they would be more willing to give up their top prospects. Hell, a team like the Padres is the kind of team that should be willing to give up the farm for a much needed power hitter in that order. But the Yankees don't lack hitting. They could easily go for a Joe Crede that will hit adequately, or a Mike Lowell and keep their top three up and coming star pitchers as well as their all star 2B. They fill the need with a formidable hitter (though not on the level of Cabrera), get much better defense and have 4 aces (that includes Wang) and a much better chance to win. That's why they won't throw all these top prospects at us. They're not in desparate need of a big hitter. If they want a big hitter they attempt to sign Andruw Jones (who is one of the best CF defensively you will ever see), or Torii Hunter (who is also up there defensively). The Marlins downfall this year was the 2 things the Yankees would be giving away to get Miguel's bat: consistent, solid starting pitching and defense (they obviously give up defense acquiring Cabs, unless they move him to 1B). But you guys are the geniuses who make fun of me because I am not opposed to adding Brian Bruney, or having Kei Igawa at a fraction of the price. Whatever. This forum is clearly filled with people from Miami: rude, know it all jerks. If the Dolphins decide to trade Jason Taylor in the offseason, I'm sure all of you will be demanding Dunta Robinson, DeMeco Ryans, Andre Johnson, and Omobi Okoye. Peace.
  15. Gotta love a guy who starts off his post, "Listen friends." You guys are insane if you think the Yankees are going to give up Joba Chamberlain, Ian Kennedy, and Phil Hughes for anyone. That would be like the A's having given up Zito, Mulder, and Hudson for any hitter in the league when the three were Oakland's top prospects. Do you honestly think the Yankees are gonna give up three top tier, Cy Young stuff type pitchers a player who is an amazing hitter.....Miguel Cabrera is an amazing hitter, one of the best (not the best, that would be Albert Pujols), and nothing more. He is slow, overweight and a liability defensively. Let's get serious. And on top of that, you guys wanna throw in Robinson Cano, a proven all star, who has decent speed, decent power, makes great contact with the ball, and plays solid defense. It's like asking for Andre Johnson (proven young star), DaMeco Ryans, Omobi Okoye and Travis Johnson (3 top defensive young players) in return for Willie Parker (a great running back, one of the best, but not the best). You can't ask for the whole team in return for one great player. If the Yankees make that deal, they're left with Wang, Mussina, Pettite (who will most likely retire if they trade their whole staff away), Igawa, and then a guy like Jason Jennings. They would have traded away all their young pitchers. It would be like the Marlins having traded Josh Beckett, Brad Penny, A.J. Burnett and Luis Castillo in 2002 for Manny Ramirez. It's literally the same. Would you have done that? Do you people think we could have come anywhere near a championship in 2003 without Beckett and Penny? Why would the Yankees do that? No one hitter is worth 3 top of the line ace potential starters AND a 2 time all star 25 year old second baseman with the potential to be a 25-30 hr/100 rbi/above .300 hitter every year. I suggested a realistic trade. Not a video game trade. You can't trade the entire Chicago Bulls team for Kobe Bryant...If you do, what do the Bulls become? At the most, an 8 seed, 1st round elimination team. Oh and by the way, I LOOVE how we write off Kei Igawa after one year. We just wrote off a 27 year old pitcher with a lot of talent based a rookie season. Good call there. Kinda like the guy who would have written John Smoltz off for going 2-7 with an ERA of almost 6.00 in his first season, or Johan Santana who went 2-3 with an ERA upwards of 7.00 in his rookie year. Igawa is due 4 million a year for the next 4 seasons. The Yankees would pay 2 million a year for Igawa, and 7 million for the final year of Pavano's deal. Those 2 salaries combined for the Marlins would be 5 million, while Cabrera would be making around 11 million this year. Cano won't make that much, and Chamberlain has a rookie deal, and Betemit makes 405,000 while Bruney also has a rookie deal. Ohlendorf is a potential number 3 or 4 guy in the rotation and also has a rookie deal, so combine each player in this equation and they still don't make more than Miggy will this year. I'm sorry, use your heads people. We all love what Miguel Cabrera has done, but without a stadium in place, nor a deal on the verge of being done, we should sell while his stock is at its peak, and get a good set of players. 2 major league ready high tier prospects, a young perennial all star, a young pitcher with a lot of potential, and a throw in (Pavano). Remember how Mike Lowell was a throw-in in the Beckett deal? Look how that worked out. If the Yankees deal for Cabrera I expect a lot of angry fans on this forum when they see that the Marlins didn't get the entire Yankees starting rotation, Cano, and Melky Cabrera...Hey you might as well throw Matsui in there, and Jeter. Why not? Since we are asking for ridiculously unrealistic amounts of major league talent for one player. Good luck with that. Here is my final and most realistic trade offer I think the Yankees will be willing to make. Miguel Cabrera Ross Wolf for Robinson Cano Chase Wright Joba Chamberlain Kei Igawa (2 of his 4 million dollar salary per year paid by NY) Brian Bruney Carl Pavano (7 million of his 10 million dollar salary paid by NY) Wilson Betemit Cash considerations Seriously, that deal is not only realistic, but so solid for the Marlins. We get 5 pitchers (4 of which are under 28 years old), 2 of which are top prospects, 1 is a hard throwing solid reliever, 1 has potential and talent to be a decent starter in the NL, and 1 is a filler who had great success in his contract year with us. We also get 2 infielders, 1 of which is a top 3 best 2B in the majors right now, and the other is a productive hitter with power and a decent glove. Obviously a young, solid player like Wilson Betemit got overlooked in my last trade proposal. P.S. Allen Iverson got dealt last year for garbage, and he was the top scorer in the NBA at that point. ps iverson wasnt a 24 year old superstar that is on the career path of the homerun king and is one of the top 5 hitters in teh game. And that offer is horrible why would we want igawa who isnt worth his weight and pavano whos now become a broken down pitcher? it doesnt matter how much of the salary the yankees pick up yeah, you're right, why would we want a guy who 2 years ago won 18 games. just like...why would the red sox want mike lowell in the beckett deal after hitting a truly awful .236 with 8 HR and 58 RBI? That was a mistake to take a chance on a veteran who had an off year. He didn't just win WS MVP after a spectacular season. And I seriously find all of you ridiculous for completely writing off Igawa after a rough MLB ROOKIE season!!!!! Johan Santana, 2-3, ERA in the 7.00s his rookie year, Smoltz's rookie year he was roughed up pretty good, Danny Haren too. I could go on and on naming all star, even Cy Young starters who were roughed up in their first season. But yeah, let's write Igawa off already. i think the main part of that statement would be 18 games 2 YEARS AGO..this is a what have you done for me lately business...what has he done since? pitched in 19 games over 2 years. it might be worth to find out whether another round in fla could revive his career but not at the expense of miguel cabrera. and as far as igawa i along with a lot of people is ready to write him off because he only had one dominant year in japan and wasnt even considered servicable and at this age should not have problems throwing strikes. wow...u really don't read what i'm saying. yes, 2 years ago he won 18 games...last year peavy had an off year, a rough year...and look what he comes back and does...carlos pena was absolutely nowhere, and a nobody before this season. and i am in no way saying to take a risk on pavano at the expense of miguel cabrera. that's the most ridiculous thing i have ever read. i never said that...i said Pavano is a FILLER in the trade because the yankees wanna get rid of him. why the hell not take him as a filler? the main players in the trade were cano, chamberlain, wright, tabata (that's 3 pitching prospects and a 2 time all star who is 25), then igawa and pavano at a fraction of the cost of their contracts.....as fillers, along with betemit and brian bruney. to think that the yankees would be stupid enough to give up hughes, chamberlain and kennedy for any one player is ridiculous. it's utterly ridiculous. if i were the yankees and the marlins offered me an amazing hitter who is an absolute defensive liability and will be playing first base for them within the year.....for 3 top end, ace potential starters.....would u make that trade? i would seriously hope not. now would u trade an 2 ace prospects, a top 3 2b, a potential 2 or 3 starter in wright, and 4 fillers for miguel? i don't see how from both sides, that doesn't make more sense.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.