I may be the only guy to vote for him, but my vote goes to Danny Kolb, he has been SICK this year.

I may be the only guy to vote for him, but my vote goes to Danny Kolb, he has been SICK this year.

441994[/snapback]

 

 

I watched him today! He has never given up an extra base hit! pretty good

Mariano and Gagne tie in my book.

All of them are deserving to be on this poll but come on.

 

It's Gagne, he's in a league of his own and he use to have to share that with Smoltz and Rivera.

either Rivera or Kolb

A few numbers on these guys:

 

RP Armando Benitez 26 1.11

 

RP Eric Gagne 21 1.54

 

RP Danny Graves 31 3.02

 

RP Francisco Cordero 24 1.85

 

RP Joe Nathan 23 1.19

 

RP Mariano Rivera 29 0.86

 

RP Danny Kolb 24 0.87

 

The Numbers after the names are total saves and ERA

I voted for Kolb even though I like Gagne.

Kolb's got the lowest non-yankee ERA, so he's best.

benitez hes been lights out

until Gagne streak is broken, Gagne is the man. Stats go out of the window. He does his job, and doesn't blow the saves

Agreed. Gagne has to blow one before he can get dethroned.

 

Urbina has sucked.

Can I change my vote?

until Gagne streak is broken, Gagne is the man. Stats go out of the window. He does his job, and doesn't blow the saves

442241[/snapback]

so i guess he isnt the man anymore?

Do any of you all who voted for Gagne want to now change your vote??

 

Naw. I'm gonna keep my vote. He's only blown one and that's pretty darn good.

Naw. I'm gonna keep my vote. He's only blown one and that's pretty darn good.

442928[/snapback]

 

My pick Kolb has also only blown 1, with a lower ERA and more save chances than Gagne.

 

Ditto for Joe Nathan.

 

Ditto for Joe Nathan.

 

442945[/snapback]

giants should never have traded him for pierzynski :mad :

Ditto for Joe Nathan.

 

442945[/snapback]

giants should never have traded him for pierzynski :mad :

442960[/snapback]

 

No, that was a good move man.

 

After all, Robb Nen is healthy.

 

:plain

Ditto for Joe Nathan.

 

442945[/snapback]

giants should never have traded him for pierzynski :mad :

442960[/snapback]

 

No, that was a good move man.

 

After all, Robb Nen is healthy.

 

:plain

442967[/snapback]

actually the Giants had plans to put him in the rotation, but then they decided Yorvit Torrealba wasn't ready to be an everyday starter so they traded for Pierzynski and then picked up Bret "can't pitch for s***" Tomko