Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Who Won the Debate

Featured Replies

talk about stubborn partisan spin. Bush told you staunch supporters everything you want to hear. If youre in love with his message, how can he lose? By saying he molests children? Even then I imagine there would be spin.

 

Be sensible. Neither side can get into the substance of the argument in a 90 minute debate. Its all about how you deliver the message and Kerry delivered it much better. Bush was defensive, lost, and deer in headlights. What you people are defending is basically the more detailed policy issues. Why dont you read the title of the thread and then start a new one before trying to spin this your way.

so pretty much nothing to do with the debates themselves right? Was Kerry trying to convert you or fish fillet? I seriously doubt it. Was he trying to convert the undecided wavering voter? Yes. And what better way than to debate your points better and look better in terms of delivery?

  • Author

so pretty much nothing to do with the debates themselves right? Was Kerry trying to convert you or fish fillet? I seriously doubt it. Was he trying to convert the undecided wavering voter? Yes. And what better way than to debate your points better and look better in terms of delivery?

578024[/snapback]

:notworthy :notworthy

 

I am pretty sure that this all Hannity and Rush Limbaugh have been saying. Honestly, they have an uphill battle to try and spin the "deer in the headlights".

I personally think that Kerry came off looking better. Neither one really outdid the other so clearly you could only say there was one winner. I was at school today and heard both sides, a Bush supporter said: "Kerry just pouted." While a Kerry supporter was walking around saying, "We won! We won!"

 

It's too early to say. My vote hasn't been changed at all, but it was enlightening.

  • Author

I personally think that Kerry came off looking better. Neither one really outdid the other so clearly you could only say there was one winner. I was at school today and heard both sides, a Bush supporter said: "Kerry just pouted." While a Kerry supporter was walking around saying, "We won! We won!"

 

It's too early to say. My vote hasn't been changed at all, but it was enlightening.

578039[/snapback]

 

You really think it was a draw? wow, even Bush supporters admit Kerry kicked Bush's ass.

  • Author

"The National Verdict is In: John Kerry Wins First Debate"

 

Washington, DC The reviews are in and according to the talking heads and today's news it is clear that at last night's debate America saw John Kerry as the next President of the United States. Kerry's strength, conviction, and steady command of the facts left no doubt that he can lead the fight on terrorism and finish the job in Iraq. Kerry beat expectations, he looked presidential, and he proved his foreign policy credentials.

 

But don't take out our word for it:

 

KERRY'S THE WINNER HE BEAT EXPECTATIONS

 

Joe Scarborough: "John Kerry won the debate. Karl Rove: John Kerry won the debate." [MSNBC, 10/1/04]

 

Peggy Noonan: "Mr. Kerry did himself some good in that he seemed focused, to my mind, for once." [Fox News Channel, 9/20/04]

 

Sen. John McCain: "I think that Kerry did a good job." [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

 

Fred Barnes: "Kerry did very well and we will have a presidential race from here on out" [Fox News Channel, 9/30/04]

 

Howard Fineman: "Kerry won the event." [MSNBC, 10/1/04]

 

Mark Whitaker, Newsweek: "I think Kerry won on style in this debate." [CNN, 9/30/04]

 

Joe Scarborough: "It was John Kerry's best performance everAs far as the debate goes, I don't see how anybody could look at this debate and not score this a very clear win on points for John Kerry." [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

 

Ron Reagan: "Kerry was the clear winner." [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

 

Bill Kristol: "I think Kerry did pretty well." [Fox News Channel, 9/30/04]

 

Andrea Mitchell: "Kerry began to narrow the gap." [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

 

Chris Matthews: "I thought it was smart for Kerry to keep going back to saying that 90% of the casualties were American. For the President to deny that is going against American perceptions." [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

 

Craig Crawford: "Kerry was good about not being put on the defensive. There were many opportunities he may have wanted to respond to the mixed messages that Bush kept talking about, he would just kind of laugh and let it go and make his points. He won the cutaway shots." [MSNBC, 10/1/04]

 

George Stephanopoulos: "Kerry has momentum coming out of here." [ABC, 9/30/04]

 

Boston Globe Headline: "Kerry stays focused, projects strength" [10/1/04]

 

Los Angles Times Headline: "TV Analysts Give Kerry an Early Lead in Quest for Spin" [10/1/04]

 

Kerry "may well have struck undecided voters as not much like the Republicans' worst caricatures. He spoke plainly, politely, but did not shrink from direct and pointed criticism of Mr. Bush's policies." [New York Times, 10/1/04]

 

"I thought Kerry did very, very well; and I thought Bush did poorly much worse than he is capable of doing. If I were just a normal, fairly conservative, war-supporting guy: I would vote for Kerry. On the basis of that debate." [Jay Nordlinger, National Review Online, 10/1/04]

 

"Sen. John F. Kerry won Thursday night's debate on foreign policy by a comfortable margin." [Editorial, Los Angeles Times, 10/1/04]

 

"Kerry won the debate, according to three polls. Gallup said a phone survey called Kerry the winner by 53 percent to 37 percent for Bush. A CBS News instant poll said 44 percent called Kerry the winner and 26 percent picked Bush. In an ABC News instant poll, 45 percent said Kerry won; 36 percent picked Bush. Both political parties said they had encouraged supporters to participate in instant surveys." [bloomberg News, 9/30/04]

 

"You could tell who won this debate with the sound off. Every time John Kerry spoke, the split-screen showed President Bush looking like he took a swig of milk three weeks past the expiration date. Kerry beat the president Thursday night on the one issue that defines this election: the war on terrorism." [Tommy Tomlinson, Charlotte Observer, 10/1/04]

 

Roger Wilkins, George Mason University history professor: "Kerry did what he had to the whole way through. He was crisp. He didn't meander as he's done. He was clear and in command of facts and he was focused." [uSA Today, 10/1/04]

 

"But in terms of presentation, Kerry seemed to have more success Thursday night projecting the clarity' he and his campaign have been seeking to convey." [Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 10/1/04]

 

"John Kerry has a reputation, invoked so often that it invites parody, of being a strong closer in his political campaigns. But in Thursday night's first presidential faceoff, Kerry also came across as a strong opener." [Walter Shapiro, USA Today, 10/1/04]

 

"Those who expected the Massachusetts senator to be the droning, long-winded patrician he has been so far this campaign had to have been startled by the sharp, focused fighter Mr. Kerry was last night. He finally connected with audiences, speaking with uncharacteristic passion and directness about what he sees as the Bush administration's failures. If we had seen this John Kerry three months ago, the race might look very different today. On substance, too, Mr. Kerry landed some serious blows to the president. He struck hard on Mr. Bush's lack of planning for the Iraq occupation, and questioned the quality of his judgment. The Democrat's most memorable line turned the president's greatest virtue his decisiveness into a vice: It's one thing to be certain. But you can be certain and be wrong.'" [Editorial, Dallas Morning News, 10/1/04]

 

KERRY WAS PRESIDENTIAL

 

Mort Kondracke: "I think Kerry looked like a commander-in-chief." [Fox News Channel, 9/30/04]

 

Melinda Henneberger: Kerry came across in a way I hadn't seen him before. Kerry was presidential, standing up straight. Kerry did a great job with the flip flop question saying there's no virtue in consistency if you're wrong. Kerry was so much stronger in answering what Bush had to say. [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

 

Rich Lowry: "Kerry certainly helped himself tonight. He had command of the facts." [Fox News Channel, 10/1/04]

 

Mike Barnicle; Boston Herald: "I think people when they saw Kerry tonight said they saw someone who could be president of the United States. He used the word kill' several times tonight. I hadn't heard him use that on the stump. It's a very forceful, powerful word. It leaves no interpretation." [MSNBC, 10/1/04]

 

Bill Kristol: "Kerry was forceful and articulate." [Fox News Channel, 9/30/04]

 

Wolf Blitzer: "We saw Bush smirkingKerry was more poised." [CNN, 9/30/04]

 

William Weld: "[John Kerry] looked like John Kennedy Jr. out there and that never hurts." [CNN, 9/30/04]

"By the time the debate ended, Mr. Kerry appeared to have accomplished his primary goal for the evening: establishing himself as a plausible commander in chief." [New York Times, 10/1/04]

 

"Kerry was cogent and focused, something he needed to do to look presidential. He went on the attack early and kept Bush on the defensive through much of the event. Bush sometimes looked peeved and fidgety and his twitching mouth and blinking eyes indicated a nervousness." [David Yepsen, Des Moines Register, 10/1/04]

 

KERRY PROVED HIS CREDIENTIALS ON FOREIGN POLICY

 

Sen. John McCain: "I think that John Kerry's strongest point was that he was very well understood the issues. I think he came across as somebody who had a very good grasp of the issues. He understands Korea, he understands Iran. He did make a valid point when we these are major threats. I agreed with him, particularly on this issue of the threat of nuclear proliferation." [CBS, 9/30/04]

 

David Gergen: "John Kerry was the one who had the most to prove and I think he proved it. And that was that he's knowledgeable about international affairs and he can make his points in a concise, compelling way." [CNN, 9/30/04]

 

Tim Russert: "George Bush is certain about the war in Iraq, certain about the war on terror, certain about his positions, John Kerry is now raising real questions about all of them and the American people I think are listening." [NBC, 9/30/04]

 

Jon Meacham, Newsweek: "Kerry's done a good job of becoming Mr. Homeland Security." [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

 

Anthony Mason: "John Kerry appeared to score the highest ratings tonight when he described his plans for Iraq." [CBS, 9/30/04]

 

"Kerry's position on Iraq is now clear." [Editorial, Boston Globe, 10/1/04]

 

 

 

DNC

  • Author

Do you agree with Kerry's bi-lateral DPRK negotiations stance?

 

If so why? (Since he seems to want coalitions everywhere else)

 

Should the US bear the sole burden of the inevitable economic bribes/payoffs because we boldly chose to "go it alone" in such a solo manner?

578093[/snapback]

 

:lol I suggest you watch something else other than Fox. Your arguments are clearly Republican spin.

 

John Kerry said, he wants other countries involved as well, BUT he wants us to NOT rely on them only. He wants the United States to take a more prominent role and hold bilateral talks with that country... Because as far as we can see, Bush's way hasn't worked a bit and N. Korea has actually increased his arsenal.

 

Pick another one Tonyi. :mischief

Kerry's bilateral DPRK negotiations stance is completely bogus - he takes it only because its not Bush's position.

 

Its plain as day the DPRK is looking to extort bribes/aid.

 

It would clearly cost the US less if the ultimate cost of those bribes/aid are spread around among more of the concerned nations in the area.

578060[/snapback]

 

tonyi, did Bush make the points better than Kerry on this subject last night or is this going to be a thread with tonyi making the points Bush was supposed to make?

The most frustrating part of the debate was when Bush accidentaly said "Saddam Hussein" instead of "Osama Bin Laden" :banghead

  • Author

The most frustrating part of the debate was when Bush accidentaly said "Saddam Hussein" instead of "Osama Bin Laden" :banghead

578163[/snapback]

 

That's what we "libs" call a freudian slip. :cool

Kerry had Bush by the throat on police funding. Had him. Can't wait to see the domestic policy debate. That will be very key.

 

 

 

Edwards vs. Cheney should be interesting.

Oh yeah, I forgot. Kerry won the debate and anyone who says he didn't is obviously not open.

578349[/snapback]

I guess if it was a high school debate tournament and I was judge I would give it to Kerry for best delivery and seeming a bit more confident. :confused

 

I though both did mediocre to bad.

Oh yeah, I forgot. Kerry won the debate and anyone who says he didn't is obviously not open.

578349[/snapback]

I guess if it was a high school debate tournament and I was judge I would give it to Kerry for best delivery and seeming a bit more confident. :confused

 

I though both did mediocre to bad.

578354[/snapback]

I thought Kerry explained his views well. And the most important thing was how he did under the accusations and he did so fine under them that he turned them against Bush IMPOV.

Edwards vs. Cheney should be interesting.

578340[/snapback]

 

578342[/snapback]

 

You that confident eh? :mischief We'll see how it ends up.

 

 

From whats being said, it sounds mainly like a lot of damage control from the Bush supporters.

Chewbacca you are sorely mistaken and are in for a HUGE, HUGE surprise.

 

I've met Sen. Edwards twice when I ran his campaign in my area in the Wisconsin primaries. Edwards will defeat Cheney. He will take Cheney on about Halliburton and Edwards will use his skills as a sucessful trial lawyer to make Cheney look to be the biggest a$$hole on the face of the planet.

 

An Edwards/Cheney debate is much better then an Edwards/Bush debate, you thought Kerry destroyed Bush folks, Edwards would have ended Bush's campaign last night,

 

but at any rate, Cheney is much more intelligent, much more sneaky, clever, and slimier, and Cheney will be a WORTHY adversary to Edwards, in the end I believe with all my heart and soul Edwards will prevail, but Cheney is definitely a more formidable task then debating Bush.

 

But Chewy, don't underestimate Edwards, otherwise you'll be contemplating suicide after the VP debate when Edwards rips Cheney a new one on Halliburton.

 

Oh and by the way, Kerry beat Bush handily as well.

 

"mexed missages" (mixed messages)

"vesserfolousfly" (visciferously)

"Abu-Grahabi" (abu-ghraib)

"Kim Xing Ill" (xiong)

"flop-flipper" (flip-flopper)

 

5 new classic Bushim's to ad to the list.

 

Fantastic!

My weak spot is domestic issues.? Republicans don't have a good record on those and that is the only debate that will/may sway my opinion... or vote.

577871[/snapback]

 

Are you telling me that you would willfully change your vote from the Bush camp to the Kerry camp if he convinces you on Domestic issues? :o

 

Dude, Bush is so toast. His domestic record is appallingly bad. He has a lot of explaining to do.

577875[/snapback]

 

Domestic issues are very important to me. It's my most liberal area. If I vote for Bush, it will be only reluctantly, because I know how irresponsible the current Administration is (in that respect).

 

I am far right on foreign policy and social issues. I can't vote for a Democrat, Lina, I just can't.

i really don't know where the media gets this crap that cheney will out debate edwards. if anything IMHO edwards will beat cheney.

I highly doubt Cheney will beat Edwards.

 

Edwards is just as smart, more articulate, more believable, and more real.

 

American people don't connect with Cheney. They do with Edwards. Edwards is the All American boy, the quintessential American dream. And he's not just good looks and a feel good story, he has the substance to back it up.

 

Theres a reason that he was probably the most underestimated candidate in the Democratic Presidential Field, coming from literally dead last to finishing 2nd place overall ahead of highly touted favorites Dean and Clark, to becoming the VP Nominee.

 

Cheney and Edwards are worthy adversaries. But in the end, I think that Sen. Edwards experience as a trial lawyer and his knowing how to attack Cheney on halliburton and Iraq and making Cheney look to be completely heartless.

 

Cheney is very good though, and will be a great matchup for my political idol (Sen. Edwards)

Cheney means business. But Edwards is a trial lawyer. Two powerhouses, IMO. People underestimate Cheney.

Kerry's bilateral DPRK negotiations stance is completely bogus - he takes it only because its not Bush's position.

 

Its plain as day the DPRK is looking to extort bribes/aid.

 

It would clearly cost the US less if the ultimate cost of those bribes/aid are spread around among more of the concerned nations in the area.

578060[/snapback]

 

tonyi, did Bush make the points better than Kerry on this subject last night or is this going to be a thread with tonyi making the points Bush was supposed to make?

578126[/snapback]

 

What I feel is not relevant.

 

Kerry has maintained that DPRK is/was a larger threat than Iraq. For the sake of argument, I will take Kerry at his word on this.

 

Are YOU comfortable with the Kerry bi-lateral approach to dealing with the DPRK? Yes or no.

 

Do YOU feel its some how OK to take the Kerry solo approach there, while whining about needing coalitions elsewhere? Yes or no. If yes, justify how this situation is different, warranting a different solo approach?

 

Do YOU feel that maybe, just maybe, the likes of the PRC, Japan, Russia, ROK will feel somewhat snubbed by the US taking this solo approach and ignoring their obvious interest in the stability of the area? Yes or no.

 

Do you feel the burden of the bribes/aid that will undoubtedly be given to DPRK should be shared by others with interests in the region? Yes or no.

 

Assuming DPRK is a larger threat than Iraq as claimed by Kerry, then would you agree that chosing the right policy on DPRK is even more important than anything in Iraq? Yes or no.

578406[/snapback]

Wow, youve taken hijacking a thread to a whole new level.

Bush and Kerry are somewhat even as debaters but Edwards will crush Cheney.

578781[/snapback]

Just like he did in the primary debates??? :blink:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.