October 2, 200422 yr I have to admit Kerry did win this debate. He kept his cool the whole time, wouldn't botch up his lines, pick his teeth, or purse his lips like Bush did. I think everybody can agree that Kerry won the debate. On the Vice President debate I think Edwards is gonna make Cheney look like a piece of sh*t. I don't even have to give details.
October 2, 200422 yr Don't be so fast to dismiss Cheney. I think Edwards will win, but Cheney is the calm confident politican, if he can rile Edwards with some half-turth, Edwards will go full scale trial lawyer on him. That doesn't look as good in a presidential debate as it does in a courtroom.
October 2, 200422 yr Why do so many people think Cheney will be crushed by Edwards. Cheney did pretty good in 2000.
October 2, 200422 yr Why do so many people think Cheney will be crushed by Edwards. Cheney did pretty good in 2000. 578965[/snapback] Joe Lieberman wasnt exactly the same caliber as John Edwards
October 2, 200422 yr Wow, youve taken hijacking a thread to a whole new level. 578815[/snapback] Perhaps I'm mistaken, but I recalled the DPRK being mentioned in the debate. Correct me if I'm wrong of course... I also recall Kerry mentioning the DPRK as more a threat than Iraq...correct me if I'm wrong of course... If the DPRK is more a threat than Iraq as claimed, then it follows logically that the candidates answers on the DPRK are more important than those on Iraq even though this issue was given short shrift and not well explored in the debate. Since this is a thread on who won the debate, examining who "won" the more important issue (by Kerry's own definition) seems perfectly relevant...correct me if I'm wrong of course... I notice you chose to not answer any of the question I posed. One presumes this is because the only logical answers don't fit well with the Kerry position and are causing some pretty rough cognitive dissonance right now. 579009[/snapback] What you are trying to do to save face for Bush is to drive this into a debate elswhere. You want me and other democrats defending Kerry's view of DPKR vs YOUR defense of Bush's view on DPKR. The issue at hand is who made their case better between Bush and Kerry at the frikkin debate itself. Listen, Ill make this simple for you. Lets say Bush and Kerry are debating say, whether the Earth is flat or round. If Bush more effectivley argues that the Earth is flat and Kerry stumbles and doesnt do a good job in arguing that the Earth is round and this is an issue that is debatable at its time, then clearly Bush would win. Then I come in ex post facto with all sorts of arguments that the Kerry's view on the Earth is actually right. Then, taking the tonyi approach, I argue that via this after fact data, Kerry actually won the debate! Thats exactly what you are trying to do. Draw this away from the thread. Do I think Kerry outdid Bush on this issue? Based on style, yes. Bush looked bad. Based on substance? Id also argue Kerry won this because he managed to highlight Bush's view on this. How can Bush argue that he wont allow other nations to protect the US against threats then at the same time argue that North Korea should be dealt with by China?(uh oh, is this flip flopping?) He effectivley got Bush on the defensiv and got him to defend multilateralism, which is preciscley what Bush attacks Kerry for! In doing so, on the substantive issue of how to deal with threats, Kerry won by making Bush defend Kerry. All this happend AT THE DEBATE ITSELF. But you come riding in arguing Bush actually won if you go into the details. You suffer from serious hindsight problems. Now Kerry sayng North Korea was a bigger threat than Iraq doesnt mean the whole debate should even be centralized to this. Most of the debate was about foreign policy and Kerry was resolute while getting Bush to defend his foreign policy. What was all this in response to? The claim that Bush won the debate itself on substance which you nor anyone else has yet to hold up without resorting to Monday morning QBing. As far as the meager attempt to change the thread itself and get me to defend Kerry's debate statments, I wont because I wont be pigeonholed into either candidates views out of convenience for you. Personally I think there is a third approach and I think Kerry will take it. I think he only used bilateralism to come off tough to the average person watching, which clearly he did. Im sure Kerry will reconcile the broken hearts of those nations somehow. And its foolish for you to call Kerry a hypocrite because a)that would also make Bush a hypocrite since he demands unilaterism with Iraq but leaving it to China with DPRK(of course you wont address this) and b)Bush unilaterally INVADED Iraq and outwardly told the the rest of the world to go to hell wheras Kerry is talking about negotiations and has not commited the idiocy Bush has yet..you foolishly assume he will..he has no neocons to botch it up. And in addition, you make Bush look more hypocritical when you assert that DPKR would simply bribe us. I mean isnt it Bush who rants about how he has created threat capital? Dont nations now know not to screw with the US as we would be willing to strike? Doesnt he always snide about how Libya shat themselves? But wait...DPRK would blackmail us? Great example of neocon hypocrisy. But is any of this relevant? No. If you and I get into a debate about multilaterism vs unilateralism, this thread dies in a statemate of both sides standing in distinctions. It would effectivley be pointless. Of course thats precisley what you want lest Bush looks bad. Maybe thats why nobody has actually been able to support the claim that Bush was better in the substance OF THE DEBATE itself? Thought so.
October 3, 200422 yr That's the thing about Cheney. His half truths will be very evident. And the thing about Edwards when he becomes the "trial lawyer" people won't even be able to tell he is in that "mode" because he's so smooth, and I mean this, that people don't even know he's in lawyer mode. Look at Kerry, who prosecuted Bush, literally prosecuted Bush. There's no way, none, that Kerry is a better lawyer then Edwards. And the thing is, Edwards and Cheney are very equal adversaries. I believe in the end my guy will win, but not by a substantial margain. Not by as much as Kerry beat Bush.
October 3, 200422 yr That's the thing about Cheney. His half truths will be very evident. And the thing about Edwards when he becomes the "trial lawyer" people won't even be able to tell he is in that "mode" because he's so smooth, and I mean this, that people don't even know he's in lawyer mode. Look at Kerry, who prosecuted Bush, literally prosecuted Bush. There's no way, none, that Kerry is a better lawyer then Edwards. And the thing is, Edwards and Cheney are very equal adversaries. I believe in the end my guy will win, but not by a substantial margain. Not by as much as Kerry beat Bush. 579361[/snapback] It would be cool if they let Edwards just cook Cheney about Halliburton, Cheney would keel over of a heart attack right there,
October 3, 200422 yr Hes probably in cahoots with jong-il and plans to help him set off a nuke in the US so that he can spread Communism throughout the land in the aftermath.
October 3, 200422 yr Kerry mentioned something kinda interesting. He says we using only American troops in Afganistan. Then he says the whole "90% casualities" thing to criticize the large proportion U.S. troops in Iraq. :o Which is it, Johny, should we have more non-American troops or not?
October 3, 200422 yr Author Kerry mentioned something kinda interesting.? He says we using only American troops in Afganistan.? Then he says the whole "90% casualities" thing to criticize the large proportion U.S. troops in Iraq.? :o Which is it, Johny, should we have more non-American troops or not? 579973[/snapback] He talked about not outsourcing the job of catching Bin Laden to warlords in Afghanistan. Get your facts straight. Plus, he also said that while Afghanistan WAS the center of the war on terror we almost completely left that country to go into the ill conceived war in Iraq. And yes, 90% of the casualties and costs in Iraq are beared by the United States. It didn't have to be, but Mr. Arrogant Bush thinks he can do it all by himself... We all know how that has worked out.
October 3, 200422 yr Anyone see the debate on SNL?? Bush was complaining how hard it was. Meanwhile, Kerry said he clearly wasn't a flip flopper since he talked for the war to pro-war supporters and against the war to anti-war supporters.
October 3, 200422 yr Wow, youve taken hijacking a thread to a whole new level. 578815[/snapback] Perhaps I'm mistaken, but I recalled the DPRK being mentioned in the debate. Correct me if I'm wrong of course... I also recall Kerry mentioning the DPRK as more a threat than Iraq...correct me if I'm wrong of course... If the DPRK is more a threat than Iraq as claimed, then it follows logically that the candidates answers on the DPRK are more important than those on Iraq even though this issue was given short shrift and not well explored in the debate. Since this is a thread on who won the debate, examining who "won" the more important issue (by Kerry's own definition) seems perfectly relevant...correct me if I'm wrong of course... I notice you chose to not answer any of the question I posed. One presumes this is because the only logical answers don't fit well with the Kerry position and are causing some pretty rough cognitive dissonance right now. 579009[/snapback] What you are trying to do to save face for Bush is to drive this into a debate elswhere. You want me and other democrats defending Kerry's view of DPKR vs YOUR defense of Bush's view on DPKR. The issue at hand is who made their case better between Bush and Kerry at the frikkin debate itself. 579198[/snapback] Apparently you believe the Kerry "go it alone" approach to the DPRK is the correct one. All I want is the dems who agree with this to defend it in a manner that makes sense logically (and fiscally) for Americans. Since Kerry himself feels the DPRK is/was a bigger issue than Iraq, logically it follows that the resolution of the DPRK issue is more important. Thusfar all we've heard is Kerry state a position that appears on the surface to be quite irresponsible, NOT defend it with anything resembling a strategically or fiscally thoughtful and responsible analysis. Since Kerry dodged the issue, maybe YOU can explain his seemingly illogical stance? 579591[/snapback] Ultimatley, I think if Kerry is elected, he will not undergo a strict go it alone policy but wont ignore it the way Bush has. I imagine he'll take a middle road. But I do think his assertion of bilateralism was brilliant. He effectivley made Bush assert the same policy that he critisizes Kerry for. Like I said, he made Bush defend Kerry. To me its no different than Reagen and taxes in 1984.
October 4, 200422 yr Ultimatley, I think if Kerry is elected, he will not undergo a strict go it alone policy but wont ignore it the way Bush has. 580454[/snapback] How would YOU have "not ignored" it? Its pretty obvious what the DPRK is after - bribes/aid. By "ignoring" them, the message was sent that the US wasn't interested in rewarding extortionists - I believe that's the appropriate message to send. Apparently you feel otherwise. As I said before, I'd like to see someone defend the Kerry "solo" in a meaningful way that makes sense logically. 580968[/snapback] And Id like to see you defend the position that Bush won the debate itself on substance in a way that makes sense logically but clearly youve avoided that one.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.