Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Encarnacion gets head start

Featured Replies

Encarnacion gets head start

 

By Juan C. Rodriguez

Staff Writer

Posted February 23 2005

 

JUPITER ? The way Juan Encarnacion sees it, the Carlos Delgado acquisition didn't leave the Marlins with a crowded outfield. Cozy, perhaps, but not crowded.

 

Three years ago, Encarnacion was in more suffocating circumstances as a member of the Reds. He was part of a group that included Ken Griffey Jr., Adam Dunn, Austin Kearns, Reggie Taylor, Jose Guillen, Ruben Mateo and Wily Mo Pena.

 

Before the Reds traded him to the Marlins that July, Encarnacion saw plenty of playing time. He started a team-high 57 games in center and was second to Kearns with 24 starts in right. He started all but two of the 83 games in which he appeared.

 

"I like things like this," Encarnacion said, referring to competition.

 

This spring he will vie with Jeff Conine, who underwent two offseason right shoulder surgeries, for playing time in right. Conine won't be cleared to participate in full baseball activities until early next month, but Encarnacion has been hitting since December.

 

"I didn't think about it too much," Encarnacion said of coming to spring training without a cemented role. "You just have to have confidence in what you can do. I was more worried when I couldn't do things."

 

Last season, Encarnacion played through a torn labrum that robbed his swing of power. He developed a hitch where he would have to lift the shoulder before taking his cut.

 

The results were career lows in batting average (.236) and slugging percentage (.405). Due $4.435 million, $1.425 million more than Conine, Encarnacion said he put on 10 pounds and is primed for a bounce-back season.

 

"The difference is from the sky to the earth," Encarnacion said. "I couldn't lift my arm. Now I can. It's a big difference. ... I don't think they're going to pay me so I can sit on the bench. There are other teams that need [right fielders]."

 

 

 

Link to Full Article

 

It's great to see Encarnacion is motivated to have a good year. He's the odds-on favorite to start in RF, IMO.

I've said often herein that I just feel this will be the year that Enc finally starts to show his talents consistently.

I see Conine as a back-up corner OF (LF, RF) and 1B and critical pinch hitter.

Conine is valuable! But, his ST prep is already restricted, being held back from facing live pitching.

Opening Day is Encarnacion's to lose.

I think he'll be in there.

Too many years his talent has gone to waste. You've got to wonder if that talent actually exists.

I hope he proves me wrong - but I think he's in for another poor season. If I remember correctly, he only started all those games for the reds b/c they were looking to shop him at the trading deadline (for Dempster ultimately) b/c he was defintely not in their plans the next year. He wasn't given the starting job over all those guys because he was outplaying everyone. And I also believe Griffey wasn't healthy during the beginning of that season and Kearns was coming off of his rookie call-up, but I may be mistaken about that. Saying he outplayed the competiton of Reggie Taylor, Ruben Mateo and Wily Mo Pena is laughable. I find it amusing that he enjoys this kind of competition, seeing as he was soundly outplayed by Cabs during the home stretch of 2003, and didn't really RISE to his competition during the post-season.

 

IMO, Eric is an out-machine. His penchant for getting outs and failing to drive in runs is only exceeded by his untimely hitting, and is completely unacceptable for a corner OF.

I hope he proves me wrong - but I think he's in for another poor season. If I remember correctly, he only started all those games for the reds b/c they were looking to shop him at the trading deadline (for Dempster ultimately) b/c he was defintely not in their plans the next year. He wasn't given the starting job over all those guys because he was outplaying everyone. And I also believe Griffey wasn't healthy during the beginning of that season and Kearns was coming off of his rookie call-up, but I may be mistaken about that. Saying he outplayed the competiton of Reggie Taylor, Ruben Mateo and Wily Mo Pena is laughable. I find it amusing that he enjoys this kind of competition, seeing as he was soundly outplayed by Cabs during the home stretch of 2003, and didn't really RISE to his competition during the post-season.

 

IMO, Eric is an out-machine. His penchant for getting outs and failing to drive in runs is only exceeded by his untimely hitting, and is completely unacceptable for a corner OF.

693201[/snapback]

 

 

Being outplayed by Miggy isn't exactly the worse thing in the world, you make it sound as if Miggy is some sort of chump... Miggy is probably a superstar in the making. I personally think Encarnacion can have a better year than 2003 precisely because it's his walk-off year... and I think that could mean .285, 20-25hr, and 100 rbi.

failing to drive in runs is only exceeded by his untimely hitting, and is completely unacceptable for a corner OF.

693201[/snapback]

Before anyone attempts to correct you...

 

Situation Career 2004 2003 2002

Runners On .256 .238 .273 .259

Scoring Position .255 .274 .262 .257

 

RBI rate (RBI/runners)

2004 .139

2003 .165

2002 .150

 

Rather unspectacular numbers.

He is likely the worst hitter among NL OF regulars over the past few seasons, even while healthy. He's never met a DP chance he didn't want to ground into, except for the ones where he strikes out. He is Gonzalez without the whole slick-fielding SS thing. He would make a great AAAA ballplayer, unfortunately for him, the minors stop at AAA.

 

But he did crush that ball at Wrigley during game 1 of the NLCS, so he's the man.

I'm optimistic about Enc this season, although unless Niner isn't ready, I can't see where they will find playing time. Platooning them doesnt make a lot of sense, since they're both tight-handed, and platooning can lead to inconsitent hitting (particularly for Niner, who is solid normally).

Being outplayed by Miggy isn't exactly the worse thing in the world, you make it sound as if Miggy is some sort of chump... Miggy is probably a superstar in the making. I personally think Encarnacion can have a better year than 2003 precisely because it's his walk-off year... and I think that could mean .285, 20-25hr, and 100 rbi.

693211[/snapback]

 

Of course Miggy isn't a chump. We owe it to Encarnacion's horrible and untimely hitting that we allowed Miggy to shift to the OF when Lowell was healthy. Trader Jack usually doesn't like playing rookies over veterans when the veterans are performing OK. Oh, and I believe Niner is in a walk-off year too.

 

By the way, the last time we had Eric for a walk-off year, he played himself right onto the bench and we allowed him to walk-off with no contract offer. He's EXACTLY like Alex Gonzalez...but at least Alex is robbed of a gold-glove every year because he can't hit - rather than allowing Encarnacion to stay on the team because he can throw the ball from the wall in RF all the way into the visitor's dugout (and usually does during the game). IMO he's the worst OF regular in the majors - and he belongs on a long list of 5-tool players that don't ever reach a tenth of their potential.

 

I'm usually not this harsh, but I'm still peeved that we had to take this guy off the Dodger's payroll. I've said this before on this forum - if Encarnacion proves me wrong - I'd gladly eat my hat...because it would mean that I'd have to buy a brand spanking new Marlins 2005 WS Champs hat.

hopefully hell be great this year. And i dont like the idea of the Marlins paying him all that money and not using the guy. Enc is healthy now and that makes a world of difference. I dont like his personality much but that doesnt interfere with how well he can play."The difference is from the sky to the earth," Encarnacion said. "I couldn't lift my arm. Now I can. It's a big difference. ... I don't think they're going to pay me so I can sit on the bench. There are other teams that need [right fielders]." I like his attitude there. Hopefully he can back it up with awsome game. And being outplayed by Miggy isnt out of the world awful. Migs is a monster, so i dont see how that is comparable.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.