July 15, 200521 yr Author Actually firing teachers that arent getting the job done is very common and has been effective in the past, just like firing managers wh oarent getting the job done. 856733[/snapback] yep. you're right. it was a weak point. i take it back.
July 15, 200521 yr I am sick of all these people saying this season is Jack's fault. Last I checked all Jack is SUPPOSED to do is make up a lineup card, sit on the bench, and make some pinch hit moves. I am not saying that I agree w/ his strategy sometimes, but that is just his style. The same style that won in 03. Jack doesn't pitch on the mound and give up 3 Home Runs in one inning (not one of them going to the Home Run Derby Champion) and will later ask for $10mil a year even though he barely has a .500 career record.. Jack doesn't get paid a couple of million dollars and barely hits .250 and has 12 less home runs than he did this time a year ago. Jack also does not let runners steal bases as they please. Oh yeah, and Jack isn't sitting in our 3 and 4th spot and combined has more than 100 strikeouts from the 2 most important spots in the lineup. And also, Jack doesn't have the weakest CF's arm in baseball so ANYTHING hit to center field will easily score a runner from 2nd with no hesitation. Not to mention struggles to get on base as well which is the only reason he is even playing CF. You see, Jack does none of these things yet he is to blame for all of it? I understand the mentality of when the going gets rough look at management. But this has been going on since May. This guy is not the problem......yet. I agree that managerial changes are a nesesary evil in baseball. But I believe this is a tad premature for a person who brought a team from the depths of the NL East and suprised everyone just 2 years ago and was in the WC hunt last year. No, you don't go on forver expecting mediocre baseball being played. But point less fingers at the person who sits on the bench and more at the players on the field. 856523[/snapback] Although I agree it is a bit unfair to call for Jack's head, I am certainly going to do it. Back in '03, we were underperforming too - by my estimation, anyway. I thought we were a playoff team going into that season and when Torborg was managing, I was one of the ones who said that firing him wouldnt change anything. Well, I was wrong - it did. But I was right in that the team had been underperforming to that point. Same thing here. The reason why we won in '03 had more to do with the style of ball we HAD to play. We had to generate runs through aggressive baserunning and moving the runner over. Smallball. Not sitting around and waiting for Cabs or Delgado to hit a blast. In '03, Jack had no choice. This year, he has continuously gone away from small ball. And only until recently when JP started stealing bases again did we start to win games. Jack messes with the lineup too much, and doesnt even put the best lineup on the field half the time. He leaves his starters in too long. He seems to find the wrong relievers too often. It just isnt clicking. And his curmudgeonly style is not helping things. Resop has very little confidence because of Jack, as did Kensing. Who knows if Olsen can weather his wrath, only time will tell. And now, Vargas will step into the fire. Right man, wrong time.
July 15, 200521 yr "Resop has very little confidence because of Jack" and how is this. just curious? 856767[/snapback] actually before last night Chris was extremely confident.... Resop looked different last night, maybe mechanics or something... wonder if WIley spoke with him on something
July 15, 200521 yr "Resop has very little confidence because of Jack" and how is this. just curious? 856767[/snapback] I dont know if you ever had a hard-a$$ manager in your life, or boss for that matter, but in that situation, one tends to press a little too hard. Instead of being relaxed, you get tense. Every mistake becomes even more scrutinized. Resop is pitching on thin ice with Jack. Dont you ever wonder why Rob Dibble cant stand Jack? Think about it - it doesnt come ex nihilo. I just noticed that after Resop got blown up out there, he looked dejected. Not because he gave up some more runs, no. It was that kind of night for the Phils. But it seemed that he came apart very early, although he was pitching pretty well to that point. He had gotten one out and looked to cruise through the inning. Just seems like he couldnt work through it because there is pressure coming from that dugout.
July 15, 200521 yr I think Resop just didn't have it last night, and that happens to every pitcher (hmm...look at AJ's performance) and to read more into it may be a mistake.
July 15, 200521 yr Why doesn't Dubble like Jack? Please tell me about that. I am not familiar with the situation. From my understanding, McKeon dislikes one thing: Pitchers who tend not to challenge hitters>>>leading to walks.
July 15, 200521 yr Author Although I agree it is a bit unfair to call for Jack's head, I am certainly going to do it. Back in '03, we were underperforming too - by my estimation, anyway. I thought we were a playoff team going into that season and when Torborg was managing, I was one of the ones who said that firing him wouldnt change anything. Well, I was wrong - it did. But I was right in that the team had been underperforming to that point. Same thing here. The reason why we won in '03 had more to do with the style of ball we HAD to play. We had to generate runs through aggressive baserunning and moving the runner over. Smallball. Not sitting around and waiting for Cabs or Delgado to hit a blast. In '03, Jack had no choice. This year, he has continuously gone away from small ball. And only until recently when JP started stealing bases again did we start to win games. Jack messes with the lineup too much, and doesnt even put the best lineup on the field half the time. He leaves his starters in too long. He seems to find the wrong relievers too often. It just isnt clicking. And his curmudgeonly style is not helping things. Resop has very little confidence because of Jack, as did Kensing. Who knows if Olsen can weather his wrath, only time will tell. And now, Vargas will step into the fire. Right man, wrong time. 856759[/snapback] Yep, i agree with you that we don't play enough small ball. But remember, you have a lead weight @ the 4th spot in delgado. and you dont want to take the bat out of your best hitter in miguel. nor do you want to move those guys down. you dont really want to bunt w/ castillo because jp can steal bags (as he tries to whenever he gets on as the leadoff guy). so tell me where the small ball is coming in? Enc and loduca as a hit and run combo? because you cant do it w/ lowell. enc doesnt have THAT great of speed to steal bags. so you are giving up outs here. Basicly what I'm asking you is this: Where do we play the small ball? I posted earlier that Jack's brash attitude would be cancerous to the team. I think he's calmed down a bit but who knows. We arent in the club house. Plus, he isnt a Minor League manager. If he puts you into the game he expects you to get outs. He's not going to baby you in the pros. Thats why we have Minor League managers. So if they cant handle the pressure then GET OUT OF THE KITCHEN!
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.