Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Greatest Individual Seasons Ever: Nominations

Featured Replies

That was a great season by Seaver, but I would take Pedro's season in 2000. He went 18-6, 1.74 ERA, 217 IP, 284 SO, and a whip of 0.74(!!!!). I don't know how in the world he didn't win more games that season. And he posted those numbers at the height of MLB's offensive outburst.

 

 

18 CG. That's mind blowing.

 

For us it is, but it wasn't all that uncommon back then. It's hard to compare pitchers of different eras. There was so much more offense in the late 90's into the early 2000's.

  • Author

Ruth 1921, Cobb 1911, McClain 1968, Bob Gibson 1968, Matthewson 1905, Maddux 1995, Koufax 1965, Bonds 2002, Seaver 1969, Pedro 2000, Ted Williams 1941, Bonds 1993, Gehrig 1927, Bonds 2001, Walter Johnson 1913, DiMaggio 1941, Sosa 2001, Lefty Grove 1931,

 

and i'm not really sure if mantle's 1961, maris's 1961 or just a comment was what that was, so im not gonna put em on the list

 

lets keep this alive and fill out the field, this could be real interesting

Here's a good one for you

 

1892 Cy Young

 

36 wins

48 Complete Games

9 Shut outs

1.93ERA

168Ks

Mickey Mantle, 1956

 

.353/.464/.705 52 HR 130 RBI (Triple Crown)

 

Jimmie Foxx, 1932

 

.364/469/.749 58 HR 169 RBI

  • Author

good call on foxx that was the other one i was waiting for

 

11 more slots til the opening round goes up

I'll be damned if this one doesn't go up there

 

1922 Rogers Hornsby

 

.401BA

42 Homeruns

250 Hits

152RBIs

46 2B/ 14 3B

.722 Slg

 

1,181 OPS

 

That's amazing. Hornsby has to be one of the most underrated players of all-time.

Steve Carlton, 1972 Phillies

 

27-10

8 Shutouts

1.97 ERA

30 CGs

Team went 59-97

amazing what playing in colorado can do. one of the best all around years in the last 50 (aside from the dubious numbers of bonds/sosa)

 

Admin Walker 1997

 

Avg - .363

HR - 49

RBI - 130

SB - 33

OPS - 1.172

 

NL MVP, Gold Glove

Bond's best season, 1993:

 

.336 BA

46 HR (led league)

123 RBI

.458 OBP (led league)

.677 SLG% (led league)

129 runs

126 BB

29 SB

Gold Glove

 

OMGBONDSROIDERHEHADNOPOWERWHENHEWASYOUNG!!!!!!!!!!

 

:plain

 

Bonds 2001

.328/.515/.863

73 HRs

137 RBI

13 SB

177 BB

Lets see Bonds had a better OBP, slugghing %, more homers(ovbiously), more RBIs, and more walks so how is his best season 93?

Here's a nice little sleeper pick that should go far

 

Denny McClain- 1968

 

31-6 W/L

1.96 ERA

28 CG

280 K's/63 BB

0.90 WHIP

 

for pitchers this is far and away #1 IMO

Bonds best season was 96...offensively he had a few better seasons, but this season emodies what he's been for most of his career, and that's the ultimate 5-tool player...one of just three 40/40 seasons and the only 40/40 season with a gold glove to boot

while I'm at it, I'll nominate the other two 40/40 seasons as well...Jose Canseco in 1988 and Alex Rodriguez in 1998

The greatest offensive season ever was Bonds in 2004...first time in baseball history a guy got on base over 60% of the time...not to mention a slugging percentage above .800 and the only OPS above 1.400

Another season the deserves mention: Rickey Henderson in 1982...130 steals is one of those records that will never be broken

Speaking of McLain, I his autograph yesterday when he was signing in SF...the guy must weigh 300 lbs. now

Here's a nice little sleeper pick that should go far

 

Denny McClain- 1968

 

31-6 W/L

1.96 ERA

28 CG

280 K's/63 BB

0.90 WHIP

 

for pitchers this is far and away #1 IMO

Bonds best season was 96...offensively he had a few better seasons, but this season emodies what he's been for most of his career, and that's the ultimate 5-tool player...one of just three 40/40 seasons and the only 40/40 season with a gold glove to boot

while I'm at it, I'll nominate the other two 40/40 seasons as well...Jose Canseco in 1988 and Alex Rodriguez in 1998

The greatest offensive season ever was Bonds in 2004...first time in baseball history a guy got on base over 60% of the time...not to mention a slugging percentage above .800 and the only OPS above 1.400

Another season the deserves mention: Rickey Henderson in 1982...130 steals is one of those records that will never be broken

Speaking of McLain, I his autograph yesterday when he was signing in SF...the guy must weigh 300 lbs. now

 

Wait, I'm confused, how can '96 be Bonds' best season while Bonds' 2004 was the "greatest offensive season ever."?

Here's a nice little sleeper pick that should go far

 

Denny McClain- 1968

 

31-6 W/L

1.96 ERA

28 CG

280 K's/63 BB

0.90 WHIP

 

for pitchers this is far and away #1 IMO

Bonds best season was 96...offensively he had a few better seasons, but this season emodies what he's been for most of his career, and that's the ultimate 5-tool player...one of just three 40/40 seasons and the only 40/40 season with a gold glove to boot

while I'm at it, I'll nominate the other two 40/40 seasons as well...Jose Canseco in 1988 and Alex Rodriguez in 1998

The greatest offensive season ever was Bonds in 2004...first time in baseball history a guy got on base over 60% of the time...not to mention a slugging percentage above .800 and the only OPS above 1.400

Another season the deserves mention: Rickey Henderson in 1982...130 steals is one of those records that will never be broken

Speaking of McLain, I his autograph yesterday when he was signing in SF...the guy must weigh 300 lbs. now

 

Wait, I'm confused, how can '96 be Bonds' best season while Bonds' 2004 was the "greatest offensive season ever."?

offensively, he was at his best in 04, but factor in defense and baserunning, and 96 was better

  • Author

Ruth 1921, Cobb 1911, McClain 1968, Bob Gibson 1968, Matthewson 1905, Maddux 1995, Koufax 1965, Bonds 2002, Seaver 1969, Pedro 2000, Ted Williams 1941, Bonds 1993, Gehrig 1927, Bonds 2001, Walter Johnson 1913, DiMaggio 1941, Sosa 2001, Lefty Grove 1931, Cy Young 1892, Mantle 1956, Foxx 1932, Hornsby 1922, Carlton 1972, Admin Walker 1997, Bonds 1996, Canseco 1988, Rodriguez 1998, Bonds 2004, Rickey Henderson 1982

 

sorry i haven't updated it lately i haven't really been around.

 

Those are the 29 so far up there. 3 more slots.

McGwire 98 deserves mentioning...as does Bonds' 2003...while statistically it wasn't even close to his best season, considering what he had to deal with throughout the season made it his most impressive

  • Author

alright thats 32 right there then

 

i'll try to get one bracket's first round matchups up soon, I have to do some seeding and such

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.