May 7, 200719 yr And what is that? Please enlighten me. Are you the only one that attempts to make money? I really don't follow. You're exactly the same team. You spend gobs of money because you have gobs of money. The business plan is the same. Both own their airwaves. Both turn their logo into a merchandising empire that uses the sport as a secondary selling point and the logo first and foremost. Is the Red Sox roster not also almost completely composed of free-agents and not internally developed players? So, what exactly is done so vastly different up in good ol' Beantown that they don't do in the Bronx? I don't know why I even entertain these 'discussions' with the czar of baseball intelect and a poster who I've never seen back away from a stance no matter what it is but I'm an incredibly stubborn person. I'll give you some quotes by Theo Epstein, from behind closed doors in the Red Sox front office that spells out the disconnect between the Yankees and Red Sox. (These were made after the 2005 season) and what eventually led to him leaving the club before being brought back because of the old disconnect between how he felt (and how it currently is) the team should be run and how the PR guys like Lucchinno thought it should be run. "We sat here in April talking about building an uber-team. That's dangerous. That's very dangerous. We need to be aware of the potential that the bubble could burst. Yes, it's a pro that on the business side we continue to grow. But on the con side is the ammount of hype as we move toward superpower status. Yes, we won 95 games this year, but this approach isn't really sustainable over the long run. Sooner or later we might need to take half a step backward in return for a step forward....I warned about this in April. What if we win 85 games (In 2006)? We're bringing up some young players that are going to be better in '07 than they will be next year. And they'll probably be even better then that in '08." "We can't always make ourselves out to be a superpower. For our part, on the baseball operations side, we know that's not an effective strategy." "That has to be reinforced on the public level. We may be reaching a saturation point. We keep asking for more, more, more. But there will be a point where we don't do more one year because we need to do things for the long term." "We have the long term solution to that problem. We can be both a large revenue club and have a strong farm system. But it's probably not going to be a seamless transition. This year we had a great year. We will probably be worse next year." Almost prophetic in these quotes about 2006 (he also predicted the Sox would win 85 games in '06 [they won 86] and how second baseman Dustin Pedroia would struggle when he was called up). The Yankees will continue to patch and patch and patch away at problems by throwing obscene ammounts of money at it because as an organization they never want to have that half-step back year like Boston had in '06 for something greater in the future. I think an easy example of the difference between the two is letting Pedro Martinez and Damon go for cheaper and long term better solutions. You're completely double talking. The team on the field is absolutely not reflective of those comments. That strong farmsystem? Well, I'd argue the jewel of it at the time of those comments is now playing short-stop in Miami. That rotation and outfield is completely the product of other team's development (until Lester comes back), and all but one regular position player (Youkilis) plus Pedroia if he can fend off Alex Cora. That quote's great, fantastic, but I don't think his words are at all indicative of his actions. He spent gonzo money on Drew and Lugo. He put an obscene amount of money on Matsuzaka, and if Gammons is to be believed, was considering offering a prorated $18 mil to Clemens, on top of a team that is already 5 SP deep. If that isn't an embarrassment of riches, I don't know what is. Sure, maybe you didn't shop at Barney's like the Yankees, but you definitely did some shopping at Saks and Bergdorf's and still have a payroll that only 4 or 5 teams could ever dream about. Are you allowed to do it? Absolutely, but to pretend that you're something completely different than the Yankees, or Mets or Dodgers or Angels is downright uninformed, and it's almost absurd that you pull up 2005 quotes to justify the 2007 team when so much in that philosophy was abandoned this past offseason (and to a degree, that 2005 offseason as well).
May 7, 200719 yr Thats fine and dandy to say that, but it really doesnt carry that much weight when they spend 70 million on jd drew, over 100 million on dice k, and lugos salary all in one offseason. If that is all you took from that you know absolutely nothing about the Red Sox organization. Again, if signing people is bad (I've never said the Yankees are bad because they sign people, that is retarded) then there is no point discussing this. My whole point, and one you chose to miss is there is a difference between how the Yankees conduct their business and how the Red Sox do. Its not just as cut and dry as large payrolls and signing free agents. I know enough about their organization, I happen to live in new england. I've probably been to more games at fenway than you have. Signing people is fine and if any team can pay for the players then I am all for it. Both teams are trying to strenghten their farm systems, both sign certain players and both have the highest payrolls in the mlb. So what if you get lumped with the yankees?
May 7, 200719 yr Thats a good point. Just off the top of my head they signed JD Drew, Manny, Ortiz (I'll give them credit because he wasnt good when they signed him), Lugo, Dice-K, Coco (I believe). Lets also not forget they got Lowell and Beckett because the marlins couldnt afford them. How is that different from the yankees? That is where the disconnect occurs. To me it seems (correct me if I am wrong) that you percieve signing free agents as evil. I will never criticize a team for signing free agents if it makes sense. I love free agency. I love owners that spend. Steinbrenner is the best owner in sports in terms of investing money he makes on the team back in to the team because he cares so much about winning. I've said before on this board I believe Steinbrenner should go in to the Hall of Fame for the way he embraced the changing baseball economics (there was a time in baseball where the owners all had an under the table agreement not to 'cave in' to free agency when it began and not negotiate with any of the players on the open market) and how he revolutionized the game that way. I don't get why you and others commend a move like Ortiz because they got payoff for very little. Is that the only way a deal is good or a team is good when it wins with only home grown talent or gets more from a player then they paid for? If you believe this, it's fine and your opinion but there is little I can say to change your stance. Manny is a bad move because he was a young man entering his prime and they gave him money to do that for them? How is that 'wrong'? If you believe signing free agents is bad then I just can't continue this conversation because we will be getting nowhere. I dont have a problem with free agency. The yankees can sign anyone they want and so can the red sox. I just dont understand why redsox fans think they arent like the yankees now? They have the second highest payroll and spent $200 million on three players last offseason. If the marlins could spend that much I would want them too. However, if we were spending that much and we were lumped in with the yankees I would have to agree. If you don't see a difference in the talent and team the Red Sox have constructed as opposed to the Yankees well again, I can't really get in to this discussion much more. 200 million? What are you talking about? The Red Sox are paying those 3 players about 30 million collectively a year and if you want to look at the total ammount of their salaries at the time of signing, which has little to do with anything when you are talking about the overall long term strength of a franchise, etc. the deals ammount to a total of 158 million (5/70, 6/52, and 4/36). Again, I have no idea what that has to do with anything to dispute the points I have made between the fundamental difference between the way the two conduct business. The Red Sox are going to have about 35 million coming off the books this year.
May 7, 200719 yr Thats a good point. Just off the top of my head they signed JD Drew, Manny, Ortiz (I'll give them credit because he wasnt good when they signed him), Lugo, Dice-K, Coco (I believe). Lets also not forget they got Lowell and Beckett because the marlins couldnt afford them. How is that different from the yankees? That is where the disconnect occurs. To me it seems (correct me if I am wrong) that you percieve signing free agents as evil. I will never criticize a team for signing free agents if it makes sense. I love free agency. I love owners that spend. Steinbrenner is the best owner in sports in terms of investing money he makes on the team back in to the team because he cares so much about winning. I've said before on this board I believe Steinbrenner should go in to the Hall of Fame for the way he embraced the changing baseball economics (there was a time in baseball where the owners all had an under the table agreement not to 'cave in' to free agency when it began and not negotiate with any of the players on the open market) and how he revolutionized the game that way. I don't get why you and others commend a move like Ortiz because they got payoff for very little. Is that the only way a deal is good or a team is good when it wins with only home grown talent or gets more from a player then they paid for? If you believe this, it's fine and your opinion but there is little I can say to change your stance. Manny is a bad move because he was a young man entering his prime and they gave him money to do that for them? How is that 'wrong'? If you believe signing free agents is bad then I just can't continue this conversation because we will be getting nowhere. I dont have a problem with free agency. The yankees can sign anyone they want and so can the red sox. I just dont understand why redsox fans think they arent like the yankees now? They have the second highest payroll and spent $200 million on three players last offseason. If the marlins could spend that much I would want them too. However, if we were spending that much and we were lumped in with the yankees I would have to agree. If you don't see a difference in the talent and team the Red Sox have constructed as opposed to the Yankees well again, I can't really get in to this discussion much more. 200 million? What are you talking about? The Red Sox are paying those 3 players about 30 million collectively a year and if you want to look at the total ammount of their salaries at the time of signing, which has little to do with anything when you are talking about the overall long term strength of a franchise, etc. the deals ammount to a total of 158 million (5/70, 6/52, and 4/36). Again, I have no idea what that has to do with anything to dispute the points I have made between the fundamental difference between the way the two conduct business. The Red Sox are going to have about 35 million coming off the books this year. I also included the 50 million fee they paid for the right to negotiate with dice k. The value of the contracts was everything to do with what we are talking about. The redsox have the second highest payroll in the league. Most of their starters came via free agency. And spent $200 million in combined contracts and fees this past offseason. You can say what you want about taking a step back or whatever, but they still spent that money. There is nothing wrong with spending money. Just dont try to seperate yourself from the yankees when you basically are doing the same thing as they are.
May 7, 200719 yr The Red Sox are going to have about 35 million coming off the books this year. If that's justification for the Red Sox to be better in the manner they "conduct business" then the Yankees have them beat there too. Posada's $12.5 mil Rivera's $11 mil Abreu's $13.5 mil Plus potentially ARod's $25 million. So the Yankees are looking at (just off the top of my head) those three huge salaries plus ARod. Does that mean they run their business well then, too, if they're setting themselves up to shave salary and be a player in this upcoming deep class? I mean, I really have no idea what relevance having money come off the books has to a discussion of a front-office's capabilty...every team every year has expiring contracts. Therefore, it's reasonable to conclude that teams with higher payrolls have higher value expiring contracts.
May 7, 200719 yr You're completely double talking. The team on the field is absolutely not reflective of those comments. That strong farmsystem? Well, I'd argue the jewel of it at the time of those comments is now playing short-stop in Miami. That rotation and outfield is completely the product of other team's development (until Lester comes back), and all but one regular position player (Youkilis) plus Pedroia if he can fend off Alex Cora. That quote's great, fantastic, but I don't think his words are at all indicative of his actions. He spent gonzo money on Drew and Lugo. He put an obscene amount of money on Matsuzaka, and if Gammons is to be believed, was considering offering a prorated $18 mil to Clemens, on top of a team that is already 5 SP deep. If that isn't an embarrassment of riches, I don't know what is. Sure, maybe you didn't shop at Barney's like the Yankees, but you definitely did some shopping at Saks and Bergdorf's and still have a payroll that only 4 or 5 teams could ever dream about. Are you allowed to do it? Absolutely, but to pretend that you're something completely different than the Yankees, or Mets or Dodgers or Angels is downright uninformed, and it's almost absurd that you pull up 2005 quotes to justify the 2007 team when so much in that philosophy was abandoned this past offseason (and to a degree, that 2005 offseason as well). Thanks for the news flash that the team in 2007 is not all the product of our farm system, that doesn't mean when those quptes were made that the focus of the team isn't that. If the Red Sox FO were the Yankees, we would have re-signed Pedro and Damon instead of replacing them with cheaper, younger, and better long term options. The way you characterize the 3 off-season signings is simply unsubstantiated and more to paint the picture of your response then actual reality. You miss the part that says, and the main part of my stance that the Red Sox can be a spending team (which is reflected in those quotes and on the field) and also a team that blends in young home grown talent (same and same). Again, the Yankees will throw the money at the problem and spend for quick, expensive right now solutions instead of blending the two like we have done. The Red Sox have the best closer in the game home grown, a young soon to be in the rotation starter, a future starting CFer, a young 2B, and more in the farm and on the current team. The Sox for the first time are in a position where they won't have to mortgage their future to have success. This team is so much better constructed then the Yankees right now in terms of age, talent, and expiring contracts it isn't even close.
May 7, 200719 yr That is why I've started to root for the Yankees over the Red Sox. Red Sox fans think they aren't an evil empire too . Not only that but it bugs me that they even talk one ounce of trash to a Yankee fan and try to act like they are on or above the same level. I mean the Yankees have 26 world championships to the Red Sox 1! Freakin' one championship in 87 years to 26. That is pathetic. Even a Florida Marlin fan can talk more trash to the Yankees. The Yankees are Jessica Biel;the Red Sox are Rosie O'Donnell. I find all of this 'discussion' pretty standard though because as is usually par for the course on this board, those that dislike the team are the ones who always side against it instead of looking at it objectively. Looking at it objectively you would see the Red Sox are free agent whores who would give away a 1st round draft pick(in one of the strongest drafts in years) and further neglect the farm system to sign Julio freakin' Lugo for 36 million over 4 years. Objectively you would see that the Yankees have a much stronger farm system than the Red Sox. Objectively you would see that just everybody in your whole starting lineup and starting rotation were bought and not developed. Thanks for taking such good care of your farm system and giving us your absolute gem in Hanley Ramirez and taking on our worst contract that nobody else in the league would touch. I see absolutely zero facts that you could come up with that refutes any of that or anything anyone is saying to you. You are the only who is not looking at this objectively. Understandably so though. Spending wise you without a doubt are in the same league as the Yankees and Mets that noone else in the league is in. History wise though.......? You're in the same league as us. Maybe that is why you spend so much time on a Marlin's board. ;-)
May 7, 200719 yr The Red Sox are going to have about 35 million coming off the books this year. If that's justification for the Red Sox to be better in the manner they "conduct business" then the Yankees have them beat there too. Posada's $12.5 mil Rivera's $11 mil Abreu's $13.5 mil Plus potentially ARod's $25 million. So the Yankees are looking at (just off the top of my head) those three huge salaries plus ARod. Does that mean they run their business well then, too, if they're setting themselves up to shave salary and be a player in this upcoming deep class? I mean, I really have no idea what relevance having money come off the books has to a discussion of a front-office's capabilty...every team every year has expiring contracts. Therefore, it's reasonable to conclude that teams with higher payrolls have higher value expiring contracts. When you have expiring contracts of older/injured players in combination with younger players coming through the system and/or younger options in free agency that is called foresight. I'll ban bet that the Yankees sign 3 of those 4 players so the point is moot. The Red Sox may sign one of theirs, and that is up in the air.
May 7, 200719 yr BTW the reason pedro is on the mets and not the redsox is because they offered him a 4th year. If both teams offered 3 year deals them pedro stays on the team. The redsox just got out bid, its not like they said "we have a vision for the future" lets get rid of this guy. Damon? They got out bid on him too. If he wasnt going to the yankees, he would still be a red sox.
May 7, 200719 yr That is why I've started to root for the Yankees over the Red Sox. Red Sox fans think they aren't an evil empire too . Not only that but it bugs me that they even talk one ounce of trash to a Yankee fan and try to act like they are on or above the same level. I mean the Yankees have 26 world championships to the Red Sox 1! Freakin' one championship in 87 years to 26. That is pathetic. Even a Florida Marlin fan can talk more trash to the Yankees. The Yankees are Jessica Biel;the Red Sox are Rosie O'Donnell. I find all of this 'discussion' pretty standard though because as is usually par for the course on this board, those that dislike the team are the ones who always side against it instead of looking at it objectively. Looking at it objectively you would see the Red Sox are free agent whores who would give away a 1st round draft pick(in one of the strongest drafts in years) and further neglect the farm system to sign Julio freakin' Lugo for 36 million over 4 years. Objectively you would see that the Yankees have a much stronger farm system than the Red Sox. Objectively you would see that just everybody in your whole starting lineup and starting rotation were bought and not developed. Thanks for taking such good care of your farm system and giving us your absolute gem in Hanley Ramirez and taking on our worst contract that nobody else in the league would touch. I see absolutely zero facts that you could come up with that refutes any of that or anything anyone is saying to you. You are the only who is not looking at this objectively. Understandably so though. Spending wise you without a doubt are in the same league as the Yankees and Mets that noone else in the league is in. History wise though.......? You're in the same league as us. Maybe that is why you spend so much time on a Marlin's board. ;-) Lugo for 4/36 isn't bad for what we can afford, age, production, and what other options we would have. I'm not going to sit here and say the way the FO has handled the situation at SS has been done well, especially in hindsight. The Yankee farm system being better, which is an opinion, means nothing for them because besides the absolute blue chipper they will always sell it off for the quick fix which I have been saying and where you and others continue to ignore is the fundamental difference between the two clubs. Our absolute gem of the system is the best closer in the game for our big league club. Good call though. I also am glad to take 'your worst contract' and the gold glove defense it provided us last year and the .294/.352/.477 he has provided us in his walk year this season so far. Also, I'm glad Hanley is working out for you but I'll take our 27 year old AL Cy Young caliber starting pitcher any day of the week. :thumbup Seriously, I always look forward to your pot shot about me being a fan of another team and this being a Marlins board. Some of the best psoters on this board have been here longer than you and better than you and haven't been fans of the fish. I've been welcomed and well recieved by nearly every vet and the Admin on this board at one time or another since I've been here so seriously grow up and until this site becomes Marlins only I'll continue to be here up until my wedding. :thumbup
May 7, 200719 yr You're completely double talking. The team on the field is absolutely not reflective of those comments. That strong farmsystem? Well, I'd argue the jewel of it at the time of those comments is now playing short-stop in Miami. That rotation and outfield is completely the product of other team's development (until Lester comes back), and all but one regular position player (Youkilis) plus Pedroia if he can fend off Alex Cora. That quote's great, fantastic, but I don't think his words are at all indicative of his actions. He spent gonzo money on Drew and Lugo. He put an obscene amount of money on Matsuzaka, and if Gammons is to be believed, was considering offering a prorated $18 mil to Clemens, on top of a team that is already 5 SP deep. If that isn't an embarrassment of riches, I don't know what is. Sure, maybe you didn't shop at Barney's like the Yankees, but you definitely did some shopping at Saks and Bergdorf's and still have a payroll that only 4 or 5 teams could ever dream about. Are you allowed to do it? Absolutely, but to pretend that you're something completely different than the Yankees, or Mets or Dodgers or Angels is downright uninformed, and it's almost absurd that you pull up 2005 quotes to justify the 2007 team when so much in that philosophy was abandoned this past offseason (and to a degree, that 2005 offseason as well). Thanks for the news flash that the team in 2007 is not all the product of our farm system, that doesn't mean when those quptes were made that the focus of the team isn't that. If the Red Sox FO were the Yankees, we would have re-signed Pedro and Damon instead of replacing them with cheaper, younger, and better long term options. Pedro's contract: 4 years 53 million dollars Dice K: 6 years 103 million(includes posting fee) Shilling: 13 million dollars this year. 40 years old Josh Beckett: 3 years 30 million dollars. Tim Wakefield: 40 years old making 4 million dollars this years. Whatever.
May 7, 200719 yr BTW the reason pedro is on the mets and not the redsox is because they offered him a 4th year. If both teams offered 3 year deals them pedro stays on the team. The redsox just got out bid, its not like they said "we have a vision for the future" lets get rid of this guy. Damon? They got out bid on him too. If he wasnt going to the yankees, he would still be a red sox. So...there wasn't a reason we didn't give him that extra year? :lol So...there wasn't a reason we didn't match the money? :lol If you think Epstein was 'upset' or didn't have subsequent and better and younger and cheaper moves in place you are extremely hard headed and ignorant.
May 7, 200719 yr You're completely double talking. The team on the field is absolutely not reflective of those comments. That strong farmsystem? Well, I'd argue the jewel of it at the time of those comments is now playing short-stop in Miami. That rotation and outfield is completely the product of other team's development (until Lester comes back), and all but one regular position player (Youkilis) plus Pedroia if he can fend off Alex Cora. That quote's great, fantastic, but I don't think his words are at all indicative of his actions. He spent gonzo money on Drew and Lugo. He put an obscene amount of money on Matsuzaka, and if Gammons is to be believed, was considering offering a prorated $18 mil to Clemens, on top of a team that is already 5 SP deep. If that isn't an embarrassment of riches, I don't know what is. Sure, maybe you didn't shop at Barney's like the Yankees, but you definitely did some shopping at Saks and Bergdorf's and still have a payroll that only 4 or 5 teams could ever dream about. Are you allowed to do it? Absolutely, but to pretend that you're something completely different than the Yankees, or Mets or Dodgers or Angels is downright uninformed, and it's almost absurd that you pull up 2005 quotes to justify the 2007 team when so much in that philosophy was abandoned this past offseason (and to a degree, that 2005 offseason as well). Thanks for the news flash that the team in 2007 is not all the product of our farm system, that doesn't mean when those quptes were made that the focus of the team isn't that. If the Red Sox FO were the Yankees, we would have re-signed Pedro and Damon instead of replacing them with cheaper, younger, and better long term options. The way you characterize the 3 off-season signings is simply unsubstantiated and more to paint the picture of your response then actual reality. You miss the part that says, and the main part of my stance that the Red Sox can be a spending team (which is reflected in those quotes and on the field) and also a team that blends in young home grown talent (same and same). Again, the Yankees will throw the money at the problem and spend for quick, expensive right now solutions instead of blending the two like we have done. The Red Sox have the best closer in the game home grown, a young soon to be in the rotation starter, a future starting CFer, a young 2B, and more in the farm and on the current team. The Sox for the first time are in a position where they won't have to mortgage their future to have success. This team is so much better constructed then the Yankees right now in terms of age, talent, and expiring contracts it isn't even close. WHERE THE f*** IS THE BLENDED IN TALENT? Show it to me. Lester, Youkilis, Papelbon. That's it. Pedroia's going to lose his job to Alex Cora, and even then, terming him consequential "talent" is dubious. Let's look at the Yankees that you so desperately hate to be lumped with. Jeter, Rivera, Posada, Cano and Hughes. Plus, in a round about way Pettitte, and Jeff Karstens. Yeah, definitely one of those teams is plugging from within and the other is a glut of expesnive free agent additions. And, for whatever reason, I find it silly to say that it's cool to blend home-grown talent and free agents as if the Red Sox are the only team to realize this is the key to success. Last I checked, Gene Michael and Brian Cashman essentially drew up this blueprint over a decade ago...it's paid off pretty well for them, and I think they're still just chugging along. And, as I outlined above, the Yankees have just as much money coming off the books largely because all teams have money coming off the books every offseason. Finally, saying that the Red Sox have the best closer in the game that was home grown doesn't justify the argument categorically. The Yankees turned a home-grown, scouted and developed star into the best player in baseball (Soriano for ARod for those who want to keep track). And a closer isn't even in the same category as the potential that Hughes has and Jeter, Pettitte and Posada have realized, to say nothing of Mariano Rivera. And, just as an aside, I'd argue that the system Epstein outlined in this wonderful closed door meeting has so drastically come back to bite him in the ass that he had to spend crazy money this offseason to offset it. Drew, Matsuzaka, Lugo and their checkbooks all benefited greatly from Epstein and the Red Sox immediately missing the impact of Damon, Pedro and Hanley. And you can't possibly justify the money that was handed out to those three as "smart" money. I'm not calling them bad players, but the money is crazy and justifiable only when working in the highest of high payroll brackets and money is secondary to talent and especially needed talent. I also realize that the inevitable counter argument is that Pedro is hurt and Damon is also struggling, but that doesn't change the fact that the Red Sox had no answer to the holes they voluntarily created and then had to spend absurd amounts of money to fix that, even if this was not part of their new policy, nor is it smart policy to bank on free agents being available. The Yankee farm system being better, which is an opinion, means nothing for them because besides the absolute blue chipper they will always sell it off for the quick fix which I have been saying and where you and others continue to ignore is the fundamental difference between the two clubs. Yup, that's why Hughes is in Kansas City and Hanley's in Boston. Oh...wait.
May 7, 200719 yr BTW the reason pedro is on the mets and not the redsox is because they offered him a 4th year. If both teams offered 3 year deals them pedro stays on the team. The redsox just got out bid, its not like they said "we have a vision for the future" lets get rid of this guy. Damon? They got out bid on him too. If he wasnt going to the yankees, he would still be a red sox. So...there wasn't a reason we didn't give him that extra year? :lol So...there wasn't a reason we didn't match the money? :lol If you think Epstein was 'upset' or didn't have subsequent and better and younger and cheaper moves in place you are extremely hard headed and ignorant. You are missing the point. You said that the redsox let them go because of this "vision" they have. They wanted both players, they just got out bid. I remember them being very close to re-signing pedro, they just didnt want to give him a 4th year. If the redsox dont get outbid, both players are still on the team now.
May 7, 200719 yr That is why I've started to root for the Yankees over the Red Sox. Red Sox fans think they aren't an evil empire too . Not only that but it bugs me that they even talk one ounce of trash to a Yankee fan and try to act like they are on or above the same level. I mean the Yankees have 26 world championships to the Red Sox 1! Freakin' one championship in 87 years to 26. That is pathetic. Even a Florida Marlin fan can talk more trash to the Yankees. The Yankees are Jessica Biel;the Red Sox are Rosie O'Donnell. I find all of this 'discussion' pretty standard though because as is usually par for the course on this board, those that dislike the team are the ones who always side against it instead of looking at it objectively. Looking at it objectively you would see the Red Sox are free agent whores who would give away a 1st round draft pick(in one of the strongest drafts in years) and further neglect the farm system to sign Julio freakin' Lugo for 36 million over 4 years. Objectively you would see that the Yankees have a much stronger farm system than the Red Sox. Objectively you would see that just everybody in your whole starting lineup and starting rotation were bought and not developed. Thanks for taking such good care of your farm system and giving us your absolute gem in Hanley Ramirez and taking on our worst contract that nobody else in the league would touch. I see absolutely zero facts that you could come up with that refutes any of that or anything anyone is saying to you. You are the only who is not looking at this objectively. Understandably so though. Spending wise you without a doubt are in the same league as the Yankees and Mets that noone else in the league is in. History wise though.......? You're in the same league as us. Maybe that is why you spend so much time on a Marlin's board. ;-) Seriously, I always look forward to your pot shot about me being a fan of another team and this being a Marlins board. Some of the best psoters on this board have been here longer than you and better than you and haven't been fans of the fish. I've been welcomed and well recieved by nearly every vet and the Admin on this board at one time or another since I've been here so seriously grow up and until this site becomes Marlins only I'll continue to be here up until my wedding. :thumbup Just find it odd that one of the top 2-3 posters on the entire site could have absolutely no rooting interest in the Marlins either way. I couldn't even fathom having 10 posts on a Kansas City Royal board. But whatever, I just always assumed Admin was your dad or something. :thumbup No hostility towards you whatsoever though, I just don't get it.
May 7, 200719 yr Pedro's contract: 4 years 53 million dollars One good year, two injury plagued years and coming off severe surgery. On his last legs.Dice K: 6 years 103 million(includes posting fee) Posting fee doesn't count and the revenue just his presence brings to the club will make that posting fee back by the time he is done here. 26 years old. Shilling: 13 million dollars this year. 40 years old 4-1. 3.28 ERA, 1.16 WHIP Walk year Josh Beckett: 3 years 30 million dollars.[/qupte] 27. Making 6.66 million this year. 6-0, 2.72 ERA, 1.06 WHIP Tim Wakefield: 40 years old making 4 million dollars this years. Whatever. 3-3, 2.11 ERA, 1.20 WHIP Yeah, whatever. :lol
May 7, 200719 yr You made it seem like they decided to really tighten up on the budget though by not signing Pedro and give some young guys they developed in the farm a chance in the rotation when that is obviously not the case. They just spent more money and gave away prospects to replace him.
May 7, 200719 yr That is why I've started to root for the Yankees over the Red Sox. Red Sox fans think they aren't an evil empire too . Not only that but it bugs me that they even talk one ounce of trash to a Yankee fan and try to act like they are on or above the same level. I mean the Yankees have 26 world championships to the Red Sox 1! Freakin' one championship in 87 years to 26. That is pathetic. Even a Florida Marlin fan can talk more trash to the Yankees. The Yankees are Jessica Biel;the Red Sox are Rosie O'Donnell. I find all of this 'discussion' pretty standard though because as is usually par for the course on this board, those that dislike the team are the ones who always side against it instead of looking at it objectively. Looking at it objectively you would see the Red Sox are free agent whores who would give away a 1st round draft pick(in one of the strongest drafts in years) and further neglect the farm system to sign Julio freakin' Lugo for 36 million over 4 years. Objectively you would see that the Yankees have a much stronger farm system than the Red Sox. Objectively you would see that just everybody in your whole starting lineup and starting rotation were bought and not developed. Thanks for taking such good care of your farm system and giving us your absolute gem in Hanley Ramirez and taking on our worst contract that nobody else in the league would touch. I see absolutely zero facts that you could come up with that refutes any of that or anything anyone is saying to you. You are the only who is not looking at this objectively. Understandably so though. Spending wise you without a doubt are in the same league as the Yankees and Mets that noone else in the league is in. History wise though.......? You're in the same league as us. Maybe that is why you spend so much time on a Marlin's board. ;-) Seriously, I always look forward to your pot shot about me being a fan of another team and this being a Marlins board. Some of the best psoters on this board have been here longer than you and better than you and haven't been fans of the fish. I've been welcomed and well recieved by nearly every vet and the Admin on this board at one time or another since I've been here so seriously grow up and until this site becomes Marlins only I'll continue to be here up until my wedding. :thumbup Just find it odd that one of the top 2-3 posters on the entire site could have absolutely no rooting interest in the Marlins either way. I couldn't even fathom having 10 posts on a Kansas City Royal board. But whatever, I just always assumed Admin was your dad or something. :thumbup No hostility towards you whatsoever though, I just don't get it. I find the Marlins very interesting and rooted like hell for them in 2003 and came over here when a Nomar-Fish deal was rumored and a thread was made on it. Saw the board was more than just a Fish fan board (we have/had great off-topic discussion, great general baseball and sport talk, political talk, etc.). I posted a n00b post, was well recieved and liked and made some e-friends (lol) along the way. We have plenty of good posters who are not Marlin fans, I don't know why you care about this so much and continue to bring it up.
May 7, 200719 yr How can you bash the Yankees for brining back Clemens, and his age (despite his previous three year ERAs of 2.98, 1.87, and 2.30), and then show Schilling's statistics as reason for him being around and the intelligence of the Sox. I'd take both players in a heart beat, but it seems like a double standard.
May 7, 200719 yr Pedro's contract: 4 years 53 million dollars One good year, two injury plagued years and coming off severe surgery. On his last legs.Dice K: 6 years 103 million(includes posting fee) Posting fee doesn't count and the revenue just his presence brings to the club will make that posting fee back by the time he is done here. 26 years old. Shilling: 13 million dollars this year. 40 years old 4-1. 3.28 ERA, 1.16 WHIP Walk year Josh Beckett: 3 years 30 million dollars.[/qupte] 27. Making 6.66 million this year. 6-0, 2.72 ERA, 1.06 WHIP Tim Wakefield: 40 years old making 4 million dollars this years. Whatever. 3-3, 2.11 ERA, 1.20 WHIP Yeah, whatever. :lol So basically if the player is doing well his age doesnt matter? And if a player is doing good it doesnt matter that he came via free agency or home grown? So basically they do what any team would do. I dont understand this vision, unless the vision is just get good players on the team. It doesnt matter how much you dont want to be lumped in with the yankees, but the fact of the matter is that you are. There is nothing wrong with that.
May 7, 200719 yr You made it seem like they decided to really tighten up on the budget though by not signing Pedro and give some young guys they developed in the farm a chance in the rotation when that is obviously not the case. They just spent more money and gave away prospects to replace him. 1. Schill and Wake were on the books already. 2. Not re-signing Pedro was a good baseball and fiscal move. 3. They have gotten younger in their rotation and better since Pedro left. We gave away two prospects to replace him - Anibal and Hanley for a good position player and a top pitcher in the game, I'll do that trade any day. It'd be one thing if Pedro went on to bigger and brighter things and the rotation got worse. But it didn't. I find it incredible that so few of you give an actual fan of the team no credit for what he knows about the inner workings of the club or how the club has been constructed and the perspective I have of being a fan of this team for 13+ years. 9/10 I'll take a back seat to what guys like Ramp and Juanky say/percieve/know about their team, its a bit amusing how that is never returned (I don't care either way) even when my track record is what it is. If someone would like to challenge my reasoning/logic/opinion with a ban bet, I'm all ears. How can you bash the Yankees for brining back Clemens, and his age (despite his previous three year ERAs of 2.98, 1.87, and 2.30), and then show Schilling's statistics as reason for him being around and the intelligence of the Sox. I'd take both players in a heart beat, but it seems like a double standard. Did I 'bash' the Yankees for bringing back Clemens? No. I just don't think its an incredible move for a team with a terrible bull pen and average rotation. Those ERAs are in the NL, look at his last year in the AL East (which is stronger than it was then and when he was 4 years younger). Schilling paid his contract in performance with two starts in October, the rest is gravy. I didn't say or spell out Schilling's numbers spell out the Red Sox intelligence but it does show how when someone questions his age, and his performance is fantastic for his age and in a walk year I don't get how people can use that as a stat for why its a bad move.
May 7, 200719 yr That is why I've started to root for the Yankees over the Red Sox. Red Sox fans think they aren't an evil empire too . Not only that but it bugs me that they even talk one ounce of trash to a Yankee fan and try to act like they are on or above the same level. I mean the Yankees have 26 world championships to the Red Sox 1! Freakin' one championship in 87 years to 26. That is pathetic. Even a Florida Marlin fan can talk more trash to the Yankees. The Yankees are Jessica Biel;the Red Sox are Rosie O'Donnell. I find all of this 'discussion' pretty standard though because as is usually par for the course on this board, those that dislike the team are the ones who always side against it instead of looking at it objectively. Looking at it objectively you would see the Red Sox are free agent whores who would give away a 1st round draft pick(in one of the strongest drafts in years) and further neglect the farm system to sign Julio freakin' Lugo for 36 million over 4 years. Objectively you would see that the Yankees have a much stronger farm system than the Red Sox. Objectively you would see that just everybody in your whole starting lineup and starting rotation were bought and not developed. Thanks for taking such good care of your farm system and giving us your absolute gem in Hanley Ramirez and taking on our worst contract that nobody else in the league would touch. I see absolutely zero facts that you could come up with that refutes any of that or anything anyone is saying to you. You are the only who is not looking at this objectively. Understandably so though. Spending wise you without a doubt are in the same league as the Yankees and Mets that noone else in the league is in. History wise though.......? You're in the same league as us. Maybe that is why you spend so much time on a Marlin's board. ;-) Seriously, I always look forward to your pot shot about me being a fan of another team and this being a Marlins board. Some of the best psoters on this board have been here longer than you and better than you and haven't been fans of the fish. I've been welcomed and well recieved by nearly every vet and the Admin on this board at one time or another since I've been here so seriously grow up and until this site becomes Marlins only I'll continue to be here up until my wedding. :thumbup Just find it odd that one of the top 2-3 posters on the entire site could have absolutely no rooting interest in the Marlins either way. I couldn't even fathom having 10 posts on a Kansas City Royal board. But whatever, I just always assumed Admin was your dad or something. :thumbup No hostility towards you whatsoever though, I just don't get it. I find the Marlins very interesting and rooted like hell for them in 2003 and came over here when a Nomar-Fish deal was rumored and a thread was made on it. Saw the board was more than just a Fish fan board (we have/had great off-topic discussion, great general baseball and sport talk, political talk, etc.). I posted a n00b post, was well recieved and liked and made some e-friends (lol) along the way. We have plenty of good posters who are not Marlin fans, I don't know why you care about this so much and continue to bring it up. Continue to bring it up? I've brought it up maybe once before and that was about a year ago. That is not continuing to bring it up. It is really not a big deal and yes we have plenty of great non Marlin fan posters here and you obviously bring a ton to this board and contribute a lot, I happen to like you and what you bring to this board. Like I said though I just genuinely do not understand it but thanks for explaining. The first jab (History wise though.......? You're in the same league as us. Maybe that is why you spend so much time on a Marlin's board. ;-) ) was meant towards the Red Sox, not you.
May 7, 200719 yr You made it seem like they decided to really tighten up on the budget though by not signing Pedro and give some young guys they developed in the farm a chance in the rotation when that is obviously not the case. They just spent more money and gave away prospects to replace him. 1. Schill and Wake were on the books already. 2. Not re-signing Pedro was a good baseball and fiscal move. 3. They have gotten younger in their rotation and better since Pedro left. We gave away two prospects to replace him - Anibal and Hanley for a good position player and a top pitcher in the game, I'll do that trade any day. It'd be one thing if Pedro went on to bigger and brighter things and the rotation got worse. But it didn't. I find it incredible that so few of you give an actual fan of the team no credit for what he knows about the inner workings of the club or how the club has been constructed and the perspective I have of being a fan of this team for 13+ years. 9/10 I'll take a back seat to what guys like Ramp and Juanky say/percieve/know about their team, its a bit amusing how that is never returned (I don't care either way) even when my track record is what it is. If someone would like to challenge my reasoning/logic/opinion with a ban bet, I'm all ears. But they wanted to resign pedro. It came down to the wire and he signed with the mets because of the 4th year. The redsox were going to offer him the same exact amount as the mets were for 3 years. So if they dont get out bid, pedro stays on the team, #3 probably doesnt happen. Then where does this vision go? You know a lot about the red sox no one is saying you don't. But you dont need to be a fan of theirs to see how similar they are to the yankees. They have the second highest payroll and spent $200 million on three players last offseason. How many teams can do that? Just the redsox and yankees. This "vision" is a load of crap. When there are good players available, the redsox will go out and get them just like the yankees do.
May 7, 200719 yr So basically if the player is doing well his age doesnt matter? And if a player is doing good it doesnt matter that he came via free agency or home grown? So basically they do what any team would do. I dont understand this vision, unless the vision is just get good players on the team. It doesnt matter how much you dont want to be lumped in with the yankees, but the fact of the matter is that you are. There is nothing wrong with that. Jesus, were talking in circles. My last post to you unless you insult my dog or something (Question my baseball opinion but I don't let people mess with that bad ass, :lol )... a. Um, yes age doesn't matter if the player can perform. He could be 72 for all I care and if he posts those numbers it doesn't matter. Now, giving money to players as they are very old and well past their peak performance is different. The Sox have not done that. b. I don't care if people do say we are Yankees II or Evil Empire II, but there are definitely different ways the Yankees and Red Sox conduct business and I believe the Sox do it in a better financial, talent, and long term way then New York does.
May 7, 200719 yr Did I 'bash' the Yankees for bringing back Clemens? No. I just don't think its an incredible move for a team with a terrible bull pen and average rotation. Those ERAs are in the NL, look at his last year in the AL East (which is stronger than it was then and when he was 4 years younger). Schilling paid his contract in performance with two starts in October, the rest is gravy. I didn't say or spell out Schilling's numbers spell out the Red Sox intelligence but it does show how when someone questions his age, and his performance is fantastic for his age and in a walk year I don't get how people can use that as a stat for why its a bad move. In many of your previous post, you have implied that this is a bad move by the Yankees, or a move that won't make a difference. I'm sorry you didn't say preface any of your previous posts with I am bashing the Yankees here: Nobody has said that Schilling is a bad move. It's fantastic to have him on the Red Sox, nobody is denying that. But for you to think that you are different than the Yankees because of a quote from 2005 is ridiculous. Of course no two teams have identical blue prints, but the underlying similarities between you guys now are undeniable. Now you can come back with your personal attack or laughing face, I expect it, but I will once again leave the post with Bill Simmons' quote, because I think it's accurate. SG: You know, I felt twinges of this reader's anger this winter, because the truth is, I never wanted to root for a team that bought championships like the Yankees, even though our 2004 payroll was easily nine figures and we landed Schilling, Pedro and Manny mainly because we were one of the only teams that could afford them. Even so, it was always more fun believing that the Red Sox were the "underdogs" in the ongoing blood feud because we didn't spend as much money as the Yanks. But when they have similar payrolls? Not as much fun. So I was bummed out. For instance, the Dice-K signing seemed excessive to me at the time, and I would have much rather seen them go the "Moneyball" route with right field and try to get lucky there (like they did with the Mueller-Ortiz-Millar signings in 2003) over just saying, "Screw it!" and throwing $70 million at J.D. Drew. There was no art to the way they slapped together the 2007 team; they started writing big, fat checks and that was that. It's the best team that money can buy. Literally. And you know what? It's not my money. So screw it. I'm on board. Even if there's absolutely no difference between the Red Sox and Yankees anymore.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.