Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Mets Acquire Luis Castillo

Featured Replies

Back to Luis.

 

Reyes is not a difference maker on defense at short. He is good, but terribly overrated. He doesn't "steal" outs the way an Ozzie Smith or Omar Vizquel does. Hell, I don't even think he's as good as Alex Gonzalez 2000-2004 with the glove. Yeah his arm is FANTASTIC, but if the footwork is so so and the range is aided basically only by speed and not instinct (yeah, I hate that expression, but it's the only way to get it across) he's not stealing any outs or creating any double plays above and beyond that of an average or slightly above average short-stop. Second base is an overrated position for turning the DP, anyway, it's basically catch and throw except in extremely rare circumstances...and if those rare events turn into 6 more DP's over the course of a season, that's not winning a division.

 

ur nuts, Reyes is wicked defensively, you can argue him for being top 3 defensive SS in the NL this year behind Jack Wilson and Omar.

 

No, you can't. Middle of the pack fielding percentage, middle of the pack put outs. Second worst range factor of any qualified NL short-stop (ahead of only JJ Hardy).

 

Then again, he is the "most overrated exciting player in baseball" ?

 

I mean, most fielding metrics are flawed, but if every single one agrees that a player is not all that good, then something's gotta give. And most fielding metrics show Reyes to be very average.

 

That's my point entirely.

 

I hate the notion of quantifying defense, but if most accepted evaluators say he's nothing overly unique, it's probably the case.

Back to Luis.

 

Reyes is not a difference maker on defense at short. He is good, but terribly overrated. He doesn't "steal" outs the way an Ozzie Smith or Omar Vizquel does. Hell, I don't even think he's as good as Alex Gonzalez 2000-2004 with the glove. Yeah his arm is FANTASTIC, but if the footwork is so so and the range is aided basically only by speed and not instinct (yeah, I hate that expression, but it's the only way to get it across) he's not stealing any outs or creating any double plays above and beyond that of an average or slightly above average short-stop. Second base is an overrated position for turning the DP, anyway, it's basically catch and throw except in extremely rare circumstances...and if those rare events turn into 6 more DP's over the course of a season, that's not winning a division.

 

ur nuts, Reyes is wicked defensively, you can argue him for being top 3 defensive SS in the NL this year behind Jack Wilson and Omar.

 

No, you can't. Middle of the pack fielding percentage, middle of the pack put outs. Second worst range factor of any qualified NL short-stop (ahead of only JJ Hardy).

 

Then again, he is the "most overrated exciting player in baseball" ?

 

I mean, most fielding metrics are flawed, but if every single one agrees that a player is not all that good, then something's gotta give. And most fielding metrics show Reyes to be very average.

 

That's my point entirely.

 

I hate the notion of quantifying defense, but if most accepted evaluators say he's nothing overly unique, it's probably the case.

 

But hey, he is the next Rickey Henderson.

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

 

Baseball prospectus also rates him as an above average defensive player. They rate Reyes as a slightly above average shortstop, but still almost a full win's worth of runs behind Tulowitzki.

 

I mean, no one defensive metric has it completely right yet, but they can't all be wrong. If they all agree, I think it's definitely a usable stat.

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

 

Baseball prospectus also rates him as an above average defensive player. They rate Reyes as a slightly above average shortstop, but still almost a full win's worth of runs behind Tulowitzki.

 

I mean, no one defensive metric has it completely right yet, but they can't all be wrong. If they all agree, I think it's definitely a usable stat.

That entire infield is ridiculous.

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

 

Baseball prospectus also rates him as an above average defensive player. They rate Reyes as a slightly above average shortstop, but still almost a full win's worth of runs behind Tulowitzki.

 

I mean, no one defensive metric has it completely right yet, but they can't all be wrong. If they all agree, I think it's definitely a usable stat.

That entire infield is ridiculous.

 

Rockies?

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

 

Baseball prospectus also rates him as an above average defensive player. They rate Reyes as a slightly above average shortstop, but still almost a full win's worth of runs behind Tulowitzki.

 

I mean, no one defensive metric has it completely right yet, but they can't all be wrong. If they all agree, I think it's definitely a usable stat.

That entire infield is ridiculous.

 

Rockies?

Yeah.

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

 

Baseball prospectus also rates him as an above average defensive player. They rate Reyes as a slightly above average shortstop, but still almost a full win's worth of runs behind Tulowitzki.

 

I mean, no one defensive metric has it completely right yet, but they can't all be wrong. If they all agree, I think it's definitely a usable stat.

That entire infield is ridiculous.

 

Rockies?

Yeah.

 

Yeah, defensively they are pretty awesome.

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

 

Baseball prospectus also rates him as an above average defensive player. They rate Reyes as a slightly above average shortstop, but still almost a full win's worth of runs behind Tulowitzki.

 

I mean, no one defensive metric has it completely right yet, but they can't all be wrong. If they all agree, I think it's definitely a usable stat.

That entire infield is ridiculous.

 

Rockies?

Yeah.

 

Yeah, defensively they are pretty awesome.

Team as a whole: 336 double plays, 42 errors, .860 zone rating, 4.260 range factor. :notworthy

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

 

 

I might be taking your post wrong because it's hard to pick up diction over the internet, but it sounds like your mocking the stats because Troy Tulowitzki is rated the highest by them.

 

Now I don't care about mocking defensive stats, but Tulowitzki's got one hell of a glove.

Back to Luis.

 

Reyes is not a difference maker on defense at short. He is good, but terribly overrated. He doesn't "steal" outs the way an Ozzie Smith or Omar Vizquel does. Hell, I don't even think he's as good as Alex Gonzalez 2000-2004 with the glove. Yeah his arm is FANTASTIC, but if the footwork is so so and the range is aided basically only by speed and not instinct (yeah, I hate that expression, but it's the only way to get it across) he's not stealing any outs or creating any double plays above and beyond that of an average or slightly above average short-stop. Second base is an overrated position for turning the DP, anyway, it's basically catch and throw except in extremely rare circumstances...and if those rare events turn into 6 more DP's over the course of a season, that's not winning a division.

That is a very valid point, Reyes is not even close to Vizquel class defensive-wise, then again who is?

Ozzie Smith and Vizquel are in a class of their own

Oh, and to be fair, if you're going just by the stats, the best defensive NL SS this year is Troy Tulowitzki, by a pretty wide margin.

 

 

I might be taking your post wrong because it's hard to pick up diction over the internet, but it sounds like your mocking the stats because Troy Tulowitzki is rated the highest by them.

 

Now I don't care about mocking defensive stats, but Tulowitzki's got one hell of a glove.

 

Not at all mocking, just presenting yet another uncommon assertion.

  • 3 weeks later...

what the hell?

 

So if im a twins fan and I make a thread about Johan santana strikiing out 17, am I still a troll?

 

Luis won the game. He's a valuable player, im hoping he can help bring what he helped bring for the marlins.

You are a troll because you are only doing it to piss people off.

 

this is a baseball forum, your acting like I post whenever something with the mets happens tahts good. ive posted so many other things man, it's not even funny.

Almost all of your posts are "omg the marlins fan base sucks, hanley and miguel are so good but nobody ever sees them because you have the worst fans ever" or "Hanley is awful, Reyes is the best player in the history of the world".

 

And pretty much everyone agrees you are a troll. Go post on a mets forum if you want to talk about the mets.

Nobody gives a sh*t he hit a walkoff.

 

Same goes with the Texiera crap.

Nobody gives a sh*t he hit a walkoff.

 

Some goes with the Texiera crap.

funny...

 

if someone else posts the Mets thing or Braves thing, everyone is like "cool"

 

but if it's Douche McDouche (starbrownies) or Lady McCox (furcalchick), everyone gets upset

 

(im on your side bobbob and junior... just sayin)

I could care less about furcalchick doing it, it's just because StarBrownies is a huge troll who goes out of his way to get people angry.

 

Like this. I fall for it every time.

Nobody gives a sh*t he hit a walkoff.

 

Some goes with the Texiera crap.

funny...

 

if someone else posts the Mets thing or Braves thing, everyone is like "cool"

 

but if it's Douche McDouche (starbrownies) or Lady McCox (furcalchick), everyone gets upset

 

(im on your side bobbob and junior... just sayin)

:lol

 

I'm not even a Marlins fan and it annoys me.

 

It's all abount intent. Douche McDouche does it just to try to get under peoples skin. He knows A. nobody on here cares and B. it will annoy people so he posts it. The fact that Castillo hit a walkoff means very little. They happen all the time. However since it was the Mets and it was done by a former Marlin (compounded with the Conine trade yesterday), he does it to annoy the sh*t out of people. As for Lady McCox, I didn't even mind the stupid video and I found it kind of funny. However the constant updates got annoying as hell. Why somebody needs to post constant updates is beyond me. It's not a Rick Ankiel or Josh Hamilton situation. He was good with the Rangers, and now he is good with the Braves. We get it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.