August 3, 200719 yr I hate this trade for so many reasons, I hate having to see Castillo playing against our Marlins, even more so that it is with the Mets. I hate that Castillo is taking playing time from Gotay, he is a an awesome young prospect who was batting around .340 and playing extremely well. I hate the fact that this pretty much asures the Mets the division because the the Reyes-Castillo DP combo is now the best in the NL. Their defense is better , making their pitching better now Ruben Gotay is far from an awesome young prospect, and Reyes and Castillo's ability to turn the double play won't win the Mets the division. And if having awesome 2nd-SS combo equates to winning, the Marlins should be the best team in the league. Gotay is 24 to me that is young and he is batting .347 in 123 ABs .379 OBP .500 slugging, those numbers are pretty awesome in my perception We have agreat SS and a very good 2nd baseman but you can not call them a great Double Play Combo. They both get the job done. They are not even close to Rollins and Utley when it comes to smoothness turning a DP. The best DP Combo i have ever seen was Vizquel/Alomar they were pure magic. Yes I do believe the improved defense has made the Mets the class of the NL. Castillo is just that type of glove that is a difference-maker. Their pitchers will immediately benefit from Castillo's glove
August 3, 200719 yr I hate this trade for so many reasons, I hate having to see Castillo playing against our Marlins, even more so that it is with the Mets. I hate that Castillo is taking playing time from Gotay, he is a an awesome young prospect who was batting around .340 and playing extremely well. I hate the fact that this pretty much asures the Mets the division because the the Reyes-Castillo DP combo is now the best in the NL. Their defense is better , making their pitching better now Ruben Gotay is far from an awesome young prospect, and Reyes and Castillo's ability to turn the double play won't win the Mets the division. And if having awesome 2nd-SS combo equates to winning, the Marlins should be the best team in the league. Gotay is 24 to me that is young and he is batting .347 in 123 ABs .379 OBP .500 slugging, those numbers are pretty awesome in my perception flash in the pan, lightning in a bottle, cliche city and no one is arguing that Gotay's numbers aren't awesome this year
August 3, 200719 yr I hate this trade for so many reasons, I hate having to see Castillo playing against our Marlins, even more so that it is with the Mets. I hate that Castillo is taking playing time from Gotay, he is a an awesome young prospect who was batting around .340 and playing extremely well. I hate the fact that this pretty much asures the Mets the division because the the Reyes-Castillo DP combo is now the best in the NL. Their defense is better , making their pitching better now Ruben Gotay is far from an awesome young prospect, and Reyes and Castillo's ability to turn the double play won't win the Mets the division. And if having awesome 2nd-SS combo equates to winning, the Marlins should be the best team in the league. Gotay is 24 to me that is young and he is batting .347 in 123 ABs .379 OBP .500 slugging, those numbers are pretty awesome in my perception We have agreat SS and a very good 2nd baseman but you can not call them a great Double Play Combo. They both get the job done. They are not even close to Rollins and Utley when it comes to smoothness turning a DP. The best DP Combo i have ever seen was Vizquel/Alomar they were pure magic. Yes I do believe the improved defense has made the Mets the class of the NL. Castillo is just that type of glove that is a difference-maker. Their pitchers will immediately benefit from Castillo's glove Reyes is an extremely overrated defender, Luis has lost a step in the field. Uggal is an extremely underrated defender, and say what you will about Hanley, but he and Danny turn the double play pretty well. The Marlins have a huge edge offensively in the 2nd-SS combo, so the fact that Reyes and Castillo are slightly better than them defensively means nothing.
August 3, 200719 yr hanley and uggla- 22 errors this season reyes and luis- 9 errors this season id say that the muts have a much much better defensive combo than we do...however overall...id still take hanley and uggla over the muts any day of the week...despite the fact that defense is every bit as important as offense is
August 3, 200719 yr hanley and uggla- 22 errors this season reyes and luis- 9 errors this season id say that the muts have a much much better defensive combo than we do...however overall...id still take hanley and uggla over the muts any day of the week...despite the fact that defense is every bit as important as offense is Overall, defense it not as important as Offense. For individual players, defense is not as important as offense. Unless you are like Ozzie Smith, the majority of players get most of their value from their bat.
August 3, 200719 yr hanley and uggla- 22 errors this season reyes and luis- 9 errors this season id say that the muts have a much much better defensive combo than we do...however overall...id still take hanley and uggla over the muts any day of the week...despite the fact that defense is every bit as important as offense is Overall, defense it not as important as Offense. For individual players, defense is not as important as offense. Unless you are like Ozzie Smith, the majority of players get most of their value from their bat. overall...defense wins more games than offense does...defense is more important for teams than individuals...but important nonetheless...and of course most players get most of the value from their offense...that could be said about pretty much every sport there is...but the teams that walk away with rings every year usually play either above average-elite defense
August 3, 200719 yr hanley and uggla- 22 errors this season reyes and luis- 9 errors this season id say that the muts have a much much better defensive combo than we do...however overall...id still take hanley and uggla over the muts any day of the week...despite the fact that defense is every bit as important as offense is Overall, defense it not as important as Offense. For individual players, defense is not as important as offense. Unless you are like Ozzie Smith, the majority of players get most of their value from their bat. overall...defense wins more games than offense does...defense is more important for teams than individuals...but important nonetheless...and of course most players get most of the value from their offense...that could be said about pretty much every sport there is...but the teams that walk away with rings every year usually play either above average-elite defense Defense absolutely does not win more games than offense does, and it's ludicrous to suggest that. Why? Because defense is not an independent factor in a game. It is entirely dependent on the pitcher. If you have Nolan Ryan striking out 15 batters a game and walking 5, you're defense isn't going to be that important. You are going to have to make like 12 plays on defense to end the game. If you have Chien Ming Wang on the mound, yeah, your defense might be extremely important, because he can't strike people out to save his life. Offense is the one part of the game that doesn't rely on other people, which is why it is the easiest to judge value, and why it is the most important single part. Pitching and defense are so intertwined that if you want to substitute "defense" with "Run prevention", which would incorporate defense and pitching, then yes, fine "defense" is more important." But I would say this, all things being equal, you will win more games with Uggla and Hanley than with Reyes and Castillo.
August 3, 200719 yr true...and i like your point about defense and run prevention...but it doesnt matter who is pitching if you have bad defensive players, then you will have a bad defense...and if you have a bad defense, your pitching will struggle...its all quite a vicious circle
August 3, 200719 yr true...and i like your point about defense and run prevention...but it doesnt matter who is pitching if you have bad defensive players, then you will have a bad defense...and if you have a bad defense, your pitching will struggle...its all quite a vicious circle Not necesarily. It depends on the type of pitchers you have. If you have a knuckleballer (who induces weak infield flies and weak grounders more than the normal pitcher), you can get away with having average defense. If you have a hard throwing sinkerballer (like Wang), you need an excellent defense, because the balls he puts into play are going to be extremely hard hit grounders, so you need a good defense or else those are going to find the holes. If you have a guy who strikes out 10 per 9 innings, walks like 2 or 3, and doesn't allow many home runs, you can, again get away with crappy defense because he's not leaning on them as much. This is why guys who strike out alot of batters and don't walk a lot of them are the best pitchers. Their value is less affected by the guys behind them, and they are more likely to be consistent.
August 3, 200719 yr true...and i like your point about defense and run prevention...but it doesnt matter who is pitching if you have bad defensive players, then you will have a bad defense...and if you have a bad defense, your pitching will struggle...its all quite a vicious circle Not necesarily. It depends on the type of pitchers you have. If you have a knuckleballer (who induces weak infield flies and weak grounders more than the normal pitcher), you can get away with having average defense. If you have a hard throwing sinkerballer (like Wang), you need an excellent defense, because the balls he puts into play are going to be extremely hard hit grounders, so you need a good defense or else those are going to find the holes. If you have a guy who strikes out 10 per 9 innings, walks like 2 or 3, and doesn't allow many home runs, you can, again get away with crappy defense because he's not leaning on them as much. This is why guys who strike out alot of batters and don't walk a lot of them are the best pitchers. Their value is less affected by the guys behind them, and they are more likely to be consistent. true...the type of pitcher is important to the defense...but knuckleballers are as prevelant in the game today as non corrupt politicians are in Washington...ie...very very very rare...and most teams dont have a guy who will strike out half the guys he sees(unless they are playing the marlins)... But when looking at the average pitcher in MLB, id rather have a bunch of great defenders behind him and average hitters than vice versa...because chances are...you will win more games than say the texas rangers, florida marlins, ny yankees, and etc. of the world
August 3, 200719 yr true...and i like your point about defense and run prevention...but it doesnt matter who is pitching if you have bad defensive players, then you will have a bad defense...and if you have a bad defense, your pitching will struggle...its all quite a vicious circle Not necesarily. It depends on the type of pitchers you have. If you have a knuckleballer (who induces weak infield flies and weak grounders more than the normal pitcher), you can get away with having average defense. If you have a hard throwing sinkerballer (like Wang), you need an excellent defense, because the balls he puts into play are going to be extremely hard hit grounders, so you need a good defense or else those are going to find the holes. If you have a guy who strikes out 10 per 9 innings, walks like 2 or 3, and doesn't allow many home runs, you can, again get away with crappy defense because he's not leaning on them as much. This is why guys who strike out alot of batters and don't walk a lot of them are the best pitchers. Their value is less affected by the guys behind them, and they are more likely to be consistent. true...the type of pitcher is important to the defense...but knuckleballers are as prevelant in the game today as non corrupt politicians are in Washington...ie...very very very rare...and most teams dont have a guy who will strike out half the guys he sees(unless they are playing the marlins)... But when looking at the average pitcher in MLB, id rather have a bunch of great defenders behind him and average hitters than vice versa...because chances are...you will win more games than say the texas rangers, florida marlins, ny yankees, and etc. of the world The Yankees have won more games than any other team in the last 8 years except for the Athletics. You know what the Yankees and Athletics have in common? Thats right, score as many runs as possible and let your defense figure itself out. Billy Beane won 102 games in 2001 with an outfield of Johnny Damon, Jeremy Giambi, Terrence Long, and Jermain Dye. Long is the only defender there who is even close to being good, and yet they won 100 games (they also had Jason Giambi playing 140 games at 1st base).
August 4, 200719 yr as much as I like Castillo for this team, Gotay is a monster against right handpitching. The guy gives quality AB after quality AB. Today was just another example, went 1-2, got back into the count 3-2, fouled off 5 pitches in a row and then hit a double. The guy is an awesome hitting prospect becuase of his ability to be patient and wait for pitches, his problem is defense, he made a bludner today, he could of saved an error from being charged to Castro but he misplayed it.
August 4, 200719 yr true...and i like your point about defense and run prevention...but it doesnt matter who is pitching if you have bad defensive players, then you will have a bad defense...and if you have a bad defense, your pitching will struggle...its all quite a vicious circle Not necesarily. It depends on the type of pitchers you have. If you have a knuckleballer (who induces weak infield flies and weak grounders more than the normal pitcher), you can get away with having average defense. If you have a hard throwing sinkerballer (like Wang), you need an excellent defense, because the balls he puts into play are going to be extremely hard hit grounders, so you need a good defense or else those are going to find the holes. If you have a guy who strikes out 10 per 9 innings, walks like 2 or 3, and doesn't allow many home runs, you can, again get away with crappy defense because he's not leaning on them as much. This is why guys who strike out alot of batters and don't walk a lot of them are the best pitchers. Their value is less affected by the guys behind them, and they are more likely to be consistent. true...the type of pitcher is important to the defense...but knuckleballers are as prevelant in the game today as non corrupt politicians are in Washington...ie...very very very rare...and most teams dont have a guy who will strike out half the guys he sees(unless they are playing the marlins)... But when looking at the average pitcher in MLB, id rather have a bunch of great defenders behind him and average hitters than vice versa...because chances are...you will win more games than say the texas rangers, florida marlins, ny yankees, and etc. of the world The Yankees have won more games than any other team in the last 8 years except for the Athletics. You know what the Yankees and Athletics have in common? Thats right, score as many runs as possible and let your defense figure itself out. Billy Beane won 102 games in 2001 with an outfield of Johnny Damon, Jeremy Giambi, Terrence Long, and Jermain Dye. Long is the only defender there who is even close to being good, and yet they won 100 games (they also had Jason Giambi playing 140 games at 1st base). those teams also had pretty damn good pitching and you can sprinkle in a few gold gloves as well...giambi has never been more than a DH for the yankees and yeah you can point to the fact he has played first but he sucks terribly at it...point is...you can have all the offense you want...but if your "run prevention" sucks...then you aint goin nowhere...see example-red sox(1918-2003), current florida marlins, texas rangers(entire history), colorado rockies(for 99% of their team's history)...and so on and so forth...but back to topic...despite how many less errors reyes and castillo will end up having in comparison, but think about all the other runs that they will save by turning the double play just that much better(just like luis did with seabass)...to overlook a defense's ability to influence the outcome of the amount of wins and losses a team has is a serious mistake...all that said...i still take hanley and uggla for several reasons that you have already pointed out...god what i would give to see miggy and hanley spend their whole career in the black and teal and uggla...well he can stay as long as he proves himself useful
August 4, 200719 yr true...and i like your point about defense and run prevention...but it doesnt matter who is pitching if you have bad defensive players, then you will have a bad defense...and if you have a bad defense, your pitching will struggle...its all quite a vicious circle Not necesarily. It depends on the type of pitchers you have. If you have a knuckleballer (who induces weak infield flies and weak grounders more than the normal pitcher), you can get away with having average defense. If you have a hard throwing sinkerballer (like Wang), you need an excellent defense, because the balls he puts into play are going to be extremely hard hit grounders, so you need a good defense or else those are going to find the holes. If you have a guy who strikes out 10 per 9 innings, walks like 2 or 3, and doesn't allow many home runs, you can, again get away with crappy defense because he's not leaning on them as much. This is why guys who strike out alot of batters and don't walk a lot of them are the best pitchers. Their value is less affected by the guys behind them, and they are more likely to be consistent. true...the type of pitcher is important to the defense...but knuckleballers are as prevelant in the game today as non corrupt politicians are in Washington...ie...very very very rare...and most teams dont have a guy who will strike out half the guys he sees(unless they are playing the marlins)... But when looking at the average pitcher in MLB, id rather have a bunch of great defenders behind him and average hitters than vice versa...because chances are...you will win more games than say the texas rangers, florida marlins, ny yankees, and etc. of the world The Yankees have won more games than any other team in the last 8 years except for the Athletics. You know what the Yankees and Athletics have in common? Thats right, score as many runs as possible and let your defense figure itself out. Billy Beane won 102 games in 2001 with an outfield of Johnny Damon, Jeremy Giambi, Terrence Long, and Jermain Dye. Long is the only defender there who is even close to being good, and yet they won 100 games (they also had Jason Giambi playing 140 games at 1st base). those teams also had pretty damn good pitching and you can sprinkle in a few gold gloves as well...giambi has never been more than a DH for the yankees and yeah you can point to the fact he has played first but he sucks terribly at it...point is...you can have all the offense you want...but if your "run prevention" sucks...then you aint goin nowhere...see example-red sox(1918-2003), current florida marlins, texas rangers(entire history), colorado rockies(for 99% of their team's history)...and so on and so forth...but back to topic...despite how many less errors reyes and castillo will end up having in comparison, but think about all the other runs that they will save by turning the double play just that much better(just like luis did with seabass)...to overlook a defense's ability to influence the outcome of the amount of wins and losses a team has is a serious mistake...all that said...i still take hanley and uggla for several reasons that you have already pointed out...god what i would give to see miggy and hanley spend their whole career in the black and teal and uggla...well he can stay as long as he proves himself useful Alright, well here's my stab at statistical analysis. This is a crude, and probably entirely misguided way to judge their ability to turn a double play, but I can't personally think of a better way without doing a lot of legwork first: Hanley and Danny have turned 139 DP this season. They have made a combined 908 putouts+assists. That is 15% of every out they record. Reyes and Castillo (albeit on different teams) have made 796 PO+A, and 112 DP, between the two of them. that is a 14% rate. That would be more useful if they had been on the same team, but Luis recorded only 12% of his outs as DP in Minnesota. The average 2B in NYM this season turned a DP about 13% of the time they made an out. Thus, by my extremely crude (and most likely entirely unreliable and surely unscientific) research, Luis probably won't represent a significant upgrade in terms of double plays allowed. (Note, I'm not sure if I proved anything with this. Luis is probably about even with Uggla with the glove at this point, as I really do feel Dan has a lot of skill at 2nd, and Luis has lost a step. I'd say Dan probably has a little more range at this point, but Luis' got a much stronger arm. As for Reyes and Hanley, Hanley's got the stronger arm, and they've got very similar range for now (though Hanley's gonna beef up and lose a step sooner or later), so the only real advantage Jose has is that he's more consistent with the glove. Hanley makes some stupid mental errors when fielding the ball, and often takes his eyes off of it. A number of his errors were on the catch at first. Basically, I don't think Reyes and Luis have a big enough advantage with the gloves to make up for Hanley and Dan's bats. I'd almost call it a wash in the field, but I'll give a slight nod to the Mets.)
August 4, 200719 yr As baseball fans it's easier to quantify everything with statistical analysis but with the ability to turn the DP it is more like a musician playing. You can have a Garage band play "Stairway to Heaven" and be accurate and precise but it sure doesn't sound the same
August 4, 200719 yr Dead serious. Epic, though it is, the first half sucks. It's a good song once it picks up ("and as we wind on down the road"), but before that part, it's pretty much a lost cause. Of course, I'm of the opinion that aside from their really heavy songs ("Heartbreaker", "Black Dog", etc), House of The Holy, and In Through The Out Door, I'm not a huge fan of their's. The mythic, viking, norse gods, bulls*** is a bit too much for me. I'd probably rank them about 10 on the list of 60's and 70's bands that are extremely good. They might be #1 on the "60's and 70's bands that are good, but aren't as good as those 9 bands from the same era who are better", though.
August 4, 200719 yr The first part sucks in your opinion. About 10 million other people think the first half, middle and last half are incredible.
August 4, 200719 yr The first part sucks in your opinion. About 10 million other people think the first half, middle and last half are incredible. Do I really need to state that it is, in fact, my opinion? I mean, come on. It's music. If you can't assume it's my opinion, then whats the point? I don't care if 10 million other people think the song is incredible. What the hell does that have to do with me liking it? Christ, I'm getting called out for having an opinion on a song now? Come on, man. Your better than this. Now to the topic, Castillo doesn't make the Mets significantly better. At most he'll add one win in the next 2 months.
August 4, 200719 yr Back to Luis. Reyes is not a difference maker on defense at short. He is good, but terribly overrated. He doesn't "steal" outs the way an Ozzie Smith or Omar Vizquel does. Hell, I don't even think he's as good as Alex Gonzalez 2000-2004 with the glove. Yeah his arm is FANTASTIC, but if the footwork is so so and the range is aided basically only by speed and not instinct (yeah, I hate that expression, but it's the only way to get it across) he's not stealing any outs or creating any double plays above and beyond that of an average or slightly above average short-stop. Second base is an overrated position for turning the DP, anyway, it's basically catch and throw except in extremely rare circumstances...and if those rare events turn into 6 more DP's over the course of a season, that's not winning a division.
August 4, 200719 yr Back to Luis. Reyes is not a difference maker on defense at short. He is good, but terribly overrated. He doesn't "steal" outs the way an Ozzie Smith or Omar Vizquel does. Hell, I don't even think he's as good as Alex Gonzalez 2000-2004 with the glove. Yeah his arm is FANTASTIC, but if the footwork is so so and the range is aided basically only by speed and not instinct (yeah, I hate that expression, but it's the only way to get it across) he's not stealing any outs or creating any double plays above and beyond that of an average or slightly above average short-stop. Second base is an overrated position for turning the DP, anyway, it's basically catch and throw except in extremely rare circumstances...and if those rare events turn into 6 more DP's over the course of a season, that's not winning a division. ur nuts, Reyes is wicked defensively, you can argue him for being top 3 defensive SS in the NL this year behind Jack Wilson and Omar.
August 4, 200719 yr Back to Luis. Reyes is not a difference maker on defense at short. He is good, but terribly overrated. He doesn't "steal" outs the way an Ozzie Smith or Omar Vizquel does. Hell, I don't even think he's as good as Alex Gonzalez 2000-2004 with the glove. Yeah his arm is FANTASTIC, but if the footwork is so so and the range is aided basically only by speed and not instinct (yeah, I hate that expression, but it's the only way to get it across) he's not stealing any outs or creating any double plays above and beyond that of an average or slightly above average short-stop. Second base is an overrated position for turning the DP, anyway, it's basically catch and throw except in extremely rare circumstances...and if those rare events turn into 6 more DP's over the course of a season, that's not winning a division. ur nuts, Reyes is wicked defensively, you can argue him for being top 3 defensive SS in the NL this year behind Jack Wilson and Omar. No, you can't. Middle of the pack fielding percentage, middle of the pack put outs. Second worst range factor of any qualified NL short-stop (ahead of only JJ Hardy). Then again, he is the "most overrated exciting player in baseball" ? This isn't to say he's bad defensively, but he's tremendously overrated.
August 4, 200719 yr Back to Luis. Reyes is not a difference maker on defense at short. He is good, but terribly overrated. He doesn't "steal" outs the way an Ozzie Smith or Omar Vizquel does. Hell, I don't even think he's as good as Alex Gonzalez 2000-2004 with the glove. Yeah his arm is FANTASTIC, but if the footwork is so so and the range is aided basically only by speed and not instinct (yeah, I hate that expression, but it's the only way to get it across) he's not stealing any outs or creating any double plays above and beyond that of an average or slightly above average short-stop. Second base is an overrated position for turning the DP, anyway, it's basically catch and throw except in extremely rare circumstances...and if those rare events turn into 6 more DP's over the course of a season, that's not winning a division. ur nuts, Reyes is wicked defensively, you can argue him for being top 3 defensive SS in the NL this year behind Jack Wilson and Omar. No, you can't. Middle of the pack fielding percentage, middle of the pack put outs. Second worst range factor of any qualified NL short-stop (ahead of only JJ Hardy). Then again, he is the "most overrated exciting player in baseball" ? I mean, most fielding metrics are flawed, but if every single one agrees that a player is not all that good, then something's gotta give. And most fielding metrics show Reyes to be very average.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.