November 28, 200718 yr I'm married to a teacher and I'm the son of a 25 year teaching veteran. I have a bit of perspective on the issue. Not sure what to tell you then...time is regularly taken from me and other teachers for the purpose of "building relationships with students" with this notion that we should all be amazing mentors to kids. I think its great when someone can be, but it is not something you can engineer forcibly. Unless you can find anything in the constitution that gives the federal government that authority - to basically bribe local governments into compliance with rules they have no authority to develop - I refer you to the 10th Amendment. It's not bribery. It's spending for the common welfare. In legal terms, that is very broad authority. Constitution please. They say "do this our way and we'll give you money". I personally have a difficult time chat=racterizing that differently. If it wasn't for the federal government's involvement in local schools with the SC ruling of "Brown v. Board of Education (Topeka, KS)", there is a decent possibility that there could still be school segregation. Racial Segregation was ruled unconstitutional. I have no problem with the federal government enforcing the Constitution and constitutional pronouncements. I do have a problem with the Federal government ignoring the constitution and exerting powers it doesn't legally have.
November 29, 200718 yr If it wasn't for the federal government's involvement in local schools with the SC ruling of "Brown v. Board of Education (Topeka, KS)", there is a decent possibility that there could still be school segregation. Considering that it took the National Guard to get schools to integrate in some cases, I don't have much faith that the Southern states would have integrated on their own any time soon. That's a non sequitur and you know it.How so?The Supreme Court is not 'federal intervention' as almost everyone refers to it. That, and no one is talking about sending the National Guard to schools. Federal intervention in schools as defined in the context of this argument is simply stating Congress exercising oversight over the schools through funds and conditions on those funds is what's being talked about.
November 29, 200718 yr I'm married to a teacher and I'm the son of a 25 year teaching veteran. I have a bit of perspective on the issue. Not sure what to tell you then...time is regularly taken from me and other teachers for the purpose of "building relationships with students" with this notion that we should all be amazing mentors to kids. I think its great when someone can be, but it is not something you can engineer forcibly.I think you took my words and took them in a different direction. I said I'd like to see and would want more leaders in our schools. What is there to disagree about with that? May not be realistic, but it will be my hope when I have kids one day to send them to a place that will not only teach them, but inspire them. Educators can be leaders and role models as well. Thats all I'm saying.
November 29, 200718 yr Let me start by saying that the main issues that interest me in this election are: effectively managing Iraq, curbing spending, enacting economic policies that will spur growth, and reforming education. However, I'm not committed to a candidate solely on the basis of how much I agree with them on these particular issues. I select my candidate based upon two factors: how much I agree with them and whether or not they will actually be able to get what they want done in office. And, while I'm willing to sacrifice some issue agreement for the sake of competence, I'm not willing to do the opposite. I'd much rather have someone in office who gets things done that I'm not 100% on board with but improve the status quo than a guy who may agree with me on issues but fails to get anything done while in office. This is one of the main reasons why I'm incredibly surprised that Ron Paul has attracted the following that he has. Whether you agree with his principles of not, do you honestly think any of his policies (with the exception, perhaps, of pulling out of Iraq) will ever see the light of day in a Democratically controlled Congress. Same thing goes with Huckabee's tax proposals (The ones that deal with fair tax and getting rid of the IRS, not the tax increases that happened under his governorship). As for the discussion about what we can do to improve our education system, I honestly think that interests are far too entrenched for anything remotely significant to ever get accomplished in the short-term. The main problem that most school districts face is the power that Teacher's Unions have acquired. If you honestly want to see substantive change in the quality of our public education system, you have to be willing to take on the unions. Good luck finding a Democrat who is willing to fight that fight. They get WAY too much money from the teacher's union to ever go against them. It would amount to political suicide. As for Republicans, we're fixated on vouchers as the be-all-end-all when it obviously isn't. Why do I single out the teacher's union? Because they operate under the misguided notion that to admit that teachers can respond to incentives hurts their cause in the long-run. By this, I mean that if you recommend performance pay for teachers, the teacher's union will take it as an insult and an insinuation that a teacher would work harder if they got paid more (like any other job) as opposed to doing their job solely out of their concern for their students. Teachers do some of the most underappreciated and noble work you can possibly do, but to say that more money won't equal more effort is just absurd. I think one of the biggest problems society faces when it tries to address the education problem is that it wants the answers to the education problem to look a certain way. Hoenstly, for me, if the answer is ugly but gets it done, I'm fine with it. I'm taking an economics course titled, "Race in America" that's looking at ways in which economic and statistical models can be used to better understand disparities among races in things ranging from health care, incarceration rates, and academic achievement. Naturally, inner city education is a big focus of the course. We've studied programs in NYC public schools where inner city students were each given personal laptop computers loaded with all sorts of education sofware(YES! you heard that right) hoping that this would cause improved academic performance. Naturally, the program had no effect on achievement because you can't expect a kid to start testing better just because you throw him a laptop without improving quality of teachers, home environment, and neighborhood peer effects. Here are some of the things I think could go a long way towards improving the system: - Increase the length of the school year (It sucks, but every other industrialized country that outperforms us has more school days than we do.) - Get away from the idea that smaller class sizes causes better test scores. (If you consider the amount of good teachers to be a scarce resource, reducing class sizes can actually lead to worse results. It forces schools to fill shortages with potentially underqualified employees, it puts schools in a position where it can't really fire underperforming teachers, and it minimizes the number of students who get taught by the excellent/role model teachers.) - Remove bureaucratic barriers and do away with needless district wide mandates. - Give school principals the effective responsibility of school CEO. He/she has a budget to manage teacher salary for the employees that work at that school and he/she has to allocate that buget as efficiently as he/she possibly can. Naturally, he/she ought to be provided with discretion to pay teachers according to performance or to attract more qualified teachers from better schools, if he/she so chooses. A principal would also have the discretion to conceivably hire a college grad with a degree in chemistry but no education degree to teach chemistry, something that can't be done under the current system. However, he/she will be held accountable for how that school performs on standardized testing. Additonally, we've gotten to the point where school performance on standardized tests can be evaluated by levels of improvement and not solely on the average score of students in that school. If improvement is seen year-to-year that principal is considered to be doing a good job. If performance falters, the principal will have time to make adjustments. Further poor performance, and changes are made. - Target students that are high risk for causing distractions and disrupting the classroom environment. Take them out of normal classrooms so that teachers don't need to devote significant amounts of time dealing with students who impact the educational experience of the rest of the class and have them taught in classrooms with teachers equipped to deal with these problem students. Obviously pay for said teachers can be raised and performance for these students won't be evaluated like students who have shown they can function in a normal classroom environment (None of this NCLB garbage).
November 29, 200718 yr This is one of the main reasons why I'm incredibly surprised that Ron Paul has attracted the following that he has. Whether you agree with his principles of not, do you honestly think any of his policies (with the exception, perhaps, of pulling out of Iraq) will ever see the light of day in a Democratically controlled Congress. Same thing goes with Huckabee's tax proposals (The ones that deal with fair tax and getting rid of the IRS, not the tax increases that happened under his governorship). Just a quick comment - maybe you are right, and even if you are, the money we will save from ending our empire alone will be worth it. But I don't think something like a competeing currency backed by Gold & Silver would be impossible with the Democrats, if a President Paul could make the case for it from that bully pulpit. And that would also be huge. Why do I single out the teacher's union? Because they operate under the misguided notion that to admit that teachers can respond to incentives hurts their cause in the long-run. By this, I mean that if you recommend performance pay for teachers, the teacher's union will take it as an insult and an insinuation that a teacher would work harder if they got paid more (like any other job) as opposed to doing their job solely out of their concern for their students. Teachers do some of the most underappreciated and noble work you can possibly do, but to say that more money won't equal more effort is just absurd. I don't support the unions, but here is the problem - how do you measure performance to reward teachers? A teacher in an inner-city high school will not produce the same grades as they would as a suburban elementary school teacher. The student body that you work with has a huge impact and one size does not fit all with education. Either way the federal government ought to stay out of it.
November 29, 200718 yr I said I'd like to see and would want more leaders in our schools. What is there to disagree about with that? May not be realistic, but it will be my hope when I have kids one day to send them to a place that will not only teach them, but inspire them. Educators can be leaders and role models as well. Thats all I'm saying. All I am saying is that you cannot train people to inspire, nor try to engineer it any other way. It happens in the right circustances. But if everyone else in child's life was doing their job, then they would never need to draw on a teacher for inspiration.
November 29, 200718 yr I don't support the unions, but here is the problem - how do you measure performance to reward teachers? A teacher in an inner-city high school will not produce the same grades as they would as a suburban elementary school teacher. The student body that you work with has a huge impact and one size does not fit all with education. Either way the federal government ought to stay out of it. Over several years, students will have several teachers. The performance of teachers can be measured by comparing the performance of students while they were teaching them as contrasted to the same students performance in earlier and later grades. By measuring against the community's average, you can filter out any regional bias. That said, I don't think the federal government should be involved.
November 29, 200718 yr I don't support the unions, but here is the problem - how do you measure performance to reward teachers? A teacher in an inner-city high school will not produce the same grades as they would as a suburban elementary school teacher. The student body that you work with has a huge impact and one size does not fit all with education. Either way the federal government ought to stay out of it. That's precisely why I said that we need to evolve the way in which we analyze performance. A better alternative to simply looking at passing rates by class (the current method) is to measure a teacher based upon student improvement. The old method (passing rates) is really dumb and is obviously subject to the biases you list (good teachers in bad schools are penalized for poor performance relative to teachers of similar quality in good schools). All of these students have ID numbers and what not that allows you track their performance year to year. With that information, it's possible to assess the impact that an individual teacher had on the performance of their students. If these tests are able to determine what grade level the student's reading and math abilities are, you can take the student's grade level ability in reading and math at the end of the previous year and compare how much they improved over the year. Teachers can be evaluated by the average improvement seen by their students. That way, you're comparing the teachers on more even playing fields than simply evaluating them on the basis of how many students pass the standardized exam. Some can contend that summer effects can play a role. (There's theories out there that poor students tend to retain less knowledge over summer relative to richer students because richer students go to museum camps and the opera or whatever while poor students play on the streets) If you want to control for that, you can simply administer a test at the beginning of the year and consider those results to be the initial results you'll compare the end-of-year results to as opposed to the results from last years exam. It's not perfect, but it gets the job done in a better way than current methods.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.