November 26, 200718 yr Tee Ball Bunt Machine has the right idea. Moneterally, this country has been heading down a slippery slope since the mid 90's. The present criminals occupying the executive branch have only worsened the situation by spending vast amounts of paper money on the reckless occupation of Iraq. IMO, in our lifetimes, we will see the value of the dollar decrease dramatically. What's happened over the last few years is only the prelim. I'd advise all to put away some gold and silver. At a minimum 10% of your net worth. The issue most important is money and the value of the dollar. It's probably too late, save for some enlightened policies from Washington, which are rare in our history. To this end the issues most important are . . 1. Ending the Iraqi occupation 2. Raising taxes on the top 1% 3. Nationalizing the oil companies or completely overhauling the tax structure for the oil companies and drug companies. The rest is more long term. Overall, avoid tariffs and look to 4. Restricting our higher education to US citizens, especially in the sciences 5. Bolstering our own education system from 1st grade to graduate school . . Civil liberties and the power of the executive branch is a big issue. But I think this is something that's more a function of Bush, Cheney in power...than any long-term trend.
November 26, 200718 yr From what I know of Paul, isn't he more interested in, essentially, allowing the free market to take over schools? No. He is interested in getting the federal government out (since it is illegal) and thus giving power back to the states and local governments who (IMO) are better able to assess and address the needs of their students than is Washington DC. [TypicalRonPaulSupporter]As a rich 20 year old who has never had to work for anything in my life, I fully support any measure that allows the rich to get richer and keeps the poor down, while creating an ever smaller middle class.[/TypicalRonPaulSupporter] Do some research. I dare you. Dr. Paul's #1 issue (that no other candidate will touch BTW) is sound money and the value of the dollar, and the fact that we have an ever-increasing money supply feeding the military-industrial complex devauling our money and that, more than anything else, is what causes the transfer of wealth from the poor & middle class to the wealthy. If schools compete, like in Belgium, they would be better. It's not about competition, it's about choice. One-size-fits-all doesn't work in education. Not every kid is going to be a doctor or lawyer or engineer. If you force the same "standards" and requirements on all schools public and private, the deciding factor will be who has the most agreeable student body, as they will all be doing the exact same things with the same expectations. But if you give the locals back control, they can address the needs of their students by giving them options as to the type of education they receive. And how exactly do you equalize situations? Isn't it implicit that the teacher who teaches in a wealthy public neighborhood has a better chance of success than a teacher who teaches in inner city school? Less distractions, more cooperative students, better parents to help, tutors, small class sizes because of small class populations. The problem lies in trying to assess the quality of all schools with their diverse populations and needs by the same narrow set of standards. Once you stop doing that, and you allow the locals to handle it, then there is no immediate need to "equalize" anything. Tee Ball Bunt Machine has the right idea. Moneterally, this country has been heading down a slippery slope since the mid 90's. The present criminals occupying the executive branch have only worsened the situation by spending vast amounts of paper money on the reckless occupation of Iraq. IMO, in our lifetimes, we will see the value of the dollar decrease dramatically. What's happened over the last few years is only the prelim. I'd advise all to put away some gold and silver. At a minimum 10% of your net worth. The issue most important is money and the value of the dollar. It's probably too late, save for some enlightened policies from Washington, which are rare in our history. To this end the issues most important are . . 1. Ending the Iraqi occupation 2. Raising taxes on the top 1% 3. Nationalizing the oil companies or completely overhauling the tax structure for the oil companies and drug companies. The rest is more long term. Overall, avoid tariffs and look to 4. Restricting our higher education to US citizens, especially in the sciences 5. Bolstering our own education system from 1st grade to graduate school While I appreciate your agreement with my assessment I have to respectfully disagree with your solutions. #1 - no argument, but then I'd take it a step further and end all of our occupations (at least in so far as is feasable, which I believe is completely) #2 - we need to stop wasting money, not taxing more. At the end of the day, any increase in taxes on the rich will get passed down to the rest of us - they don't feel a need to absorb those hits. And then even if we repeal that tax increase a week later, the prices will stay up and their profits will increase. #3 - corporate welfare is the problem, and further blurring the lines between the economic interests of a few with the government will only exacerbate the situation. We are already used to going to war to protect industrial interests. Socialism is not the answer. #4 - No. You don't punish immigrants by making them a perpetual underclass just because our immigration system is trash and doesn't do its job. Even with immigration reform I wouldn't support this. Not to mention how many fewer poor American students will get scolarships to prestigious universities without the money flowing in from wealthier international students. #5 - Not at the federal level. The Federal Dept. of Education is a failure and a waste of money, on top of being Unconstitutional (check the 10th Amendment). Let the locals handle it.
November 26, 200718 yr 1. Ending the Iraqi occupation 2. Raising taxes on the top 1% 3. Nationalizing the oil companies or completely overhauling the tax structure for the oil companies and drug companies. The rest is more long term. Overall, avoid tariffs and look to 4. Restricting our higher education to US citizens, especially in the sciences 5. Bolstering our own education system from 1st grade to graduate school 1. Agreed 2. Agreed 3. There's no chance of nationalizing the oil companies, but they certainly shouldn't be receiving government money when they are making boatloads of profits. 4. I disagree. We do need to do something about the lack of US competition in math and science, but there is no reason to kick out people who want to come here to get their education. 5. Agreed.
November 26, 200718 yr A free market system would reward better teachers with better pay and therefore improve the system, but teacher's pay has very little to do with quality of education? Am I missing something? The one thing you are missing is that truly good teachers are stuck being paid at the fixed salary increase system alongside bad teachers, thereby taking away the finanial incentive for teachers to want to improve their craft. Thus, we have a system that does not reward competance, it merely rewards years in the system regardless of teaching skill or effort. In theory, wouldn't increasing the salary of a public school teacher make it more lucrative competition wise and therefore more likely to attract good teachers and on the same field as private schools? Many private schools pay less (see parochial and non-super elite private schools), but because they do not subject teachers to a crap load of red tape, the product is better. Teachers teach better when they have more preps, creativity, and the ability to more easily work with parents. Apparently, when parents choose their child's school (and pay for it) they take a more concerned and active role in their child's education. Parental support, especially in high needs schools, is a must. I'm guessing you are trying to say we should make teachers compete for their salary? Something like "the more students in your class who get As or who get better test scores, the higher you are ranked, the more your salary becomes", right? And the worse you do, the lower your salary or you lose your job? Not really. Such test-score based salary increases encourage teachers to encourage cheating. I merely advocate the removing of red tape and letting the market decide salary. I agree that bad teachers need to lose their jobs and federal control over schools might be too distant, but how does Ron Paul address any of this? By getting rid of federal red tape, the federal grant money, and the federal mandated testing, you have less cheating, cheaper schools, and more teacher freedom. However, to be completely honest, I have worked in a school that if it did not have standardized testing, it would graduate practically illiterate students. So, I am not opposed to state level examinations. However, education in this country has not improved with an increase in per-pupil spending. So money is not going to fix this problem. Increased regulation has not fixed it. Deregulation is definitely worth a shot. How have private schools offered quality education all these years, many times for less money than the public schools pay? And how exactly do you equalize situations? Isn't it implicit that the teacher who teaches in a wealthy public neighborhood has a better chance of success than a teacher who teaches in inner city school? Less distractions, more cooperative students, better parents to help, tutors, small class sizes because of small class populations. You cannot equalize the situations. Anyone who has taught in a city has observed this. You can spend nearly 20,000 perpupil like in Newark NJ and the schools will still be God awful. What is needed is much less regulation so that urban school systems may totally redevelop their educational programs. Quite frankly, with graduation rates of 50% WITH rampid cheating among teachers, it is simply not realistic to attempt pproviding the same exact education for every student in the city as in the suburbs. Cities should start experimenting with a German system of education, which gives some students specialties and training in jobs, and other students the well-rounded education. If it were all up to me, I would give only 50% of students access to the well-rounded education. Ironically, not only would you emulate the contemporary graduation rates for the run of the mill education program (because students would compete to join the "elite" schools instead of taking them for granted), you would graduate more students from the other schools with useful skills. This means less teens become adults who turn to crime. This leads to a more stable society, which in turn leads to better students. Now, I am not saying my program is perfect, I am merely speculating. However, the system we have now DOES NOT WORK and reduc ed class size and increased spending have not improved a thing. (Though, as a NY teacher, the relatively good salary and non-insane claass sizes are certainly nice...)  If I am a top of the line teacher, why would I go to a situation that would make me less likely to succeed, such as an inner city school, vs. a situation that would make me more likely to succeed? Teachers with the most brains are almost always not the best city school teachers. Teachers with street smarts and good classroom management techniques are the best. What we need are more people from the inner-city to teach in the inner-city. Personally, I feel that my ivy league masters degree is a useless piece of sh*t in the bronx. Teachers with much less education, I humbly admit, can do much better when they have ethnic and cultural advantages working for them. It appears that you are advocating that we take some of the future rocket scientists and stockbrokers, and turn them into teachers. Those people, unless they have street smarts, are not helpful in the inner-city. Chicago has this exact situation. The out suburbs pay teachers much much more, and they actively steal teachers who teach in the city by offering higher salaries and benefits plus better kids. The city can never keep its good teachers. It is not just salaries. Minority youth who grown up in environments without whites are highly racist of white teachers and the surrounding neighborhood is often the same. Personally, I have been a victim of a "hate crime" on my way from work because I am white. Those sort of things play a much larger role in the exodus of teachers to the suburbs. Cities are dangerous and education is not valued as highly. Teachers like having their work valued. A lot of this has nothing to do with money.  Don't you think parachial schools do better because they have more funding too? They have less. But maybe your point is that a privately run school works better at weeding out bad teachers than publicly run schools which have to keep on teachers? Perhaps. But what stops a privately run school that looks at profit margin and sees other factors other than its employees as preventing max profit margin? What if they start kicking bad kids out? What if they feel an inner city school is hemorging their profits so they reduce resources because it isn't benecial to keep it open? Don't we have major problems in the health care world including HMOs rejecting necessary procedures because they look only at the bottom line? In my honest opinioon, one of the things that hurt education the most is the practice of no longer leaving back poor students and catering so much to increasingly disruptive students. Disruptive students literally ruin the education of many more students than their number. Perhaps a school which thinks of the bottom line instead of asking for tax increases every time it has a problem will get more accomplished.  Regardless of the preceding, your wife's issues with her job are only worsened by the federal government. Her salary is determined by the locality in which she works. I am sure she would like not dealing with No Child Left Behind.
November 26, 200718 yr My wife, as a first year teacher, gets paid a ridiculously low amount for what she actually does. I won't allow her to do more out of classroom time then she has to based on her pay and what her hourly wage is when you combine out of classroom time. I strongly disagree with the notion that higher pay would not equal better teachers and thus a better learning environment for the teacher. If my wife was paid more, she'd put in more time out of the classroom and in turn, give a better experience to her students. If there was less red tape, she would be able to do more in less time. If teachers were allowed to write off on our taxes on our business expenses, like buying classroom things, we would be able to keep more of our money. The highly regulated and expensive system we have now does not address either of these things.  Privately owned schools will just allow the people with money to get good education, while those who can't afford it won't be able to go to school, or will end up at an awful institution. And that's not already happening?
November 26, 200718 yr 1. Ending the Iraqi occupation 2. Raising taxes on the top 1% 3. Nationalizing the oil companies or completely overhauling the tax structure for the oil companies and drug companies. The rest is more long term. Overall, avoid tariffs and look to 4. Restricting our higher education to US citizens, especially in the sciences 5. Bolstering our own education system from 1st grade to graduate school 1. Agreed. 2. Not sure. If you end the Iraqi occupation we may not need to raise taxes. 3. Disagree. This is a free market economy, let's keep it that way. The government doesn't know how to run companies. 4. No way. A lot of non US citizens who come to study math and science here end up staying and becoming American citizens. At the very least, they contribute to research coming out of this country. This is, honestly, the dumbest idea I've read in a long time. 5. Can't disagree. I think our education is actually better than most people give it credit for. It emphasizes problem solving and creativity, which is the hallmark for ingenuity. That's why we create the best products and programs in the world, and that's why we'll continue to be leaders in so many industries. While students in other countries memorize more and learn to mimick their teachers well, our people come up with new ideas. I think our college education system is vastly superior. Those are my thoughts.
November 26, 200718 yr 1. Ending the Iraqi occupation 2. Raising taxes on the top 1% 3. Nationalizing the oil companies or completely overhauling the tax structure for the oil companies and drug companies. The rest is more long term. Overall, avoid tariffs and look to 4. Restricting our higher education to US citizens, especially in the sciences 5. Bolstering our own education system from 1st grade to graduate school 1. Agreed. 2. Not sure. If you end the Iraqi occupation we may not need to raise taxes. 3. Disagree. This is a free market economy, let's keep it that way. The government doesn't know how to run companies. 4. No way. A lot of non US citizens who come to study math and science here end up staying and becoming American citizens. At the very least, they contribute to research coming out of this country. This is, honestly, the dumbest idea I've read in a long time. 5. Can't disagree. I think our education is actually better than most people give it credit for. It emphasizes problem solving and creativity, which is the hallmark for ingenuity. That's why we create the best products and programs in the world, and that's why we'll continue to be leaders in so many industries. While students in other countries memorize more and learn to mimick their teachers well, our people come up with new ideas. I think our college education system is vastly superior. Those are my thoughts. Very true.
November 26, 200718 yr 1. Ending the Iraqi occupation 2. Raising taxes on the top 1% 3. Nationalizing the oil companies or completely overhauling the tax structure for the oil companies and drug companies. The rest is more long term. Overall, avoid tariffs and look to 4. Restricting our higher education to US citizens, especially in the sciences 5. Bolstering our own education system from 1st grade to graduate school 1. Agreed. 2. Not sure. If you end the Iraqi occupation we may not need to raise taxes. 3. Disagree. This is a free market economy, let's keep it that way. The government doesn't know how to run companies. 4. No way. A lot of non US citizens who come to study math and science here end up staying and becoming American citizens. At the very least, they contribute to research coming out of this country. This is, honestly, the dumbest idea I've read in a long time. 5. Can't disagree. I think our education is actually better than most people give it credit for. It emphasizes problem solving and creativity, which is the hallmark for ingenuity. That's why we create the best products and programs in the world, and that's why we'll continue to be leaders in so many industries. While students in other countries memorize more and learn to mimick their teachers well, our people come up with new ideas. I think our college education system is vastly superior. Those are my thoughts. . . . I made my initial points brief. To elaborate a little. I think that even with the spending stopping in Iraq, a tax raise is still needed for the long-term. I wouldn't want to see taxes on the wealthy at the crazy levels we see in Europe, but a modest 10-20% raise would help balance the books without destroying the incentive to achieve. . . Long term, something needs to be done to control health costs. The best way to do this is by revamping our tax codes and other laws that have Americans bearing the brunt of the R & D dollars. In so many ways, the tables are tilted in favor of the drug and health care companies. They have too much lobbying power. I'm not for national health care. I think the way to attack the health care crisis is by controlling prices and providing incentives. On energy, again we need to revamp the tax codes to provide the oil companies with the incentives to move away from oil and towards alternative fuels. Nationalization would not be the preferable option. I'd prefer to effect the change through incentives. . . I agree that our college and graduate programs are vastly superior to anyone else's. It's precisely this advantage that we should take advantage of. Sure, there are foreign students who stay here after college, but the vast majority go back to their own countries to help foreign companies become more competitive against US companies. I realize that it's somewhat of a radical idea, but desperate times call for radical ideas.
November 26, 200718 yr So what? In actuality, a lot of them go back and work for US companies abroad. It's fine that they compete against us. We're not afraid of anything. We're America. We can compete against anyone. The reality is that the quality of our graduate programs would decline significantly if we were to implement your idea. That means American students and American universities would suffer greatly, and you would see that decline in our economy as well. In addition, most of the students that come to study here end up having an appreciation and love for this country that will be reflected in the politics of other countries.
November 26, 200718 yr So what? In actuality, a lot of them go back and work for US companies abroad. It's fine that they compete against us. We're not afraid of anything. We're America. We can compete against anyone. The reality is that the quality of our graduate programs would decline significantly if we were to implement your idea. That means American students and American universities would suffer greatly, and you would see that decline in our economy as well. In addition, most of the students that come to study here end up having an appreciation and love for this country that will be reflected in the politics of other countries. We can compete, yes. But we're at a bit of a competitive disadvantage due to labor/health care costs here vs. abroad. Rather than tackling this disadvantage with tariffs or other similar moves, I think my thought is a valid one. The quality of our graduate and post-graduate programs would not necessarilly decline if foreign students were not allowed in. The shortfall that the universities would incur could be offset by increased assistance from the goverment. Say, an additional $5,000 per year non need based grant to all students in certain fields of study, allowing the universities to effectively raise their tuitions by close to $5,000 per year. And/or, a direct subsidy to university pofessors. The love and appreciation you speak of is hard to quantify, but my thought is that we're not training politicians. We're giving away the keys to the kingdom in training Chinese, Indian, etc, scientists who will in the vast majority go back to their countries, make their countries companies stronger, and have no effect on what the politicians think.
November 26, 200718 yr Author Cities should start experimenting with a German system of education, which gives some students specialties and training in jobs, and other students the well-rounded education. I'm pretty sure NYC had something like this in the 70's ( and may still have it, to be honest. I don't know). NOt sure if it was successful, but it has been tried.
November 26, 200718 yr Cities should start experimenting with a German system of education, which gives some students specialties and training in jobs, and other students the well-rounded education. I'm pretty sure NYC had something like this in the 70's ( and may still have it, to be honest. I don't know). NOt sure if it was successful, but it has been tried. I know for a fact that this did not occur. If you can provide an example and link to anything, that would be appreciated.
November 26, 200718 yr 1. Ending the Iraqi occupation 2. Raising taxes on the top 1% 3. Nationalizing the oil companies or completely overhauling the tax structure for the oil companies and drug companies. The rest is more long term. Overall, avoid tariffs and look to 4. Restricting our higher education to US citizens, especially in the sciences 5. Bolstering our own education system from 1st grade to graduate school 1. Agreed. 2. Not sure. If you end the Iraqi occupation we may not need to raise taxes. 3. Disagree. This is a free market economy, let's keep it that way. The government doesn't know how to run companies. 4. No way. A lot of non US citizens who come to study math and science here end up staying and becoming American citizens. At the very least, they contribute to research coming out of this country. This is, honestly, the dumbest idea I've read in a long time. 5. Can't disagree. I think our education is actually better than most people give it credit for. It emphasizes problem solving and creativity, which is the hallmark for ingenuity. That's why we create the best products and programs in the world, and that's why we'll continue to be leaders in so many industries. While students in other countries memorize more and learn to mimick their teachers well, our people come up with new ideas. I think our college education system is vastly superior. Those are my thoughts. Very true.   No doubt about our college education but I'd have to disagree overall that grades K-12 are much better here than they get credit for. Some personal examples: I went to first and second grade in Germany and when I arrived here at the end of 2nd grade, I was ridiculously ahead because the teacher would teach like half the time and half the time we colored and played with toys. My high school where I just graduated from, a decent public school, was a breeze unless you took AP courses. I hate to admit it but I don't know much about history/government/economics/etc. and I got an A in the honor classes. It's all a big joke, basically. And I know that it's not just my school. Now I'm stuck taking an Intermediate Algebra class in college because my Algebra 2 teacher was too incompetent to teach us right. It really does go back to the argument of teachers but there's also a medium that needs to be addressed. Prinmenito said we emphasize creativity and problem solving but what about the basics in math and science, not just applications? We do create a good amount of the best products/programs but don't get carried away. I would say Math and Science fields are still dominated by other countries. I think my boyfriend said it best (he went to school in China)..."I'll kick your ass in math but I wouldn't be able to locate Alaska on a map" ( :lol :| ) Yeah so obviously every country has its education problem but us 'being the best' I'm disappointed that the balance is pretty off.
November 26, 200718 yr I would say Math and Science fields are still dominated by other countries. Here is an example of how New York is addressing this particular problem. I know they are working on passing legislation to fund further incentives to address the need for better secondary school math and science teachers. The bottom line is that there is little incentive in most of the United States to teach with a degree [especially an advanced degree as is required by NYS] in math and science when you can obtain a much more lucrative position in the private sector right out of the gate. If you want better teachers, you need to pay higher salaries. Period.
November 26, 200718 yr This is from RudyTHEGANGSTER Many private schools pay less (see parochial and non-super elite private schools), but because they do not subject teachers to a crap load of red tape, the product is better. Teachers teach better when they have more preps, creativity, and the ability to more easily work with parents. Apparently, when parents choose their child's school (and pay for it) they take a more concerned and active role in their child's education. Parental support, especially in high needs schools, is a must. Private schools also do not require their teachers to hold certification in the subjects they teach. Most high-end prestigious schools do impose these requirements on their faculties but the reality of it is, anyone with enough money can open a school with a Bachelor's degree. Additionally, I am a teacher and there really is no clear cut solution to our education problems but the biggest incentive for students to do well is for them to be accountable to their parents.
November 26, 200718 yr So what? In actuality, a lot of them go back and work for US companies abroad. It's fine that they compete against us. We're not afraid of anything. We're America. We can compete against anyone. The reality is that the quality of our graduate programs would decline significantly if we were to implement your idea. That means American students and American universities would suffer greatly, and you would see that decline in our economy as well. In addition, most of the students that come to study here end up having an appreciation and love for this country that will be reflected in the politics of other countries. We can compete, yes. But we're at a bit of a competitive disadvantage due to labor/health care costs here vs. abroad. Rather than tackling this disadvantage with tariffs or other similar moves, I think my thought is a valid one. The quality of our graduate and post-graduate programs would not necessarilly decline if foreign students were not allowed in. The shortfall that the universities would incur could be offset by increased assistance from the goverment. Say, an additional $5,000 per year non need based grant to all students in certain fields of study, allowing the universities to effectively raise their tuitions by close to $5,000 per year. And/or, a direct subsidy to university pofessors. The love and appreciation you speak of is hard to quantify, but my thought is that we're not training politicians. We're giving away the keys to the kingdom in training Chinese, Indian, etc, scientists who will in the vast majority go back to their countries, make their countries companies stronger, and have no effect on what the politicians think. I am not talking about the price of tuition. That is irrelevent. The top doctoral programs actually pay their students to attend. There is no tuition. I don't give a rat's ass about tuition (and neither do the universities). The quality of the programs would decrease because we would no longer be taking the best and brightest from the world, but instead would be taking the best and brightest from the United States. In other words, you would be decreasing the quality of the students. Believe it or not, you learn more from your fellow students than you do from textbooks or professors. You simply would have lower quality programs. Many graduate students produce outstanding work in many fields on their own and even more help our scientists in the labs. Trust me, we would suffer greatly, and it would not have the effect you think it will. Our universities produce the best scientific research in the world, bar none. No one else is even close. And we do that in large part because, well, we have the best students and faculty from ALL OVER THE WORLD. In addition, your idea is way too outlandish because the government can't simply not allow any foreign students without facing a massive backlash from universities and corporations across the country. You're wrong that we're not training politicians. Many presidents and ministers around the world have studied here. In addition, in politics there are always battles of ideas in large part impacted by the positions of the private industries. If those industries are headed by American trained businessmen or scientists, you bet your ass we're better off than if those industries were headed by Russian or Chinese trained businessmen or scientists. I went to a top undergrad and graduate school and all the foreigners I met that returned to their home country have an incredible appreciation for America and the American way.
November 26, 200718 yr Author Cities should start experimenting with a German system of education, which gives some students specialties and training in jobs, and other students the well-rounded education. I'm pretty sure NYC had something like this in the 70's ( and may still have it, to be honest. I don't know). NOt sure if it was successful, but it has been tried. I know for a fact that this did not occur. If you can provide an example and link to anything, that would be appreciated. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialized_H...f_New_York_City Take Brooklyn Technical High School: "Brooklyn Technical High School, commonly called Brooklyn Tech or just Tech, and also administratively sometimes as High School 430, is a New York City public high school that specializes in engineering, math and science and is the largest specialized high school for science, technology, engineering and mathematics in the United States. [3] Together with Stuyvesant High School and Bronx High School of Science, it is one of three original specialized science high schools, operated by the New York City Department of Education, all three of which were cited by The Washington Post in 2006 as among the best magnet schools in the United States.[4] Admission is by competitive examination though, as a public school, there is no tuition fee and only residents of the City of New York are eligible to attend.[5]" I knew I had read about it in a book (Fortress Of Solitude). It isn't a city wide thing, but these are publicly run schools in Brooklyn which follow much the same principles you outlined previously. Apparently they are successful, like I said I wasn't sure. So, yes, a system like that would work, but it doesn't necesarily have to be independent.
November 26, 200718 yr I made my initial points brief. To elaborate a little. I think that even with the spending stopping in Iraq, a tax raise is still needed for the long-term. I wouldn't want to see taxes on the wealthy at the crazy levels we see in Europe, but a modest 10-20% raise would help balance the books without destroying the incentive to achieve. Income taxes will never "balance the books". They are part of a system designed to keep the nation in perpetual debt and contain prosperity. They do not pay for any government services - they pay only for interest on loans that the government doesn't need to take. When Congress ever decides they care about the American people, they'll be able to do what was done the last time we killed the national bank - pay off the national debt. Long term, something needs to be done to control health costs. The market controlled costs before the government got involved. If the government got out of the way, the market can do it again. Very few people can pay hundreds of thousands for every treatment, and health care providers would not be able to charge so much if they had to deal with that. On energy, again we need to revamp the tax codes to provide the oil companies with the incentives to move away from oil and towards alternative fuels. Nationalization would not be the preferable option. I'd prefer to effect the change through incentives. We could also just stop subsidizing them with tax payer money and stop going to war to protect their interests. Let OPEC stop selling us oil - then the whole country will have plenty of incentive to solve this problem. But so long as our government continues its policy of protecting billionaire interests, there will be no incentive. I agree that our college and graduate programs are vastly superior to anyone else's. It's precisely this advantage that we should take advantage of. Sure, there are foreign students who stay here after college, but the vast majority go back to their own countries to help foreign companies become more competitive against US companies. I realize that it's somewhat of a radical idea, but desperate times call for radical ideas. Letting xenophobia guide policy has never worked. And as said earlier, the federal government has no constitutional authority to regulate education in any way shape or form. I guess one thing they could legally do though be to stop granting student visas. I don't really like the idea though. The end result will be better foreign schools absorbing the students we reject, and in a generation or two they surpass us and more of our top kids will be going abroad to study while universities close here.
November 27, 200718 yr I agree that our college and graduate programs are vastly superior to anyone else's. It's precisely this advantage that we should take advantage of. Sure, there are foreign students who stay here after college, but the vast majority go back to their own countries to help foreign companies become more competitive against US companies. I realize that it's somewhat of a radical idea, but desperate times call for radical ideas. Good stuff, pierre. My brother has made the same point but only related to math and sciences for several years now.
November 27, 200718 yr I agree that our college and graduate programs are vastly superior to anyone else's. It's precisely this advantage that we should take advantage of. Sure, there are foreign students who stay here after college, but the vast majority go back to their own countries to help foreign companies become more competitive against US companies. I realize that it's somewhat of a radical idea, but desperate times call for radical ideas. Good stuff, pierre. My brother has made the same point but only related to math and sciences for several years now. Yep. Keep them foreigners out of our colleges I say! :|
November 27, 200718 yr 1. Tax reform, consumption taxes would put US companies ahead in the world and spur our economy 2. Energy policy (Nuke plants, US drilling, new refineries, new vehicle fuels) 3. Fighting the war to win 4. Immigration reform (make it easier to come legally, but punish those that break the law) 5. Social program reform (restructure Social Security before it buries us, put a nominal cost on Medicare to reduce frivolous usage)
November 27, 200718 yr Cities should start experimenting with a German system of education, which gives some students specialties and training in jobs, and other students the well-rounded education. I'm pretty sure NYC had something like this in the 70's ( and may still have it, to be honest. I don't know). NOt sure if it was successful, but it has been tried. I know for a fact that this did not occur. If you can provide an example and link to anything, that would be appreciated. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialized_H...f_New_York_City Take Brooklyn Technical High School: "Brooklyn Technical High School, commonly called Brooklyn Tech or just Tech, and also administratively sometimes as High School 430, is a New York City public high school that specializes in engineering, math and science and is the largest specialized high school for science, technology, engineering and mathematics in the United States. [3] Together with Stuyvesant High School and Bronx High School of Science, it is one of three original specialized science high schools, operated by the New York City Department of Education, all three of which were cited by The Washington Post in 2006 as among the best magnet schools in the United States.[4] Admission is by competitive examination though, as a public school, there is no tuition fee and only residents of the City of New York are eligible to attend.[5]" I knew I had read about it in a book (Fortress Of Solitude). It isn't a city wide thing, but these are publicly run schools in Brooklyn which follow much the same principles you outlined previously. Apparently they are successful, like I said I wasn't sure. So, yes, a system like that would work, but it doesn't necesarily have to be independent. You pulled a 180, and began agreeing with my original point. However, the schools you noted are elite schools that cherry pick their students that include a well-rounded education WITH a specialization. In my honest opinion, you can yake a NYC school and make it "The School of Bacon Frying," but as long as you cherry pick students, it would be great.  Becaon High School is such an example. It is essentially a storage building turned communist training camp, but they choose their students...and now they are considered one of the finest high schools in America.  The specialization I would speak of would be much more extreme and it would be offered particularly to the bottom 50%, not the top 2%.
November 27, 200718 yr Author Cities should start experimenting with a German system of education, which gives some students specialties and training in jobs, and other students the well-rounded education. I'm pretty sure NYC had something like this in the 70's ( and may still have it, to be honest. I don't know). NOt sure if it was successful, but it has been tried. I know for a fact that this did not occur. If you can provide an example and link to anything, that would be appreciated. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialized_H...f_New_York_City Take Brooklyn Technical High School: "Brooklyn Technical High School, commonly called Brooklyn Tech or just Tech, and also administratively sometimes as High School 430, is a New York City public high school that specializes in engineering, math and science and is the largest specialized high school for science, technology, engineering and mathematics in the United States. [3] Together with Stuyvesant High School and Bronx High School of Science, it is one of three original specialized science high schools, operated by the New York City Department of Education, all three of which were cited by The Washington Post in 2006 as among the best magnet schools in the United States.[4] Admission is by competitive examination though, as a public school, there is no tuition fee and only residents of the City of New York are eligible to attend.[5]" I knew I had read about it in a book (Fortress Of Solitude). It isn't a city wide thing, but these are publicly run schools in Brooklyn which follow much the same principles you outlined previously. Apparently they are successful, like I said I wasn't sure. So, yes, a system like that would work, but it doesn't necesarily have to be independent. You pulled a 180, and began agreeing with my original point. However, the schools you noted are elite schools that cherry pick their students that include a well-rounded education WITH a specialization. In my honest opinion, you can yake a NYC school and make it "The School of Bacon Frying," but as long as you cherry pick students, it would be great.  Becaon High School is such an example. It is essentially a storage building turned communist training camp, but they choose their students...and now they are considered one of the finest high schools in America.  The specialization I would speak of would be much more extreme and it would be offered particularly to the bottom 50%, not the top 2%. I'm not sure I ever disagreed with you on that specific topic.  My point is there are schools that do such a thing, whether or not you think they do it right is an altogether different topic, but it seems to me like you will try to write off any successes in the public schooling system to serve your own point.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.