November 27, 200718 yr Cities should start experimenting with a German system of education, which gives some students specialties and training in jobs, and other students the well-rounded education. I'm pretty sure NYC had something like this in the 70's ( and may still have it, to be honest. I don't know). NOt sure if it was successful, but it has been tried. I know for a fact that this did not occur. If you can provide an example and link to anything, that would be appreciated. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialized_H...f_New_York_City Take Brooklyn Technical High School: "Brooklyn Technical High School, commonly called Brooklyn Tech or just Tech, and also administratively sometimes as High School 430, is a New York City public high school that specializes in engineering, math and science and is the largest specialized high school for science, technology, engineering and mathematics in the United States. [3] Together with Stuyvesant High School and Bronx High School of Science, it is one of three original specialized science high schools, operated by the New York City Department of Education, all three of which were cited by The Washington Post in 2006 as among the best magnet schools in the United States.[4] Admission is by competitive examination though, as a public school, there is no tuition fee and only residents of the City of New York are eligible to attend.[5]" I knew I had read about it in a book (Fortress Of Solitude). It isn't a city wide thing, but these are publicly run schools in Brooklyn which follow much the same principles you outlined previously. Apparently they are successful, like I said I wasn't sure. So, yes, a system like that would work, but it doesn't necesarily have to be independent. You pulled a 180, and began agreeing with my original point. However, the schools you noted are elite schools that cherry pick their students that include a well-rounded education WITH a specialization. In my honest opinion, you can yake a NYC school and make it "The School of Bacon Frying," but as long as you cherry pick students, it would be great. Becaon High School is such an example. It is essentially a storage building turned communist training camp, but they choose their students...and now they are considered one of the finest high schools in America. The specialization I would speak of would be much more extreme and it would be offered particularly to the bottom 50%, not the top 2%. I'm not sure I ever disagreed with you on that specific topic. My point is there are schools that do such a thing, whether or not you think they do it right is an altogether different topic, but it seems to me like you will try to write off any successes in the public schooling system to serve your own point. I do apologize for misunderstanding your original post, but let me make clear I am not a total enemy of public education. However, the problems with urban education in my opinion are much greater than what can be fixed with government interference. I am talking about gigantic social problems and ill conceived approaches to what education even means.
November 27, 200718 yr Author I do apologize for misunderstanding your original post, but let me make clear I am not a total enemy of public education. However, the problems with urban education in my opinion are much greater than what can be fixed with government interference. I am talking about gigantic social problems and ill conceived approaches to what education even means. Which is an important thing to note. It is going to be very difficult to change the minds of people in inner cities who don't seem as inclined to care about school, and I'm not sure there is a solution to this problem. It is a social problem, more than it is a government problem. Anyone can point to private or parochial schools and say "look how much better they do, it will work for everyone" because there are so many factors involved with this issue. The best way for kids to do well in school is for their parents to hold them accountable, but this isn't something that you can change by just changing the system. So what is the answer? No more compulsory public education? Vouchers? Letting the free market take over? Technical schools? I will agree with you that localities should be in charge of education, as they should (but that doesn't necesarily mean they will) have a better grip on what they need, but that doesn't mean the funding can't come from the federal govt.
November 27, 200718 yr Better administrators and better teachers would be a start. We need more Joe Clark's leading our tough schools then just throwing money at them when they don't know what to do with it or how to use it. I know when my father was going to school in the Bronx, the teachers there did little to no motivation and hardly hammered in to anyone's head accountability, personal responsibility, or a need to stay in school. Not saying this is universal or how the majority of it is today but I do know from family that is still in the area that it still isn't being done nearly enough. We also need to start concentrating on elementary school way more than we do as that is where kids learn the fundamentals and basis of the future of their education. The elementary grades are where kids can get the motivation and drive to succeed in school.
November 27, 200718 yr Better administrators and better teachers would be a start. Accountability starts at "home" - whatever a child's definition of "home" is. It's hard to concentrate on homework when you are worried about if your mom is going to buy bread with her food stamps or buy a bunch of similac and sell it on the streets for drugs instead. This is an even bigger problem when said mom doesn't know who her baby daddy is and gets arrested for buying drugs from an undercover narcotics agent and said child is shipped off to a cousin's or grandparent's house - sometimes in a different school district. I don't know what the answer is but - as bad as this sounds - abortion is probably a step in the right direction. I read a fascinating book called "Freakonomics." There is an interesting chapter in there that shows correlation between a massive reduction in crime and the verdict of Roe v. Wade. Crazy stuff if accurate.
November 27, 200718 yr I don't need tough home situations spelled out for me, I'm the product of someone who had a similar and possibly worse home life then what you describe. The thing about wanting accountability to start at home is a lot of times, that accountability will never be there. Ever. So is that kid just screwed? No, they need leaders in the school and classroom then if they won't be getting it elsewhere. I'm looking at this from the school's point of view, not an overall social point of view. You can't factor in accountability at home when it sometimes will never exist. My dad's mother was and is a drug addict. My dad had no father ever in his life. Now I believe my dad was inherently a great man which helped him to rise out of the slums and make a helluva life for himself but he also had one, single mentor at his school that helped him persevere and go to college. We need more people like that as leaders in the schools. I think they are too few and far between.
November 27, 200718 yr That is clearly the exception rather than the rule. Here are a couple of chapter summaries germaine to this discussion: Chapter 4: Where Have All the Criminals Gone? In this chapter, the authors set forth the controversial claim that has generated more attention than any other aspect of the book: Levitt?s research has suggested that the 1973 legalization of abortion was the cause of the dramatic decline in violent crime that had become apparent by the mid-1990s. Recognizing the volatility of this argument, the authors approach it from numerous perspectives, methodically challenging and undermining all of the most common theories that have been advanced to explain the sudden crime drop. In a detailed analysis, they demonstrate that factors such as improved policing strategies, new prisons, diminished drug demand, an aging population, stricter gun control, a strong economy, and a number of other possible explanations simply do not correlate with the available crime data. The authors note a number of variables that are strongly correlated with criminality, such as poverty or an unstable family environment, are also likely to be the same reasons that compel pregnant young women to seek abortions. Levitt?s research suggests that the drop in violent crime in the United States occurred at the same time that the first wave of babies conceived after the legalization of abortion were entering late adolescence. Presumably, many of the additional 1.6 million children who would have been born annually if abortion had remained illegal would have been at high risk for engaging in violent crime. Although the authors refrain from taking an ideological stance on the issue, they do conclude that women with the right to choose abortion tend to make good decisions, based on the crime data. Chapter 5: What Makes a Perfect Parent? Several years before Freakonomics was published, author Steven Levitt lost his infant son Andrew to a sudden, fatal bout of pneumococcal meningitis. In the aftermath of this tragedy, Levitt and his wife became active in several support groups for bereaved parents. Even as he sought help and guidance for the terrible loss, Levitt noticed the disproportionate number of parents in the groups whose children had drowned in backyard swimming pools. This prompted him to research the issue, as well as a number of other aspects of parenting, from an economic point of view. His research uncovered the high risk of allowing children to play in swimming pools: Levitt estimates that a child is more than 100 times more likely to die in a swimming pool than playing with a gun. In a series of subsequent articles, Levitt explored other facets of parenthood and their outcomes. He determined that in spite of the cottage industry of parenting and the millions of how-to books on the subject sold every year, who you are matters much more than what you do. In other words, positive parenting outcomes are linked more strongly to factors such as socioeconomic status and parental education than any specific parenting practices. Factors that are important in determining high standardized test scores in children include: highly educated parents, high socioeconomic status, maternal age of greater than thirty when the child was born, low birth weight, English as the primary language spoken in the home, parental involvement in the PTA, and many books in the home environment. Also, adopted children tended to have lower standardized test scores than their non-adopted peers.
November 27, 200718 yr he also had one, single mentor at his school that helped him persevere and go to college. We need more people like that as leaders in the schools. I think they are too few and far between. People like that are great, but if you think you can find enough people like that to fill every classroom in America then you simply aren't dealing in reality. You can't hire teachers with an expectation that they will all be great mentors to underpriviledged kids. Some people will have those special connections, but it isn't something you can engineer, and honestly, it really shouldn't be the responsibility of math and english teachers to instruct kids in social values and inspire them. If they can while also effectively delivering the material they are responsible for then great. But it isn't fair, to expect us to be an amazing life coach to 100-160 kids (give or take) for around $40K a year.
November 27, 200718 yr I will agree with you that localities should be in charge of education, as they should (but that doesn't necesarily mean they will) have a better grip on what they need, but that doesn't mean the funding can't come from the federal govt. It sounds good, but the fed uses that money to exert unconstitutional power over the local governments. I would rather local governments and schools would outright reject that money and take control by themselves. But why would the federal government need to fund education anyway? It is horrendously in debt, and any taxes it collects could be collected by the states & localities just the same if they were really needed.
November 28, 200718 yr I will agree with you that localities should be in charge of education, as they should (but that doesn't necesarily mean they will) have a better grip on what they need, but that doesn't mean the funding can't come from the federal govt. It sounds good, but the fed uses that money to exert unconstitutional power over the local governments. I would rather local governments and schools would outright reject that money and take control by themselves. How so? The federal government says: "if you do X we will give you money, if not, we won't." How is that unconstitutional?
November 28, 200718 yr he also had one, single mentor at his school that helped him persevere and go to college. We need more people like that as leaders in the schools. I think they are too few and far between. People like that are great, but if you think you can find enough people like that to fill every classroom in America then you simply aren't dealing in reality. You can't hire teachers with an expectation that they will all be great mentors to underpriviledged kids. Some people will have those special connections, but it isn't something you can engineer, and honestly, it really shouldn't be the responsibility of math and english teachers to instruct kids in social values and inspire them. If they can while also effectively delivering the material they are responsible for then great. But it isn't fair, to expect us to be an amazing life coach to 100-160 kids (give or take) for around $40K a year. Awesome. Saying we need more people like that equates to you implying I said we should have those people fill every classroom in America. I said we need more people like that in our schools. I don't get your point. Also, I've made clear my desire for teachers to get paid more (that 40k is not a reasonable figure either, new teachers are not getting paid that much) which will attract better teachers and people.
November 28, 200718 yr I will agree with you that localities should be in charge of education, as they should (but that doesn't necesarily mean they will) have a better grip on what they need, but that doesn't mean the funding can't come from the federal govt. It sounds good, but the fed uses that money to exert unconstitutional power over the local governments. I would rather local governments and schools would outright reject that money and take control by themselves. How so? The federal government says: "if you do X we will give you money, if not, we won't." How is that unconstitutional? Unless you can find anything in the constitution that gives the federal government that authority - to basically bribe local governments into compliance with rules they have no authority to develop - I refer you to the 10th Amendment.
November 28, 200718 yr he also had one, single mentor at his school that helped him persevere and go to college. We need more people like that as leaders in the schools. I think they are too few and far between. People like that are great, but if you think you can find enough people like that to fill every classroom in America then you simply aren't dealing in reality. You can't hire teachers with an expectation that they will all be great mentors to underpriviledged kids. Some people will have those special connections, but it isn't something you can engineer, and honestly, it really shouldn't be the responsibility of math and english teachers to instruct kids in social values and inspire them. If they can while also effectively delivering the material they are responsible for then great. But it isn't fair, to expect us to be an amazing life coach to 100-160 kids (give or take) for around $40K a year. Awesome. Saying we need more people like that equates to you implying I said we should have those people fill every classroom in America. I said we need more people like that in our schools. I don't get your point. Also, I've made clear my desire for teachers to get paid more (that 40k is not a reasonable figure either, new teachers are not getting paid that much) which will attract better teachers and people. Get a teaching job and you will understand where I am coming from.
November 28, 200718 yr he also had one, single mentor at his school that helped him persevere and go to college. We need more people like that as leaders in the schools. I think they are too few and far between. People like that are great, but if you think you can find enough people like that to fill every classroom in America then you simply aren't dealing in reality. You can't hire teachers with an expectation that they will all be great mentors to underpriviledged kids. Some people will have those special connections, but it isn't something you can engineer, and honestly, it really shouldn't be the responsibility of math and english teachers to instruct kids in social values and inspire them. If they can while also effectively delivering the material they are responsible for then great. But it isn't fair, to expect us to be an amazing life coach to 100-160 kids (give or take) for around $40K a year. Awesome. Saying we need more people like that equates to you implying I said we should have those people fill every classroom in America. I said we need more people like that in our schools. I don't get your point. Also, I've made clear my desire for teachers to get paid more (that 40k is not a reasonable figure either, new teachers are not getting paid that much) which will attract better teachers and people. Get a teaching job and you will understand where I am coming from. I'm married to a teacher and I'm the son of a 25 year teaching veteran. I have a bit of perspective on the issue.
November 28, 200718 yr Unless you can find anything in the constitution that gives the federal government that authority - to basically bribe local governments into compliance with rules they have no authority to develop - I refer you to the 10th Amendment. Sadly, the 10th Amendment is dead and buried.
November 28, 200718 yr I will agree with you that localities should be in charge of education, as they should (but that doesn't necesarily mean they will) have a better grip on what they need, but that doesn't mean the funding can't come from the federal govt. It sounds good, but the fed uses that money to exert unconstitutional power over the local governments. I would rather local governments and schools would outright reject that money and take control by themselves. How so? The federal government says: "if you do X we will give you money, if not, we won't." How is that unconstitutional? Unless you can find anything in the constitution that gives the federal government that authority - to basically bribe local governments into compliance with rules they have no authority to develop - I refer you to the 10th Amendment. It's not bribery. It's spending for the common welfare. In legal terms, that is very broad authority.
November 28, 200718 yr If it wasn't for the federal government's involvement in local schools with the SC ruling of "Brown v. Board of Education (Topeka, KS)", there is a decent possibility that there could still be school segregation. Considering that it took the National Guard to get schools to integrate in some cases, I don't have much faith that the Southern states would have integrated on their own any time soon.
November 28, 200718 yr If it wasn't for the federal government's involvement in local schools with the SC ruling of "Brown v. Board of Education (Topeka, KS)", there is a decent possibility that there could still be school segregation. Considering that it took the National Guard to get schools to integrate in some cases, I don't have much faith that the Southern states would have integrated on their own any time soon. That's a non sequitur and you know it.
November 28, 200718 yr If it wasn't for the federal government's involvement in local schools with the SC ruling of "Brown v. Board of Education (Topeka, KS)", there is a decent possibility that there could still be school segregation. Considering that it took the National Guard to get schools to integrate in some cases, I don't have much faith that the Southern states would have integrated on their own any time soon. That's a non sequitur and you know it. How so?
November 28, 200718 yr If it wasn't for the federal government's involvement in local schools with the SC ruling of "Brown v. Board of Education (Topeka, KS)", there is a decent possibility that there could still be school segregation. Considering that it took the National Guard to get schools to integrate in some cases, I don't have much faith that the Southern states would have integrated on their own any time soon. That's a non sequitur and you know it. How so? How do we know that wouldn't have happened without the federal government's hand? It never had a chance that way.
November 28, 200718 yr If it wasn't for the federal government's involvement in local schools with the SC ruling of "Brown v. Board of Education (Topeka, KS)", there is a decent possibility that there could still be school segregation. Considering that it took the National Guard to get schools to integrate in some cases, I don't have much faith that the Southern states would have integrated on their own any time soon. That's a non sequitur and you know it. How so? How do we know that wouldn't have happened without the federal government's hand? It never had a chance that way. :| :| :| :| :| :| :| First of all, by definition it would have taken longer because each state would have had to make the decision on its own had the Supreme Court not made that decision. Second of all, the shere resistence to the decision underscores how unlikely the southern states were to make that decision within a short period of time after Brown. Strong and open resistence lasted well into the 80s.
November 28, 200718 yr No sh*t. I'm simply backing up Juanky's reasoning of it being a non sequitur. Just because the federal government accomplishes something, doesn't mean that is the only and best way it could have happened. It was a loaded statement or 'fact' that isn't easily refutable since that was the only possible way that part of history could have unfolded. GM's post is nearly the definition of affirming the consequent.
November 28, 200718 yr He clearly made that statement with a certain historical and legal background. It's not like that statement was made in a vacuum. This isn't philosophy class. And what's up with using all these Latin terms? It's much better to use plain English, IMO. It certainly doesn't impress me.
November 28, 200718 yr He clearly made that statement with a certain historical and legal background. It's not like that statement was made in a vacuum. This isn't philosophy class. Thank you. Exactly my point.
November 28, 200718 yr And what's up with using all these Latin terms? It's much better to use plain English, IMO. It certainly doesn't impress me. I don't think Juanky's trying to impress you. The word is frequently used by English speaking people to describe illogical arguments. Not to mention, it's the most concise way of getting across what he's trying to say. Tell me, what sounds better: That's a non sequitur and you know it. or That's an non sequitur argument whose conclusion does not necesarily follow from its premises and you know it.
November 28, 200718 yr And what's up with using all these Latin terms? It's much better to use plain English, IMO. It certainly doesn't impress me. I don't think Juanky's trying to impress you. The word is frequently used by English speaking people to describe illogical arguments. Not to mention, it's the most concise way of getting across what he's trying to say. Tell me, what sounds better: That's a non sequitur and you know it. or That's an non sequitur argument whose conclusion does not necesarily follow from its premises and you know it. Or, how about, "that's a fallacious argument"? Don't get all condescending on me.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.