May 27, 200818 yr Greatest hitter of all time to wear a marlins jersey- Mike Piazza Smack dab in his prime. Greatest hitter of all time IN a marlins jersey- Gary Sheffield. Chris
May 28, 200818 yr Depends if you mean greatest player to even wear it, or greatest AS a Marlin... because I mean if its just anybody Im sure Luis Gonzo gets up there too... but my vote still goes to Sheffield.
May 28, 200818 yr We can't have a Greatest Marlins Hitter Ever thread without at least whispering the name of the all-time leader in pinch hits....Lenny Harris. True, he doesn't come close in terms of production when compared to Cabrera, Sheffield, or Piazza, but he was used in a completely different situation. There is some merit in that.
May 28, 200818 yr If Lenny Harris was a great hitter, he wouldn't have been a pinch hitter. That is how baseball works. Guys who aren't good enough to be regulars are platoons, guys who aren't good enough for that are pinch hitters.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.