Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

What makes America great?

Featured Replies

Opportunities. Whether you make it or not depends on YOU.

Far from the truth. Minorities in particular do not have all of the opportunities that others might have. It's just a sad fact of this country. The same goes for women, who are only making 60-70% or so on average as men are, and they are still having difficulties getting into the highest reaches of the political and business world, even after all this time. We still have a ways to go.

Inequities in opportunities between men and women are nonexistent. The fact is men and women who perform the same work earn the same salary. Women on the average earn less than men because of personal choices and not because of inequities in opportunities or pay.

 

There are still some inequities with minorities but even with the added hurdles their success depends on them.

 

 

What FutureGM forgot to mention is that even more than minorities and women, the people that have the hardest time in this country are the poor. A rich black person or woman has a lot more chances than a poor person of any ethnic group. We tend to ignore this very often, but from what I've seen growing up in a working class family is that I relate much more to a working class black person or white person than a high class hispanic.

While I agree the rich have more opportunities I think the poor have plenty of opportunities to succeed and if they don't I think the decisions they made throughout their lives are the primary cause for the lack of success as opposed to opportunities denied. This is not a 3rd world country where you're destined to a miserable life (in economic terms) if you were born poor.

 

There's no question that in the U.S. much more so than in a 3rd world country, the potential for upward mobility exists. There is also no question that decisions a person make in life affect what happens to you in the grand scheme of things. But it's undeniable that a lower class person has to work harder to be successful than someone born into money. The opposite is also true, there are people born with plenty of opportunities and they squander it.

This is in no way an argument for the government stepping in to 'help' the people in the workign class, it's a statement of a reality.

I have to say that I feel like Poloa is adhering to the old arguments used by the Reaganites to decry social welfare programs (ie. the 'welfare queens') that were just myths. Not unlike the current GOP boogeyman in the form of ACORN.

no where in the constitution does it say we should have a minimum wage or maternity leave or a department of education, transportation, health & human services, or social security, or healthcare for every american, or labor laws, or workman's comp, or

I have to say that I feel like Poloa is adhering to the old arguments used by the Reaganites to decry social welfare programs (ie. the 'welfare queens') that were just myths. Not unlike the current GOP boogeyman in the form of ACORN.

 

Under Clinton, most welfare was reformed anyway, because President Clinton believed in the Reaganite 'myths'. Since then welfare has been more about getting people back on their feet than just givign hand outs

Clinton was a very conservative Democrat who ran on continuing most of Reagan's policies economically, while moving in a different direction socially.

Clinton was a very conservative Democrat who ran on continuing most of Reagan's policies economically, while moving in a different direction socially.

 

Although, I didn't agree with all of Clinton's policies. He was a decent president. Had his screw ups and things I didn't like, but he worked well with the Republican congress to keep things moving.

I will concede that he was better than Bush, however.

 

I think most people can agree that that's not saying much.

I don't know about that. He robbed the trust funds and his foreign policy is arguably what culminated into 9/11.

 

I will concede that he was better than Bush, however.

 

IMO equal blame for 9/11 lies with Clinton and Bush II

I don't know about that. He robbed the trust funds and his foreign policy is arguably what culminated into 9/11.

 

I will concede that he was better than Bush, however.

 

Why not just take it back to Reagan and the military support and training the U.S. gave the Afghan mujahideen? But really none of these presidents had a hand in founding the terrorist organizations behind these attrocities. Blaming the U.S. for 9/11 is like blaming a woman for getting raped because she was wearing a skimpy dress.

  • Author

While Clinton had plenty of things wrong with him, I'll give him credit for having a balanced budget. While he certainly benefitted from the business cycle going well during his time in office, at least he doesn't have the insane spending of the last 8 years on his record.

 

I'm not sure how much I want to blame Reagan because if you do concede that the Soviets were a real threat, then it made sense to support the Mujahadin. But that should've been the end of it. We never should've been involved in the first Gulf War, we never should've stayed bombing Iraq with no-fly-zones and all that and never should've been building bases in the Middle East.

I don't know if supporting the mujaheddin was any trigger, but leaving that region to themselves afterwards, and letting the Taliban move in (with Pakistani help) probably caused a lot of the problems.

I don't know if supporting the mujaheddin was any trigger, but leaving that region to themselves afterwards, and letting the Taliban move in (with Pakistani help) probably caused a lot of the problems.

 

What were we going to do then? Occupy Afghanistan? We went in there back in the 80s to serve a purpose, which was served when the Mujaheddin pushed back the Soviets.

 

I agree with Penguino that I am no fan of Clinton's foreign policy, but together with the Republican controlled Congress, aside from the balanced budget, they also managed to reform other spending programs. I do have to read up on what Penguino is saying about the trust funds, because I was unaware about that.

I'm surprised you aren't familiar with it given your wealth of knowledge. Or perhaps I'm just poorly describing it.

 

Clinton's legacy is saved by the fact that Bush 43 proved to be one of the worst presidents in US history. Clinton never ran a budget surplus, he actually used clever accounting tricks to cook the books. He essentially treated the Social Security funds as general revenues to "balance the budget." In 1998, he reported a $69 billion surplus, but this includes almost $100 billion of social security revenue. This is important because these trust funds should technically be counted toward the national debt. Factoring in these obliged entitlements through programs like Social Security or drug plans, the de facto national debt would approach something like $50,000,000,000,000 that we will have to answer to in the coming decades.

 

The question you need to ask in regards to Clinton is "did he actually cut anything?" Our fiscal dilemma is a philosophical problem not an accounting problem. Fiddling with wasteful social programs is not merely enough to solve the impending crisis of the national debt.

 

Thanks for the info, I try to educate myself as much as possible, but a few things always fall thorough the cracks.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.