October 29, 200818 yr I agree. My belief is that the 2nd amendment was created so that we the people may protect ourselves from tyranny. I'm in the minority that says that the 2nd Amendment was only meant for militias, not individuals.
October 29, 200818 yr The militia was individuals. If our government God forbid in my lifetime becomes so tyrannical and the people must revolt, individuals will compose a militia. If the second amendment were taken away, the government would truly have nothing to fear. I do not trust the nature of those in power enough to surrender that right.
October 29, 200818 yr I agree. My belief is that the 2nd amendment was created so that we the people may protect ourselves from tyranny. I'm in the minority that says that the 2nd Amendment was only meant for militias, not individuals. there are so many scenarios that can put the general public in harms way.....or do you believe the gov will always be there to defend people?
October 29, 200818 yr We're screwed regardless if the government for whatever reason wanted to take over. They have weapons far more advanced than the average citizen. It's extremely unlikely that it will ever happen, so I'm not counting on it. I would like to see restrictions on guns so that only small handguns and hunting rifles/shotguns can be legally owned in this country. People don't need military grade automatic weapons or assault rifles for self-defense or for hunting purposes. We need to ban ownership of things like Bushmaster assault rifles, automatic shotguns, Uzis, MAC-10s, TEC-9s, etc.
October 29, 200818 yr No way the government could quell an uprising of millions of Americans even if they were only armed with basic hunting rifles. In war quality is usually more important than quantity, but quantity can still win.
October 29, 200818 yr I just don't foresee the government doing such a thing. If they were going to do it, it would have been under this administration in the name of 'national security', and it didn't happen. That leads me to believe that it's never going to happen, short of a nuclear weapon detonating on US soil.
October 29, 200818 yr Author although I am against legal possession of guns, I have to argue with you that a person can rob a bank with a rock. You can't make knife's illegal, there are always other ways of robbing a bank and killing other people. But guns are the cause of the majority of murders in this country, nobody can dispute that making the possession of guns would significantly decrease the death rate in the U.S That's exactly what I'm saying. And also, someone could try to rob a bank with a rock, it would just be really hard to do. And stupid. And sorry Jimmy Jack for turning your thread into the exact opposite of what you wanted. Couldn't help it no problem...oh...and more information coming out...and i dont have the link sorry...but apparently the boy's father was standing right behind him when the incident occurred and supposedly he was offered to fire other auto rifles but they decided on firing the uzi because of its size and little recoil...that worked out well huh? anyone under 16 should not be allowed by law to fire any kind of a weapon IMO because they cant fully comprehend at that age the consequences of guns
October 29, 200818 yr I agree. My belief is that the 2nd amendment was created so that we the people may protect ourselves from tyranny. I'm in the minority that says that the 2nd Amendment was only meant for militias, not individuals. The militia has been nationalized as the national guard. So the militia that is supposed to defend our rights against tyranny is now controlled by the government. Furthermore, to say something like tyranny WILL NEVER happen is completely absurd. You have no way to know that it'll never happen, you think it's unlikely, sure. You don't know what can happen 50 years from now, 60, 100. That's why we have the constitution to protect us from the government. Hell, let's get rid of that first amendment, the government isn't going to control the content of speech or of the press. Especially not on the radio.
October 30, 200818 yr "but but but guns don't kill people! People kill people!" Man, what a sad story. RIP. Seriously, who lets an 8-year old kid shoot a gun period--let alone a gun of that magnitude? Supervision my butt, the "licensed official" was probably some drunk guy named Chuck. I think whoever let him touch the gun should be tried for negligence, or something. The problem here is with a PERSON letting an 8 year old use that sort of weapon, not the weapon itself.So it remains true that people kill people. The gun didn't float up int othe air on its own and shoot anybody. It required the stupidity of a human being for this incident to happen. Fingers don't kill people. Bullets do. Bullets dont fly around the air unless someone causes it to. You can kill someone with a rock if you throw it at them as well, should we ban rocks? I can argue against this all day. Here's the thing. People kill people. Guns make it really easy for people to kill people. Would someone rob a bank with a rock? It's only hard to rob a bank with a rock because the security guards probably do have guns. If I were living in a society where nobody could legally own a gun and the police rarely carried guns and I certainly think I could rob a bank with rocks. Or at least a few molotov cocktails. Or are we gonna make bottles and flammable liquids illegal too? You're never gonna be able to prohibit every possible dangerous weapon because once you do, someone who wants to commit a violent act will invent a new one. The best you can do is create a situation where the law abiding citizens have the means to protect themselves. I don't say that it would stop every criminal, but if most armed robbers and such knew that the person they were about to target was armed and capable of fighting back, they would turn around. Even for criminals, money is worth killing over, its not worth dying over. Yeah, the thing in the OP is horrible and ridiculous. The "licensed professional" who was supervising should be charged with negligent homicide and the office that licensed him should be sanctioned as well. But we all realize how insane this situation is and it doesn't have anything to do with the gun, it has to do with the idiot "supervising". Yes, people kill people. People killed people before guns were invented, and if we should reach a time when guns are rendered obsolete, then people will continue killing people once guns are gone. Punish the guilty who kill and let then innocent keep their means of protection, and also punish the idiots who put children in harm's way.
October 30, 200818 yr I just don't foresee the government doing such a thing. If they were going to do it, it would have been under this administration in the name of 'national security', and it didn't happen. That leads me to believe that it's never going to happen, short of a nuclear weapon detonating on US soil. They did go in and take away guns from everyone after Hurricane Katrina, which contributed to a good bit of looting since no one could really defend their own property.
October 30, 200818 yr I just don't foresee the government doing such a thing. If they were going to do it, it would have been under this administration in the name of 'national security', and it didn't happen. That leads me to believe that it's never going to happen, short of a nuclear weapon detonating on US soil. They did go in and take away guns from everyone after Hurricane Katrina, which contributed to a good bit of looting since no one could really defend their own property. Yes, then Blackwater was patrolling the Garden District with weapons-free authority. :blink:
October 30, 200818 yr I just don't foresee the government doing such a thing. If they were going to do it, it would have been under this administration in the name of 'national security', and it didn't happen. That leads me to believe that it's never going to happen, short of a nuclear weapon detonating on US soil. They did go in and take away guns from everyone after Hurricane Katrina, which contributed to a good bit of looting since no one could really defend their own property. Yes, then Blackwater was patrolling the Garden District with weapons-free authority. :blink: My point is that government coming in and siezing the firearms of private citizens isn't some phantom boogey man scare tactic scenario we are inventing for the purpose of trying to justify the 2nd Amendment. It is something that has and can very realistically occur in our modern nation.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.