November 11, 200818 yr This is the bottom line. People aren't upset because of the people we got rid of. People are upset because of the FO intentions of making this trade. It wasn't done to help our team, it was done to save every possible penny possible. That has been this teams motto for years. It's sad we can't maintain a $40 million payroll. If we kept Scott Olsen, that would've allowed us to move a guy like Anibal to the bullpen and be an insurance pitcher and safety spot just in case a guy like Olsen did bad, Miller wasn't ready to be a starter or one of the top three got injured. Now that Olsen is gone, I feel that we are on thin ice when it comes to starting pitching. We do not have an insurance pitcher in case one of our guys flop or gets injured, we would be stuck putting in a Ryan Tucker or a Rick Vanden Hurk into the rotation. If we were going to trade Olsen, we would've liked it to be for a catcher, because like it or not, that is a position of need for us. I'm surprised we needed to add Willingham to get this deal done. I would've thought Olsen could've comanded those three players easily. All I am trying to say here is that we dug ourselves into a potential whole here, and we may look back at this trade later on next season and say this is what cost us a shot at the playoffs. An insurance pitcher can be signed, in free agency. Those aren't difficult to find. Re: Dan Meyer, Rick VandenHurk Rick VandenHurk= Middle Reliever (he is good for 4 innings then implodes, not close to starter material) Don't know enough about Meyer to evaluate him
November 11, 200818 yr A 4.63 ERA / 1.45 WHIP is probably right along the lines of a #5. Especially when you consider that Olsen's stuff now is worse than when he entered the league, leading to declining K rates, every year. A pitcher who doesn't K many batters, and pitches to contact, allowing plenty of fly balls is not a good combo. Olsen also has a 5.35 career ERA away from Dolphin Stadium. Not sure what you'd call that, but I'm sure it can't be more than a #4 (to be nice). I'm more of a what have you done lately kind of guy and Scott Olsen was a pretty solid starter all season long. It's not like he is now going to a homerun heaven in DC either. And while his K rate went down, his hits, baa, walks, opp obp, slg all improved. I think I would take that kind of improvement anyday. Oh yea, he' all of 25 years old too. Irregardless if the Marlins have a nice player to take his place, you don't just throw a player like this away for the package we got in return. Furthermore, in Olsen's 3 seasons now, his rookie and third year are more likely the player you are going to see than the 2007 version that was abysmal.
November 11, 200818 yr But we traded Olsen away to relieve some salary cap space. Why would we then go out and spend money on an insurance pitcher for about the same price if we already had a guy who has shown he can be a reliable starter? We traded away Olsen b/c the Marlins weren't going to pay him arbritration, considering he's shown he's not worthy of the type of money he wants to receive. A 4.63 ERA / 1.45 WHIP says that. A 5.35 ERA (6+ ERA this past year) away from Dolphin Stadium says that. Insurance pitchers aren't supposed to cost a team millions per year. The Marlins are fine with Nolasco & JJ (whom they still have to pay arby to), Volstad, Miller, and Sanchez / insurance pitcher (a guy like Pavano who will probably produce the same type of #'s as Olsen, if healthy...at a cheaper price). It's not a big deal. I'm just upset with what we received, when you consider the rumors were for Max Ramirez, not so long ago. Olsen and Willingham leaving? I wish them the best of luck, but I won't miss their production. I'm confident Andrew Miller can, at least, produce a mid-4 ERA (which IS Scott Olsen), as I am confident that Cody Ross can produce equally / better than Willingham offensively...while providing more, defensively. Not worried. The difference is Andrew Miller isn't going to give you the 200 innings Olsen gave us
November 11, 200818 yr The difference is Andrew Miller isn't going to give you the 200 innings Olsen gave us Why not?
November 11, 200818 yr The difference is Andrew Miller isn't going to give you the 200 innings Olsen gave us ?
November 11, 200818 yr You people actually expect Andrew Miller to pitch 200 innings next year with his control issues?
November 11, 200818 yr You people actually expect Andrew Miller to pitch 200 innings next year with his control issues? Does it really matter, though? I think he can come close to it...maybe he won't reach it. But, really...how many # 4's give you 200 innings, anyways? If Nolasco, Josh Johnson, and possibly even Volstad (with HIS control) can stay healthy...they can give 200 innings. I don't envision a lack of innings from starters being a problem this year. I mean...we're not starting the year with Hendrickson / Vanden Hurk / Badenhop / (you remember the rest) this year. Miller is tougher to figure out...the potential is definitely there; it's a "we'll see" type of thing.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.