January 2, 201016 yr People didn't even know who the centerpiece of the Josh Willingham trade was supposed to be. At some point we thought it was PJ Dean (before he vanished and retired), then during the first week of the season we felt it was Bonifacio, now many believe it is Smolinski. Overall, it was a horrible trade when it happen and is still a horrible trade imo. Salary dumps ftw! That was a horrible trade, period. that trade was to get rid of olsen. we knew willingam was good, if not great Willingham was replaceable in our OF. Plain and simple. He was a fan fav, but continuous back problems that he refused to get fixed and guys that could step right in made him expendable. I always thought, and recently more or less confirmed, that he was the throw in to get that trade done. Think about it a bit. The Nats had more OFers than most 2 teams had at that time. And did we really miss him this year? Olsen was the guy they really wanted to get rid of. Off field problems and poor attitude made him trade viable. I do have stories to back this up, but they are not for here. Suffice it to say that some suspicions me and some friends had were confirmed.
January 2, 201016 yr The trade was driven largely by Willingham's back problems and his arbitration eligibility, but the Marlins absolutely could have used him in 2009. Hermida struggled terribly and Maybin showed little indication of being ready. Willingham was considered to be trade bait not because of his ability but for the reasons I just mentioned. They essentially had to choose to keep either Hermida or Willingham. Hammer was the odd man out because of his back and the Marlins' hopes that Hermida would finally break out. They made the wrong choice but that's only in hindsight. The Marlins are very fortunate that Coghlan answered the call or else that trade would have looked like a massive failure.
January 2, 201016 yr It's too bad that the Marlins didn't trade Hermida to the Nationals instead of Willingham. Hermida would have likely fetched a little more that Willingham would have. Chalk it up that sometimes Admin Beinfest makes a mistake, after all, he is human.
January 3, 201016 yr The trade was driven largely by Willingham's back problems and his arbitration eligibility, but the Marlins absolutely could have used him in 2009. Hermida struggled terribly and Maybin showed little indication of being ready. Willingham was considered to be trade bait not because of his ability but for the reasons I just mentioned. They essentially had to choose to keep either Hermida or Willingham. Hammer was the odd man out because of his back and the Marlins' hopes that Hermida would finally break out. They made the wrong choice but that's only in hindsight. The Marlins are very fortunate that Coghlan answered the call or else that trade would have looked like a massive failure. That trade was driven to download Scotty. Willingham was to entice them a little more. And anyone following the Marlins knew that both would be on the table for trade that off season, for different reasons. But I will say it was a bit of a head scratcher as to why they would want another OFer on their roster. He wasn't even a starter for them at first. Jeremy had been on the trading block since about halfway through the season before. It's only reasonable to assume they did offer him but the Nats opted for Josh instead. About the only correct decision that GM made. Took a guy with a decent bat that he knew probably wouldn't be an every day starter because of his back over a guy that for the most part had been underachieving. They needed SPs badly, and we wanted to get rid of Scotty. After that it was just what had to be included on both sides to make the deal happen.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.