Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

I give

Ichiro, Ryan Franklin and Matt Cain

I get

Nick Markakis, Jose Reyes and Jonathan Papelbon.

 

Was this a smart trade for me? This is in a league worth 250 Dollars.

Thats a horrible trade imo. Cain is a beast, as is ichiro and franklin. Markakis has looked like just an above average player instead of taking that next step in his development. Jose Reyes is good but has been terrible so far. Papelbon as well has been pretty wild so far. K/bb is terrible thus far. You can tell you tried to matchup what you get but i dont like it for you.

I see a bunch of overrated fantasy players and Matt Cain. Matt Cain wins...you lost.

It's not that bad of a trade, but losing Matt Cain kills you.

  • Author

I don't think losing Cain kills me as much since I have Ubaldo Jimenez, Matt Garza and Adam Wainwright.

I also have some solid pitchers in Carmona, Pavano, Wells and Silva who all have 3 wins and ERA's under 5.

The reason I could afford losing Ichiro is because I already have Werth, Byrd, Podsednik, Soriano, Quentin and Hunter in the OF and Ichiro really hasn't done anything out of the ordinary and I feel Reyes and Markakis can replace his production.

I feel that Papelbon is the more reliable closer aswell even though his team is struggling he's done well in SVO.

  • Author

Also, should I pick up any of these pitchers?

Wade Davis, Jaime Moyer, Gio Gonzalez.

If so who should I drop.

Carmona, Silva or Randy Wells.

Also, should I pick up any of these pitchers?

Wade Davis, Jaime Moyer, Gio Gonzalez.

If so who should I drop.

Carmona, Silva or Randy Wells.

 

 

 

 

Drop Silva and Wells and pick up Davis and Gio.

  • Author

What about this trade I was offered?

 

Zimmerman and Willingham

for

Wainwright Podsednik and Gregg

 

I'm trying to have him give me Slowey also. would that be a good deal.

I'm kind of 50/50 because Pods is a great run scorer and will steal bases and Wainwright is my 3rd best pitcher plus Gregg is my second closer and I have Cantu manning 3rd base at the moment.

I would not accept that 2nd offer. Wainwright is extremely consistent and should win 16-18 games or so. Zimmerman is a really good player but I hold Wainwright to be more valuable for fantasy. They are the major players in that deal so you should evaluate them and not other "add ins"

  • Author

I would not accept that 2nd offer. Wainwright is extremely consistent and should win 16-18 games or so. Zimmerman is a really good player but I hold Wainwright to be more valuable for fantasy. They are the major players in that deal so you should evaluate them and not other "add ins"

 

 

Yeah I wasn't really feeling the trade either as I'm losing more then I'm getting.

 

Also Jose Reyes 2/3 2 Runs 2 SB Today!

What about this trade I was offered?

 

Zimmerman and Willingham

for

Wainwright Podsednik and Gregg

 

I'm trying to have him give me Slowey also. would that be a good deal.

I'm kind of 50/50 because Pods is a great run scorer and will steal bases and Wainwright is my 3rd best pitcher plus Gregg is my second closer and I have Cantu manning 3rd base at the moment.

 

 

 

No

  • Author

Another deal sent.

David Freese for Carl Pavano

Possibly Freese and Rasmus for Pavano and Hunter or Quentin.

Should I do it

or

Rasmus or Freese and Leo Nunez for Pavano and Tori Hunter.

 

Please respond ASAP.

 

P.S. I'm getting Rasmus/Freese/Leo.

  • Author

May I inform you guys, this is a head to head league where the stats are averaged together by the entire team.

 

Runs/HR/RBI/AVG/SB are the hitting Categories.

Wins/Strikeouts/Saves/ERA/WHIP are the pitching categories.

Kazmir for Greinke and Markakis---

 

I send Kaz to the other team. Thoughts?

 

Thoughts on Johan Santana and Adrian Gonzalez for Hanley and David Wright?

 

I have Santana, Sabathia, Johnson, Nolasco, Strasburg, Kazmir, Bedard, Livan Hernandez currently.

  • Author

Kazmir for Greinke and Markakis---

 

I send Kaz to the other team. Thoughts?

 

Thoughts on Johan Santana and Adrian Gonzalez for Hanley and David Wright?

 

I have Santana, Sabathia, Johnson, Nolasco, Strasburg, Kazmir, Bedard, Livan Hernandez currently.

 

 

Kazmire for Greinke and Markakis is a steal the other guy has to be dumb.

 

I'd do Santana and Gonzalez for Hanley and Wright if you needed a better SS and 3B since you're staff is pretty good already.

  • 1 month later...

Kazmir for Greinke and Markakis---

 

I send Kaz to the other team. Thoughts?

 

Thoughts on Johan Santana and Adrian Gonzalez for Hanley and David Wright?

 

I have Santana, Sabathia, Johnson, Nolasco, Strasburg, Kazmir, Bedard, Livan Hernandez currently.

 

 

 

I'd make both deals.

Funny how some of these things turn out, and how you're right/wrong. Like I told MMP to drop Carlos Silva...who would've thought Carlos Silva would do what he's done? At least I've been correct on some, as well, though. :hat

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...