August 6, 201016 yr In this case it does not matter where it landed once it passed third base because it bounced before getting to the bag. That is the rule in Major League Baseball. Once a ball bounces before either first or third it is considered a "bounding" ball. And a "bounding" ball is judged fair or foul by where it is the moment it passes the bag, not where it eventually lands. A bounding ball can pass the bag fair, land 10 feet foul, and be a fair ball, or vice-versa since it is called based on where the ball was as it passed the bag. As for the kinds of curves and paths balls can take: baseballs are unpredictable. You are talking about, in this case, a ball that bounced twice, is rotating a ridiculous amount of times per second off of a jagged surface, it is not all that crazy to believe it could pick up a little bit of english. I am not well versed in aerodynamics, but I understand enough to know why knuckle balls work, and why bouncing balls do not travel in a straight line. This is what I said in another thread on the matter, and I think it is relevant here too: It's not impossible, it could have taken a "bad" hop on the second hit, and curved around the bag just slightly. Harold Reynolds demonstrated how balls can curve once they bounce on the MLB Network tonight (on a smooth studio set, not even a pitted, beat up dirt infield): http://mlb.mlb.com/v...ent_id=10659457 And a lot of people, including in that clip, do not understand MLB rules. Once a ball has bounced before passing the bag, it is all about where the ball is when it passes the bag. The ball tonight could have landed 10 feet fair, and everyone could have seen it, but if it really did curl around the bag it would be a foul ball. Davidson was right there and didn't flinch an inch, he watched the entire play and believes he made the right call. Any ball that "bounds [which means it bounced at least once before reaching the bag] past first or third base on or over foul territory" is a foul ball according to MLB rules: http://mlb.mlb.com/m...on_of_terms.pdf Again, not trying to be rude, but I dont need a lesson in baseball my friend. Where it lands is still indicative of where it originates from, unless there is some strong, strong wind, that's just physics. Bob Davidson made a premature call, because he clearly did not know where the ball was over the base. Yes, I understand a ball can curve due to it's spin. A bad hop would do nothing but send it in one direction, it would never send it out and back in. A ball cannot at that speed sneak out and back in, let alone at high speeds without an outer force effecting it. You've got to remember that the ball is already moving in one direction! A ball cant complete a 180 degree arch after going almost 0 degrees out of nowhere. That ball doesnt have enough energy to be going towards the outfield, turn left, then quickly turn right again, and then continue towards the outfield. There was not strong enough wind to move that ball in the air either. The ball defnitely can be heading one direction and then after another bounce be heading another direction, but it can change directions in air. You cant even significantly see that with pitches, which are traveling at a much higher velocity, and have much higher energy than that ball did. You're ignorant to think Davidson watched the entire play, I'm sorry. A ball moving at such speeds cannot change directions without an outside force acting on it. It cant "sneak around the bag". It can definitely bounce and turn, Im not doubting that, but it wont be a 8 inch curveball (moving left to right rather than up to down) off the ground. It hit the line, it went over the base directly over the line. Davidson figured since Gaby pulled it that it's only direction would have been FOUL. It makes sense, because it was very hard to see. But since the end of fair territory is the end of 3rd base, and the ball was traveling in fair territory directly over the line, and crossed the plate on a bang-bang play, and landed fair, it's evident that even though the ball was hit towards the foul territory, it took a hop off the dirt and changed directions, once, into fair territory, and then went back towards foul grounds. Davidson simply made his decision too soon, because he tried to put 2 and 2 together when in fact the other number was 3. Yes, and the ball landed two different times before it crossed the bag. Also, spiraling balls do not travel in straight lines, they wobble. Footballs, baseballs, etc., it doesn't matter. The spin put on them can make them take weird paths. Baseballs move in three dimensions, not just up and down, not just side to side, both all directions, at the same time. The ball was heading towards the outfield, but it can curve just a bit here and there on the way, there is nothing not normal about that. Again, go watch the Harold Reynolds video I linked to above. He shows you in a controlled studio how a ball can take weird hops and curve around a spot. Or, you can even do it yourself with a ball on your own. We are talking about a matter of inches to the outside of the bag and then about 3 inches back inside of the line, not much real estate. There is no definitive video, nor photos, of the ball going over the bag. We know the ball was moving towards the line before the bag, then back into it afterwards, before kicking away again, but can't tell where it was in between. Davidson's eyes never left the bag, which is where, by rule, the play was. Once the ball passed the bag there is no need to watch the ball, none. So I am not sure how you can say, if you understand the rules, that he did not watch the entire play. He was a couple feet, at most, away from the bag, and was in the best position to see it. Might the ball have got the edge of the bag? It might have, but it is not clear, nor would replay have helped in this situation given the evidence we have.
August 6, 201016 yr Instant replay using the collage football format(except managers get 3 challenges like the NFL) and FoxTrax for balls and strikes. What could be bad about using FoxTrax for balls and strikes? There wouldn't be arguments about balls and strikes anymore. All the talk about instant replay slowing down the game won't be an issue if each team only has 3 challenges. There's usually only a couple(at most) controversial calls per game anyway. Maybe they can use the replay system used in tennis for calls like in last night's game: http://news.bbc.co.u...nis/3851023.stm+
August 6, 201016 yr Yes, and the ball landed two different times before it crossed the bag. Also, spiraling balls do not travel in straight lines, they wobble. Footballs, baseballs, etc., it doesn't matter. The spin put on them can make them take weird paths. Baseballs move in three dimensions, not just up and down, not just side to side, both all directions, at the same time. The ball was heading towards the outfield, but it can curve just a bit here and there on the way, there is nothing not normal about that. Again, go watch the Harold Reynolds video I linked to above. He shows you in a controlled studio how a ball can take weird hops and curve around a spot. Or, you can even do it yourself with a ball on your own. We are talking about a matter of inches to the outside of the bag and then about 3 inches back inside of the line, not much real estate. There is no definitive video, nor photos, of the ball going over the bag. We know the ball was moving towards the line before the bag, then back into it afterwards, before kicking away again, but can't tell where it was in between. Davidson's eyes never left the bag, which is where, by rule, the play was. Once the ball passed the bag there is no need to watch the ball, none. So I am not sure how you can say, if you understand the rules, that he did not watch the entire play. He was a couple feet, at most, away from the bag, and was in the best position to see it. Might the ball have got the edge of the bag? It might have, but it is not clear, nor would replay have helped in this situation given the evidence we have. No, no it cant curve a bit here and a bit there. A baseball does not move in 3 directions unless all paths are not opposite of one another. A baseball can go from the pitchers mound to the catcher. It can go from the left to the right, or right to left, if can go up to down, or even down to up. But it cant go from the pitchers mound to the catcher, go left to right, and then go right to left. This ball cannot change directions without an outside force acting upon it, that's just newton's law my friend. This ball isnt moving fast enough to be picked up by the wind either, and especially when you consider the wind wasnt even quick enough to move the ball last night. I fully understand that the ball can change directions, yes, of course.But before it hits the ground, a ball traveling at such speeds does not have the potential to change directions in the air and then continue to roll all the way down the field. If you want some more stupid comparisons, yeah the rule is at the plate, but this was as stupid as the call at 2nd base last night where the ump saw the ball hit the glove, and immediately called an out, even though the 2nd baseman clearly dropped the ball. Whatever happens after the ball reaches its destination is just as important as what happens when it crosses the plate. The location the ball landed was indicative of its origin. You're just not observing physics here at all, which is important in a game of baseball. What makes a baseball change paths in a pitch is the spin against the wind. That ball was moving significantly slower than any pitch with movement. The fact that it ended up about 5 inches over in fair territory makes it physically impossible for a ball traveling about 30-50 mph to hit the ground and loop horizontally around a bag, There was not enough wind, Gravity doesnt play a role here because it's horizontal movement, a ball cant hop and move in two equally opposite directions so it didnt hop (only the spin on the ball could make it do so, at much higher speeds). The ball crossed the bag, it was fair the entire time, and ended up in foul territory after it's 3rd or 4th bounce. From it's 1st bounce on the line, it was fair the entire time until it rolled into foul territory in the outfield. Stop trying to be the opposition here, because nobody, from Philly fans to Philly announcers, thinks that ball was foul. Except you, who is doubting it for the sake of being an opposition to an argument.
August 6, 201016 yr It really is quite ridiculous when you consider the money involved in sport and also riding on sport games (betting) that the outcomes can be wrongly decided like last night. Technology is the way forward providing it can be implemented in an efficient manner that doesnt bog down the momentum of the sport and keeps the game moving along at a near regular pace.
October 8, 201016 yr Author This should be brought back up. Last night, there was a play in the Yankees/Twins game where a ball was said to have hit the ground when it should've been a catch and the final out. It brought up the possibly tying run to the plate, and if Thome would've hit a home run the game would've been tied when that AB shouldn't have even happened. Today, another blown call in the Giants/Braves game. I really don't get it. Right now it's blatantly obvious to everybody that instant replay is needed by next season. Every year it isn't implemented we will be forced to focus on more and more mistakes by the umpires that will take away the meaning from the games themselves because we will be focused on these blown calls. When will baseball finally get it right?
October 8, 201016 yr When will baseball finally get it right? When there's a colossal screw-up in the world series. Don't worry. Its imminent.
October 8, 201016 yr I know when. When the other 3 major N.A. Sports think it's cool to go traditional, baseball will get with the times. i.e. never.
October 8, 201016 yr When will baseball finally get it right? When there's a colossal screw-up in the world series. Don't worry. Its imminent. exactly. I've been saying it for a while. It's only a matter of time at this point. Just wait for it, Game 7 of the World Series, bottom of the 9th, HUGE BLOWN CALL DRAMA, and a team is erroneously crowned champion. It's only a matter of time before it happens. Yesterday, at the very least Mariano Rivera retired the next guy, and the blown call didn't affect the game. But today buster posey was called safe when he was stealing a base, when he was clearly out. He would later score on Cody Ross' hit, and that was the ONLY RUN IN THE GAME.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.