Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2011-2012 NBA Thread

Featured Replies

Kind of like how things were in the 80's and 90's in the East, huh?

 

Also, Boston's core is getting broken up real soon. They don't belong on that list.

 

 

I was going to leave them off, but they are together. And I am talking about this season, so I felt the need to mention them.

 

In the West, I can see LAL giving the Heat issues with their size. But, I don't see anyone else other than them. Sucks, if they got Paul and Howard that would have been quite the rivalry.

 

Memphis and OKC are awesome young teams with lots of room to grow and no holes. They'll be tough for anyone.

 

True, especially OKC, but I just don't see them as legit competition against Miami. They're good, though.

And the difference between now and then is that players can now cry like babies and decide whereever the hell they want to go even under contract. Because the Heat did the big 3 thing, so it's now the cool thing to do. The only player who decided not to do this was Kevin Durant.

 

 

Man, you're really eating up the narratives, huh.

 

Comparing Kevin Durant to LeBron, Carmelo, Dwight, or Chris Paul is just silly, and it's silly for a very obvious reason. I'll see if you can figure it out.

 

And you're still wrong. It's happened throughout the history of the NBA, as well as every other sport.

 

Off the top of my head, I can think of Kareem Abdul Jabar, Magic Johnson, Charles Barkley, and Adrian Dantley as players who forced or threatened to force their way out of situations they didn't want to be in. So, you know, 3 of the top 25 players ever and another who is probably top 100.

 

Kobe tried doing it, too. I know it wasn't back in the 90s but worth mentioning.

Also, different point, but isn't it hypocritical to veto this trade? What's the difference between what Paul is doing in New Orleans and what Melo did in NY? The NBA is dysfunctional right now.

This is dumb. I think the trade makes the Lakers a worse team. As a Heat fan, I welcomed the trade.

 

 

yeah i dont really get the trade. khloe kardashian must be happy it was called off.

 

the hornets would be making some serious upgrades with that trade though. they basically get 3 very good players and one solid player for 1 guy.

 

No, they wouldn't have.

 

yes, they would have. At worst, they would not have been all that much worse than they were with just Paul. That team was totally empty as it stands. They would have competed for a playoff spot next year.

 

The reason it wasn't a great deal was because if you lose a superstar in the NBA, your best bet is to tear the whole thing down and try to find another. But they would have been competitive and kept things interesting, just like the Nuggets did last year when they lost Carmelo.

 

Yeah, exactly.

 

And no, not really. At least the Nuggets got young players with upside for Melo. This trade was just veterans going to New Orleans.

 

The trade was completely lopsided. The Lakers get the superstar, trade two guys which actually ends up giving them more cap room to land a trade for Howard, and they don't even give up a 1st rounder. For some reason, it's Houston who has to give up the 1st rounder.

 

In the NBA, the only team that truly gets better is the team adding the star.

 

 

The Hornets got a better collection of talent back than Denver did. Yes, Denver got younger players back, but at the end of the day, they got a bunch of role players. None of the players they got back in the trade are franchise building blocks, which is what you need to rebuild. So at the end of the day, they're in the same spot: Compete for a low seed every year, never get good draft picks, never get a franchise player.

 

You don't win in the NBA without drafting a franchise player and building around them. The way the game and the contracts are set up, even if you can acquire other talent, almost every NBA champion in the last 25 years has developed at least one franchise player and surrounded him with talent.

 

The Nuggets didn't get any potential franchise players, and that's coming from someone who is a huge Galinari fan. They got spare parts. Youth doesn't matter that much if the players aren't game changers. This isn't baseball. Quality depth is useless if you don't have the guns at the top.

And the difference between now and then is that players can now cry like babies and decide whereever the hell they want to go even under contract. Because the Heat did the big 3 thing, so it's now the cool thing to do. The only player who decided not to do this was Kevin Durant.

 

 

Man, you're really eating up the narratives, huh.

 

Comparing Kevin Durant to LeBron, Carmelo, Dwight, or Chris Paul is just silly, and it's silly for a very obvious reason. I'll see if you can figure it out.

 

And you're still wrong. It's happened throughout the history of the NBA, as well as every other sport.

 

Off the top of my head, I can think of Kareem Abdul Jabar, Magic Johnson, Charles Barkley, and Adrian Dantley as players who forced or threatened to force their way out of situations they didn't want to be in. So, you know, 3 of the top 25 players ever and another who is probably top 100.

 

I guess the difference would be that Durant's not nearing free agency? Either way, he didn't have to sign an extension with them.

 

Also, I'm only 20 so I guess you're right. Magic, Barkley, and Kareem forced trades even when under contract?

I don't see this happening in other sports right now. What are you talking about?

 

Durant signed a max extension coming off his rookie contract, the same way LeBron, Wade, Bosh, Rose, Howard, and every single other young star in the NBA since the last lockout changed the rules for rookie contracts. There is nothing special about Durant in that regard. He could make about $25 million more over the life of his contract by resigning with his original team.

 

 

I'm only 23, but I know my NBA history. Kareem, Dantley and Barkley did. Johnson would have skipped the draft if the Lakers did not end up with the first pick the year he came out.

 

It happens all of the time in the NFL with rookie lockouts, it happened with Albert Haynesworth, it's happening with DeSean Jackson.

In MLB there have been plenty of players who have demanded trades for various reasons, including the star of our Marlins team, reportedly. The difference is star players are held to much more scrutiny in the NBA because they hold so much more value. That's just the nature of the game.

Kind of like how things were in the 80's and 90's in the East, huh?

 

Also, Boston's core is getting broken up real soon. They don't belong on that list.

 

 

I was going to leave them off, but they are together. And I am talking about this season, so I felt the need to mention them.

 

In the West, I can see LAL giving the Heat issues with their size. But, I don't see anyone else other than them. Sucks, if they got Paul and Howard that would have been quite the rivalry.

 

Memphis and OKC are awesome young teams with lots of room to grow and no holes. They'll be tough for anyone.

 

True, especially OKC, but I just don't see them as legit competition against Miami. They're good, though.

 

Any team with legitimate size and depth is going to give the Heat problems if they know how to play. The Grizzlies certainly fall into this category. I'd be terrified to try to match up to Z-Bo and Gasol in short series.

 

In a series with the Thunder, the Thunder might have the 2nd, 4th, 6th-8th best players in the series. They're super talented.

I think the difference in the NBA is, the stars are literally forcing their way to teams. Carmelo did it. Chris Paul is doing it. Dwight is doing it. I don't think that has ever happened in the NFL or MLB. It's rare if it does.

I think the difference in the NBA is, the stars are literally forcing their way to teams. Carmelo did it. Chris Paul is doing it. Dwight is doing it. I don't think that has ever happened in the NFL or MLB. It's rare if it does.

 

 

Chris Paul never once demanded a trade. All he did was inform the Hornets that he would not resign.

 

Neither did Deron Williams, whose team traded him out of nowhere. Neither did LeBron James Dwyane Wade, or Chris Bosh, who always get lumped in with that conversation.

I think the difference in the NBA is, the stars are literally forcing their way to teams. Carmelo did it. Chris Paul is doing it. Dwight is doing it. I don't think that has ever happened in the NFL or MLB. It's rare if it does.

 

 

Chris Paul never once demanded a trade. All he did was inform the Hornets that he would not resign.

 

Neither did Deron Williams, whose team traded him out of nowhere. Neither did LeBron James Dwyane Wade, or Chris Bosh, who always get lumped in with that conversation.

 

Chris Paul did.

 

And I don't see why you named those players. I know they didn't demand trades. The subject is on players who demanded trades to specific teams. It happens way too much in the NBA compared to the NFL or MLB, where it rarely happens.

He did it in 2010, and when it didn't happen, he didn't mention it again. This offseason, all he did was tell the Hornets he would not re-sign.

 

And I brought up the other guys because Erick brought them up as a model for what everyone else is trying to do.

He did it in 2010, and when it didn't happen, he didn't mention it again. This offseason, all he did was tell the Hornets he would not re-sign.

 

And I brought up the other guys because Erick brought them up as a model for what everyone else is trying to do.

 

 

No, he didn't. According to his agent, he demanded a trade to NY this season. I posted a link about it.

 

He was wrong about those particular players, but his point still stands. There are players forcing their way out to certain teams. It's as clear as day. Carmelo forced his way to NY. Dwight is going to demand to be traded to NJ. Chris Paul demanded to be traded to NY. It seems both will get their wishes.

http://probasketball...ts-to-be-knick/

 

Chris Paul did demand a trade to the Knicks.

 

 

http://espn.go.com/n...ck-trade-assets

 

"He has not asked for a trade to the Knicks because he knows the Knicks don't have anything to offer," the source said. "He wouldn't insult the Hornets by doing that."

 

 

Yea, I'm not buying that. But, it's a matter of opinion. I believe his agent over an anonymous source.

And the difference between now and then is that players can now cry like babies and decide whereever the hell they want to go even under contract. Because the Heat did the big 3 thing, so it's now the cool thing to do. The only player who decided not to do this was Kevin Durant.

 

 

Man, you're really eating up the narratives, huh.

 

Comparing Kevin Durant to LeBron, Carmelo, Dwight, or Chris Paul is just silly, and it's silly for a very obvious reason. I'll see if you can figure it out.

 

And you're still wrong. It's happened throughout the history of the NBA, as well as every other sport.

 

Off the top of my head, I can think of Kareem Abdul Jabar, Magic Johnson, Charles Barkley, and Adrian Dantley as players who forced or threatened to force their way out of situations they didn't want to be in. So, you know, 3 of the top 25 players ever and another who is probably top 100.

 

I guess the difference would be that Durant's not nearing free agency? Either way, he didn't have to sign an extension with them.

 

Also, I'm only 20 so I guess you're right. Magic, Barkley, and Kareem forced trades even when under contract?

I don't see this happening in other sports right now. What are you talking about?

 

Durant signed a max extension coming off his rookie contract, the same way LeBron, Wade, Bosh, Rose, Howard, and every single other young star in the NBA since the last lockout changed the rules for rookie contracts. There is nothing special about Durant in that regard. He could make about $25 million more over the life of his contract by resigning with his original team.

 

 

I'm only 23, but I know my NBA history. Kareem, Dantley and Barkley did. Johnson would have skipped the draft if the Lakers did not end up with the first pick the year he came out.

 

It happens all of the time in the NFL with rookie lockouts, it happened with Albert Haynesworth, it's happening with DeSean Jackson.

In MLB there have been plenty of players who have demanded trades for various reasons, including the star of our Marlins team, reportedly. The difference is star players are held to much more scrutiny in the NBA because they hold so much more value. That's just the nature of the game.

 

I can't argue there. The value of an NBA player is certainly greater than an individual player in another sport.

That article also makes it clear that he has done everything in his power not to undermine the Hornets' ability to receive fair compensation for him.

 

I think it's unfair to lump Paul in with Howard and Carmelo, who have been much more explicit in the way they have handled their situations. And, given the situation with New Orleans being owned by the league and their uncertain future, it's not comparable at all to Dwight and Carmelo wanting to leave simply because they don't like it there.

 

It's basically Dwight Howard and Carmelo Anthony representing the viewpoint some have of all NBA players as selfish divas who want nothing more than to ruin their organizations, ignoring the number of players (including stars) who have handled their situations well.

 

Except, apparently Kevin Durant. He's the only NBA player anyone can bring up in a positive light.

Isn't a little early to say Galinari's just gonna be like the average role player? The guy was a 1st rounder, still young, and has a great skill set. Offensively, it seems like there's not much he can't do.

He did it in 2010, and when it didn't happen, he didn't mention it again. This offseason, all he did was tell the Hornets he would not re-sign.

 

And I brought up the other guys because Erick brought them up as a model for what everyone else is trying to do.

 

 

No, I just said that players are now demanding trades ever since those three came together in the offseason.

 

I have no problem with what they did; LeBron and Bosh were free agents.

 

I'm just saying that ever since that happened, it seems like it's become more of a trend with star players.

That article also makes it clear that he has done everything in his power not to undermine the Hornets' ability to receive fair compensation for him.

 

I think it's unfair to lump Paul in with Howard and Carmelo, who have been much more explicit in the way they have handled their situations. And, given the situation with New Orleans being owned by the league and their uncertain future, it's not comparable at all to Dwight and Carmelo wanting to leave simply because they don't like it there.

 

It's basically Dwight Howard and Carmelo Anthony representing the viewpoint some have of all NBA players as selfish divas who want nothing more than to ruin their organizations, ignoring the number of players (including stars) who have handled their situations well.

 

Except, apparently Kevin Durant. He's the only NBA player anyone can bring up in a positive light.

 

 

But he's reportedly done it. Per reports, he has demanded a trade to New York. Like I said, it's a matter of who you believe.

 

What worries me about this is if it becomes a trend. It seems like it is.

I think Dan Gilbert's an idiot, but his recent letter makes a lot of sense. That Chris Paul deal is ridiculous. Teams are basically bending over backwards for the Lakers championship run. That trade not only gets them Paul but it automatically gets them Howard, as well. Easily. Why is Andrew Bynum not even involved in that 3-way deal?

He was. He was going to be traded to Orlando.

 

 

Yes, for Howard. I'm asking how it's possible that the Lakers are basically getting the best PG in the NBA without having to give up their young center in that trade. Or a 1st round pick. That's ridiculous.

He was. He was going to be traded to Orlando.

 

 

Yes, for Howard. I'm asking how it's possible that the Lakers are basically getting the best PG in the NBA without having to give up their young center in that trade. Or a 1st round pick. That's ridiculous.

 

Oh, well yea, I don't know honestly lol

I think Dan Gilbert's an idiot, but his recent letter makes a lot of sense. That Chris Paul deal is ridiculous. Teams are basically bending over backwards for the Lakers championship run. That trade not only gets them Paul but it automatically gets them Howard, as well. Easily. Why is Andrew Bynum not even involved in that 3-way deal?

 

 

 

 

 

Nobody is bending over backwards. The Lakers are really well built as a team. They shouldn't apologize for that.

 

If the Lakers traded Gasol for Martin, Scola, Dragic, and a No. 1 Draft pick straight up, nobody would blink. If anything, the Lakers might not have gotten enough in return for that.

 

If they gave up Lamar Odom and Pau Gasol for Chris Paul straight up, nobody would blink, as it would give the Hornets a chance to contend right away.

 

And, as far as I've seen (and I follow a lot of NBA writers; I work for a company that covers the NBA pretty extensively, and I spent the whole day writing Fantasy basketball updates based on player moves, including this very trade) the end package the Hornets got back has received a mixed reaction. The reaction has been no worse than it was to the Nuggets' package for Anthony.

 

The letter is bulls***. The Lakers shouldn't be punished for being shrewd. Dan Gilbert has consistently proven to be a petulant child who doesn't know how to properly run his franchise. The only unfair trade they made was to get Gasol in the first place, and David Stern didn't step in to stop that. But this trade really isn't that bad, all things considered. They gave up a lot and totally lost any depth in their frontcourt. Marc Gasol is a top-15 player in the NBA, and Lamar Odom is probably the 3rd best player included in the deal.

 

 

Isn't a little early to say Galinari's just gonna be like the average role player? The guy was a 1st rounder, still young, and has a great skill set. Offensively, it seems like there's not much he can't do.

 

 

Sure. However, for all of his gifts, he's been super inefficient as a scorer in two of the best offensive systems in the NBA.

 

He's a really talented scorer, but right now, he looks like a high-end role player. His statistical profile reads like a tall Jason Terry. He doesn't do anything else in an above average manner. He's a good shooter, he's excellent in transition, and he can create off the dribble well for a guy his size. But nothing about his production thus far says future franchise building block.

 

And I never said he's an average role player. You can be a good role player. But the point still stands, re: that trade. If you trade a franchise cornerstone and don't get a potential one in return, it doesn't really matter what else you did. The Jazz, for their trouble, might have gotten two potential franchise players in Derrick Favors and Enes Kanter, for Deron Williams. That's how you trade a franchise player.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.