August 8, 201313 yr First offense containing more than one offense. So, let's say the first offense is one of those, and then the next one is the second, and the one after is the third and so on and so forth. Thus, he should be given two lifetime bans and he's lucky it's just 211 games ... that he can APPEAL! *throws a chair*
August 9, 201313 yr First offense? Only technically. SI reported 4 years ago that he tested positive for steroids in 2003 when he was MVP for the Rangers. He had denied ever using steroids, but finally admitted it and said he'd never do it again. Never, ever, ever. Nope, I did that when I was young and stupid, but now I'm older and smarter and I'll never do anything like that again. Trust me. 10 years later (and probably every year in between) his hand was again in the cookie jar. And, he got caught. Again. He's an inveterate liar who doesn't understand when to just go away and stop embarrassing himself. But, they don't call him A-fraud for nothin'. MLB should be embarrassed for wimping out and not imposing a lifetime ban and preventing him from ever again playing at any level connected to MLB. They should have thrown the heaviest book possible at him on every possible infraction, which no doubt is an impressive list. Let him go to Japan and BS them.
August 9, 201313 yr The agreement explicitly excludes anything before 2006. The agreement also covers multiple simultaneous discoveries. The issue at hand is not that A-Rod is a douche-nozzle, but his punishment for what he was caught doing. 50 for doing it (tests positive or otherwise violates) 15 for covering it up (impedes the investigation) 100 if he is found to have distributed it He has a strong 65 game case, he has a not-insignificant 50 game case. MLB overreached with a whole season plus the rest of this one. If they went 165 (and claim his alleged recruiting of players was tantamount to distributing) then they would be in much better position to enforce their decision.
August 9, 201313 yr Author The agreement also covers multiple simultaneous discoveries. Does that refer to multiple positives for different substances after a single test or a paper trail pointing toward several years of abusing different substances?
August 9, 201313 yr It would require piecing together several sections, so I will short hand the first part, that basically indicates that, for the purposes of the agreement, a playter "otherwise determined to have used a subtance" shall be treated as if he tested positive. So A-Rod shows up in the evidence, he is treated as if he tested positive for it, which is the basis for the suspension in the first place. The section in question: A player who violates shall be considered to have tested positive for the prohibited substance with the longest suspension only. It goes on for future punishment, each substance is considered to have been detected. Lets say he tested for stimulants AND PEDs, he would be punished for the lenght of time for PEDs (the longest) but if he was later found to use stimulants again, it would be a 2nd offense for stimulants. I understand it to mean, one discovery, one punishment. Anything before 2006 does not count, at all.
August 9, 201313 yr Author I don't know if it matters but I think you are quoting from the 2008 agreement, which has since been updated. Regardless of that, what you are quoting seems to be talking about multiple substances being found during a single test. That doesn't really seem to apply to what MLB has against A-Rod. His documented history of substance abuse is not equivalent to a single failed drug test revealing use of multiple substances. I've yet to really see anything in the agreement that readily applies to A-Rod's situation. Furthermore, the 2006 stuff doesn't matter, either. It sounds like MLB has proof of multiple offenses after that time period. Still siding with MLB on this one regardless of my personal feelings toward A-Rod.
August 9, 201313 yr Author Let's look at it this way. Say MLB had proof that A-Rod received a shipment of a banned PED every 6 months over a period of 4 years. Do you really think that the joint agreement clearly treats this as a single, first offense? I see that being a completely non-standard case that demands MLB to set a penalty unique to A-Rod.
August 11, 201313 yr There is an agreement. The agreement stipulates that all burden of proof lies with the Commissioner's office. The agreement has terms of punishment spelled out. MLB did not use any of the terms listed. With an arbitrator, MLB would first have to demonstrate that the agreement should not apply - and then that its punishment is appropriate. If MLB used 50, 65, or 165 games, they would then be able to argue for the 15 + 50 + 100 punishment levels under the "otherwise violates", "hinders" and "distributes" portions.
August 12, 201313 yr Author But the terms of the drug agreement don't clearly spell out what A-Rod's punishment should be. That's why MLB is also suspending based upon alleged violations of the CBA as well.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.