Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

The Abortion Thread

Featured Replies

the issue to me is not whether it is a human being or not. It is whether that life form should be considered as a whole other entity different from the mother.

Well first of all...

 

Correct me if I'm wrong, but does every sex act result in a pregnancy? God- I hope not- we have enough world population problems as it is

Actually, the world is underpopluated. I'm not trying to be a smartass but I learned that in Global Studies, just wanted to clear that up.i don't want to get off topic here, but do you think a country is underpopulated when it is forced to enact a law that makes it illegal for a couple to have more than one child? (china) or what about a country that has difficulty feeding its population, is crawling with communicable diseases, and whose cities are 20 times more congested than any city in the US? (india)

Well I was talking about the world in a whole, not just specific countries. The world as a whole is underpopulated judging from how much land is available. So while there is deserted land everywhere, everyone is crammed into places like China or India because the deserted land cannot be used due to weather or whatever. I also realize that I'm making no point at all because people don't live there anyway but I had to respond with something. :p

 

But anyway...Alkazoid you make really good points and my view on abortion is never gonna be clear. I can't really say that I think abortion is totally wrong because that sounds hyprocritical of me to say it's wrong but I would do it if I was in the situation. But that's just the way it is I guess. I'll never think its right but everything Katrina1211 (see 1st pg) was so true. Err this topic is hard.

 

It was scary because last night I had a dream that I was pregnant and I was gonna get an abortion (see what the message board does to you). It was so werid because I was freaking out in my dream and crying. I woke up and it took me a while to realize it was a dream, talk about relief lol.

Some of you mention that Women shouldnt have the right to abortion because there are many couples who cant have babies that want to.

 

Give me a break, there are plenty of homeless children that are out in the street or other children stuck in foster homes.

 

IMO why do you want to have a baby if you cant give it a suitable life? Lets say they do have the baby but dont want it?

 

What do they do then? They stick it in a foster home or orphange with no real parents or anything waiting for couples to come and adopt and some children never get adopted and end up with no real family.

 

I think its the womens right to choose if she wants to have the baby. I believe abortions are fine as long as they are not done in the 3rd trimester and are done before the baby can survive out of the womb.

the issue to me is not whether it is a human being or not. It is whether that life form should be considered as a whole other entity different from the mother.

Its a different entity, not part of the mother...but so is a tape worm.

 

And to all the comments concerning population- if everyone lived like us, the world would be overpopulated ebcause we use so much damn resources, so yes, we ARE overpopulated. luckily, population should start decreasing by 2060, but it might be too late.

Question to ponder: What would happen if you would have been aborted? What if you were a failed abortion? I know a girl who was a failed abortion, and I'm sure if she ever knew her parents she would probably not get along with them very well.

If i were aborted, I would dis-exist, and that would be that. It is not bad at all.

so at what point does a baby become human?

I believe after the baby is even born, its mind is so primative, that abortion as an "issue" is non-existant.

too many replies, sorry!

 

SorianoFanHFW

 

you are just seriously disturbed. how you can think that something that is attached to a breathing women isn't a life form. when you have a heart beat and are breathing you are considered living.

 

i don't kno how to tell you my views on life because i think one way and sh.it i can just spill all mine out because all you will do is find a way to criticize them or make them sound "wrong" so fu.ck your sadistic thinking methods for i'm glad to say tha ti don't kno you personally.

A tumor is attached to a breathing human, it is made of human flesh, is IT human? Your logic is faulty, that doesn't make me disturbed, it makes you illogical.

 

You're obviously a disturbed person, who hasn't thought hard about your beliefs. I have a pretty simple argument: murdering is wrong. However, we kill animals all the time, so when is killing okay? Obviously, it is okay when something is cognitively inferior to us. A fetus does not excercise a high amount of cognition to warrant it a place in the human race.

 

How dare you call me sadistic. You know what's sadistic? Having an unwanted child ruin his mother's and father's chance of further education (most people drop out of school) or the get a worse job, bring the baby up in worse conditions, and it is less loved. Make sure that life never exists by ending it before it starts, that's rather simple. By being pro fetus life, you are anti human life and are the truly sadistic one. I believe my argument is fairly consistant, and judging by your quote find a way to criticize them or make them sound "wrong"

you feel intimidated by the way I debunk your illogical beleifs.

 

-being attached to a human does not make it human

-cognition makes us human

-fetus does not excericse human cognition

-the fetus is therefore not human

-we kill beings of far higher cognition all the time

-thus killing a fetus is morally okay

 

How am I the only sadistic one according to your logic? A lot of people here support abortion. I just back my beliefs up without the fancy PC talk. I'll give it to you straight, and if you cannot handle that, too bad.

Its a different entity, not part of the mother...but so is a tape worm.

:huh What? They (the fetus and the tapeworm) are outside organisms living inside of the human body.

 

However, I think a tapeworm lacks cognition entirely, and after 30 weeks, the fetus develops some.

 

To the guy who posted the weeks chart, thanks for the info.

what is the purpose of killing animals?

To eat

 

or

 

They are threatening (like a bear attack.)

 

I don't believe in hunting for sport.

So let me ask, because I am sort of confused... From an earlier post you said "I do not believe in a woman's right to choose" and now it appears that you support abortion... I am confused. Which is it? Pro or con?

 

I am not pro-abortion, but I am not pro-life either. I do not think it is anybody's business what the hell happens inside my body and what choices should I make. Period.

So let me ask, because I am sort of confused... From an earlier post you said "I do not believe in a woman's right to choose" and now it appears that you support abortion... I am confused. Which is it? Pro or con?

 

I am not pro-abortion, but I am not pro-life either. I do not think it is anybody's business what the hell happens inside my body and what choices should I make. Period.

Oh, you mean the articles? One was from an pro fetal life friend of mine. I'm pro killing fetuses, there I said it.

 

I know your position, you have the right to have anything done on your body.

i'm just waiting for someone who opposes abortion to tell me where on that chart they think the moral cutoff should be.

 

on the chart, the fetus has no brain connections during the 16th week, though its organs start to differentiate. it starts making brain nerve connections during the 20th week. personally, i think i'd play it safe and set a cutoff for the 16th week.

 

surely most people can agree that it is acceptable to pass a single cell (one fused egg + sperm) before the 2nd week. so where is your cutoff?

i'm just waiting for someone who opposes abortion to tell me where on that chart they think the moral cutoff should be.

 

on the chart, the fetus has no brain connections during the 16th week, though its organs start to differentiate. it starts making brain nerve connections during the 20th week. personally, i think i'd play it safe and set a cutoff for the 16th week.

 

surely most people can agree that it is acceptable to pass a single cell (one fused egg + sperm) before the 2nd week. so where is your cutoff?

I'm sure no one wants more of my opinion, but in reality, the "cut-off" is probably a month or so after the baby is born if we are to base everything on cognition.

 

Now I'm not saying we should go kill all the babies out there, but we have to realize that cognition develops, thus becoming human is a process of development. I'm not a scientist, but until the baby's cognition is greater than something like a kitten, in the terms of morality, the "cut off point" isn't yet reached.

 

I beleive as long as the baby is in the mother's body, it can be "dealt with" in a way she chooses. However, how about how abortion affects men? What about all those women who get pregnant on purpose to steal rich guys money? If they are not opposed to abortion in principal, why should the man have no say about his child?

 

just more questions.

  • 3 weeks later...

http://www.xanga.com/item.aspx?user=craigr...gs&uid=54244715

 

Do Not Say, "I'm Personally Against Abortion, but I Believe In The Woman's Right To Choose"...Ever!

 

 

 

When one acquires a belief system of their own, they must be consistant or they do not risk being a hypocrite, they ARE a hypocrite. First one must consider whether killing can be justified. I do believe in this, because I am pro abortion, pro euthanasia, and pro death penalty. I have my own platform, the "Pro Killing Party." The PKP has a very consistent stance on these issues: killing can be justified. Who will say that the Jews who escaped from the Sobibor death camp were not justified in killing their Nazi oppressors?

 

Several inconsistant beliefs exist within party lines. The left would like to tell you that killing fetuses is right, but killing hardcore criminals is wrong. The right would like to tell you it is okay to kill criminals (which are established humanity), but not fetuses. If one is against the death penalty because, "All civilized nations find it that killing another man is morally reprehensible", they are a hypocrite. Killing is morally reprehensible if you believe in killing fetuses. They might say, "Well, it is the woman's body", but the truth is that the organism is a seperate, but attached entity. Does a conjoined twin have the right to kill the twin adjacent to her or him, because it is "her or his body?" No, but people will contend that the fetus is not as worth of a lifeform as a full grown human...then why will they support the death penalty?

 

One has to be consistant. If you believe killing is justifiable, you cannot start making exceptions and vice versa. However, what annoys me the most are the idiots who say, "I am personally against abortion, but I believe in the woman's right to choose." What? That's like saying, "I am against killing, but O.J. has the right to kill if he chooses too." Why is anyone against abortion? It is because they view the fetus as a human life. How can you say that though you are personally against killing human lives, it is not in your place to deny others the right to kill other human lives. That is absolutely ridiculous. If you believe the fetus is not human, killing is fine and this is the stance the PKP takes. However, if you believe the fetus is a human, you cannot believe in the so called, "Woman's right to choose." You are either for killing something not human or against killing a human, not against killing a human, but for the right to choose to do so.

 

So please, be consistent. It is better to be wrong and not a hypocrite than right. It is not the belief one holds that makes someone moral, but how one honestly arrives to a belief. For this reason, one must believe killing is justifiable or it is not.

I know some people who get really giddy about abortion.

 

 

It practically brings the kid out of them.

I believe abortion is wrong, unless it puts the mother's health in jepoardy (I think I spelled that wrong). Therefore, I believe it should be illegal, unless it puts the mother's health in ummm that j-word.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.