Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
List of non-tenders
You do realize Dioner Navarro was one of the better catching prospects in baseball going in to last season, right? Not to mention he's only 21 years old (with five years of professonal experience, that right he was signed when he was 16). I would give up anyone not named Willis or Cabrera in a heartbeat for him, and I bet Admin Beinfest would too.
-
Eric Byrnes
Well nothings been reported. lololol...I was asking it rhetorically.
-
Eric Byrnes
If the Buccos are in talks, that means he is affordable. I see no reason why we shouldn't at least speak to his agent. How do you know we haven't?
-
Eric Byrnes
There appears from news accounts to be a love affair going on between the Byrnes' camp and Pittsburgh, for what it's worth. http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/05357/626946.stm
-
Marlins notes from the Herald
Does that mean Olsen is only one part of the deal, or did they just word it poorly? Lol, I almost fell out of my chair when I read that. I have to believe it is a) as you said worded poorly, or b) part of a bigger deal. In some ways the Marlins are in the driver's seat here. Fan expectation in South Florida is so low that not trading Olsen for Gathright is barely a blip on the radar screen as far as the typical Fish fan goes, but in Tampa Bay where new ownership is touting how they're finally going to put a competitive team out there, making this, or some other deal, is almost a must. Time will tell though, but I just keep seeing Scott Olsen standing up there next to Dontrelle Willis a week ago, and it's hard to imagine the FO turning around and trading the guy. But if there's anything we've learned in the last month, it's to expect the unexpected.
-
List of non-tenders
From the Baltimore Sun - "Byrnes was acquired from the Colorado Rockies in exchange for OF Admin Bigbie on July 29. He hit .192 with 3 homers and 11 RBI in 52 games for the Orioles and combined to bat .226 in 126 games between the Oakland A's, Rockies and Orioles last season. After hitting safely in his first 11 games with the Orioles, he batted .137 over his final 41 games of the season, including an .073 average over the final month." http://www.baltimoresun.com/sports/basebal...ports-headlines Maybe Byrnes can turn his career around, I hope so. But if the Marlins are going to spend $2,000,000 give or take, or even half that, I doubt it will be on someone who has underacheived so dramatically. The real problem regarding Byrnes and the Marlins is even if he were to regroup and have a productive season next year, he would surely be gone at the end of the season. The Marlins just aren't going to offer him a multi-year deal, not after his performance in '05. Clearly the direction the Marlins are taking is to build a team for the future, and Byrnes wouldn't be part of that. Good guy, bad fit.
-
Marlins notes from the Herald
Just for what it's worth on a slow news day, regarding Dante Brinkley... Dante Brinkley is listed as 5-foot-11, but when he stands next to strapping 6-foot-4 first baseman Davidson, he looks like a runt. Dante may not be exceptionally tall, but a day spent watching him at the batting cage and in a game shows you why this Southwest Missouri State product is an outfield prospect to whom attention must be paid. On Sunday, July 11, the Cyclones varied their normal batting practice routine by playing a game where the team was divided into two squads. Each would bat in a simulated game against manager Tony Tijerina, pitching for both teams. The game was played without fielders and each batter?s at-bat resulted in Tijerina, also serving as umpire, ruling the ball an out or a hit. When Brinkley?s team wasn?t hitting, he stood near the cage, playfully making remarks to disturb the opposing batter?s concentration. When opponent Davidson hit a home run over the 315 mark in left field, Brinkley was non-plussed. ?316 feet,? he cackled to Davidson. When Grant Psomas, one of Dante?s opponents, interrupted a string of his team?s outs with a hit, Brinkley announced to his ?enemies,? ?Psomas is carrying you guys like a backpack!? The batting practice game was close, and, along with losing a bit of face, the losing team would be responsible for picking up all the baseballs in the outfield after the drill was over. As the simulated game went into the last inning, Brinkley?s opponents had a chance to win. Behind the batter?s back, Brinkley indicated with his hand that he wanted Tijerina, who throws a pretty good knuckleball, to let loose with a floater. Tijerina declined, and the batter hit a ball to the outfield. Tijerina ruled the ball a hit, thus allowing Dante?s opponents to win. Brinkley playfully protested, but he meant it. Later, in the real game against Staten Island, when Psomas, the Cyclones? third baseman, went to his left for a grounder, Brinkley hustled from left field to cover third in case he was needed. In the last inning, with the score tied and none out, Brinkley, hitting second behind Derran Watts, mentioned to Watts, that a bunt against the Yankee first baseman might work. Brinkley told Watts that if he could bunt his way on and then steal second, Brinkley could bunt him to third. Watts did bunt towards the first base side and, on the ensuing throwing error into right field, he rounded the bases for the win. Dante Brinkley lost the simulated game, but his hustle and smarts helped to win the real one. -------------- FROM BA: Q: Randy from NYC asks: I was surprised to see that Dante Brinkley didn't make the Top 20, despite strong numbers across the board. Is that a function of his age? What are the projections for him, and could he move up the Mets' system quickly from this point forward? A: Aaron Fitt: Brinkley did have a terrific year, and league managers liked him as a player. He handles the bat well, uses all fields, plays hard and plays solid defense. But he's not a real big guy, only 5-10, 180 pounds, and he projects best as a fourth or fifth outfielder in the big leagues. Still, it's worth noting that a couple managers think he'll develop some power - one even said that his swing reminds him of Miguel Tejada. Brinkley has an outside shot of becoming an overachieving starting outfielder in the majors.
-
List of non-tenders
Penny didn't keep guys honest... LOL, you know Swifty, I was going to say the same thing. When it came to baserunners Brad Penny had to be one of the laziest starting pitchers ever. I lay it at the feet of Jeff Torborg and pitching coach Brad Arnsberg who spent so much time making excuses for their pitchers and so little time teaching them how to actually pitch to win.
-
List of non-tenders
I think we should reject Phillips on principle because of those glasses LMAO :notworthy
-
List of non-tenders
[i also dont want a guy, when we have a young pitching staff, that allowed 78 of 97 baserunners to steal safely. I realize you think that if you repeat yourself a thousand times it will make your fantasy league view of baseball come true but baserunners steal, for the most part, off pitchers. A good base stealer times his jump off the pitcher's set position and leg kick. It's the inattentive pitcher who ignores what's going on around him that leads to most steals. Catchers can't throw out a guy at second, I don't care who the catcher is, if he receives the ball and the runner is twenty feet from 2B. I'm hoping that between Girardi and Kranitz they can teach these kids the importance of keeping guys close and using the right pitch selection when you have a burner on base.
-
Marlins hire coaching staff
Everybody has to start somewhere. Some of you guys are unreal. absolutely :thumbup
-
List of non-tenders
We should pass on Phillips. But the truth is both Phillips and Treanor suck. First of all neither one "sucks". They are both major league ballplayers, albeit backups, but they've earned their place on major league rosters because they are good enough to be there. If you actually read what I've posted, I've suggested we carry two catchers PLUS Willingham who is a work in progress. I hope Willy turns around and makes us all forget about Pudge or LoDuca and has a long productive career as our guy behind the plate, but in the meantime there will be plenty of playing time to go around and whether it's Phillips or someone else with real major league experience (as opposed to minor league experience where every batter is someone the catcher has no idea about) calling games and being the field general, I'd like to see someone out there who knows what he's doing. What you don't want is a catcher who has to look into the dugout for a sign on every pitch see what the manager wants to call for next. That doesn't help anybody. I'm willing to accept the notion it isn't Phillips, but it isn't because he "sucks", it's because there's maybe someone Beinfest can find who's better.
-
List of non-tenders
Jamal Strong is fast and an above-average defender... might be a good backup plan for Gathright! ...and he was suspended last season for steroid use. One has to wonder why a kid this young with the good numbers he's put up was cut unless the back story isn't pretty.
-
Why we won't be soooo bad next year..
The bench manager, a catching instructor, has been put in charge of watching after Willingham. Re: 03's original point. With these young pitchers (and Jacobs at 1B), we're going to be run on anyway. I don't think you have to cede base stealing just because you have a rookie first baseman and kids on the mound. Good traits need to be taught from the beginning and having a catcher (regardless of who it is) who can help keep runners from advancing from first to second is going to assist in the development of young pitchers and position players. If I had one criticism of Mark Wiley it was he seemed totally unconcerned with working with his staff on holding runners at first. Hopefully that will change next season, but part of the equation is having a guy behind the plate who can catch and throw. Like many here, I'm enamored with Willingham's offensive potential. I am concerned though that his bat may suffer the more he catches. Getting banged up every game takes its toll on a catcher in a way that can't be compared to any other position player. For me, I was quite pleased when it seemed he'd get a chance in left field because this team is going to need to score runs and he is a guy I think many of us were counting on to contribute offensively in '06. It's hard to hit day in, day out when your hands are banged up, your knees hurt, your ribs are sore and you're coming off the slight concussion you received when some guy came barreling into home a week ago. So maybe some of you don't see the value in a Jason Phillips, you're certainly entitled to your point of view. But recognize at least that catcher is the one position where experience and defensive ability does matter, especially when it comes to making baserunners think twice before attempting a steal on a rookie pitcher. Double plays are a pitcher's best friend but it's difficult to turn when the lead runner is already at 2B.
-
List of non-tenders
The reason I like Phillips (which is not to say he's a great catcher) is because he's got the right defensive tools for a young team and he's had enough major league experience (three full seasons in the NL, knows batter's tendencies etc.) to be an asset who doesn't need on the job training the way others mentioned do. I'm not saying he's the second coming of Pudge Fisk or Johnny Bench, but if the Marlins really want to give Willingham a shot at learning the position, Phillips is a guy who can be platooned and not be a detriment to the team while he's out there.
-
Jason Stokes
Not that I really care what the guy who had a joy filled aneurism when Castillo was traded ... In fact I was unhappy that Castillo had to go. I was unhappy to see most of the trades happen. But I was being realistic when the first shoe dropped, that Castillo's salary over the next two seasons made it obvious he'd be traded. I don't think you can find a post in which I demeaned Castillo the ballplayer or the man, it was just economics.
-
Jason Stokes
QUESTION: Who would be in favor of flopping Jacobs for Choi? Assuming for a moment your question wasn't tongue in cheek, I don't think any of us saw enough of Jacobs to make anything other than a guess. He could be another Franceour or Hermida or he could be out of baseball by September. Besides, unless it was a three team deal, the Dodgers don't need another first basebaman.
-
Jason Stokes
Really not high on Jason Phillips either. He cant hit and I think Treanor is superior defensively. lolololol
-
Jason Stokes
There was an article this afternoon that suggested the Dodgers would keep Choi to dangle him as tradebait over the winter. With something like four guys on the roster who can play first the conventional wisdom is Choi is the od man out. BTW, Jason Phillips is now afree agent, non-tendered.
-
Why we won't be soooo bad next year..
Treanor is the least of our problems at catcher, and for the record it was his left shoulder that surgery was performed on, not his throwing arm. From what's been reported he'll be fine for spring training. What the Fish need is a veteran catcher who can help Girardi handle the kids and keep baserunners honest.
-
Why we won't be soooo bad next year..
Since I'm often accused of being the chief apologist here for the Marlins organization let me say it will be very telling how the FO views the upcoming season, and in my eyes it will be perceived very negatively, if Beinfest and company don't immediately pounce on Choi, Phillips and Aurilia tomorrow morning. And while it's one thing to debate the value of trading away some of their new corps of pitchers for a Gathright and/or a Gomes, here's three bonafide major leaguers who could be had without any compensation and for little $$$ and without committing to lengthy contracts. For about a million and a half dollars (roughly $400k each to Choi and Phillips, and about $700,000 or so for Aurilia) they have a chance to make this team significantly better, and quickly. Sitting idly by and letting these guys slip through their fingers would be in my estimation a huge mistake. Perhaps there will be better players set free that Beinfest will target instead, and if so, great, but it's time to start making some moves. To me, number one is Jason Phillips, who I believe is the perfect cheap solution at catcher that can still allow for Willingham (mentored by Girardi) to get playing time and keep Treanor in the fold as backup. If the Marlins are contemplating using John Baker as anything other than their AAA catcher we're in for a long, season. Phillips at least knows how to shut down a running game and works well with pitchers. Aurilia can play all three infield skill positions and would give kids like Uggla and Ramirez the time to mature into ML ballplayers. He's frustrated as hell with the Reds FO who have just signed Womack and Freel and wants an opportunity to play everyday. Between SS and 2B with the Fish I could see him playing 120+ games next season. And the guy can still hit, not like Looie to be sure but if he can do anything near what he did last season (.280, 14Hrs, .343 w/runners in scoring position) he could make a difference next season. Choi. I've already said my piece about Choi. With the possible exception of Gary Sheffield, no Marlin, including Carlos Delgado, ever hit the ball harder and further than Choi. For $400k you have to be crazy not to take a chance on the guy. Now maybe Choi will be offered a contract in LA and maybe Aurilia will be offered a reasonable enough contract by the Reds to stay but the Marlins ought to be in there trying to acquire these guys right up until the moment they sign with their respective teams. I'm not one who usually or casually says they (the Marlins organization) owe the fans anything after a World Championship and fielding two subsequent competitive teams, but not going after these guys, or players equal to or better, starting right now, will be a real slap in the face to Marlins fans whether they be in South Florida or Iowa or wherever. So Admin, it's time to deliver on what you said to us last week. Put together a truly competitive team starting at 12:01am tomorrow and don't let us down.
-
My Amex Dispute with the Marlins
Hasn't this thread outlived its usefulness?
-
Dan Uggla on MLB Radio
I'll probably miss it but for those interested, Marlins Rule 5 signing second baseman Dan Uggla is a scheduled guest on Jonathan Mayo's show today. Show runs from 2-3pm. Here's a link to MLB radio: http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/mlb/radio/index.jsp
-
Why we won't be soooo bad next year..
Doesn't Choi have one more year before arbitration? Phillips would be arbitration eligible this year? PB, there have been literally dozens of articles that refer to the Dodgers potentially not tendering a contract to Choi, for example: "Tuesday is the deadline to tender contracts and the Dodgers have a pair of arbitration-eligible former starters who are out of jobs. The club is not expected to tender a contract to catcher Jason Phillips and could choose the same route with first baseman Hee-Seop Choi." http://losangeles.dodgers.mlb.com/NASApp/m...xt=.jsp&c_id=la
-
Winter Ball updates
Champ, if you notice I used the phrase "could be working", the operative word being "could". I happen to agree with you that there's alot of local pride involved in the WLs but the point of my post was that we just don't know. Bowyer for example put up some lousy numbers in the AFL this fall but then we hear that he was told to not use (or depend heavily on) his fastball, rather to work on his other pitches. A guy like Miggy doesn't have much to prove or work on in the WLs, he can go out there for the fun of it, and the pride of representing his country. Someone else who is trying to find his way into the MLs "may" be there for a different reason.