Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
The Delgado Thread
I realize newbies always think they can't be wrong but there were numerous published stories, quoting Jack and others, that Olsen couldn't be used ot of the pen. They asked him to go to the pen to make room for Valdez and he declined, leaving the Marlins with the only option left to them, which was to option him to Carolina.
-
I Wonder who we signed
It could also be someone like Chad Bentz (example) although Easley and Harris are first two to come to mind.
-
The Delgado Thread
Spike is essentially correct. Part of the decision to option Olsen back to Carolina was based on his inability, or desire not to, pitch out of the pen, that he wanted to be a starter. It was that decision that ultimately led to Vargas finding his way into the starting rotation. If I remember correctly, the problem was Olsen took too long warming up out of the pen and he preferred to continue his career as a starter, I suppose fearful of being pigeon-holed as a reliever. Vargas on the otherhand was happy with any opportunity to pitch in the bigs and the rest, as they say, is history.
-
Uh oh...hey Admin -
Penn, put another way, there is no "right" answer. It's a matter of conjecture and as long as we're only getting part of the story, all we can do is make an educated guess. It kind reminds me of that old decision-making tool where you take a piece of paper and divide it down the middle, listing the Pros to one side and the Cons to the other. There's a case to be made on both sides.
-
Uh oh...hey Admin -
We all have to remember there's more to this than what we get from the media. Obviously there's a backstory here we're not privy to and all we can do is guess at the motives of Sloane, Delgado and Beinfest (and the organization). As I proffered above, it may have nothing to do with baseball per se. I have noticed that none of the local papers have mentioned Delgado's "out clause", while out of town papers have. If anything ruins Delgado's trade value it's that. For example, from the Seattle Times: "... If Delgado became available, he could be the ideal acquisition. He hit .301 for the Marlins, with 33 homers and 115 runs batted in, numbers the Mariners once envisioned for him at Safeco Field. The downside: the money, the knowledge that Delgado has balked in the past at being a designated hitter, and the fact he could demand a trade after one season (having been dealt in the midst of a multi-year contract)." http://www.king5.com/sports/mariners/stori...G.29011f8c.html
-
Uh oh...hey Admin -
Sloane is just protecting his client and his client may be antsy because his bride-to-be is antsy. There's a million reasons (well, not a million but you know what I mean) why Delgado/Sloane are reacting to rumors this way. It almost seems like he's inviting a trade, but since we have to depend on the hack community to report what transpired on the conference call, it's really difficult to know the motivation behind it.
-
D-Rays interested in Lowell? (link)
Lowell, Olsen, Willingham + cash (2 million a year) for Badelli + middle relief pitcher (baez?) Willingham would fit an AL team well in the DH, Olsen would give them the young ace that they crave like Kazmir. Lowell at a cheaper contract. solves their logjam in the outfield and lets them dump a very expensive contract in baez. Baldelli just signed a multi-year deal to stay in Tampa a day or two ago. He's not going anywhere.
-
The Delgado Thread
Because someone has a different opinion, another thread goes down the drain? 03 you were one of those saying no way Delgado was being shopped. So basically when your opinion is proven wrong, there is no room for dialogue? Hey newbie, I know you're trying to make a splash here but your act is getting a bit old...
-
The Delgado Thread
Another thread goes down the drain...
-
The Delgado Thread
What I think Sloane was doing in holding his press conference was saying "...hey we don't want to be traded and we certainly don't want to be the LAST ONE traded". There's no question that the Marlins are going to look markedly different than '05. Whether they are better or worse at the end of the season remains to be seen. No one can say definitively how the season will play out, not me, not Swift, not 161, no one. It may be that an injection of youth is just what this team needs. Or it may be an ugly year. What's being ignored is who we might get in return for some of the players who are moved and who we'll acquire with the $$$ freed up by moving certain players. It's not all the doom and gloom some would paint. All I know is I'll be there for another fifty games and I'll cheer just as hard whether Castillo or Gonzo or Delgado is there or not.
-
The Delgado Thread
Spike, he's talking about how he sees the team when the youth movement he thinks will come about becomes a reality. He may be right, he may be wrong, time will tell.
-
The Delgado Thread
2003, that limp you see from Louie is his pimp limp. :hat luv ya buddy :thumbup
-
The Delgado Thread
Swifty, I might point out Castillo is two years older than Pierre. And Pierre has never had to go under the knife the way Castillo has. But again, this is my thinking, no one has to agree with me. Fair enough, but Pierre is just one bad slide away from having any of the same problems. And any of us could walk out into traffic and get hit by a bus too. I don't think we want to go down the what-if road because none of us can forsee what will happen next.
-
The Delgado Thread
Castillo's OBP was .418 in year 2000, five seasons ago. See my above post which I edited while you were writing your response. Overall, Castillo's OBP is about 15 points higher than Pierre. In other words he reaches first base about ten times per season than JP. The difference is when JP gets on base he moved along 47 more times than Castillo last season. I'm not disparaging Castillo. I love the guy. But if tough choices have to be made, I say keep JP and trade Castillo. You want to get rid of the best fielding second baseman in the game? Who do you replace him with Joe Dillon? We saw how dreadful we are defensively with Andino in there instead of Gonzo. Castillo saves so many runs with his glove. This team already gave up way too much defense when Beinfest mis evaluated D Lee. By Beinfest not having the vision to see that Lee was worth $21 mil for three years a few years ago, he instead spent $52 mil on Delgado. Of course the team has no intention of honoring the remaining $48 mil owed to Carlos. Trading Castillo would be yet another personal blunder by Beinfest. You obviously didn't spend much time reading my post because I gave two examples of free agent second basemen who by all accounts are excellent ballplayers. In fact Grudz led the league on doubleplays last season and we'd be damn lucky to land him, and Graffanino did an extraordinary job as well. If you want to trash Admin Beinfest no one is stopping you but that's not the subject at hand. You obviously don't read what I write. Castillo IS the best fielding second baseman in the league. I'd take him over Grudzielanek any day. I believe when I read Perry Hill says no one is better turning double plays than Castillo that the opinion of Hill is greater than that of yours. So what if the Cardinals turned more double plays, Castillo was hurt the final month so of course his numbers would be down. Plus, you saw that disaster in Andino lobbing underhand slow balls that not even Castillo could turn for two. Graffanino over Castillo? Come on. Not even close. If you want to ignore the financial considerations of keeping Castillo you can. And what Andino has to do with this subject I have no idea.
-
The Delgado Thread
Swifty, I might point out Castillo is two years older than Pierre. And Pierre has never had to go under the knife the way Castillo has. But again, this is my thinking, no one has to agree with me.
-
The Delgado Thread
Castillo's OBP was .418 in year 2000, five seasons ago. See my above post which I edited while you were writing your response. Overall, Castillo's OBP is about 15 points higher than Pierre. In other words he reaches first base about ten times per season than JP. The difference is when JP gets on base he moved along 47 more times than Castillo last season. I'm not disparaging Castillo. I love the guy. But if tough choices have to be made, I say keep JP and trade Castillo. You want to get rid of the best fielding second baseman in the game? Who do you replace him with Joe Dillon? We saw how dreadful we are defensively with Andino in there instead of Gonzo. Castillo saves so many runs with his glove. This team already gave up way too much defense when Beinfest mis evaluated D Lee. By Beinfest not having the vision to see that Lee was worth $21 mil for three years a few years ago, he instead spent $52 mil on Delgado. Of course the team has no intention of honoring the remaining $48 mil owed to Carlos. Trading Castillo would be yet another personal blunder by Beinfest. You obviously didn't spend much time reading my post because I gave two examples of free agent second basemen who by all accounts are excellent ballplayers. In fact Grudz led the league on doubleplays last season and we'd be damn lucky to land him, and Graffanino did an extraordinary job as well. If you want to trash Admin Beinfest no one is stopping you but that's not the subject at hand.
-
The Delgado Thread
Castillo's OBP was .418 in year 2000, five seasons ago. See my above post which I edited while you were writing your response. Overall, Castillo's OBP is about 15 points higher than Pierre. In other words he reaches first base about ten times per season than JP. The difference is when JP gets on base he moved along 47 more times than Castillo last season. I'm not disparaging Castillo. I love the guy. But if tough choices have to be made, I say keep JP and trade Castillo.
-
The Delgado Thread
...It's just that JP simply doesn't get on base enough to justify using him as a leadoff hitter. I know steals are nice, but the man needs to get on base at a .385 or higher clip to be a leadoff hitter. I'm not going to try to convince you that JP had a stellar year last season, and that might work to our advantage in negotiations, but if you look at his '04 OBP, it was .374, which in my mind, when combined with the terror he creates on the basepaths, is enough for me. I think with a new hitting instructor and a season to work on a few things he has the potential to be better than ever. BTW, you know how many times Castillo has had an OBP of .385 or greater? Once. Last season. In fact, in 2004 Castillo's OBP was lower than Pierre's. You of course have no obligation to agree. That's what makes forums like this work. :thumbup
-
The Delgado Thread
With all the negativity swirling around it sure would be nice to have the FO or Loria make a statement that Delgado isn't going anywhere. There is no reason I can see where payroll would have to be cut as much as 15%. The market is growing and if Loria wants to continue to watch it grow he needs to be perceived as wanting to field a winning team. Trading Carlos would negatively affect ticket sales next year. Let's say the average ticket next year is $20 and the team gets another $10 on their share of parking, concessions and gifts. An attendance drop of 300K fans would represent a loss in revenue of $9M....about the amount the team might save by trading Carlos. It's a lose-lose situation....the biggest loser will be Loria's credibility that he has worked so hard to establish during his short tenure. :thumbup
-
The Delgado Thread
Wait... let me get this straight. Quality replacement at second base? You want to trade Castillo, and for some reason known and understandable to you, sign Pierre to a long expensive contract? I assume my dear friend, you are begging for an explanation. First of all, the word "expensive" in regards to signing Juan Pierre to a multi-year contract, is your word, not mine. I believe that the opposite is true, and in the longrun, much more worthwhile than continuing to pay $5 million a year to a player who only plays part-time at second base. The biggest difference between Juan Pierre and Luis Castillo is that Pierre will give you +/- 700 PAs year in, year out, and while he isn't the perfect leadoff guy (and putting aside for a moment your rabid hatred of him) he is a guy a GM and manager can build a top of the lineup around knowing he'll be there. Castillo on the otherhand has never fully recovered from his hip surgery, playing less and less games for three years straight. If you actually went to games you know that even when healthy, Castillo looks injured, almost always sporting a limp. His speed has evaporated, going from 48 stolen bases in '02 to 21 in each of the next two years, and finally down to 10 last season. Nobody loves Luis more than me but anyone can see his game is in decline. Without asking them, I bet guys like PB and Money, guys I know go to games will agree. Castillo's contract calls for $5 million this upcoming season ('06) and if he has 400 PA in 2006 the team is obligated to extend his contract thru '07 at $5.75 million. Then there's the matter of the $2 million bonus he gets during his contract (which appears unpaid at this point) bringing his total compensation over the next two years to a whopping $12.75 million. Pretty big chunk of change for a guy who may or may not be your leadoff guy down the stretch when you need him the most. Certainly alot more money than a Tony Graffanino or Mark Grudzielanik would cost for the same period. In fact about three times as much. On the other hand you have Juan Pierre, he of the perpetual 650 to 700 PAs, average 55 stolen bases and career .305 BA. I realize a hater like you will start quoting this stat and that to demean the fellow but the fact is half of baseball would line up around the block to trade for him if given the opportunity. He isn't perfect, he needs to improve in some areas but he's still one of the premier leadoff guys in the game. As we all know, Pierre is arbitration eligible this off season and conventional wisdom seems split whether to trade him now or go the arbitration route with him, but I have a different POV. I say let's try and sign him to a three year deal at a price BELOW what he'd receive probably receive thru arbitration, (for example purposes, let's say JP would be awarded $5 million in arb, I'm suggesting we give negotiate a contract of let's say, $14 million for three years, but again these numbers are just for illustration purposes) not unlike the D'Rays just did with Rocco Baldelli, thus creating value in his contract, the exact opposite of the situation we have right now with Delgado, where his remaining contract is above value because the remaining three years of his contract include $$$ to offset the paltry $4 million the Fish paid him in '05. Castillo still has significant value in the marketplace with a dozen teams in search of a leadoff guy and a Gold Glove to boot. Now is the time to trade him, when he has value. Castillo, at the very least should bring either pitching or prospects, or conceivably both. And at some time in the future, if we've negotiated the right deal with Pierre, we may have the opportunity to trade him as well, and bring more resources to the Marlins, whether it be a position player or pitcher, thus continuing to feed the team with fresh blood that keeps payroll low, but still competitive. I could go on and on with a more indepth explanation but I think I've sketched out enough so that you can grok what my thinking is. I don't expect you'll agree and perhaps others will agree with you, but from my perspective, if the Marlins want to get well financially this is one of the tough moves they will have to make going into the 2006 season.
-
Rotoworld predicts Sammy Sosa will sign with the Marlins
I'll take him over Conine... That's right, I said it! Why don't you amble over to orioleshangout.com and profess your choice there and see what they think of your comment.
-
Just saw this..............
I can be 100% wrong but I don't see any merit in a discussion that includes the Marlins signing Furcal when just about everyone realizes we'll be cutting payroll and probably letting Gonzo walk because we done want to pay him the $4-5 million a year he's seeking. Maybe we aren't paying him $4-5 million a year not because we're cutting payroll, but we believe we can get a better player on the open market. I truly believe the front office cares more about production than sentimentality. Some of you guys need to remember that just because the guy turned the tide of the World Series with a swing means we have to give him contracts he isn't worth. Who said anything about sentimentality? Oh, it was you
-
Just saw this..............
I can be 100% wrong but I don't see any merit in a discussion that includes the Marlins signing Furcal when just about everyone realizes we'll be cutting payroll and probably letting Gonzo walk because we don't want to pay him the $4-5 million a year he's seeking.
-
Baseball America names Top 10 Prospects for 2005
Instead of this insanity continuing, it might be productive to agree to disagree and get back to the subject at hand, the depth and appeal of the ten players Baseball America has deemed our best prospects. No one is going to change their minds at this point and while it's tempting I know to keep debating this, come spring training it will all play itself out and we'll see who starts in LF.
-
Baseball America names Top 10 Prospects for 2005
:banghead this is getting painful