Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Tee Ball Bunt Machine

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Tee Ball Bunt Machine

  1. Alex Sanchez is not the answer in CF, not for next year, not ever... "Answer" or not, he is the best CF in the organization. Much closer to being "the answer" than the Reggie Abercrombies and Eric Reeds of the world, or even Amezagas & Codys. And he cost the team next to nothing.
  2. a stopgap for 2007 who would still figure to be a good bench player in coming seasons once we get a "permanent" solution. Alex Sanchez. If he's ready & healthy, he can easily be hitting over 300 and contributing offensively, even if not a defensive dream. Still, it would be a step up with veteran who has played the position in the majors more than anyone else on our roster. It will improve things a bit for the time being and give us another year or two to solve the CF riddle.
  3. can we just get rid of him all together and give the 5th spot in the rotation to one of the oodles of prospects that we have...i mean come on...its not like this team wastes their minor league depth...i would be shocked to see mitre come march...he has throw-in in a deal written all over him Prospects are prospects for a reason - most of them aren't ready. Mitre would be an ok 5th starter. Not the most consistent guy, but he has his moments. With decent defense & run support + a serviceable bullpen, he would be fine.
  4. if Messenger is on the roster next season, there is no way we could not call this offseason a complete failure. lol I kinda have to agree though. I would rather see less (or none) of Messenger until he makes some significant improvements.
  5. I have no problem with Cordero (although his hat does look funny), but it's not happening.
  6. Not going to happen, just because of the division. If the Nats were willing to strengthen us in order to bring talent into their system they would have done it last year for Soriano.
  7. we're not thinking about trading him either way. Especially with a stadium deal potentially close.
  8. As you all sit here and compare Amezaga to Bernie Williams to explain why Bernie would be fine in CF, remind yourself that we are talking about a 10-year age difference, not to mention the difference in the physical wear & tear on the body of a guy who has spent the bulk of those years playing a lot as a starter. That said it's not happening and I wouldn't bother pursuing it. I doubt Bernie would be interested unless he thinks all that closer-revival magic will work for him in CF. But he's as much a Yankee as we all want Cabrera to be a Marlin - forever. And if we were going to pay what he would cost us, we could probably spend it better.
  9. I'm looking forward to (I'll be honest, hopefully) Alex Sanchez making all you whiners look silly. None of the big name FAs or trade "options" were going to happen. He's no Andruw Jones, but the guy's got a career 290 avg at the ML level, and was bringing it up every season, with an avg over 320 over 04-05 combined, and an OPS over 750. All that without any of the problematic splits that plague virtually every other offensively decent CF candidate we have (Amezaga, Ross, Borchard) and obviously wouldn't be the black hole that Reggie & Eric Reed are. Even if his defense is down right awful, you can only consider it so much of a downgrade from what we had last year. If the guy hits close to what he was hitting last time in the bigs, we are better off for it. Could Beinfest have done more? Arguable. Depends on how you value our pitching staff, and how you think their value might change in the future. But I think many people on this board are over-estimating the quality of many prospect and backup OFs in other systems, who actually have had worse career MLB numbers and less experience than Sanchez, not to mention the fact that all he costs us is minor league contract. If he's a complete bust, we've lost nothing. Personally, I'd be more upset if we gave up significant talent in exchange for a questionable CF solution.
  10. And much better off at catcher than we are at CF.
  11. His winter league numbers are great, but I do not take them too seriously. Just like I do not take ST numbers too seriously. While both can be indicators of a players skills, I want to see progression of a major league professional over the course of his career in the minors and/or in the bigs. And when I look at Sanchez's performance there I am unimpressed. Or do you seriously suggest that his performance in a Latin winter league should be given more weight than what he has done in MLB and the minors over the course of his career? With the list you give, I am a convert of the much touted on this board (though untested in the field) Cofredo Amezachard platoon (if a better option is not present, and it isn't). I'd like to see that given a chance in 2007 before Sanchez, any day of the week. Are you serious? Or have you just simply not looked at his MLB numbers? The guy had one ugly stretch when he played in the minors last season. If you look at his entire MLB career, you see a 290 AVG (without any ugly splits requiring a platoon) with a career OPS of around 703, which, while not staggering, is still better than any in house options we have. And if you want progression, just look at his stats season to season while he was in the bigs. Over the time he played his last two major league seasons (04-05, so that should count for consisitency) his AVG was more than 30 points up his career #s at 324 while his OPS was about 50 points higher in that span as well. I'm not trying to sell the guy based on his LVBP numbers. The fact of the matter is that his MLB offensive numbers are better than every other CF candidate we have, and in most cases it's not even close. I only look at the LVBP #s to demonstrate that he's gotten out of whatever funk he was in while in the minors last year. If you look at his career #s over the past 3 or 4 years, that stretch sticks out as way below his usual performance at any level, and as more of a prolonged slump than a real indicator of his abilities.
  12. Hopefully it IS Pompano. Seriously, most of us (believe it or not) do live in Miami. Without question, most of us work (or otherwise spend our work-day hours) in Miami. And in the afternoon (during which we would all be heading to games) there is insane traffic going NORTHBOUND out of Dade, into Broward. Do you really think having the stadium on the opposite side of the worst traffic (when most will be going) from where most fans live/work is a good idea?
  13. As good as he could. He needs to prove he can play up to that level again in the bigs (which I have serious doubts), and his post-suspension performance in the minors last season definitely is not encouraging. And even if he ends up hitting as well as he did, between his terrible defensive skills and his poor plate discipline he still will be at best a 4th outfielder. Is his performance in the VWL not encouraging? Nevermind that - for all his weakenesses, and assuming no CF FA is signed and none are acquired through trades, who do you see getting ahead of him? The only one of the 5 or 6 guys that is regarded as having decent defense is the offensive black hole known as Eric Reed. But seriously, who else is there? Reggie - niether offense nor defense will work as a selling point for him unless he has a MONSTER ST, and even then, anything wrong with Sanchez will be much worse with Reggie. Cody - he slugs well vs LHP, but that's it as afar as offense goes. Defensively, I think he makes a great corner OF with good awareness of the walls and such, but not so much for CF. Borchard - better vs RHP than Cody is vs LHP, even if he didn't have any sexy 3 HR games. Is mentioned the least around here, as no one seems confident in his D. Either way, it'd be hard to see him & Cody in there not as a platoon. Amezaga - not an OF at all, and it shows. Also looks like Eric Reed at the plate when facing LHP. Eric Reed - he is Eric Reed. He is lucky to have a ML OBP around 200. Am I missing anyone?
  14. If the guy just plays up to his previous MLB performance (which was a 324 avg over his last 2 MLB seasons (04-05) ) the job is his to lose. No one currently in the organization belongs ahead of him if he plays as good as he can or close to it.
  15. If it's going to be a trade or (relatively) big contract FA I'd like to get something more than the names mentioned here. I don't think that many will/would be that much better than Sanchez to justify the costs. That said, I think Sanchez will be starting in CF in April unless he blows it in ST. The defense being bad is almost a given with everyone we have (and almost everyone available), but if he can hit 300, have a 350ish OBP and steal 30-40 bases, he'll be head & shoulders above the rest. And those #s shouldn't be too unrealistic for him.
  16. I'll wait till I can buy them at their actual price. No need to overpay some season-ticket holder who can't go. But I plan to catch all 3 games.
  17. 1. It's only logical to assume that there was some financial incentive for the FO to play a game in Dayton, Ohio in March rather than the traditional game here in Florida. 2. The probability of an injury is greater in 1 game in March in Ohio rather than 1 game in March in Florida. 3. This is just a discussion about the one meaningless game...it is irrelevant to talk about weather in Washington or any time to adjust. 4. The Marlins are in a precarious financial situation. We can't afford a pulled hamstring by a roster player. 5. It is my contention that it's greed winning out over the welfare of the team, and I don't think there's another FO in a like situation that would act this way, but I believe Loria was lured by the loot. 6. I hope that in the end everybody comes back as healthy as they left and that's the end of it. Why? How? does the weather in Dayton cause injuries or something? so much so even if you play just one game there? & Reggie Abercrombie pulling his hamstring would hardly be the end of the world.
  18. But you have to look at age. You can't just ignore that factor. That's huge! Although not extreme, I feel like Upton's situation is similar to Josh Willingham's was. Everyone knew he was going to hit, but for one reason or another, we kept moving Willingham to positions where he was blocked by very good players(Id rather not get started on how we totally blew it with Josh, as he should be on his 3rd or 4th year, not his second).(now that I think about it, maybe Willingham's situation isnt that similar, but I felt like venting anyway) With the talent level of our pitchers(as a whole), and the awesome talent that is BJ Upton, I would have no problem giving them Josh Johnson or Ricky Nolasco(+any minor league arm). He's that good of a prospect. In terms of a single year's performance, age doesn't make a difference, and I can ignore it. In a vaccuum, I don't care if the guy batting 300 is 30 or the guy batting 200 is 20. I will play the guy hitting 300. In terms of signing to a long term contract, that may be a different story. Nolasco & JJ especially have already shown a good bit at the ML level, which BJ Upton has not. Besides that, he doesn't have a position to play in Tampa. No matter what they ask for, Upton isn't worth any of our 5 SPs, not to us or them, at least not yet.
  19. I'm not going to try to go through this entire thread cause it seems to have snowballed into something else, but I will add a few things: This thread was about Alex Rios and the possibility of acquiring him. He could very well be worth one of our starting pitchers, but I'd like to have a better idea of whether or not he can consistently look as good as he did before he got hurt this year. BJ Upton isn't worth any of our starting pitchers. He may develop and be a great consistent player in the future. Right now, he's not even good enough to win a starting position on one of the worst teams in the major leagues. Every one of our SPs are at the very least Good at the major league level. Comparing him to Aguila is valid, even if not toally accurate. Sure, it took Aguila longer to be a good minor league player, but the point remains that he does post good minor league numbers, but is garbage in the majors. If you look at the numbers they are posting now, rather than trying to adjust for age, you'll get it. The fact is though that if we wanted Minor league 300 hitter in CF we could've resigned Aguila and used him. Or Eric Reed for that matter. I'm not saying he's a bust, but we aren't talking about bringing him in as a prospect and giving him time to develop for a year. We are talking about giving up more than 1 quality SP to make this guy or full-time CF. And that is a bad idea. I'd rather play Alex Sanchez than trade for Upton personally. Both will/would be defensive liabilities, both should hit better than the other CF candidates, but Sanchez is a career CF with a career ML Avg of 290, over 320 if you look at his last 2 seasons in the bigs (04 & 05). And while he may not be the CF of the future at age 30, we also already have him for cheap, and don't need to give up any arms for him. Point is, BJ is going to be a plus CF for somebody, sooner rather than later, and he fits exactly into what we're trying to do. He'll probably OPS .750-.800 for 1-3 seasons (which is still really good for CF). Unlikely, since TB seems to like him on the bench so much that they want too much for him. As far the OPS predictions, just remember Hermida and his ROY season that never was.
  20. any news about new recruit for marlins, I live in france and not much marlins informations here ? and second question , why not tankersley for our closer next year in place to pay much dollars for benitez whoi isn't long term solution for our team in contrario of tankerlsey ? opinion and see you later on this forum :notworthy I'd keep Tank as a setup guy just because I think good setup guys are harder to find, even closers are more expensive. And wouldn't mind seeing some of the guys we traded for also getting a shot to close, particularly Matt Lindstrom (I mark out for the 100MPH fastball from a closer).
  21. I'm constantly amazed that people put forward Heilman for trades. The guy is so bad a SP that the SP-starved Mets, who send out guys ERAs over 5 and 6 refuse to let him start for them. No one WANTS Heilman. They might take him as trade filler, but nobody is actively trying to get him on their squad.
  22. While I do agree that a statistical outlook ignores some important intangibles, I will say that the "human element" often openly embraces the fallacious principles of the game that appear to be in place just to appease simplistic fans. So you don't believe a pitcher's comfort level with his role and use affects his performance? At least significantly? It would be nice to measure talent in a vacuum and perhaps everyone SHOULD be able to do their best regardless of personal feelings or comfort, but that isn't reality. Reality is that a guy who might do well as a setup man (like Mota) might completely fail as a closer, and a good closer (like Todd Jones) might be just average as a middle reliever. Perhaps that also has to do with how we measure each, and certainly there are guys who just plain can't cut it either way, but it's more simplistic to ignore that the same talented player's performance might suffer or improve based on how it's used, and that there might be a "best" way to utilize it.
  23. Anyone concerned that perhaps Rios year last year might of just been a career half of a year and he never will do something like that again? Yes, that's why I think we should be very conservative with the offer (none of the top 4, maybe not even Nolasco and a prospect).
  24. Been thinking the same thing. And while I know relatively little about him, Lindstrom is one guy I'd like to see get a shot at closing in ST. Maybe that's a bit simplistic just on the strength of a 100MPH fastball, but I think a guy like that would have no greater value then to overpower and intimidate hitters at the end of 9 innings. I would like to keep Tank in a setup role simply because I think it's a much harder role to fill with a consistent pitcher. And if another starter develops, I'm willing to experiment with Ricky as a closer, but not until he has a viable replacement (or two) for his spot in the rotation.
  25. I like the idea of getting Rios if the FO believes he is capable defensively, but I wouldn't give up more than a package of Nolasco + Mitre + MAYBE a prospect, and even that I'm iffy about. Top 4 are still too good and off limits. Unless the Braves want to send us Andruw Jones for one and pay 100% of both salaries, those guys stay put.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.