Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Dr Beinfest

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Dr Beinfest

  1. A third of the season isn't enough to indicate that they're legit, especially considering that Fernandez will no longer be around for the second half. You're remark about Alvarez makes no sense, either, because he was already in the rotation when Fernandez was healthy. In other words, you cannot say that Alvarez has replaced Fernandez's weight when he isn't filling his spot in the rotation. The overall talent in the rotation has not recovered from the Fernandez loss. A third of a season is enough to say that players who have played in all of the games aren't just merely overperforming. That isn't to say that things are going to stay the same, but I'd say one third is a significant portion. My "remark about Alvarez" makes sense if you want it to. Maybe you don't, I don't know. He's carrying the weight of Fernandez, i.e. he is now the ace. We aren't shorthanded at the high end, we are shorthanded at the low end. Alvarez had been a luxury until Fernandez fell, now he's pivotal.
  2. Well, we aren't sure yet when Heaney will be up. I'm high on him long term, but we also don't know how he will perform. You can't automatically assume that he's going to perform out of the gates. But, yes, he'll certainly be an upgrade over Wolf, but the extent is still completely unknown. Most of the overachieving hitters have regressed to the mean by now, yes, but my point is that the offense is now showing its signs of mediocrity. They just demoted the second best hitter in the lineup and replaced his production with Ed Lucas. I'm also not sure what kind of production the Marlins can expect from Yelich down the stretch. I'm sold on him long term, but after a solid April, he's been pretty lousy since then. The line since May 1st has been .209/.319/.400/.719. All of this is in addition to the bullpen woes. The bottom line is that it's still too early to look at standings. It's early enough in the season that teams in the NL are still clustered together. Looking over the talent level of the team, it's really hard to see them as legitimate contenders. I really have no idea what you mean by saying they just demoted the second best hitter... maybe I didn't get the joke.
  3. This is silly. It's early June. That isn't close to being "long enough to say its sustainable," in large part because Fernandez is out and they basically replaced him with nothing. There were also a bunch of guys who were playing over their heads during the early part of the season and have since come back down to earth. The season is early enough that it's much more necessary to look at the talent on the field than the record when determining whether or not the Marlins should add. They're over a third the way through the season. If you don't think that's significant, I don't know what to tell you. Fernandez is out, but for now Henderson Alvarez has been pulling Fernandez's weight. Plus, if you're considering the team's future with Giancarlo, you better want this team to consider adding responsibly right now. Because I think he's made himself pretty clear, he's gone unless things change.
  4. The only thing I disagree with is calling Henderson Alvarez an inning eater... I mean I know it's short term but you do realize how sick he's been this year, and that he was pretty damn okay last year.
  5. Huh? Huh what? Yeah I think our team is actually off to a good start and has lasted long enough to say it is sustainable. It can't hurt to make additions and now is better than it ever was since like... Cantu era.
  6. Well I think the more important thing is seize the opportunity while it is still there because this team is bound to make stupid mistakes or perhaps key players don't pan out.
  7. Every team has plenty of players who don't pan out. It's no real reason to make a trade like this. You could just as easily make a list of young players who have panned out for this team, as well. I never said that. I started off by calling it bad value. I just don't agree with saying our time isn't now. Our time is more now than it has ever been. That doesn't mean take bad value. It means don't wait for this 'future' bullshit. Because usually it isn't a perfect world. But let me reiterate, I don't support this move. I was speaking specifically at the idea that we shouldn't be adding.
  8. The Marlins are far enough away from being legitimate contenders that they shouldn't be trading away draft picks for "someone that could possibly help this year." I dunno man. Don't get me wrong, this trade looks like it's simply bad value. But... we can sit there and say we're far enough away from being legitimate contenders but it seems like the Marlins are the same team that keeps falling flat on their franchise face. Every time they are supposed to be good for once, they fuck up. Guys like Jeremy Hermida get worse. Chris Coghlan shits his pants. Scott Olsen fucking sucks. Andrew Miller and Cameron Maybin fucking suck. And every year we see 'that one guy' who should take over. Heaney should be great. We'll be a competitor with him for sure. But then Heaney actually sucks and we wait so long on him that we're "supposed to be competitors" down the line with whatever players we draft with our super high picks because Heaney didn't pan out and become a core part of our team. Sorry for the rant, but my point here is that it's okay to move assets even if you're not supposed to be good. Why? Because we're a little over a quarter the way into the season and despite being broken to bits, we are right there in the mix of things. More so than we have been in a very, very long time.
  9. It must be in the vote bitches thread.
  10. Where's the voting?
  11. Edgar Renteria, Orlando Cabrera and Julio Teheran would disagree with you (BTW I left out Donovan Solano in order not to open a can or worms) ALL THE OTHER Colombian players agree. Wait... they don't exist.
  12. I was Olmos excited until I realized Colombians don't make good baseball players.
  13. Old school or new school I'd venture to say that batting average is important at the end of the season. Because at that point it's more than just an average, it's a permanent ratio of hits to at bats. It reflects impact, deserved or not (what I mean by that is... if something like BABIP is suggestive of a lower BA, it really doesn't matter). I think my favorite case of this is Ricky Nolasco. All his peripherals suggested he was due for better performance. But when the season ends, he's still got shitty performance facts. And at the end of the season, fact is fact and there's no hiding it.
  14. In with some sin
  15. Yeah, if this team is the real deal it wont be because of an addition of David Price.
  16. Attention grabbing for all the wrong reasons, dontcha think? I certainly didn't open this thread to go vote for Giancarlo.
  17. Did you really just say "vote, bitches!!!"? You should be ashamed.
  18. They've also been involved in 16 games where the score was decided by 5 runs or more. My guess is that they lead the league there. That includes winning and losing. Which means their run differential is and always will be volatile so long as that trend continues.
  19. Yeah, let's not imagine being buyers until we prove it. So far so good, though.
  20. You and my cat would get along so well.
  21. squall is an old man who doesn't love happy things.
  22. I didn't know Jose's feet were that big...

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.