Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

If we trade anyone, it should be...

Featured Replies

at the moment, we've got three highly capable guys who can play first:

 

conine, choi, and cordero

 

 

it doesnt matter if stokes continues to suck since we've got conine signed for the next 3 seasons anyway. strategically, we can trade choi without losing a step. in my mind nunez will probably outperform choi offensively this season and the next, so who really has the biggest upside of the two?

 

i think a big reason why so many people (including me) are reluctant to deal choi is because of the tremendous hype that has gone into him. top that off with the fact that we gave up derrek lee for him, and many folks are loath to wrap up the hee seop choi experiment without giving him more of a chance.

 

at the moment, i don't know what the solution is, but i do think we ought to trade one of them.

I rather not trade neither guy if you look at the big picture.Chances are Mike Lowell contract will be void.

we'll have lowell for at least one season and probably two.

 

if we're concerned about losing him two seasons from now, then we ought to deal choi rather than nunez, considering our depth at first.

we'll have lowell for at least one season and probably two.

 

if we're concerned about losing him two seasons from now, then we ought to deal choi rather than nunez, considering our depth at first.

huh?

 

Lowell Contract will be voided if there is no stadium deal by deadline which is sometime this year if not mistaken.

we'll have lowell for at least one season and probably two.

 

if we're concerned about losing him two seasons from now, then we ought to deal choi rather than nunez, considering our depth at first.

huh?

 

Lowell Contract will be voided if there is no stadium deal by line which is sometime this year if not mistaken. It doesn't void mid season. Its a one-year deal and I think he has the option to leave if we don't get a stadium deal in place at the end of the year.

at the moment, we've got three highly capable guys who can play first:

 

conine, choi, and cordero

Exactly.

 

So why trade Choi who has shown in the spring he has very good potential.

 

Trade Cordero for middle relief help. He is totally expendable with Conine able to play first....and Nunez available to play left.

we'll have lowell for at least one season and probably two.

 

if we're concerned about losing him two seasons from now, then we ought to deal choi rather than nunez, considering our depth at first.

huh?

 

Lowell Contract will be voided if there is no stadium deal by line which is sometime this year if not mistaken. It doesn't void mid season. Its a one-year deal and I think he has the option to leave if we don't get a stadium deal in place at the end of the year. LOL....

 

DUH....

He said he will be here for at least 2 seasons.

 

Which is why neither guy should be traded.The possability of not having Lowell is high.Nunez and Choi will be keys to the future if no stadium deals is in place.Probably main reason Beinfest is not considering trading Nunez.

Let's get back to the subject at hand.

 

If you don't want to trade Choi and you don't want to trade Nunez, who do you trade to better this team, especially the pen?

Let's get back to the subject at hand.

 

If you don't want to trade Choi and you don't want to trade Nunez, who do you trade to better this team, especially the pen?

Good question...

 

As of right now you would have to stay put and "re-evaluate" bullpen once season starts.I think we can get by with what we have until A.J return.

  • Author

I rather not trade neither guy if you look at the big picture.Chances are Mike Lowell contract will be void.

Excellent Point

  • Author

at the moment, we've got three highly capable guys who can play first:

 

conine, choi, and cordero

 

 

it doesnt matter if stokes continues to suck since we've got conine signed for the next 3 seasons anyway. strategically, we can trade choi without losing a step. in my mind nunez will probably outperform choi offensively this season and the next, so who really has the biggest upside of the two?

 

i think a big reason why so many people (including me) are reluctant to deal choi is because of the tremendous hype that has gone into him. top that off with the fact that we gave up derrek lee for him, and many folks are loath to wrap up the hee seop choi experiment without giving him more of a chance.

 

at the moment, i don't know what the solution is, but i do think we ought to trade one of them.

I agree... But in baseball, you dont make or not make moves base on public opinion, this isnt a PR firm. I think there are several teams that need a good young First Baseman, that would be willing to give a relief pitcher. I honestly think we should wait on trading anyone, let these guys play some REAL games and then start the best one out of the two. I do think Nunez is the best player out of the two and will fit in with the Marlins better. He is a 5-Tool player that has a lot of potential. We have Conine and Cordero behind Choi, so trading Choi will not be the end of the world.

We have Conine and Cordero behind Choi, so trading Choi will not be the end of the world.

i agree with you totally

  • Author

Finally, you and Fishtank are the only ones with real baseball common sense.

probably will never have AGon's home run power, he's a guy who can steal bases, hit for a better average and score more runs.

 

Not to say that Gonzo gives us a lot of power but isnt the one thing cant afford less of power? I mean we have two guys who hit for average and steal at the top of the order.

 

I understand your argument that saving money might be key. I think we should wait it out until the stadium issue settles though. If it doesnt, we might end up trading more than just Gonzo. Castillo might go too and Valdez might be the replacment at the top of the order. But why have Valdez wasted at the bottom of the order?

Finally, you and Fishtank are the only ones with real baseball common sense.

 

Because you want to trust a player who has a career .188 average and has done nothing at the major league level except have a good spring training. Lets wait a while see how everything plays out the first month of the season and then go from there.

  • Author

Finally, you and Fishtank are the only ones with real baseball common sense.

 

Because you want to trust a player who has a career .188 average and has done nothing at the major league level except have a good spring training. Lets wait a while see how everything plays out the first month of the season and then go from there. All I am saying is that someone shares my view that Choi is not a god that cant be traded...

probably will never have AGon's home run power, he's a guy who can steal bases, hit for a better average and score more runs.

 

Not to say that Gonzo gives us a lot of power but isnt the one thing cant afford less of power? I mean we have two guys who hit for average and steal at the top of the order.

 

I understand your argument that saving money might be key. I think we should wait it out until the stadium issue settles though. If it doesnt, we might end up trading more than just Gonzo. Castillo might go too and Valdez might be the replacment at the top of the order. But why have Valdez wasted at the bottom of the order?

I don't want make this sound like it's all about Valdez because it isn't, but he wouldn't neccessarily inherit AGon's eighth position in the lineup. You would probably hit him seventh (to try and get a guy on base) and move Castro/Redmond into the usual catcher position which is eighth, to drive him in.

 

At the same time, even if you hit him eighth, after the pitcher you have Pierre and Castillo coming up, both of whom can move a swifty baserunner along.

 

To me this is about managing your roster and your finances first and personalities are a distant second. It's about winning, and I think over a 162 game season the Marlins can win more games with Valdez or someone else at SS and a strong relief corps than with Agon at SS and no relief help.

  • Author

probably will never have AGon's home run power, he's a guy who can steal bases, hit for a better average and score more runs.

 

Not to say that Gonzo gives us a lot of power but isnt the one thing cant afford less of power? I mean we have two guys who hit for average and steal at the top of the order.

 

I understand your argument that saving money might be key. I think we should wait it out until the stadium issue settles though. If it doesnt, we might end up trading more than just Gonzo. Castillo might go too and Valdez might be the replacment at the top of the order. But why have Valdez wasted at the bottom of the order?

I don't want make this sound like it's all about Valdez because it isn't, but he wouldn't neccessarily inherit AGon's eighth position in the lineup. You would probably hit him seventh (to try and get a guy on base) and move Castro/Redmond into the usual catcher position which is eighth, to drive him in.

 

At the same time, even if you hit him eighth, after the pitcher you have Pierre and Castillo coming up, both of whom can move a swifty baserunner along.

 

To me this is about managing your roster and your finances first and personalities are a distant second. It's about winning, and I think over a 162 game season the Marlins can win more games with Valdez or someone else at SS and a strong relief corps than with Agon at SS and no relief help. Very much in Agreement

Here is another idea to through around in this thread. In Coninie's last stint here in 1997, he struggled with the bat. We traded him and when he ended up in Baltimore he immediatley returned to his old form. Now some would argue that his second half here with us wasnt impressive since he hit .238 and essentially Conine struggles in Pro Player and his best numbers are in Baltimore, ala Charles Johnson. Id argue against this since his OBP and Slugging were the same as they were in Baltimore, making his batting average statisically less significant. But the possibility does exist that he reverts to his struggles in 1997 and that it has to do with Pro Player. If he does struggle and Choi does thrive, having that depth might be invaluable. Do we put Nunez in and bench Conine?

Conine was my second choice to trade but from a PR and team chemistry standpoint it would be criminal to trade "Steve" again. The bad-mouthing in the local media would cost the Marlins a million in lost revenue and give the naysayers another chance to equate the 2004 Marlins to the 1998 Marlins, as unfair as it would be.

 

Had Conine not become "Mr. Marlin", were he not a local icon, were he just another late thirties ball player I'd agree 100%, but he isn't.

But in baseball, you dont make or not make moves base on public opinion, this isnt a PR firm.

sorry, if you are the Marlins you do.

 

you have to

How about we don't trade anyone now and if things work out well, we trade with Detriot to bring back Urbina sometime in June or July.

You cant really trade either and you dont need to right now. Choi almost broke out last season before his concussion and I think either this year or next he will put up top 5 numbers at 1B in the NL. I anticipate Nunez taking 9ner's job and I've heard of that scenario occuring from some credible sources. Abe's ST was not a fluke...hes for real.

  • Author

But in baseball, you dont make or not make moves base on public opinion, this isnt a PR firm.

sorry, if you are the Marlins you do.

 

you have to Thank God your not our GM...cause u r a fool...

Actually the PR job is done by the President who dictates to the GM what to do.

Do you not know the situation the Marlisn are in? They need good press to get support for a new stadium and get out of Huizenga's lease.

 

 

To trade list, although IMO not necessary yet:

1. Cordero

2. Nunez

3. Pavano

4. Choi

5. A-Gon

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.