Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

BBTN:TRASH

Featured Replies

Mets bs, if you would be so kind to tell me the Mets active pitchers, I would appreciate it.

  • Author

Seo is on his way out as well though; be it by Erickson, Heilman, or Garcia.

Garcia?? ha, if you guys get GArcia, we're getting beltran!

 

 

:lol :p

We have a hell of a lot more to offer even beyond David Wright than the Yankees or any other team.

 

And for Ninja Ubi:

Glavine

Leiter

Trachsel

Ginter

Seo

 

Wheeler

Parra

Moreno

Stanton

Franco

Bottalico

Looper

After doing the math, and coming up with the ERA's of both teams ACTIVE pitching staff, the Mets have a better ERA by...

 

0.5

 

Marlins active roster ERA: 3.59

 

Mets active roster ERA: 3.09

 

No reason to argue, really.

There's no reason to argue this. We all know the Fish have the best rotation in the league.

thats just being a homer

 

you gotta back it up

 

but yes, no doubt the marlins rotation is better than the mets because it goes much deeper than a top 3

After doing the math, and coming up with the ERA's of both teams ACTIVE pitching staff, the Mets have a better ERA by...

 

0.5

 

Marlins active roster ERA: 3.59

 

Mets active roster ERA: 3.09

 

No reason to argue, really.

Half a point is a lot...

There's no reason to argue this. We all know the Fish have the best rotation in the league.

thats just being a homer

 

you gotta back it up

 

but yes, no doubt the marlins rotation is better than the mets because it goes much deeper than a top 3 No, I wasn't being a homer. It's not like our team is clearly worse than the Mets with all starters with over 4.00 ERA's. But down the road, I'd choose our guys so there's no reason to argue, im my opinion. You call everyone a homer.

I never said your team was worse than the Mets, that was never the argument. The argument is we have better pitching ... which is clearly true. You guys have better offense, it goes both ways.

ERA is a meaningless stat. You can't always go with what's written down on paper.

 

Just because a team has a lower ERA than us doesn't mean they have a better pitching staff. The way a person pitches isn't based on numbers. One bad day could ruin an ERA.

ERA is a meaningless stat. You can't always go with what's written down on paper.

 

Just because a team has a lower ERA than us doesn't mean they have a better pitching staff. The way a person pitches isn't based on numbers. One bad day could ruin an ERA.

EXAMPLE: AJ BURNETT.

 

Take away the game Vs Cleveland, and his ERA is 2.11

How is ERA a meaningless stat? The whole goal of the pitching staff is to let the other team allow as little runs as possible. ERA is how many runs your staff allows on average.

 

You can't just discount one game because it went against the norm, every pitcher has games like that. Tom Glavine had a whole season like that.

Totally off-topic, I'm watching the A's/Angels game and David Justice was asked who would make the World Series and he said The Yankees and Marlins.

 

In Justice We Trust.

Whos STARTING ROTATION is better? Marlins or Mets?

 

1. Glavine (2.07) vs. Burnett (5.06)

2. Leiter (2.14) vs. Beckett (3.86)

3. Trachsel (3.44) vs. Penny (2.65)

4. Ginter (3.38) vs. Pavano (2.88)

5. Seo (4.84) vs. Willis (3.58)

 

If you match them up according to there spot in the rotation (ex. ace against ace, 2nd best vs 2nd best) then the Marlins win 3 games to 2 games...

 

If you average the ERAs, Mets win by about half a run...

 

Its extremely close but its not fair to judge Burnett by a 5.06 ERA, simply because he is the best pitcher on the Marlins staff and he just came back from TJ surgery.

  • Author

How is ERA a meaningless stat? The whole goal of the pitching staff is to let the other team allow as little runs as possible. ERA is how many runs your staff allows on average.

 

You can't just discount one game because it went against the norm, every pitcher has games like that. Tom Glavine had a whole season like that.

I agree with you, but we also have to acknowledge the fact that there are many elements that factor in the ERA, and therefore, it might not always be an objective parameter when measuring pitching performances (i.e. pitching to hot/better teams, etc)

How is ERA a meaningless stat? The whole goal of the pitching staff is to let the other team allow as little runs as possible. ERA is how many runs your staff allows on average.

 

You can't just discount one game because it went against the norm, every pitcher has games like that. Tom Glavine had a whole season like that.

The problem is that the sample size of amount of innings pitched by AJ is too small to use that disgusting ERA of 5....

 

Everyone knows that AJ Burnett's ERA is not going to be anywhere near 5.06

 

you can't say the same for jay seo

Totally off-topic, I'm watching the A's/Angels game and David Justice was asked who would make the World Series and he said The Yankees and Marlins.

 

In Justice We Trust.

word

 

:notworthy David justice :notworthy

How is ERA a meaningless stat? The whole goal of the pitching staff is to let the other team allow as little runs as possible. ERA is how many runs your staff allows on average.

 

You can't just discount one game because it went against the norm, every pitcher has games like that. Tom Glavine had a whole season like that.

So you're telling my V.Zambrano from TB is a better pitcher than AJ?

 

Well, he has a lower ERA than AJ... based on what u said that makes him a better pitcher. That's ludacris.

Whos STARTING ROTATION is better? Marlins or Mets?

 

1. Glavine (2.07) vs. Burnett (5.06)

2. Leiter (2.14) vs. Beckett (3.86)

3. Trachsel (3.44) vs. Penny (2.65)

4. Ginter (3.38) vs. Pavano (2.88)

5. Seo (4.84) vs. Willis (3.58)

 

If you match them up according to there spot in the rotation (ex. ace against ace, 2nd best vs 2nd best) then the Marlins win 3 games to 2 games...

 

If you average the ERAs, Mets win by about half a run...

 

Its extremely close but its not fair to judge Burnett by a 5.06 ERA, simply because he is the best pitcher on the Marlins staff and he just came back from TJ surgery.

I thought Penny was your "ace". Put Penny in your ace spot and the Mets win 4-1.

How is ERA a meaningless stat? The whole goal of the pitching staff is to let the other team allow as little runs as possible. ERA is how many runs your staff allows on average.

 

You can't just discount one game because it went against the norm, every pitcher has games like that. Tom Glavine had a whole season like that.

So you're telling my V.Zambrano from TB is a better pitcher than AJ?

 

Well, he has a lower ERA than AJ... based on what u said that makes him a better pitcher. That's ludacris. That's an extreme case, AJ has pitched 3 games and the Devil Rays are riding a lucky streak. But in most instances ERA is very accurate.

I just did some more math.

 

If you add the ERA's of the guys who have played for the whole season, the Marlins have a better ERA.

 

I took away Leiter, Ginter, Beckett, and Burnett because and the ERAs of the teams were...

 

Penny, Pavano, Willis = 2.90

 

Glavine, Trachsel, Seo = 3.22

 

...cough...

Whos STARTING ROTATION is better? Marlins or Mets?

 

1. Glavine (2.07)? ? vs. Burnett (5.06)

2. Leiter (2.14)? ? ? ? vs. Beckett (3.86)

3. Trachsel (3.44)? ? vs. Penny (2.65)

4. Ginter (3.38)? ? ? vs. Pavano (2.88)

5. Seo (4.84)? ? ? ? ? vs. Willis (3.58)

 

If you match them up according to there spot in the rotation (ex. ace against ace, 2nd best vs 2nd best) then the Marlins win 3 games to 2 games...

 

If you average the ERAs, Mets win by about half a run...

 

Its extremely close but its not fair to judge Burnett by a 5.06 ERA, simply because he is the best pitcher on the Marlins staff and he just came back from TJ surgery.

I thought Penny was your "ace". Put Penny in your ace spot and the Mets win 4-1. How the hell would Penny be out ace? He's pitched like it but he's not our ace. Coming into the season he wasn't our ace either. You're clearly favoring the Mets.

The Mets have a better team ERA, if you want to take your starters and releivers that have played a full season and match those with the Mets I think we know who would win.

  • Author

Well, he has a lower ERA than AJ... based on what u said that makes him a better pitcher. That's ludacris. [/color][/b]

Ludicrous, you mean?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.