Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

BBTN:TRASH

Featured Replies

The Mets have a better team ERA, if you want to take your starters and releivers that have played a full season and match those with the Mets I think we know who would win.

You have to be the biggest homer of all time. You know what injuries are, right?

 

Please tell me that when healthy, the Mets have a better pitching staff. Please go ahead.

Whos STARTING ROTATION is better? Marlins or Mets?

 

1. Glavine (2.07)? ?? vs. Burnett (5.06)

2. Leiter (2.14)? ? ? ? vs. Beckett (3.86)

3. Trachsel (3.44)? ? vs. Penny (2.65)

4. Ginter (3.38)? ? ?? vs. Pavano (2.88)

5. Seo (4.84)? ? ? ? ? vs. Willis (3.58)

 

If you match them up according to there spot in the rotation (ex. ace against ace, 2nd best vs 2nd best) then the Marlins win 3 games to 2 games...

 

If you average the ERAs, Mets win by about half a run...

 

Its extremely close but its not fair to judge Burnett by a 5.06 ERA, simply because he is the best pitcher on the Marlins staff and he just came back from TJ surgery.

I thought Penny was your "ace". Put Penny in your ace spot and the Mets win 4-1. How the hell would Penny be out ace? He's pitched like it but he's not our ace. Coming into the season he wasn't our ace either. You're clearly favoring the Mets. Take it easy, I was just pointing out the flaws in using that method of comparing head to head. I already concede you have a better rotation, the Mets have a better all-around staff.

The Mets have a better team ERA, if you want to take your starters and releivers that have played a full season and match those with the Mets I think we know who would win.

You have to be the biggest homer of all time. You know what injuries are, right?

 

Please tell me that when healthy, the Mets have a better pitching staff. Please go ahead. You think we haven't had injuries? Do you think that we liked sending James Baldwin and jae Seo out there? Every team has its share of injuries. You think we wouldn't have a better ERA with Strickland in the pen insted of Dan Wheeler or Jose Parra? And that's just or pitching! Every team has injuries, it's all about how you deal.

That's an extreme case, AJ has pitched 3 games

Exactly. Therefore you can't compare our teams ERA with the Mets ERA. Due to the fact AJ has only pitched a few games and his ERA is 5.06.

The Mets have a better team ERA, if you want to take your starters and releivers that have played a full season and match those with the Mets I think we know who would win.

You have to be the biggest homer of all time. You know what injuries are, right?

 

Please tell me that when healthy, the Mets have a better pitching staff. Please go ahead. You think we haven't had injuries? Do you think that we liked sending James Baldwin and jae Seo out there? Every team has its share of injuries. You think we wouldn't have a better ERA with Strickland in the pen insted of Dan Wheeler or Jose Parra? And that's just or pitching! Every team has injuries, it's all about how you deal. So who the hell is your number 5 if you take out Seo?

 

Glavine

Leiter

Trachsel

Ginter

???

 

...

AJ Burnett's performance doesn't have a huge effect, he's only pitched 4 games. That's 21 innings of out of all of the innings have been played.

The Mets have a better team ERA, if you want to take your starters and releivers that have played a full season and match those with the Mets I think we know who would win.

You have to be the biggest homer of all time. You know what injuries are, right?

 

Please tell me that when healthy, the Mets have a better pitching staff. Please go ahead. You think we haven't had injuries? Do you think that we liked sending James Baldwin and jae Seo out there? Every team has its share of injuries. You think we wouldn't have a better ERA with Strickland in the pen insted of Dan Wheeler or Jose Parra? And that's just or pitching! Every team has injuries, it's all about how you deal. So who the hell is your number 5 if you take out Seo?

 

Glavine

Leiter

Trachsel

Ginter

???

 

... Aaron Heilman and Scott Erickson were both ahead of Seo on the depth charts. Erickson got injured and management is giving Heilman more regular starts at AAA.

Mets have a nice (and ancient) 3 headed rotation.. with that being said, ill take the marlins rotation in a heartbeat.

Whos STARTING ROTATION is better? Marlins or Mets?

 

1. Glavine (2.07) vs. Burnett (5.06)

2. Leiter (2.14) vs. Beckett (3.86)

3. Trachsel (3.44) vs. Penny (2.65)

4. Ginter (3.38) vs. Pavano (2.88)

5. Seo (4.84) vs. Willis (3.58)

 

If you match them up according to there spot in the rotation (ex. ace against ace, 2nd best vs 2nd best) then the Marlins win 3 games to 2 games...

 

If you average the ERAs, Mets win by about half a run...

 

Its extremely close but its not fair to judge Burnett by a 5.06 ERA, simply because he is the best pitcher on the Marlins staff and he just came back from TJ surgery.

I thought Penny was your "ace". Put Penny in your ace spot and the Mets win 4-1. We can argue this forever...but every marlin fan knows that penny is not the best pitcher on our staff

 

The order the pitchers were listed is clearly in the order of how important they are to each of the teams

 

Don't tell me that Penny is better than Beckett and Burnett, because he is not...

 

The ace of this team is AJ, and he is racking up the shittiest numbers as of now...

 

ERA in this case does not do the pitcher justice

The Mets certainly do have better pitching than the Marlins. We have the lowest ERA in the majors, a rock steady pen, and a top 3 that is right up there with the best in baseball. The Marlins starters may be good, but your pen is junk.

thank God there is someone else here with a brain.

The Mets certainly do have better pitching than the Marlins. We have the lowest ERA in the majors, a rock steady pen, and a top 3 that is right up there with the best in baseball. The Marlins starters may be good, but your pen is junk.

thank God there is someone else here with a brain. if you werent from new york you would disagree

 

although i do agree with mets bs...as of now the mets have better PITCHING, not SP

How is ERA a meaningless stat? The whole goal of the pitching staff is to let the other team allow as little runs as possible. ERA is how many runs your staff allows on average.

 

You can't just discount one game because it went against the norm, every pitcher has games like that. Tom Glavine had a whole season like that.

So you're telling my V.Zambrano from TB is a better pitcher than AJ?

 

Well, he has a lower ERA than AJ... based on what u said that makes him a better pitcher. That's ludacris. That's an extreme case, AJ has pitched 3 games and the Devil Rays are riding a lucky streak. But in most instances ERA is very accurate. We have three "aces" and the other two are pretty damn good twos

i cant believe everyone is having a legitimate debate on wether the mets rotation is better than the marlins

We aren't in first because our offense sucks, not our pitching. Hence the acquisition of Hidalgo.

 

And the claim was the Mets have a better staff, rotation AND pen.

Oh yeah Hidalgo is really going to help your offense. :rolleyes:

 

 

And AJB34: LMAO at your last comment. :lol

i cant believe everyone is having a legitimate debate on wether the mets rotation is better than the marlins

Did you even bother reading this thread?

The Mets certainly do have better pitching than the Marlins. We have the lowest ERA in the majors, a rock steady pen, and a top 3 that is right up there with the best in baseball. The Marlins starters may be good, but your pen is junk.

thank God there is someone else here with a brain. if you werent from new york you would disagree

 

although i do agree with mets bs...as of now the mets have better PITCHING, not SP As of NOW, the Mets have better pitching around the board. Just look at the stats.

 

MetsBS, you're speaking the truth. C'mon, if someone throws ahrd, they're an ace! Who cares if they have a 5 era! Burnett is better than Glavine, because Glavine throws slow! DERRR!

 

And how about that met bullpen! Wheeler, Parrish, Botallico, Stanton, Franco, Looper...the Mets pitching is good because they're starting (especially Leiter, Glavine, and Trachsel) and Looper and Botallico is ptiching well. the Met's pitching is msot definitely excelent this year. For the love of God, we have to call up david wright before we surrender the season.

The Mets certainly do have better pitching than the Marlins. We have the lowest ERA in the majors, a rock steady pen, and a top 3 that is right up there with the best in baseball. The Marlins starters may be good, but your pen is junk.

thank God there is someone else here with a brain.and this coming from someone that before the season started:

A. Called Pavano the most overated pitcher in the league

B. Stated that the Yankees have the best rotation in the league by far

 

:rolleyes:

Wright's going to be a monster, I'm hoping he can have a Miguel Cabrera-like impact on this team.

The Mets certainly do have better pitching than the Marlins. We have the lowest ERA in the majors, a rock steady pen, and a top 3 that is right up there with the best in baseball. The Marlins starters may be good, but your pen is junk.

thank God there is someone else here with a brain.and this coming from someone that before the season started:

A. Called Pavano the most overated pitcher in the league

B. Stated that the Yankees have the best rotation in the league by far

 

:rolleyes: I said oakland had the best and the yankees were tied with the cubs...neither have the best, because of injjury...oh, how many games back is boston now???

my prediction

 

Pavano is not going to end the year with less than a 3 era. most likely, it will soar close to 4.

 

Oh yeah, with the Mets having the best rotation, that shows how much predictions are really worth.

The Mets certainly do have better pitching than the Marlins. We have the lowest ERA in the majors, a rock steady pen, and a top 3 that is right up there with the best in baseball. The Marlins starters may be good, but your pen is junk.

thank God there is someone else here with a brain.and this coming from someone that before the season started:

A. Called Pavano the most overated pitcher in the league

B. Stated that the Yankees have the best rotation in the league by far

 

:rolleyes: I said oakland had the best and the yankees were tied with the cubs...neither have the best, because of injjury...oh, how many games back is boston now???

my prediction

 

Pavano is not going to end the year with less than a 3 era. most likely, it will soar close to 4.

 

Oh yeah, with the Mets having the best rotation, that shows how much predictions are really worth. we aren't expecting Pavano to the Ace of this staff. And why you think his ERA will soar to 4, I'm not sure. Please back it up.

 

Pavano is a solid 3 or 4 starter on any team of this league. That's all it's been expected of him. How is he overrated?

And why you think his ERA will soar to 4, I'm not sure. Please back it up.

 

His entire career he was a mid 4 era 5 starter. nothing more. history tells me he should be closer to 4...and get an injury some time soon.

And why you think his ERA will soar to 4, I'm not sure. Please back it up.

 

His entire career he was a mid 4 era 5 starter. nothing more. history tells me he should be closer to 4...and get an injury some time soon. oh sure, like he did last year. . . . .NOT

The Mets certainly do have better pitching than the Marlins. We have the lowest ERA in the majors, a rock steady pen, and a top 3 that is right up there with the best in baseball. The Marlins starters may be good, but your pen is junk.

thank God there is someone else here with a brain. if you werent from new york you would disagree

 

although i do agree with mets bs...as of now the mets have better PITCHING, not SP As of NOW, the Mets have better pitching around the board. Just look at the stats.

 

MetsBS, you're speaking the truth. C'mon, if someone throws ahrd, they're an ace! Who cares if they have a 5 era! Burnett is better than Glavine, because Glavine throws slow! DERRR! i dont fault soriano for not knowing much about other NL east teams, but someone familiar with the marlins' rotation would have to be utterly clueless (or a total homer) to say the mets have a better rotation than the marlins.

 

burnett hadnt pitched for more than a year and got lit up his first two starts, including 7 ER in that one outing... he has been absolutely phenomenal since. youd have to have no brain in your skull to use burnett's current inflated ERA as the basis of your comparison of SPs.

 

similarly, a person would have to be clueless to compare current staff ERAs of the two teams. darren oliver--who had the 2nd highest ERA of all starters in baseball when he got pulled--is no longer in the rotation and has been replaced by one AJ burnett.

 

marlins rotation > mets rotation, and it's not even close.

burnett hadnt pitched for more than a year and got lit up his first two starts, including 7 ER in that one outing... he has been absolutely phenomenal since. youd have to have no brain in your skull to use burnett's current inflated ERA as the basis of your comparison of SPs.

 

similarly, a person would have to be clueless to compare current staff ERAs of the two teams. darren oliver--who had the 2nd highest ERA of all starters in baseball when he got pulled--is no longer in the rotation and has been replaced by one AJ burnett.

 

marlins rotation > mets rotation, and it's not even close.

 

It's so not close? Glavine and LEtier are pitching better than any marlins starter. Trachsel and Ginter are doing well as well. which rotation would you take? The marlins because of age. But for this YEAR? Definitely the mets. Stop living in delusion land.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.