July 12, 200323 yr I don think we overpayed at all. We gave up 3 marginal prospects - yes, marginal - for the AL leader in saves. U3 is the league leader, mind you, on one of the worst teams in the game! 26 saves?! How many would he have with the MArlins if he was here all season?! I think we just made a huge move that says we are serious. I just wish we got Juan Gone in the deal too, I dont know what it would take. I think once Benitez is moved, Juan Gone will be moved too. I am surprised that U3 was moved before Benitez, and especially because u3 was supposed to be apart of a 3 team deal that included Benitez too. Seems we booby-trapped that deal as well. Now, go get Juan Gone for that all-Juan OF and send Cabs down to AAA for some more seasoning. We over payed badly let's face it. Gonzalez has finally figured it out and he will be a Solid player to say the least if not a star. Also Smith and Snare were 2 of our top 10 prospects. Urbina will only be here for one year. Even if we make the playoffs in long run the Rangers have gotten by far the better deal. Right now it might look good to you guys but just wait after Gonzalez makes the All Star team year after year.
July 12, 200323 yr By the time we're done trading, now, before the July 31st deadline, and after the season, I'm sure we'll be picking plenty of prospects. Urbina is a FA at the end of the season. Whoever signs him will be compensating us with draft picks. And so the cycle continues...
July 12, 200323 yr i like Adrian, but how has he figured it out? he has played well in AA, but sucked in AAA.... give this trade some time short term this is a great move by the Fish long term, it should be good for the Rangers
July 12, 200323 yr I think we may have overpayed. Why say NO to the Cash, and send 2 players instead of 3? A top prospect that performs later on the mayors means a lot of $$$ saved over a comparable FA over the long run. I'm a Marlins fan, and I do hope that U3 gets the job done!
July 12, 200323 yr I think we may have overpayed. Why say NO to the Cash, and send 2 players instead of 3? A top prospect that performs later on the mayors means a lot of $$$ saved over a comparable FA over the long run. I'm a Marlins fan, and I do hope that U3 gets the job done! Because we need the money for new guys we're about to sign. BTW, last time I checked Juan is playing lights out for Texas tonight as he has for the last couple of weeks.
July 12, 200323 yr I gotta say that we overpaid on this one. Kurkjian on Baseball Tonight thinks we overpaid by a lot. I hate to say it, but if we don't get into the playoffs, we traded away three players with good upside. Here are their stats thus far this year (all in AA): OF Will Smith: .293, 36 of 123, 23 runs, 5 2B, 1 3B, 1 HR, 13 RBI, 11 BB, 23 K, 1 SB 1B Adrian Gonzalez: .307, 42 of 137, 15 runs, 9 2B, 1 3B, 1 HR, 16 RBI, 14 BB, 25 K, 1 SB P Ryan Snare: 5-4, 3.67 ERA, 18 G/GS, 103 IP, 98 H, 42 ER, 37 BB, 77 K I just noticed we don't have a lot of power-hitting prospects in the minors. Oh well. Time will tell about this trade....I bet when the Giants gave up prospects for Nen and Livan, everybody was saying "wow, they gave up WAY too much." Now, most of us can probably barely name a prospect we got. Of course, Nen and Hernandez were there longer than half a year.
July 12, 200323 yr i dont think anyone is arguing..... we did overpay.... but the FO needed to do something.... bringing in the AL leader in saves is something all right.... just my thoughts
July 12, 200323 yr I think we overpaid, but you also have to factor in that these guys were expendable. We have Stokes so we could get rid of Gonzalez. Our outfield is pretty much set for the future, and we have plenty of good pitching prospects so that made Snare expendable. That makes it a little easier for me to take.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.