February 16, 200521 yr TALLAHASSEE, Fla. - Gov. Jeb Bush said Wednesday he's not sure whether Florida's sports teams or enterprises should receive tax breaks from the state. The Florida Marlins want $60 million to help build a new baseball stadium near downtown Miami, the Orlando Magic are looking for similar assistance to renovate their arena or build a new one and Daytona Beach is asking for $75 million for a NASCAR Hall of Fame complex. Bush said the requests create a dilemma because the teams spur economic development, but he wonders if they deserve tax dollars. "Each and every one of these things, a legitimate case can be made," Bush said before Wednesday's Cabinet meeting. "The cumulative effect of it, though, begins to call into question is this a high enough priority to compete with other issues?" Bush said he shares some of the concerns of Senate President Tom Lee, R-Brandon, and other lawmakers concerned about handing out tax breaks to sports franchises. "You're subsidizing really rich people for their business," Bush said "I want to keep an open mind about this as well," Bush added. "Sports franchises have a unique role in community life as well. It's not just a business." The Marlins have reached an agreement in principle with the city of Miami and Miami-Dade County on a plan for a $420 million ballpark next to the Orange Bowl, but the deal hinges on receiving $60 million from the state. Lawmakers have twice before rejected similar requests by the team. http://www.macon.com/mld/macon/sports/coll...er/10916514.htm
February 17, 200521 yr Sports teams should never get state money. I would be hard pressed to argue against country money however. But in a state such as Florida, there is no reason someone in Tampa should be paying for the Marlins, let alone people in the panhandle, etc..
February 17, 200521 yr well nascar isn't a sport so they can just collect donations from hicks to fund their complex and let the marlins get the tax money.
February 17, 200521 yr If Bush isn't in favor of this, it's probably game over. But if he supported the state funding last year, I find it hard to believe that in crunch time he would shoot down the potential state money, undeserving as it may be. For the Marlins' sake, let's hope he doesn't bail out at the last minute.
February 17, 200521 yr Sports teams should never get state money. I would be hard pressed to argue against country money however. But in a state such as Florida, there is no reason someone in Tampa should be paying for the Marlins, let alone people in the panhandle, etc.. 687677[/snapback] You really don't have a clue do you about how this works?
February 17, 200521 yr I think the Marlins alone he would support, it's just that with the Magic and the racetrack, it's hard to see them giving it to the fish and nobody else.
February 17, 200521 yr Sports teams should never get state money.? I would be hard pressed to argue against country money however.? But in a state such as Florida, there is no reason someone in Tampa should be paying for the Marlins, let alone people in the panhandle, etc.. 687677[/snapback] You really don't have a clue do you about this works? 688077[/snapback] Actually, yes, I do. But, if Bush isn't in favor of it, it's going to be harder to pass, simply because there are already others who are on the fence (see Lee, Tom and his "terrorist" comments) that will need to be persuaded. If you have a governor who is outwardly opposed, it is tougher to persuade other leaders to go in favor of your policy. Not to mention that Bush has veto power. Without Bush, it's not impossible, but much, much tougher.
February 17, 200521 yr Sports teams should never get state money. I would be hard pressed to argue against country money however. But in a state such as Florida, there is no reason someone in Tampa should be paying for the Marlins, let alone people in the panhandle, etc.. 687677[/snapback] You really don't have a clue do you about this works? 688077[/snapback] Okay then how does this work oh great one? Explain to me how people outside of south florida never pay a single penny if this goes through. Or how people in south Florida won't pay if the Magic deal goes through. And if the Marlins deal gets pushed through, that only makes the Magic gripe all the stronger, and probably Daytona's as well. If the deal is signed it basically allows the Marlins to take a $30 million dollar loan from the state right upfront. And that is what is paid off by the state over the next 30 years. But you want to say it lets Loria keep his taxes, fine. If you don't let Loria keep his taxes, where would those taxes go? To the state. And who does the state spend money on? On eeeeeveryone, not only on Broward, West Palm Beach and Miami-Dade counties. If Miami wants a team, Miami can pay for it.
February 17, 200521 yr I'm sorry, Marlins2003, I misread due to lack of sleep and thought you were questioning me. My fault and apologies.
February 17, 200521 yr The PhishFan vs. Marlins2003 arguments are always great :jerry . 688188[/snapback] Its just an idealogical difference. I will never believe a state should help fund what is essentially a private business. Like I have said before. Would people be okay with the state funding publixes? Cause I am sure as hell publixes are a lot more important in northern florida than the marlins are. If the state does not get a piece of the Marlins by helping them out then screw it, why pay for them? I want to make money too, build me a stadium for 15 million dollars. 1/4 of what the Marlins are asking for. I'll have mud and crisco oil wrestling in it. That'll draw crowds.
February 17, 200521 yr Idealogically I am opposed to public money financing private ventures like this also. That said, I am also a realist. I know that politicians dip their fat hands in the money pot all the time to get their local projects like museums and art exhibits and other wastes of public money. In my opinion, there is little or no difference between these public projects and public financing of a private project- especially when you consider the marginal tax revenue that the state will have the benefit of. In a perfect world our politicians would be frugal with our money and spend it on needs, not use it on pork to get themselves re-elected. Our world is definitely not perfect, and we will always be working to some degree to fund things we will never get the benefit from. The same politicians saying that they don't want a stadium in S. Fla are trying to get their own pork projects passed to benefit their home districts. Will I, living in Tallahassee, benefit from either? No. The one silver lining in the Marlins situation is that the state, as a whole, will benefit from the increased tax revenue that we would not benefit from should the Marlins relocate. Will the increased revenue cover the 30 million they are asking for? Probably not, but it will at least cut that number in half, and that is much better than most of the other projects provide. I don't think opposing public financing for private projects is a bad stance at all. Honestly, it it wasn't the Marlins I probably would object as well.
February 17, 200521 yr I think this may be aimed at the Dolphins more than the Marlins, Magic, and NASCAR.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.