May 9, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero
May 9, 200521 yr Author AL: Starters: C. Joe Mauer 1B. Mike Sweeney 2B. Brian Roberts 3B. Alex Rodriguez SS. Carlos Guillen OF. David Dellucci, Jacque Jones, Vladimir Guerrero DH. David Ortiz SP. Johan Santana Bench: C. Jason Varitek, Javy Lopez 1B. Dimitri Young 2B. Alfonso Soriano 3B. Melvin Mora, Shea Hillenbrand SS. Miguel Tejada, Derek Jeter OF. Manny Ramirez, Gary Sheffield, Johnny Damon DH. Travis Hafner SP. Jon Garland, Rich Harden, Jose Contreras, Eric Bedard, Kenny Rogers, Scott Kazmir RP. Francisco Cordero, Eddie Guardado, Joe Nathan, Dustin Hermanson
May 9, 200521 yr Author btw, before someone starts ragging on me for picking Kazmir, you try picking a Devil Ray for the All Star team
May 9, 200521 yr Nice three posts in a row that could have been one. All-Star predictions on May 9th are lame.
May 9, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it
May 9, 200521 yr btw, before someone starts ragging on me for picking Kazmir, you try picking a Devil Ray for the All Star team 767737[/snapback] how about Carl Crawford?
May 9, 200521 yr btw, before someone starts ragging on me for picking Kazmir, you try picking a Devil Ray for the All Star team 767737[/snapback] how about Carl Crawford? 767754[/snapback] Or Huff.
May 9, 200521 yr Author NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4
May 9, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] Shut up.
May 9, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] With all due respect that is the dumbest reasoning I have ever seen. Peavy: 2-0, 2.32era, 49k, 0.91whip, .208baa, Willis: 6-0, 1.07era, 35k, 0.86whip, .189baa consider yourself pwned.
May 9, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] Since when does having 12 more strikeouts make you a better pitcher when you are inferior in every other category?
May 9, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] Since when does having 12 more strikeouts make you a better pitcher when you are inferior in every other category? 767818[/snapback] It obviously does, just like Micheal Tucker is a better player than Ichiro.
May 9, 200521 yr Since when does having 12 more strikeouts make you a better pitcher when you are inferior in every other category? 767818[/snapback] It's the same guy who said JP is "average" because his OPS isn't high. Link
May 9, 200521 yr Author NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] Since when does having 12 more strikeouts make you a better pitcher when you are inferior in every other category? 767818[/snapback] not 12 more strikeouts, 12 notches higher let's see... Willis barely has peavy beat in two major categories he leads, but Peavy blows out WIllis in the category he leads Peavy's lowest ranking in the 3 major categories is 6th Willis' lowest ranking in the 3 major categories is 15th Also, Peavy's DIPS era is 2.70 while Willis is 2.76
May 9, 200521 yr Author NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] Since when does having 12 more strikeouts make you a better pitcher when you are inferior in every other category? 767818[/snapback] It obviously does, just like Micheal Tucker is a better player than Ichiro. 767825[/snapback] when did i say TUcker is a better player than Ichiro?
May 9, 200521 yr As of right now Crawford is the D-Rays all-star, if not Alex "Dirty" Sanchez. Tejada should start over Guillen, even though its close. The sad thing is is that Jeter will be voted the starter once again and one of those guys will get screwed. Brandon Inge is a better candidate than Hillenbrand...almost equal OPS, Inge has 5 more RBI's and 13 more walks and has 4 more triples.
May 9, 200521 yr Author As of right now Crawford is the D-Rays all-star, if not Alex "Dirty" Sanchez. Tejada should start over Guillen, even though its close. The sad thing is is that Jeter will be voted the starter once again and one of those guys will get screwed. Brandon Inge is a better candidate than Hillenbrand...almost equal OPS, Inge has 5 more RBI's and 13 more walks and has 4 more triples. 767850[/snapback] Picking the Devil Ray for the team was the hardest thing...however, it was easier to bump the last pitcher than the last outfielder, that's why I chose Kazmir Tejada and Guillen could go either way...and if (and when) Jeter gets voted in, both will make it as backups anyways As for Inge over Hillenbrand, I chose Hillenbrand because I needed a Blue Jay for the team while I already had Guillen and Young from the TIgers
May 9, 200521 yr As of right now Crawford is the D-Rays all-star, if not Alex "Dirty" Sanchez. Tejada should start over Guillen, even though its close. The sad thing is is that Jeter will be voted the starter once again and one of those guys will get screwed. Brandon Inge is a better candidate than Hillenbrand...almost equal OPS, Inge has 5 more RBI's and 13 more walks and has 4 more triples. 767850[/snapback] Picking the Devil Ray for the team was the hardest thing...however, it was easier to bump the last pitcher than the last outfielder, that's why I chose Kazmir Tejada and Guillen could go either way...and if (and when) Jeter gets voted in, both will make it as backups anyways As for Inge over Hillenbrand, I chose Hillenbrand because I needed a Blue Jay for the team while I already had Guillen and Young from the TIgers 767857[/snapback] I dig man. It's cool. It's tough trying to get those lone players from each team.
May 9, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] Since when does having 12 more strikeouts make you a better pitcher when you are inferior in every other category? 767818[/snapback] not 12 more strikeouts, 12 notches higher let's see... Willis barely has peavy beat in two major categories he leads, but Peavy blows out WIllis in the category he leads Peavy's lowest ranking in the 3 major categories is 6th Willis' lowest ranking in the 3 major categories is 15th Also, Peavy's DIPS era is 2.70 while Willis is 2.76 767840[/snapback] what are the 2 major categories Willis barely leads in? Peavy: 2-0, 2.32era, 49k, 0.91whip, .208baa, Willis: 6-0, 1.07era, 35k, 0.86whip, .189baa
May 9, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] Since when does having 12 more strikeouts make you a better pitcher when you are inferior in every other category? 767818[/snapback] not 12 more strikeouts, 12 notches higher let's see... Willis barely has peavy beat in two major categories he leads, but Peavy blows out WIllis in the category he leads Peavy's lowest ranking in the 3 major categories is 6th Willis' lowest ranking in the 3 major categories is 15th Also, Peavy's DIPS era is 2.70 while Willis is 2.76 767840[/snapback] Peavy also plays in the most extreme pitchers' park in all of baseball and he still can't get to the individual stat levels of Willis. If you want to discredit wins saying it's not so much the pitcher as it is the pitcher and the team, fine, but WHIP and ERA are pretty fair evaluators of starting pitchers, as is BAA, and Dontrelle flat out dominates those categories.
May 10, 200521 yr I'm only doing starters C- Phillips / Mauer 1B- Lee / Sweeney 2B- Kent / Roberts SS- Barmes / Tejada 3B- Glaus / Arod OF- Cabrera, Dunn, Floyd / Vlad, J. Jones, Man-Ram P- Willis / Garland
May 10, 200521 yr AL C: Mauer 1B: Konerko 2B: Roberts SS: Tejada 3B: ARod OF: Vlad OF: Ichiro OF: Ramirez DH: Guillen SP: Garland NL C: Phillips 1B: Pujols 2B: Kent SS: Barmes 3B: Glaus OF: Cabrera OF: Edmonds OF: Dunn DH: Griffey SP: Willis *knocks on wood*
May 10, 200521 yr NL. Starters: C. Jason Phillips 1B. Derek Lee 2B. Jeff Kent 3B. Chipper Jones SS. Clint Barmes OF. Adam Dunn, Cliff Floyd, Miguel Cabrera P. Jake Peavy Bench: C. Paul Lo Duca 1B. Lyle Overbay, Albert Pujols 2B. Jose Vidro, Craig Biggio 3B. Troy Glaus, Edgardo Alfonzo SS. Omar Vizquel OF. Jim Edmonds, Jose Guillen, Luis Gonzalez, Brady Clark, Milton Bradley SP. Dontrelle Willis, Brett Myers, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Mike Hampton, Josh Beckett RP. Jose Mesa, Brandon Lyon, Billy Wagner, Chad Cordero 767734[/snapback] Dontrelle Willis not being your starter is so laughable it aint even funny how can you justify Peavy over Willis? I would LOVE to hear it 767751[/snapback] Willis is 6 notches higher in ERA and 2 notches higher in record, but Peavy is 12 notches higher in strikeouts... 12-6-2=4 767801[/snapback] Since when does having 12 more strikeouts make you a better pitcher when you are inferior in every other category? 767818[/snapback] not 12 more strikeouts, 12 notches higher let's see... Willis barely has peavy beat in two major categories he leads, but Peavy blows out WIllis in the category he leads Peavy's lowest ranking in the 3 major categories is 6th Willis' lowest ranking in the 3 major categories is 15th Also, Peavy's DIPS era is 2.70 while Willis is 2.76 767840[/snapback] you are a bigger idiot than i thought.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.