Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

The Ace Question

Featured Replies

Anibal has the highest ceiling, IMO. I expect full-on "I got the internet going nuts" type of dominance in a few years.

if scot olsen is so good why are the marlins trying to trade hi for that scrub gathright who is overrated. olsen is gonna be a stud.......

Train

Olsen

Pinto (sleeper)

Sanchez

Volstad

West (sleeper)

Petit

Nolasco

I choose Volstad. I for one just feel that theres something that makes this kid special. I have a really good feeling that he'll be a big time pitcher when he gets up to the majors. I also of course like D-Trains and Olsens ceilings.

It's a crap shoot when you're speaking of younger players, but I'm going with Volstad. He's been impressive during his short tenure in the pros. He's young and still has a lot to learn.

 

As far as Willis goes, he's awesome, and we'll just have to see how many seasons he has like 2005. He's deceiving with his delivery and damn tough to get good wood on when he locates. But I'm still not convinced MLB players won't figure him out. His W-L this upcoming year will suffer because for the first time he'll be pitching in the front of the rotation against other teams aces.

 

I've seen Olsen and he looks good, I'm just not sure he'll ever be an ace. The rest I'm just not familiar enough with yet.

Based on current stuff(pitching) the list should look like this:

 

Scott Olsen

Anibal Sanchez

Dontrelle Willis

Renyel Pinto

Chris Volstad

Jason Vargas

Jeff Allison

Josh Johnson

Sean West

Ricky Nolasco

Aaron Thompson

Yusmeiro Petit

Taylor Tankersley

Gaby Hernandez

Ryan Tucker

 

 

Potential. Bases on height, age, frame, control, experience, # of pitch depth.

 

1)Jeff Allison- almost died, didn't have his usual control or velocity, basically skipped rookie ball, hadn't played in 2 years, didn't face that good of a competition in high school cause played baseball in the north. Yet still more than held his own in the Sally League. If ne regains his 93-97 velocity, control, and breaking pitch. #1 Potential. Comparison: Josh Beckett

 

2)Anibal Sanchez- not polished yet, with limited action cause of TJ but already has 2 plus pitches(FB and C-Up) if only improves Curveball command he is no worse than a #2 with potential for #1. Comparison: Not sure

 

3)Scott Olsen- 2 plus pitches(FB and SL) needs only to improve command and alittle bit the Change-up. With that #1. Comparison: Scott Kazmir but a notch below

 

4)Dontrelle Wilis- not much to say. is only rank this low cause he of the funky delivery and doesn't have the stuff the guys in the top have. Based on batting avg against and K's. Currently #1

 

5)Chirs Voldstad- doesn't have the stuff the guys in top have or some guys below him but has 2-3 average pitches already. So high in the list cause of age and frame. At 6-7 and only 195 scout believe he can add 2-4 more miles of fastball velocity. Tops at 95 currently but is usually more in the 89-92 range. As of now comparison: Steve Tracshall. If grows into his body or fills that frame of his then sky is the limit. Now #3 could be #1

 

6)Josh Johnson- still young, constanly improving, huge frame, good body. Comparison: Carl Pavano #2

 

7)Sean West- tall lefty 6-8 but only 195. Stuff close to Voldstad but from the left size and the control. Very raw. Like Voldstad sky is limit. Comparison: Not sure

 

8)Renyel Pinto- Trust me when I say this similar stuff to Johan Santana. 2-3 above average pitches. Mainly 2 though. 92-94 FB, wicked change-up, and same goes for his slider at times. Major problem throwing strikes. Not able to set up pitches cause of it. Ranks where he is at cause I don't feel he is gonna fix the problem. Potentail could be anything. If everything clicks. Johan Santana/Al leiter cross. If it clicks half way then he is a Author Rhodes. If stays the same journey man.

 

9)Aaron Thompson- Very polished like Voldstad but a lefty. Frame is almost filled, can still get better though. Comparisons: Al Leiter/Randy Wolf/Cliff Lee cross #2

 

10)Yusmeiro Petit- can throw 4 pitches for strikes any time he wants and most of them of them are above average. Problem is they are all above average cause he hides the ball very good, control, and delivery. Like Willis this hurts his stock. Also like Willis hasn't proven at every level that he can pitch in the big's. Was rough up in his first 3 AAA starts but in his 4th had a 14 K game I believe. Could have been a result of nerves and innings. Comparison: Greg Maddux/Livan Hernandez cross Potential varias from #1-4

 

11)Jason Vargas- stuff wise what you see is what you get. Hasn't been a full time pitcher much time but doesn't show it. Can improve a tab but by experience. Comparison: Randy Wolf #2

 

12)Ricky Nolasco- not much room for improvement. Very good control of 3 pitches. All of which are average atleast. He is like a poor's man Josh Johnson. Comparison: Jeff Suppan #3-4

 

13)Gaby Hernandez- probably the most polished high school pitched from the 2004 class. Has a very good sinking FB and above average change-up. Since his 2 other pitches are not that superier, he is polish already, and doesn't miss wood as much as you like he is gonna have to improve his curveball. If he doesn't improve the curve to atleast average then he is a future reliver. If he does ceiling is a #3 but more can't be ruled otherwise. Like a Righty Jason Vargas but with more experience. Comparison: ?

 

14)Ryan Tucker- many will argue with me on why he is so low in the ranking but the answer is simple. He only has 1 pitch. It is a very good one but that won't get you anywhere. He has the bets fastball in the system probably including the major league ball club as well. A 95-97 mph fastaball with incredible movement. But since his change-up and slider are well below average hitters just sit on his fastball. Future is probably as a closer. Comparison: Billy Koch

 

15)Taylor Tankersley- injuries last season and the move to the bullpen has hurt his stock quite a bit. Not locked as a frontline starter anymore. Tankersly has a above average slider and about average fastball in the 90-93 range. I see him as verstile, swing man, bulldog pitcher out of the pen. Comparison: Al Leiter/Ron Villone cross (both in there better days)

 

Of course I did not give scouting reports on Jacoby Marceaux, Paul Mildren, Matt Goyen, Logan Kensing, Travis Bowyer, Chris Resop, Jose Garcia...and some others but if you want I can provide you with some info about them. I know the the farm system pretty well

considering Resop and Bowyer and relievers, you wouldnt need to provide any info on them

 

and Tank has yet to pitch in the pen in his Marlins career

  • Author

All other things equal, Allison probably has as high a cieling as any pitcher we've ever drafed, possibly even higher than Beckett's given Allison's absurd senior year in high-school (no earned runs and close to 200 K's...you've got to be kidding me).

 

Olsen compares quite favorably to Scott Kazmir as a youngin' and more likely could fill out as a Randy Johnson-type.

 

Sanchez could be a fireballer like Beckett...could be. Serious injury (nerve damage) worries me.

 

In no way is Volstad a #1, he's a control freak, middle of the rotation kind of guy, he isn't going to over-power you.

 

Johnson is a Brad Penny clone, not a Carl Pavano clone.

 

In terms of talent, West is probably up there with Olsen, profiles as a #1 and even with his incredibly raw stuff, his strikeout numbers were insane last year. A K/9 close to 11.

 

I don't love Pinto like some, he's had to repeat AA too many times. Repeating AA is like repeating 5th grade, it happens sometimes, but it isn't a good sign for things to come. Plus, he's got control issues. He's supposedly got a plus breaking ball, I think he may end up as a specialist, at best.

 

Tucker and Tank also probably move to the 'pen.

 

And for the record, I want to see Petit in a Marlins uniform, he's too damn intriguing to miss out on seeing what unfolds with him. I'd be disappointed if he's traded, but I can understand that he probably should be the first to go given the return we can get for him, and the risk associated with him.

Tank did some 'pen work in the AFL, if that counts

 

ah dammit... I knew that :confused

All other things equal, Allison probably has as high a cieling as any pitcher we've ever drafed, possibly even higher than Beckett's given Allison's absurd senior year in high-school (no earned runs and close to 200 K's...you've got to be kidding me).

 

Olsen compares quite favorably to Scott Kazmir as a youngin' and more likely could fill out as a Randy Johnson-type.

 

Sanchez could be a fireballer like Beckett...could be. Serious injury (nerve damage) worries me.

 

In no way is Volstad a #1, he's a control freak, middle of the rotation kind of guy, he isn't going to over-power you.

 

Johnson is a Brad Penny clone, not a Carl Pavano clone.

 

In terms of talent, West is probably up there with Olsen, profiles as a #1 and even with his incredibly raw stuff, his strikeout numbers were insane last year. A K/9 close to 11.

 

I don't love Pinto like some, he's had to repeat AA too many times. Repeating AA is like repeating 5th grade, it happens sometimes, but it isn't a good sign for things to come. Plus, he's got control issues. He's supposedly got a plus breaking ball, I think he may end up as a specialist, at best.

 

Tucker and Tank also probably move to the 'pen.

 

And for the record, I want to see Petit in a Marlins uniform, he's too damn intriguing to miss out on seeing what unfolds with him. I'd be disappointed if he's traded, but I can understand that he probably should be the first to go given the return we can get for him, and the risk associated with him.

 

 

I strongly disagree on Olsen filling out like Randy Johnson. The only thing Johnson and Penny have in common is either the high school or home state. Stuuf wise he is a Carl Pavano. i have scouting reports to prove that. West strike out rate was not insane by any means. He also only tops out at 93 mph right now.

West strike out rate was not insane by any means. He also only tops out at 93 mph right now.

 

 

http://www.minorleaguebaseball.com/app/mil..._pbp&pid=476811

 

40 K's in 38 innings (I thought I saw 31, but it was 38.1...what a difference a decimal point makes) and a 2.35 ERA as an 18 year old is pretty darn impressive.

 

Thats only rookie ball though. He did not do so well when we faced the college hitters. Here is his scouting report.

 

8. SEAN WEST, lhp, Marlins

Age: 19 Ht: 6-8 Wt: 195 B-T: L-L Drafted/Signed: Marlins '05 (1)

 

 

The 6-foot-8 West is surprisingly athletic for his size, with moves like a basketball player. He's adept at holding runners and fielding his position. His stuff is close to Volstad?s, but he lacks Volstad's mound presence and pitching knowledge. West?s fastball ranged from 88-90 mph, with a high of 92. He moved it in and out well and the pitch looked faster because it got on hitters quickly.

 

West drew comparisons to Randy Johnson because of his size and three-quarters release point. His slider was especially tough on lefthanders and was an effective backdoor offering against righties. He also gets good deception on his curveball.

His W-L this upcoming year will suffer because for the first time he'll be pitching in the front of the rotation against other teams aces.

 

Maybe at first, but how often do team's rotations get switched around due to ineffectiveness, injury, extra days rest, etc? It's not like he's gonna face another team's ace all year.

  • Author

West strike out rate was not insane by any means. He also only tops out at 93 mph right now.

 

 

http://www.minorleaguebaseball.com/app/mil..._pbp&pid=476811

 

40 K's in 38 innings (I thought I saw 31, but it was 38.1...what a difference a decimal point makes) and a 2.35 ERA as an 18 year old is pretty darn impressive.

 

Thats only rookie ball though. He did not do so well when we faced the college hitters.

He only threw 11 innings!!!! And he still had more K's than innings pitched.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.