Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Girardi Tonight

Featured Replies

Rferry if your not suggesting Girardi is unable to read his pitcher then what exactly is your point???

:blink:

 

That he didn't last night, and/or that he doesn't have a great read on his pitchers.

 

And you know that how, RFerry?

 

Did you talk to the bullpen coach and pitching coach, as well as the trainer? Do you think YOU can actually "read" the pitchers better than those guys?

 

ROFLMAO!

How many times have you said to yourself during a game that the pitcher was done? Or that he couldn't throw a certain pitch for a strike? That's how I base my opinions. What do you base your opinions on?

 

I do the same thing, but you need to read more carefully. As I said, while I enjoy questioning moves as much as the next guy, I realize that the things I would like to know as a manager, that might cahnge my mind or make the decison obvious, are known to Girardi but not always known to us.

I understand. I fully appreciate that. And I agree! But let's turn your point on its head. What makes any manager good or bad at any at his tasks? What makes any player good or bad at hitting or throwing a fastball? But by third party opinion? As well as the results that come about? I'm not saying Girardi is stupid or that he is purposely causing us to lose a game (as some suggest in their criticisms of Loria when he doesn't take a rumored stadium offer or Beinfest for this taking a rumored trade), but surely one can hold an opinion (and like all opinions, they're based on the information available) of a person's various skills.

Did anyone here Sid Resenberg on the 790 today rip girardi, about last nights game, its not only most of us who think he did a piss poor job yesterday or on ther games, and dont start w/ the excuse of bunch of rookies and look at their record, but all these rookies are talented and some nasty. He also mentioned how him and boog talk about girardi so i cant wait to hear what boog has to say about it. even tommy hutton talked about it yesterday that jake shouldve been hitting for olivo, " you replaced jake vs heilman for aguila vs wagner" hmmm damn i think i'll take the first match up even though chris got a hit. yes the ump sucked also cause if jobo strikes out delgado or wright which he did then its a 1 run game and wagner has more pressure and who knows what couldve happened

 

 

Lets just win tonight But damn girardi plz dont f*** up this one, also plz start ross and jo and not amezega remember glavine is a lefty!!!

 

The way Hutton ripped Girardi last night is a good indicator Girardi is gone after the season. Over his 10 years as the color guy Hutton has rarely ever questioned or criticized anything any Marlin manager has done but the past few days he has questioned move after move. That tells me he's gotten the okay from management to be critical of Girardi.

Passed balls are rare. Scoring off them even rarer. Let's say we do. Now the game is tied with what 2 out and Amezaga up, the game tied and our hottest hitter taken out of the game.

 

A double play is an extremely rare occurrence. I believe only 1.5 occur for every MLB game. Obviously such a play is terrible. A double play in that situation is a loss of .863 runs and 36.7% chance of scoring. However you can not play scared. You can't send your best situational hitter and better baserunners and tell them that you don't trust them. That you're afraid and to play it as safely as possible. To bunt to avoid a double play is the equivalent of being a shut in because you're afraid a car is going to run you over.

 

Olivo has hit much worse than Helms this year. And much worse than Helms and Ross recently. And not well at all against righthanders. To score from second, Reed would had to been running on contact (check, 2 outs and all) and a hit to the outfield gap and/or an outfielder with a weak arm. That's one big egg to putting in such a small basket.

 

 

Now let's imagine if Willngham had stayed on first and Helms hit. Just right there, that's roughly a 14.4% chance he'll score Willingham, 22.8% chance he'll become our second baserunner, 60.4% he'll make an out (and some of those would advance even the slow-footed Willingham), 2.4% chance he'll hit into a double play. Or let's imagine Reed steals second. He has roughly a 66.7% chance of doing that. What did we do instead? He utilized Helms and Reed to make a 99.9% certainty we advance ONE base of the 3 we need to tie and the 7 we need to win in exchange for one of our 3 outs.

 

Wrong, RFerry. Helms either hits a ground ball or strikes out about 70% of the time. Either,with or without the double play, that would have meant AT BEST man on 1st, one out, and a greatly reduced chance of scoring the run we needed. So much for your mangerial skills.

 

As I said before, the bunt virtually guarantees that with the almost inevitable outout (which was the most likely outcome by far) the runner would move into scoring position. Baseball 101. It was the right move, if you know the percentages and how to use them, and it was obvious, not really a matter for debate with your hottest hitter on deck. The subsequent hitters just failed to deliver with the runner in scoring positon.

 

By the way, Reed, the fastest player on the Marlins, would score easily from second on a single. They are taught to take the "2 out lead" and run on contact in that situation, with the responsibility to score on a single. Reed, of all players, would have done it easily.

I was using his splits AGAINST RIGHTHANDERS in which he has a .372 OBP with 18 extra base hits and 3 double plays in 125 plate appearances.

 

Let's expand on that. Among balls put in play (unfortunetly we don't have the benefit of lefty/right splits for this exercise), Helms hits a groundball (whether hit or out or error) 40% of the time. Heilman has a groundball percentage of 44.2%, dead on with the NL league average. By my calculations there's been roughly 39325 groundballs hit this year (44% * total PA) and 1838 double plays grounded into. So the league average is 4.7%. Heilman's percentage would work out to 4.9% per groundball. Helms is 5.5%. (Again both of these come from their overall numbers, not their splits.)

 

Take the largest percentage, 5.5%. Compare that to a 37.2% chance that the runner gets to second (or further) with none out. A double play is hardly the most likely outcome. Guess what other event is more likely than a double play? Helms has hit homers in 5.6% of his plate appearances against righties.

 

Now to bring back the math illiterate... And you're still playing scared. You're telling your one of your best hitters and your best baserunners that you DON'T trust them. That you don't believe they can win the game. That they should be more concerned about possibly hitting into double plays than winning. You're playing like you've already lost the game. And as we all know, losers never triumph.

Joe bailed on Nalasco too quickly.

He had Hanely run in the mud with the best hitters on their way to the plate.

He put Tankersley back out there after too many pitches.

He gave up one of his final 6 outs to have one of his better hitters bunt.

He didn't use Jacobs for Olivo.

Using Wood and Aguila was not a mistake in the 9th, it just shouldn't have come to that.

 

 

The bottom line is that Girardi shouldn't have been put in the position to make these types of decisions (game deciding) if the umpire didn't decide to give the game to the Mets. But to go through your points:

 

1) Nolasco is scheduled to re-enter the rotation and maybe he didn't want him to get into a long inning and lessen his effectiveness when that comes around by having to throw too many pitches and possibly getting bombed out of the inning. Nolasco was getting squeezed and should have gotten the strikeout versus Delgado. But it looked like it was going to get ugly after Wright's double.

Nalasco is not going in 2 days, he is going in 4, a double with a 4R lead is not a reason to pull a guy.

 

2) The steal for Hanley may have been ill timed, but it looked to me like he was safe.

 

Replays showed he was out and that the ump was in the exact right spot to see that. Only the homeplate ump was bad last night.

 

3) Tank last pitched three days ago and during that outing he had a similiar pitch count. So being tired is not an excuse. The guy just seems to have a thing for giving up game tieing homeruns when JJ gets a start. When JJ is pitching, it is time to have a quick trigger pulling Tank apparently (if you have to go to him).

 

He should not have been put back out, but frankly I don't think he should have been out there at all in the 7th anyhow. Now he is burned for tomorrow for no gain.

 

4) Minor quibble. Girardi was just trying to get the tieing run in.

 

Huge quibble, because that move makes it less likely the team will score a run. Is it going to take 30 years to change the misuse and misunderstanding of the bunt? Bunt with a man on 2nd and no outs or with a pitcher only.

 

5) Jacobs does not have the best track record as a pinch hitter, but I wouldn't have minded seeing a pinch hitter for Olivo.

 

Jacobs was ideally suited to bat in that position.

 

6) ----

 

 

Yeah, that one is really not at all in question.

Did anyone here Sid Resenberg on the 790 today rip girardi, about last nights game, its not only most of us who think he did a piss poor job yesterday or on ther games, and dont start w/ the excuse of bunch of rookies and look at their record, but all these rookies are talented and some nasty. He also mentioned how him and boog talk about girardi so i cant wait to hear what boog has to say about it. even tommy hutton talked about it yesterday that jake shouldve been hitting for olivo, " you replaced jake vs heilman for aguila vs wagner" hmmm damn i think i'll take the first match up even though chris got a hit. yes the ump sucked also cause if jobo strikes out delgado or wright which he did then its a 1 run game and wagner has more pressure and who knows what couldve happened

 

 

Lets just win tonight But damn girardi plz dont f*** up this one, also plz start ross and jo and not amezega remember glavine is a lefty!!!

 

 

 

 

 

Let me be the first to say :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol :lol

 

Since when does Sid Rosenberg know anything about baseball?

 

Because he second guessed Girardi's decisions it validates all your crying?

 

Laughable

Um no.

 

The national media just understands that tankersley gave up a HR to CARLOS DELGADO last night and that ANY of our pitchers could have given up the 3 run jack.

I do think it is interesting that the portion of the media that favors Girardi the most is the national level that probably hasn't even watched a Marlins game.

 

All they see is the win-loss record and the payroll figure.

 

 

Actually a number of local sportswriters have praised Girardi for what he has done for this team and ripped Loria for how he has treated Girardi/kept silent on where he and Girardi stand. If Girardi is fired by the Marlins after this season, I fully expect Loria to be villified in both local and national media. If the Marlins are foolish enough to try and trade Girardi to a club ala Lou Pinella for prospects the Marlins will be lampooned/laughed at/castigated by both local and national media to no end.

I do think it is interesting that the portion of the media that favors Girardi the most is the national level that probably hasn't even watched a Marlins game.

 

All they see is the win-loss record and the payroll figure.

 

If the Marlins are foolish enough to try and trade Girardi to a club ala Lou Pinella for prospects the Marlins will be lampooned/laughed at/castigated by both local and national media to no end.

Until they win the World Series after the said move.

 

 

 

Is a World Series win next year your prediction following a managerial change?

I do think it is interesting that the portion of the media that favors Girardi the most is the national level that probably hasn't even watched a Marlins game.

 

All they see is the win-loss record and the payroll figure.

 

If the Marlins are foolish enough to try and trade Girardi to a club ala Lou Pinella for prospects the Marlins will be lampooned/laughed at/castigated by both local and national media to no end.

Until they win the World Series after the said move.

 

 

 

Is a World Series win next year your prediction following a managerial change?

Well, it has happened before (2003).

I do think it is interesting that the portion of the media that favors Girardi the most is the national level that probably hasn't even watched a Marlins game.

 

All they see is the win-loss record and the payroll figure.

 

If the Marlins are foolish enough to try and trade Girardi to a club ala Lou Pinella for prospects the Marlins will be lampooned/laughed at/castigated by both local and national media to no end.

Until they win the World Series after the said move.

 

 

 

Is a World Series win next year your prediction following a managerial change?

Well, it has happened before (2003).

And possibly this year. Hint hint.

you two know everything.

 

i hear they're taking applications at Gate G for next years manager opening

No thanks, I'm too busy, but if there's truly an opening, I'll shoot an email over to the Marlins about some qualified candidates. Qualified candidates who surely will mistakes every now and again and maybe even more than Girardi. And we'll have these same threads. Why? Because it's fun to talk about baseball strategy. It's productive to come together, share our thoughts and make sense of what we just saw (or didn't see).

I agree it's easy to cite a scapegoat. But I don't think anyone's doing that here. I don't see many people who have posted who have said or implied 'it's all Girardi's fault', and none that you have challenged and responded. In contrast, take a look at the bullpen thread in which some suggest the team (and its manager) are UNABLE to get quality outings from that bullpen. No one here has suggest Girardi is unable of doing anything. No, what we are discussing here is what was possible. What could have been done differently. And if it should, based on the information that WE have available. Holding such an opinion neither qualifies us or disqualifies Girardi for the job of major league manager any more than someone questioning whether we (the US) should have gone to war or not qualifies them to be President or Bush to be impeached. I think everyone realizes there's information asymmetry in place here. Everyone recognizes that the role of manager or President requires certain specialized abilities and/or training. What I don't think some understand is that if your role is so prestigious that you are constantly observed, criticism is inevitable. Both warranted and unwarranted.

I do think it is interesting that the portion of the media that favors Girardi the most is the national level that probably hasn't even watched a Marlins game.

 

All they see is the win-loss record and the payroll figure.

 

 

Actually a number of local sportswriters have praised Girardi for what he has done for this team and ripped Loria for how he has treated Girardi/kept silent on where he and Girardi stand. If Girardi is fired by the Marlins after this season, I fully expect Loria to be villified in both local and national media. If the Marlins are foolish enough to try and trade Girardi to a club ala Lou Pinella for prospects the Marlins will be lampooned/laughed at/castigated by both local and national media to no end.

Until they're leading the division by ten games at the All-Star break.

 

As for Loria being villified in the press I might remind you on the morning after the Marlins captured the wildcard in 2003, after eighteen months of enduring daily insults for sins real and imagined by a cruel and ugly South Florida media, the front page of the Miami Herald sports section showed a fan holding a sign that read "Loria=MVP" which the writer of the accompanying piece said meant "Loria=Most Vile Parasite".

 

I so hope McClatchy cleans house in Miami.

No thanks, I'm too busy, but if there's truly an opening, I'll shoot an email over to the Marlins about some qualified candidates. Qualified candidates who surely will mistakes every now and again and maybe even more than Girardi. And we'll have these same threads. Why? Because it's fun to talk about baseball strategy. It's productive to come together, share our thoughts and make sense of what we just saw (or didn't see).

I agree it's easy to cite a scapegoat. But I don't think anyone's doing that here. I don't see many people who have posted who have said or implied 'it's all Girardi's fault', and none that you have challenged and responded. In contrast, take a look at the bullpen thread in which some suggest the team (and its manager) are UNABLE to get quality outings from that bullpen. No one here has suggest Girardi is unable of doing anything. No, what we are discussing here is what was possible. What could have been done differently. And if it should, based on the information that WE have available. Holding such an opinion neither qualifies us or disqualifies Girardi for the job of major league manager any more than someone questioning whether we (the US) should have gone to war or not qualifies them to be President or Bush to be impeached. I think everyone realizes there's information asymmetry in place here. Everyone recognizes that the role of manager or President requires certain specialized abilities and/or training. What I don't think some understand is that if your role is so prestigious that you are constantly observed, criticism is inevitable. Both warranted and unwarranted.

 

 

I agree with the general sentiment about critcizing a manager, but I don't see how you can write that people do not scapegoat Girardi or imply losses are all Girardi's fault. That happens on a daily basis here.

 

While criticizing a manager is fine, it just takes on a different tenor this season with the Marlins. Players have credited the Girardi for the Marlins turnaround on numerous occasions and this rookie team seems to have completely bought into his system and believes in him (and he has repeatedly said he believes in them). Then you have a front office who has, since Loria almost fired Girardi in August, been embarassing Girardi in the press by spreading stories about supposed bad moves he made. To top it off you find that many of the same people on this board who seem to believe the Marlins front office can do no wrong are the same people who would like to see Girardi gone or wouldn't mind seeing him in another team's uniform.

 

In the end, I think the best solution is for Girardi and Loria to make their peace. That seems to be increasingly unlikely as the days pass and we still see stories fueled by unnamed sources in the Marlins FO popping up badmouthing Girardi. I don't know what the ramifications of firing Girardi after this season will be, but I suspect they will be bad on almost all fronts. How bad? Only time will tell.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.