Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Girardi Tonight

Featured Replies

The umpire in no way gave the game to the Mets. The ump was terrible, but he was terrible all around. Let's not fall into that trap. We did enough to blow this on our own.

The umpire in no way gave the game to the Mets. The ump was terrible, but he was terrible all around. Let's not fall into that trap. We did enough to blow this on our own.

 

 

Now I'm usually the last to complain about the umpire, but this was appalling tonight.

 

Both big Mets innings (8th and 9th) coincided with numerous one sided calls.

 

As I outlined earlier.

 

8th inning- LoDuca - certainly should have been ejected.

8th inning- Beltran - Tank should have had him struck out, but the 0-2 pitch became 1-2, which quickly went full.

 

9th inning- Delgado - Should have had called strike 3, perhaps twice.

9th inning- Wright- Absolutely, 100% should have been struck out.

 

That's 4 outs the Mets were given out of 6!! 66% of their allotted outs were GIVEN to them by the umpire. 66%!!!!!!!!!

Since people don't read big posts: THE UMPIRE CAUSED THE 8TH AND 9TH INNING RALLIES, NOT GIRARDI!

 

 

Stop trying to make sense. It isn't going to go over well on a bashing thread. But I do have an idea. Why don't we start a thread when we win on how he did a great job managing. Never see those kinds of comments from the bashers or the ones that always ask "What have you done for me lately??"

The bullpen blows a 4 run lead and someone starts a Girardi hate thread.

 

 

 

 

:lol :lol :lol :lol

 

:plain

 

 

 

 

Where's the bullpen hate thread?

 

EDIT: I found the bullpen hate thread. Its basically a Girardi hate thread with a different title. Thanks mostly to a certain individual who's sig appears to be in violation of this boards rules in reference to size.

The umpire in no way gave the game to the Mets. The ump was terrible, but he was terrible all around. Let's not fall into that trap. We did enough to blow this on our own.

 

That's kind of how I see it. There were bad calls on both sides. I believe that over a 162 game season the bad calls pretty much even themselves out so unless you're one of those fans that thinks the umps are out to get your team then there's no point in complaining about it.

 

I agree with the criticism about Helms bunting and Jacobs not PH for Olivo but some of the other stuff is ridiculous.

this is nothing new, as my sig shows

 

 

Please rename your sig. It should be "A list of criticisms made by a dumbass, ignorant fan."

 

Girardi knows alot more about baseball strategy than you do, my friend, and your criticsms prove your ignorance. You sound like someone who got kicked off his Little League team for running the wrong way around the bases, and hs learned nothing since. There are many things that went into each of Girardi's decisions, and you are totally unaware even of what SHOULD be considered, as well as ignorant of what the facts were in each situation.

 

For example, you apparently do not even know we have a pitching coach and bullpen coach. The manager makes pitching decisions based on what they tell him as to readiness of pitchers, stamina to be expected, whether they have their best stuff on a given night, what needs to be planned as far as upcoming games so the rotation and bullpen availability are in good shape, etc. You in your ignorant bliss are unaware that those issues even exist, and I am sure you don't know what information was given to Girardi on those issues. Until you at least understand the different reasons why a decision might be made, you just look like an idiot when you criticize.

 

Girardi played 15 years in the majors, has 3 World Series rings, and is universally respected in baseball for his managerial skills. He has taken a team with by far MLB's lowest payroll, with a bunch of rookies and journeyman minor leaguers, and skillfully molded them into a contender. So, until you learn enough about baseball to make intelligent comments on his strategic decisions, shut up so you quit looking llike a fool.

The umpire in no way gave the game to the Mets. The ump was terrible, but he was terrible all around. Let's not fall into that trap. We did enough to blow this on our own.

 

That's kind of how I see it. There were bad calls on both sides. I believe that over a 162 game season the bad calls pretty much even themselves out so unless you're one of those fans that thinks the umps are out to get your team then there's no point in complaining about it.

 

I agree with the criticism about Helms bunting and Jacobs not PH for Olivo but some of the other stuff is ridiculous.

 

I beg to differ. I am not a big fan of the bunt, but late in a game trailing by 1 at home is one time that just about every manager at every level will think bunt. I wouldn't have had Helms bunt, because he's been one of our better hitters, but in Girardi's defense, Helms was being followed by Ross, who has been on fire. Also, even your best hitters can fail, as Uggla and Cabrera did later by striking out to end the game with the tying run on base (albeit against Billy Wagner). So while it is legitimate to disagree with the bunt, it is not a managerial error to go the other way and use the bunt to put the tying run in scoring position for one of your hottest hitters. I am sure if Girardi listened to me, let Helms hit, and he grounded into a double play, the bashers would be blaming Girardi, since most of them don't know much baseball, and just like to gripe about anything that doesn't work.

 

The bottom line is that we lost because our best relievers didn't do their job against what arguably is the NL's best team.

The funny thing is, had Wes helms swung and grounded into a double play, the Girardi haters would then be wondering why he didn't bunt the runner into scoring position, becuase thats what everyone would have done, instead of wasting two outs.

 

And keep in mind, this is Girardi's first year, and he's going to make mistakes and decisions that make everyone wonder, "WTF?!?", and he is going to have to learn from them. Just like all of the rookies on this team have to learn from thiers.

 

I can remeber people already giving up on Girardi when we were 11-31. Since then were 62-41, 2 games out of the playoffs with 17 to go, and poeple are still calling for his head, because for some reason he's a horrible manager. COME ON!!!!

The bullpen blows a 4 run lead and someone starts a Girardi hate thread.

 

Last time I checked bullpens and benches are made up of people of various skill sets which can be utilized by the manager to win games.

The bullpen blows a 4 run lead and someone starts a Girardi hate thread.

 

 

 

 

:lol :lol :lol :lol

 

:plain

 

 

 

 

Where's the bullpen hate thread?

 

EDIT: I found the bullpen hate thread. Its basically a Girardi hate thread with a different title. Thanks mostly to a certain individual who's sig appears to be in violation of this boards rules in reference to size.

 

:rolleyes:

 

Get off your high horse.

 

 

 

 

Under your own admission you did not watch last nights game.

 

Watch the game first and then come back and roll your eyes.

 

 

 

The bullpen blows a 4 run lead and someone starts a Girardi hate thread.

 

Last time I checked bullpens and benches are made up of people of various skill sets which can be utilized by the manager to win games.

 

 

 

Correct!

 

 

"Various skill sets"!!!!!!!

 

 

And they are variously BELOW average.

 

 

:o

The bullpen blows a 4 run lead and someone starts a Girardi hate thread.

 

Last time I checked bullpens and benches are made up of people of various skill sets which can be utilized by the manager to win games.

 

 

Exactly what is the "skill set" of our bullpen? Blowing games?

 

What else can you expect with MLB's cheapest, and poorest, owner.

4) Minor quibble. Girardi was just trying to get the tieing run in.

 

I have a major problem with that. We should be concerned with winning, not tieing. There's no ties in baseball and teams who focus on tieing often lose.

4) Minor quibble. Girardi was just trying to get the tieing run in.

 

I have a major problem with that. We should be concerned with winning, not tieing. There's no ties in baseball and teams who focus on tieing often lose.

 

 

 

Basic Fundamental of Baseball Managing Rule #36

 

 

You play for the tie at home.

 

You play for the win on the road.

 

 

This is one of the basics boys.

The bullpen blows a 4 run lead and someone starts a Girardi hate thread.

 

Last time I checked bullpens and benches are made up of people of various skill sets which can be utilized by the manager to win games.

 

 

Exactly what is the "skill set" of our bullpen? Blowing games?

 

What else can you expect with MLB's cheapest, and poorest, owner.

These are major leaguers. Even semi-pro pitchers have some ability to get some kind of batter out in some kind of situation. Each pitcher has a different skill set. A collection of pitches he throws. A delivery he throws from. Some attempt to apply deception to the pitches he throws. The armhe throws with and the arm angle he uses. When used together they're known as strengths and weaknesses. It is the manager's job to recognize these and put his player's in situations which help the team. If a manager is unable to do that (not that I'm suggesting Girardi is, he seems more adept at reading pitchers than McKeon), he'll be unable to put any bullpen to good use. Whether it's a collection of a semi-pro pitchers, this staff or an All-Star team.

The bullpen blows a 4 run lead and someone starts a Girardi hate thread.

 

Last time I checked bullpens and benches are made up of people of various skill sets which can be utilized by the manager to win games.

 

 

Exactly what is the "skill set" of our bullpen? Blowing games?

 

What else can you expect with MLB's cheapest, and poorest, owner.

These are major leaguers. Even semi-pro pitchers have some ability to get some kind of batter out in some kind of situation. Each pitcher has a different skill set. A collection of pitches he throws. A delivery he throws from. Some attempt to apply deception to the pitches he throws. The armhe throws with and the arm angle he uses. When used together they're known as strengths and weaknesses. It is the manager's job to recognize these and put his player's in situations which help the team. If a manager is unable to do that (not that I'm suggesting Girardi is, he seems more adept at reading pitchers than McKeon), he'll be unable to put any bullpen to good use. Whether it's a collection of a semi-pro pitchers, this staff or an All-Star team.

 

 

 

 

Rferry if your not suggesting Girardi is unable to read his pitcher then what exactly is your point???

 

:blink:

4) Minor quibble. Girardi was just trying to get the tieing run in.

 

I have a major problem with that. We should be concerned with winning, not tieing. There's no ties in baseball and teams who focus on tieing often lose.

 

 

 

Basic Fundamental of Baseball Managing Rule #36

 

 

You play for the tie at home.

 

You play for the win on the road.

 

 

This is one of the basics boys.

I know that book. It's a set of rules and guidelines designed by coaches and managers to establish parameters of strategy that allow them to be spared from criticism. The thing is the strategies that win games often fall outside of those parameters.

 

 

 

 

 

The bullpen blows a 4 run lead and someone starts a Girardi hate thread.

 

Last time I checked bullpens and benches are made up of people of various skill sets which can be utilized by the manager to win games.

 

 

Exactly what is the "skill set" of our bullpen? Blowing games?

 

What else can you expect with MLB's cheapest, and poorest, owner.

These are major leaguers. Even semi-pro pitchers have some ability to get some kind of batter out in some kind of situation. Each pitcher has a different skill set. A collection of pitches he throws. A delivery he throws from. Some attempt to apply deception to the pitches he throws. The armhe throws with and the arm angle he uses. When used together they're known as strengths and weaknesses. It is the manager's job to recognize these and put his player's in situations which help the team. If a manager is unable to do that (not that I'm suggesting Girardi is, he seems more adept at reading pitchers than McKeon), he'll be unable to put any bullpen to good use. Whether it's a collection of a semi-pro pitchers, this staff or an All-Star team.

Rferry if your not suggesting Girardi is unable to read his pitcher then what exactly is your point???

:blink:

That he didn't last night, and/or that he doesn't have a great read on his pitchers.

Hypothetically, for everyone moaning about the Reed/Helms bunt.

 

What if, just what if, LoDuca has a past ball (we've seen those an ass-load of times, haven't we?) Reed scores almost standing up from third.

 

What if, just what if, we don't pinch run for Hammer and Helms swings away right into an easy DP?

 

What if, just what if, Olivo singled with Willingham on first and not Reed at second?

 

Girardi made the right moves, running yourself out of an inning or still playing with the DP in order is not smart baseball, nor is going for the jugular at home when all you need is 1 run to keep playing.

Hypothetically, for everyone moaning about the Reed/Helms bunt.

 

What if, just what if, LoDuca has a past ball (we've seen those an ass-load of times, haven't we?) Reed scores almost standing up from third.

 

What if, just what if, we don't pinch run for Hammer and Helms swings away right into an easy DP?

 

What if, just what if, Olivo singled with Willingham on first and not Reed at second?

 

Girardi made the right moves, running yourself out of an inning or still playing with the DP in order is not smart baseball, nor is going for the jugular at home when all you need is 1 run to keep playing.

 

 

 

 

 

Your being way to open minded and making way too much sense.

 

The haters only understand one thing:

 

The Marlins lost, it must be the managers fault.

 

It cant be the bullpens fault because our bullpen is made up of specialists who are molded to succeed (they have tons of experience you know) and the manager is not utilizing the mountains of talent that have been bestowed upon him.

Rferry if your not suggesting Girardi is unable to read his pitcher then what exactly is your point???

:blink:

 

That he didn't last night, and/or that he doesn't have a great read on his pitchers.

 

And you know that how, RFerry?

 

Did you talk to the bullpen coach and pitching coach, as well as the trainer? Do you think YOU can actually "read" the pitchers better than those guys?

 

ROFLMAO!

Passed balls are rare. Scoring off them even rarer. Let's say we do. Now the game is tied with what 2 out and Amezaga up, the game tied and our hottest hitter taken out of the game.

 

A double play is an extremely rare occurrence. I believe only 1.5 occur for every MLB game. Obviously such a play is terrible. A double play in that situation is a loss of .863 runs and 36.7% chance of scoring. However you can not play scared. You can't send your best situational hitter and better baserunners and tell them that you don't trust them. That you're afraid and to play it as safely as possible. To bunt to avoid a double play is the equivalent of being a shut in because you're afraid a car is going to run you over.

 

Olivo has hit much worse than Helms this year. And much worse than Helms and Ross recently. And not well at all against righthanders. To score from second, Reed would had to been running on contact (check, 2 outs and all) and a hit to the outfield gap and/or an outfielder with a weak arm. That's one big egg to putting in such a small basket.

 

 

Now let's imagine if Willngham had stayed on first and Helms hit. Just right there, that's roughly a 14.4% chance he'll score Willingham, 22.8% chance he'll become our second baserunner, 60.4% he'll make an out (and some of those would advance even the slow-footed Willingham), 2.4% chance he'll hit into a double play. Or let's imagine Reed steals second. He has roughly a 66.7% chance of doing that. What did we do instead? He utilized Helms and Reed to make a 99.9% certainty we advance ONE base of the 3 we need to tie and the 7 we need to win in exchange for one of our 3 outs.

 

Rferry if your not suggesting Girardi is unable to read his pitcher then what exactly is your point???

:blink:

 

That he didn't last night, and/or that he doesn't have a great read on his pitchers.

 

And you know that how, RFerry?

 

Did you talk to the bullpen coach and pitching coach, as well as the trainer? Do you think YOU can actually "read" the pitchers better than those guys?

 

ROFLMAO!

How many times have you said to yourself during a game that the pitcher was done? Or that he couldn't throw a certain pitch for a strike? That's how I base my opinions. What do you base your opinions on?

I think he did a few things that I wouldve done differently.

 

I think that Pinto shouldve gone the 8th and Jacobs shouldve pinch hit for Olivo.

 

Those are the only two things that I have a problem with BUT hes the manager so I trust his decisions.

Passed balls are rare. Scoring off them even rarer. Let's say we do. Now the game is tied with what 2 out and Amezaga up, the game tied and our hottest hitter taken out of the game.

 

A double play is an extremely rare occurrence. I believe only 1.5 occur for every MLB game. Obviously such a play is terrible. A double play in that situation is a loss of .863 runs and 36.7% chance of scoring. However you can not play scared. You can't send your best situational hitter and better baserunners and tell them that you don't trust them. That you're afraid and to play it as safely as possible. To bunt to avoid a double play is the equivalent of being a shut in because you're afraid a car is going to run you over.

 

Olivo has hit much worse than Helms this year. And much worse than Helms and Ross recently. And not well at all against righthanders. To score from second, Reed would had to been running on contact (check, 2 outs and all) and a hit to the outfield gap and/or an outfielder with a weak arm. That's one big egg to putting in such a small basket.

 

 

Now let's imagine if Willngham had stayed on first and Helms hit. Just right there, that's roughly a 14.4% chance he'll score Willingham, 22.8% chance he'll become our second baserunner, 60.4% he'll make an out (and some of those would advance even the slow-footed Willingham), 2.4% chance he'll hit into a double play. Or let's imagine Reed steals second. He has roughly a 66.7% chance of doing that. What did we do instead? He utilized Helms and Reed to make a 99.9% certainty we advance ONE base of the 3 we need to tie and the 7 we need to win in exchange for one of our 3 outs.

 

 

Rferry if your not suggesting Girardi is unable to read his pitcher then what exactly is your point???

:blink:

 

That he didn't last night, and/or that he doesn't have a great read on his pitchers.

 

And you know that how, RFerry?

 

Did you talk to the bullpen coach and pitching coach, as well as the trainer? Do you think YOU can actually "read" the pitchers better than those guys?

 

ROFLMAO!

How many times have you said to yourself during a game that the pitcher was done? Or that he couldn't throw a certain pitch for a strike? That's how I base my opinions. What do you base your opinions on?

 

I do the same thing, but you need to read more carefully. As I said, while I enjoy questioning moves as much as the next guy, I realize that the things I would like to know as a manager, that might cahnge my mind or make the decison obvious, are known to Girardi but not always known to us.

Did anyone here Sid Resenberg on the 790 today rip girardi, about last nights game, its not only most of us who think he did a piss poor job yesterday or on ther games, and dont start w/ the excuse of bunch of rookies and look at their record, but all these rookies are talented and some nasty. He also mentioned how him and boog talk about girardi so i cant wait to hear what boog has to say about it. even tommy hutton talked about it yesterday that jake shouldve been hitting for olivo, " you replaced jake vs heilman for aguila vs wagner" hmmm damn i think i'll take the first match up even though chris got a hit. yes the ump sucked also cause if jobo strikes out delgado or wright which he did then its a 1 run game and wagner has more pressure and who knows what couldve happened

 

 

Lets just win tonight But damn girardi plz dont f*** up this one, also plz start ross and jo and not amezega remember glavine is a lefty!!!

Passed balls are rare. Scoring off them even rarer. Let's say we do. Now the game is tied with what 2 out and Amezaga up, the game tied and our hottest hitter taken out of the game.

 

A double play is an extremely rare occurrence. I believe only 1.5 occur for every MLB game. Obviously such a play is terrible. A double play in that situation is a loss of .863 runs and 36.7% chance of scoring. However you can not play scared. You can't send your best situational hitter and better baserunners and tell them that you don't trust them. That you're afraid and to play it as safely as possible. To bunt to avoid a double play is the equivalent of being a shut in because you're afraid a car is going to run you over.

 

Olivo has hit much worse than Helms this year. And much worse than Helms and Ross recently. And not well at all against righthanders. To score from second, Reed would had to been running on contact (check, 2 outs and all) and a hit to the outfield gap and/or an outfielder with a weak arm. That's one big egg to putting in such a small basket.

 

 

Now let's imagine if Willngham had stayed on first and Helms hit. Just right there, that's roughly a 14.4% chance he'll score Willingham, 22.8% chance he'll become our second baserunner, 60.4% he'll make an out (and some of those would advance even the slow-footed Willingham), 2.4% chance he'll hit into a double play. Or let's imagine Reed steals second. He has roughly a 66.7% chance of doing that. What did we do instead? He utilized Helms and Reed to make a 99.9% certainty we advance ONE base of the 3 we need to tie and the 7 we need to win in exchange for one of our 3 outs.

 

Wrong, RFerry. Helms either hits a ground ball or strikes out about 70% of the time. Either,with or without the double play, that would have meant AT BEST man on 1st, one out, and a greatly reduced chance of scoring the run we needed. So much for your mangerial skills.

 

As I said before, the bunt virtually guarantees that with the almost inevitable outout (which was the most likely outcome by far) the runner would move into scoring position. Baseball 101. It was the right move, if you know the percentages and how to use them, and it was obvious, not really a matter for debate with your hottest hitter on deck. The subsequent hitters just failed to deliver with the runner in scoring positon.

 

By the way, Reed, the fastest player on the Marlins, would score easily from second on a single. They are taught to take the "2 out lead" and run on contact in that situation, with the responsibility to score on a single. Reed, of all players, would have done it easily.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.