Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Girardi's status is still tenuous

Featured Replies

"...in hopes of extracting compensation"???

 

More like "in anticipation of significant compensation". And if what the Cubs gave up for Pierre is any indication, Beinfest will have a field day.

Ahhh...sweet validation.

 

Yes, because someone else thinks so, you are validated. Congrats, you're hyper-sensitive.

some of you must be new yorkers because some have the attitude of "what have you done for me lately?". I see no reason why Girardi should be fired. His in-game management might not be HOF worthy, but he's still a rookie. When hanley was booting groundball after groundball, we we talking about firing him? no. they're both rookies. I give Joe a ton of credit for this season, he's done a fantastic job..what more do you want for the guy?

The Marlins have rookie players for a very specific reason.

 

Why have a rookie manager lead a rookie team?

 

are you saying that Girardi has had no impact on the sucess of the team?

(if you're referring to my post)

The Marlins have rookie players for a very specific reason.

 

Why have a rookie manager lead a rookie team?

 

are you saying that Girardi has had no impact on the sucess of the team?

(if you're referring to my post)

SOME impact in an intangible manner. However I think the team would have posted a better record with a different manager.

 

 

 

How many more wins?

I have to say I hate the in game management decisions by Girardi.

 

With that said, I sit back and look at the teams record and I have to give Girardi a ton of credit. He needs to be back next year.

 

I will continue to say this team has overachieved, and I think Girardi has a significant role in that.

 

we came back from a huge 20-game hole, and weren't losing in April due to Girardi. We saw how these rookies imploded on the field and the growing pains early in the season.

 

To have this team in contention is something we can't overlook.

Ahhh...sweet validation.

 

Yes, because someone else thinks so, you are validated. Congrats, you're hyper-sensitive.

yep...apparently the management, which is all I care about.

So a different manager would have only resulted in MORE wins and not possibly LESS wins?

I have to say I hate the in game management decisions by Girardi.

 

With that said, I sit back and look at the teams record and I have to give Girardi a ton of credit. He needs to be back next year.

 

I will continue to say this team has overachieved, and I think Girardi has a significant role in that.

 

we came back from a huge 20-game hole, and weren't losing in April due to Girardi. We saw how these rookies imploded on the field and the growing pains early in the season.

 

To have this team in contention is something we can't overlook.

 

Some of us didn't overlook the talent of the acquired players and just how soon they were able to contribute.

I guess Ive been wrong about Girardi all along.

 

 

 

This team would have dominated the NL East with a better manager. We would have had at least a 4 game lead in the NL East with this group of ballplayers.

 

 

Come to think of it, how could I not realize that our horrible record in one-run games is because we have an awful rookie manager who knows NOTHING about baseball (or at least much less than many posters on MB.com).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

:rolleyes:

I guess Ive been wrong about Girardi all along.

 

 

 

This team would have dominated the NL East with a better manager. We would have had at least a 4 game lead in the NL East with this group of ballplayers.

 

 

Come to think of it, how could I not realize that our horrible record in one-run games is because we have an awful rookie manager who knows NOTHING about baseball (or at least much less than many posters on MB.com).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

:rolleyes:

 

Ummmm, no one said that at all. Why do you always put words in peoples' mouths? This isn't the first time you are guilty of such.

 

No the Marlins would not be leading the NL East but with a superior manager the Marlins would be well above the .500 mark. Their current record is no indication of their talent level.

 

 

 

 

News flash:

 

 

This is a message board.

 

I can post whatever I want as long as its within this forum's rules.

 

 

 

Im not putting words in anyones mouth and Im certainly not "guilty" of anything.

 

 

You feel the need to bash the manager of my favorite team at every corner?

 

Then learn to deal with people who disagree with you.

 

 

:thumbup

Just stop making stuff up and we will all have a higher opinion of you. :thumbup

 

And yes, you have slandered me multiple times.

 

 

 

 

 

Pot

 

 

 

Kettle

 

 

 

 

Black

Girardi's game strategy also has been questioned internally at times. Management was unhappy that he didn't walk the Phillies' Ryan Howard on Friday during the at-bat in which he hit his second homer off Olsen. (Howard was intentionally walked twice Saturday.)

 

Ahhh...sweet validation.

 

 

 

:lol

 

Its funny that no one is quoted as saying that in the story.

 

Its just kind of stuck in the article with no origination or credibility.

 

more like imagined validation wouldnt you say?

So, you're assuming that because it isn't a quote that it is untrue that "[m]anagement was unhappy that [Girardi] didn't walk the Phillies' Ryan Howard on Friday during the at-bat in which he hit his second homer off of Olsen"?

 

Who did you want them to quote? Loria? Samson? Beinfest? Please...let me know, because I'm sure you would have NO skepticism for a quote from an "unnamed source from the FO."

 

See, here's the thing about writers.

 

If they quote an "unnamed source," it's probably made up, but maybe true.

 

If they don't use a quote and try to pass that information off as fact, it's just the writer trying to attach his opinion to the power of suggestion, which some infer to be truth from another source that just doesn't exist.

 

Being a sports writer myself, I would never imagine making up a quote.

 

But everything else is very, very true. That's how ridiculous player movement rumors get started in the off-season. One writer explains that "the Marlins may express interest in either Andruw Jones or Torii Hunter to solidify center field" and all the sudden eveyone starts thinking we're going to sign one of them, when in fact the front office never had any intentions of doing so.

Girardi's game strategy also has been questioned internally at times. Management was unhappy that he didn't walk the Phillies' Ryan Howard on Friday during the at-bat in which he hit his second homer off Olsen. (Howard was intentionally walked twice Saturday.)

 

Ahhh...sweet validation.

 

 

 

:lol

 

Its funny that no one is quoted as saying that in the story.

 

Its just kind of stuck in the article with no origination or credibility.

 

more like imagined validation wouldnt you say?

So, you're assuming that because it isn't a quote that it is untrue that "[m]anagement was unhappy that [Girardi] didn't walk the Phillies' Ryan Howard on Friday during the at-bat in which he hit his second homer off of Olsen"?

 

Who did you want them to quote? Loria? Samson? Beinfest? Please...let me know, because I'm sure you would have NO skepticism for a quote from an "unnamed source from the FO."

 

See, here's the thing about writers.

 

If they quote an "unnamed source," it's probably made up, but maybe true.

 

If they don't use a quote and try to pass that information off as fact, it's just the writer trying to attach his opinion to the power of suggestion, which some infer to be truth from another source that just doesn't exist.

 

Being a sports writer myself, I would never imagine making up a quote.

 

But everything else is very, very true. That's how ridiculous player movement rumors get started in the off-season. One writer explains that "the Marlins may express interest in either Andruw Jones or Torii Hunter to solidify center field" and all the sudden eveyone starts thinking we're going to sign one of them, when in fact the front office never had any intentions of doing so.

I can see how a sports writer can say "the Marlins may express interest" in a certain player...and the sports writer actually injected 100% of his own opinion and the FO actually has zero interest. The sports writer qualified the statement by the use of the word "may." But, I think it is a joke to simply assume that this particular writer's statement is 100% false because he didn't include a quote. That's all I'm going for here. I don't know if the statement is true or not. I understand TSwift and Co.'s general mistrust of sports journalists...particularly South FL sports journalists....but it doesn't make the statement FALSE (aka a LIE) that "management was unhappy" about a specific move Girardi made. Who was the writer supposed to quote in that instance? Who would have gone on the record from the organization that Girardi's move was not a good one? If anything...it would have been an unnamed source, and then TSwift and Co. would have still said "well, it's an unnamed source, so it is obviously a lie."

 

BTW, I'm not trying to dump on TSwift here...I'm just invoking his name because he is generally the most open on these boards about his mistrust of the media.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.