November 15, 200620 yr GMs want to explore instant replay Opinions differ on whether it's right for baseball By Barry M. Bloom / MLB.com NAPLES, Fla. -- Next up: Instant replay? Perhaps. For the first time on Wednesday, the general managers gathered here for their annual meetings asked the Major League Baseball committee that oversees umpires to explore the use of the technology as an aid to arbiters in the sport. Though no vote was taken on the issue, the GMs asked that the committee come back with some recommendations. "There's a consensus among all of us that we should at least explore the available technology," said one general manager, who asked to remain anonymous. "The more-senior guys felt strongest about this. It's not a rap on the umpires, they do a great job. This is just a viable aid to help them get important calls right." Not one GM voiced any opposition to at least analyzing the controversial subject. "There's an element of fairness in this day and age of technology," said Mike Port, MLB's vice president of umpiring, who made a presentation about his group to the GMs on Wednesday. "A lot of people in the ballpark have PDAs or television monitors, and so you have a situation where a lot of them might know what a correct call is before the people on the field who are charged with making it." Every major professional team sport, aside from baseball, already uses television replay to overturn or substantiate officials' calls, at least on a limited basis. Replay is most widely used in the National Football League, where a head coach can challenge a call at the risk of losing a timeout if the play is not overturned. In the National Basketball Association, replay is used on buzzer-beater shots and to determine whether a foul is committed before time expires in a quarter or game. And in the National Hockey League, it's the on-ice referee's discretion whether to call up to officials in an instant-replay booth to analyze the validity of a goal. At this point, there are no criteria for when and how replay might be implemented into Major League Baseball. The committee was just asked to explore all areas. "We have our own perspective on it," Port said. "Our opinions are probably varied. It's been a topic of discussion for as long as I can remember. Becoming an action item is something else, and I don't believe we're at that stage yet." One of the main stumbling blocks may be the opposition of Commissioner Bud Selig, who has often stated that he's against the use of instant replay, which he believes takes "the human element" out of a sport. "Yes, we've had some incidents that certainly need to be looked at," said Selig, at last year's GM Meetings, making a point he reiterated earlier this month. "So I'm not minimizing them. But do I believe in instant replay? No, I do not. Human error is part of our sport." The Commissioner, though, doesn't have the final say on the matter. The owners do. If the umpires committee ultimately generates a rule change that the GMs accept, the recommendation would be sent on to the rules committee, which, if it passed that body, would be given to the collective owners for consideration. Selig could lobby against it and the issue might never be called. But he could change his opinion if he finds there's a general spirit among the owners to add instant replay to the officiating rules. "It's a big item," acknowledged Joe Garagiola Jr., MLB's vice president of baseball operations and a former GM of the Arizona Diamondbacks. "You want to solicit the views of the GMs. The Commissioner's views are well known, but I know he respects the body here. So it's an important topic to continue to discuss." This year's flare-up on the subject grew out of a critical game on Sept. 26 in Washington, D.C., when Philadelphia's Chase Utley was denied a three-run homer after first-base umpire Rob Drake called his shot down the right-field line foul. Replays showed that the ball hit the outside of the foul pole and deflected off the top of a fence in foul territory. The Phillies, who lost the game, 4-3, were in the thick of the National League's Wild Card race at the time. They finished three games behind the Wild Card-winning Dodgers. Port, who was once general manager of the Angels and more recently an assistant GM in Boston, said instances with that kind of impact are few and far between. "We're admittedly waffling on the thing," Port said. "As a matter of personal philosophy I don't endorse it. On the other hand, are our umpires afraid of it? Given the confidence in their work, probably not. There's a segment that believes it will prove them right infinitely more often than it proves them wrong." Barry M. Bloom is a national reporter for MLB.com. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs. As for my opinion: NO!
November 16, 200620 yr I'm not sure about this topic, sometimes I say yes, sometimes no... At the moment, I'd say yes. They shouldn't do it too often though.
November 16, 200620 yr Like the article says, the Commish has no say in this, it's up to the owners, and you know what I think we are going to see this happen this year or even next. I am totally against it though, but hey, times change, things change.
November 16, 200620 yr Can you imagine umpires saying "after reviewing the play, the ruling on the field stands" or some crap like that?
November 16, 200620 yr Author Can you imagine umpires saying "after reviewing the play, the ruling on the field stands" or some crap like that? Yea I know... how stupid is that! After reviewing the play the runner is indeed safe.. The Marlins will not be charged with an out..... NO WAY to REPLAY!
November 16, 200620 yr I think Mike Port is absolutely right - when FOX has an opportunity to show a replay 10 or 12 times while the umpires are out on the field scratching their heads, why WOULDN'T you have a guy look up at the jumbotron and go, "hey - that ball went inside the foul pole not outside - home run." It's not a big deal to allow an ump to look at a tough call [how many tough calls are there in baseball - really?] and get the call right. I would have a replay official sitting with the official scorer. If the crew chief asks for help - git er done.
November 16, 200620 yr They should copy the instant replay system in cricket. For those who dont know, there is a judge in a seperate booth, and he judges the call. If the booth umpire agrees with the umpire on the field, a green light flashes, and if it goes against the field umpire's ruling, then they flash a red light.
November 16, 200620 yr The MLB's stab at trying to eliminate arguing and fighting from every sport. To me, arguing and fighting makes a sport more exciting. That's why the NHL is so great. Eliminating arguing with an umpire in baseball would take something away from a game that is already perfect. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. And the MLB certainly is not broken.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.