November 20, 200620 yr ...it would be entertaining to watch you manage a big league club... Put the best guy in your pen in with 2 on & 2 outs in the 7th. Then send out some bum in the 9th who gets hit at around .400.
November 21, 200619 yr ...it would be entertaining to watch you manage a big league club... Put the best guy in your pen in with 2 on & 2 outs in the 7th. Then send out some bum in the 9th who gets hit at around .400. You are not describing a league average relief pitcher. Jo Borowski and Antonio Alfonseca are average pitchers. Combined save percentage for the Marlins? 86%. I also don't believe in sacrificing bunting unless it's the pitcher. :thumbup I'll get my chance someday. Statistical bunt advantages: Man on 2nd, nobody out, not down more than one run. Man on 1st and second, nobody out, not down more than two runs. Hitter with under .650 OPS, no outs. Hitter with under .575 OPS, one out.
November 21, 200619 yr ...it would be entertaining to watch you manage a big league club... Put the best guy in your pen in with 2 on & 2 outs in the 7th. Then send out some bum in the 9th who gets hit at around .400. You are not describing a league average relief pitcher. Jo Borowski and Antonio Alfonseca are average pitchers. Combined save percentage for the Marlins? 86%. In regards to the guy giving up a 400 BA, that's Resop, who was a suggested closer. As for average pitchers, Borowski was less than spectacular, but looking at pitchers's stats in 06, the (roughly) median ERA (closest I can come to averaging without much time) was in the 4.70s compared to JoBo a full run lower. Even he was above average. But you'll find no argment that there are better closers out there. If you look at the top 20 in saves for 06 (actual closers), there are only 2 with ERAs over 4. 5 of them have ERAs under 2. These aren't average pitchers, and there is a reason why fewer games are lost in the ninth. Beyond that - I think we should aim for something better than 85%.
November 21, 200619 yr In regards to penguino's comments about being a middle relief man is harder than being a closer. To say that it is easier to be a closer than be a middle relief guy is just flat out funny. I dont care what studies show if you have ever played the sport you will know that the final 3 outs are by far the hardest three to get. Saying that makes you seem like you've never seen/played the game in your life which well Im not going to argue.
November 21, 200619 yr If you look at the top 20 in saves for 06 (actual closers), there are only 2 with ERAs over 4. 5 of them have ERAs under 2. These aren't average pitchers, and there is a reason why fewer games are lost in the ninth. Beyond that - I think we should aim for something better than 85%. ERA sucks as a stat. It relies upon a subjective judgement and ignores inherited runners. Using it as a standard, Resop is a good pitcher. :whistle Many managers also sacrifice offensive efficiency in the 9th due to an outdated bunting philosophy that has been statistically demonstrated to be faulty, and that alone lowers ERA. Closers do tend to be good pitchers, I merely contend that that is a waste of their talent, since the spread between average and great will be about 5% of saves converted, or about 2-3 a year. A portion of those are still won by the team. Leads are in far more peril with men on than with the bases empty. JoBo had a WHIP of 1.38, one might notice that that is almost exactly the league average. Joe is the very picture of average. I would love 100% save efficiency, but 85% is about what you can expect from a reliable bullpen pitcher. 90% is league-leader almost every year, which is what Antonio Alfonseca brought to the table for the Marlins, and if Antonio Alfonseca were any more average he'd be Joe Borowski with more fingers. In regards to penguino's comments about being a middle relief man is harder than being a closer. To say that it is easier to be a closer than be a middle relief guy is just flat out funny. I dont care what studies show if you have ever played the sport you will know that the final 3 outs are by far the hardest three to get. Saying that makes you seem like you've never seen/played the game in your life which well Im not going to argue. Getting out of an inning with 2 on and nobody out it harder than any 3 outs with the bases empty. I hardly think that Penguino advocates putting your closer in to start the 7th.
November 21, 200619 yr if you don't like ERA then pick another stat. The point is that closers are better than your average relief pitcher, even if they may, in select stats, appear average. Closers do tend to be good pitchers, I merely contend that that is a waste of their talent, since the spread between average and great will be about 5% of saves converted, or about 2-3 a year. There is no basis for such contention because average pitchers are not given opportunities to convert saves. Any stats that could possibly relate to it would be an unreasonably small sample size. Anyway, I'll say this again - while it may seem worse to you to have the scrub come in with 2 on in the bottom of the 7th and give up a grand slam, and now you're down 3 instead of up 1 - it would be worse to have them give up a 2-run HR in the bottom of the ninth to give the lead. Because at that point, there's no coming back.
November 21, 200619 yr Teams with crappy closers tend not to win. Teams with crappy middle relief tend not to win. Lesson? Deep bullpen with a strong head at the end.
November 21, 200619 yr ...it would be entertaining to watch you manage a big league club... Put the best guy in your pen in with 2 on & 2 outs in the 7th. Then send out some bum in the 9th who gets hit at around .400. Indeed. Why? Because that 9th inning bum wouldn't even give up a tight 1-run lead unless those hits were of the extra base variety. there is a reason why fewer games are lost in the ninth. It's because the offensive team has only three outs remaining and even the best batters make outs 60% of the time, or as you suggest, the worst pitchers give up hits 40% of the time. Thus even under the best circumstances, the offensive team is inclined to not to plate a run.
November 21, 200619 yr Teams with crappy closers tend not to win. Teams with crappy middle relief tend not to win. Lesson? Deep bullpen with a strong head at the end. Exactly. Especially in today's game with fewer innings per outing by pitchers, both starting and relieving, and explosive offenses.
November 21, 200619 yr Pitchers that can't handle the ninth inning consistently shouldn't be major league pitchers. By that standard there would be very few major league pitchers at all, a fraction (much much smaller than a half) of what there is. Who has the greater mental advantage when there are only three outs remaining in the game and a team is up by one-three runs? The pitcher whose team is leading? Or The hitters whose team is losing? Depends on the pitcher & hitter. I don't think a Chris Resop would have a mental advantage over a Carlos Delgado, a Pujols, Bonds, etc. Just the same, the Billy Wagners of the world will be at an advantage when facing an Alfredo Amezaga. And you don't want to cede any advantages with the game on the line. I could even argue that there's more pressure on the pitcher because he's protecting the work put in by the team to get the lead. If he screws up his job, he effectively loses it for the team, all by himself. If the hitter fails to score - well, they were losing anyway to begin with, and the closer is (or should be) a dominant and intimidating pitcher. But it's on the entire team, not just him.
November 21, 200619 yr Joe Borowski. Danny Graves. Braden Looper. Danys Baez. Derrick Turnbow. Bobby Jenks, Jason Isringhausen, Ryan Dempster, Tom Gordon
November 21, 200619 yr In regards to the argument using Papelbon... think about this as well... (I'm not sure if someone brought this up)... As a closer he only has to face one set of batters in the 9th... that means he has a 1/3 chance of facing the weakest part of the order... (7,8,9) a great advantage... not quite sure how much that supports the "closers are overrated side"... but this does... Anytime a pitcher has to face batters more than once, their ERAs will tend to be higher each time around... Long relievers tend to have higher ERAs because they might face the same hitters multiple innings on back to back nights... I think the best way to look at this is like this... in the first inning of a game... the pitcher's aim is to set a dominating tone, meaning he is going to treat the first inning like the last... And hitters want to jump out to an early lead, meaning they are going to try to "jump" on the pitcher quickly... Much like in the 9th inning, hitters can't sit back and wait like they could in the 5th or 6th... Compare a league average pitcher's first inning ERA to a closer's ERA, they will be suprisingly similar...
November 21, 200619 yr The question I posed can be answered without any qualification (obviously certain variables can be at stake, but the fact you are making it more complicated than it needs to be shows that you are dodging it). I can throw out variables too if you want...what if it's the 7-8-9 hitters batting? In general terms, the team with the lead will always have the mental advantage. And no, there would not be less pitchers, if below average pitchers such as Graves, Turnbow, and Baez can so easily thrive in the ninth inning role. Below average pitchers are placed in the closers role all the time, ostensibly thrive there, so their stock goes up. It is highly ironic that when pitchers such as Baez are removed from their roles, their performance drops. Yes, if it's 7-8-9, its advantage pitcher. But I wouldn't be willing to send out my best RP in the 7th on the projection that 7-8-9 will be up for the 9th. Because all it takes is one hit, and you're back at the top of the order. And call those guys below average if you like (although I must say I'm interested in how you are qualifying who/what is average.), but there are tons of much much worse pitchers out there eating up innings in the major leagues. Guys who would never be able to cut it as closers. And if those guys were thrown out of baseball tomorrow no one would be able to fill their bullpen.
November 21, 200619 yr Yes, if it's 7-8-9, its advantage pitcher. But I wouldn't be willing to send out my best RP in the 7th on the projection that 7-8-9 will be up for the 9th. Because all it takes is one hit, and you're back at the top of the order. Maybe it hasn't been stated clearly enough. You do not send out your best bullpen guy to start the 6th, or the 7th, or the 8th, or the 9th. You send him out with men on base to get the club out of a jam.
November 21, 200619 yr He was referring to the 7th, 8th, and 9th hitters in the order... Not the point I was answeringm instead: But I wouldn't be willing to send out my best RP in the 7th
November 21, 200619 yr Question for all of you: Who has the greater mental advantage when there are only three outs remaining in the game and a team is up by one-three runs? The pitcher whose team is leading? Or The hitters whose team is losing? No one can possibly offer a definitive answer to this. It depends on the pitcher and the situation. As crazy as it sounds and flies in the face of reason, a pitcher could be sh*tting his pants facing Reggie Abercrombie and one strike away from securing a 5-run victory. Who says that pitcher can't have an irrational fear? But I wouldn't be willing to send out my best RP in the 7th on the projection that 7-8-9 will be up for the 9th. Because all it takes is one hit, and you're back at the top of the order. Neither would I. I'd use my best guy in a tight spot in the 7th if I didn't expect to need him for an equal or greater challenge later. The pitcher's batting spot or my other available pitchers would also have to be considered. And, no, I don't consider a 2+-lead in the 9th a challenge equal to that of the tying run on base in a earlier inning. I think the most telling sign of a closer's true ability may come from a party that is often handcuffed to the role. I recall reading a report that many managers were handing over closer positions to groundball pitchers. The thought was not that the player could handle it better or he was the best reliever, but because among other flyball candidates he was the least likely to give up a big costly HR or double. Danny Graves would be exhibit A of course.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.