November 18, 200620 yr I think people really underrate JJ on this site. I love his stuff, and think he has the potential to be a very good #1-#2 starter. Like someone mentioned, when you are 6'7'' and throwing 94 MPH 4 seamers with very good control plus a good changeup, you are a pretty valuable commodity. I'd rank the pitchers like this: 1. Willis 2. JJ 3. Scott Olsen 4. Anibel 5. Nolasco Now saying that about JJ: I would trade him for a young CF in the mold of Baldelli,Crawford, or Milledge. I'm in the camp that believes we need to do whatever it takes to get a real CF in Joe Robbie stadium, even if it means trading away one of our most talented pitchers. JJ's two-seamer/sinker is his money pitch, but it is always good to be able to reach back and throw that 94-96 mph four-seamer when the situation calls for it. As far as his changeup goes, that still needs more work and I wouldn't classify it as good yet. Last season he threw some good ones, but more often when he threw it the changeup was decent to average. Hopefully that shows some improvement in 2007. As far as trading JJ, Willis, Olsen or Anibal for a centerfielder ? this is not the offseason to do it. Maybe next year when we have someone who could credibly replace any of those four in the rotation, but not now. Milledge or Baldelli will not bring home more wins than any of those four in 2007 and Crawford would be too expensive. Plus I'd like to see what those four can do pitching together for a full season before the Marlins start dismantling the rotation. exactly...im not really opposed to having a stop gap again if we can continue to evaluate our own pitching before we potentially give away a future cy young award winner
November 18, 200620 yr As far as trading JJ, Willis, Olsen or Anibal for a centerfielder ? this is not the offseason to do it. Maybe next year when we have someone who could credibly replace any of those four in the rotation, but not now. Milledge or Baldelli will not bring home more wins than any of those four in 2007 and Crawford would be too expensive. Plus I'd like to see what those four can do pitching together for a full season before the Marlins start dismantling the rotation. Very arguable because you cannot just compare them 1-1. This deal would fix CF longterm, and not drastically effect our SP over the next 3-5 seasons because of the severe depth we have. Depending on who they trade for a CF (if at all), this would drastically effect which players we would target in free agency with the remaining $3-4 we would have to spend the fill the last 3-4 roster spots. Personally, I trade Johnson for Rocco, I trade Mike Jacobs to Pittsburgh for one of their RP, I sign a 1B/3B bench player, I sign anyone to upgrade Matt Traenor, I sign Dustin Hermanson to an incentive-laden deal to close, I look for a young bench outfielder that can play all three spots and is capable in both speed and defense (see 03's boy Willits, etc), and then invite anyone with a pulse to spring training for the bullpen. I go into next year with my $25 million budget and this team as my base lineup: Hermida Hanley Cabrera Hammer Rocco Uggla Ross/Borch (I can make a strong LHP/RHP platoon split for LF batting 7th here) Olivo Amezaga Ross/Borch Speed/Def 5th OF (Willits types, etc) 1B/3B type Upgraded Backup Catcher (which is basically anyone) Willis Anibal Olsen Nolasco J.Garca (Petit/Mitre next in line) Hermanson Pittsburgh RP (Gonzalez or Capps) Tank Pinto Mitre Pick 2 - Resop/Messenger/Vargas/Fields/Spring Training Invites Is this team better or worse on paper then keeping everyone, stop gapping CF with something for 07, and keeping Johnson and Jacobs? I can see arguments where it's smart to sign Kenny Lofton to a 1 year deal, but in the end, this is just what my ideal offseason would look like and it proves the general point - we can field an increasingly competitive team without one of the "big 4" starting pitchers, if we get a player of equal caliber back for them.
November 18, 200620 yr Lou Mike Jacobs is not going to bring in either Mike Gonzalez/Matt Capps by himself. It will likely take Jacobs, J. Garcia/Petit, Doolittle/Nestor package to get Gonzalez and a Jacobs, Petit/Garcia package for Capps
November 19, 200620 yr Lou Mike Jacobs is not going to bring in either Mike Gonzalez/Matt Capps by himself. It will likely take Jacobs, J. Garcia/Petit, Doolittle/Nestor package to get Gonzalez and a Jacobs, Petit/Garcia package for Capps 3 players for a RP. ha. At absolute most, it would be Jacobs and Doolittle for Gonzalez (whose most likely to go).
November 19, 200620 yr Very arguable because you cannot just compare them 1-1. This deal would fix CF longterm, and not drastically effect our SP over the next 3-5 seasons because of the severe depth we have. We have great pitching depth when looking at 2008 onward, but not so much when you look at 2007. We should wait one or two more seasons to see whether or not JJ is the real deal (and whether or not Anibal and Olsen are also to lesser degrees). And even beyond that, the Marlins will have a better idea whether or not they will sign Dontrelle to a contract extension beyond his arbitration years. If not, they deal him for the CF we need (plus maybe our future catcher) and sign FA CFs like Lofton, Roberts or Payton for the interim period and in the meantime shore up our bullpen with lesser trades/FA signings.
November 19, 200620 yr After milledge didnt show promise in 06, the ny media thinks that the Minaya who is somewhere near the level of jesus christ, can con a lesser team like the marlins into taking milledge of their hands for one of our stud pitchers. Milledge's value is as low as its been the last few years, b/c he hasnt lived up to the hype as of yet in limited playing time.
November 19, 200620 yr I really don't see Milledge's value that much lower. The only change I see is that the Mets may deal him now, which they shouldnt.
November 19, 200620 yr I really don't see Milledge's value that much lower. The only change I see is that the Mets may deal him now, which they shouldnt. If the Mets go ahead and sign Moises Alou they've have something like five or six guys over 34. As much as Milledge probably thinks he "deserves" to be in the bigs, the Mets control his destiny and ought to just park him at AAA until he forces the situation by playing his way onto their ML active roster. A years or so from now, unless they believe they've seen the best he'll ever have to offer, they'll be able to put him to good use.
November 19, 200620 yr Lou Mike Jacobs is not going to bring in either Mike Gonzalez/Matt Capps by himself. It will likely take Jacobs, J. Garcia/Petit, Doolittle/Nestor package to get Gonzalez and a Jacobs, Petit/Garcia package for Capps 3 players for a RP. ha. At absolute most, it would be Jacobs and Doolittle for Gonzalez (whose most likely to go). el penguino Posted Today, 08:20 PM Yeah, you're crazy to think the Marlins would have to give up all of that talent just for Mike Gonzalez. Seriously tell me why would the Pirates (small market/low payroll) ball club trade Mike Gonzalez(their closer, who is cheap) for just Jacobs and lets say Doolittle when in this free agent market a Jamie Walker gets 12-13 for 3 years of his service. By the way Gonzalez career stats http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/G/Mike-Gonzalez.shtml
November 19, 200620 yr Yeah, you're crazy to think the Marlins would have to give up all of that talent just for Mike Gonzalez. While I do agree that that's too much to give up for Gonzalez, that dude has the capability to be one hell of a closer. He would surely solve that question mark.
November 19, 200620 yr Yeah, you're crazy to think the Marlins would have to give up all of that talent just for Mike Gonzalez. Mike Gonzalez is way better then Bill Bray and Gary Majewski. Seriously tell me why would the Pirates (small market/low payroll) ball club trade Mike Gonzalez(their closer, who is cheap) for just Jacobs and lets say Doolittle when in this free agent market a Jamie Walker gets 12-13 for 3 years of his service. By the way Gonzalez career stats http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/G/Mike-Gonzalez.shtml Because the Pirates # 1 priority is a power hitting left handed 1B bat and I've seen that absolutely everywhere for months. Maybe it's not 1-1, or 1-1 + nominal prospect, but if the Marlins figure out their CF issue and are confident with their 3-4-5 outfielders in a consistent LF platoon, these two teams match up very well in a Jacobs for RP swap.
November 19, 200620 yr We have great pitching depth when looking at 2008 onward, but not so much when you look at 2007. We should wait one or two more seasons to see whether or not JJ is the real deal (and whether or not Anibal and Olsen are also to lesser degrees). And even beyond that, the Marlins will have a better idea whether or not they will sign Dontrelle to a contract extension beyond his arbitration years. If not, they deal him for the CF we need (plus maybe our future catcher) and sign FA CFs like Lofton, Roberts or Payton for the interim period and in the meantime shore up our bullpen with lesser trades/FA signings. And this team is building itself into a contender, don't expect a 15 win jump next season if they keep Johnson and plug CF with Lofton. Roberts is going to get a 3/$15+ type deal, and Payton is looking multi-year as well. Lofton is the only guy I see, besides lowballing Jose Cruz Jr. types and hope they transform back to prior numbers, that is a nice 1 year plug without trading. I really don't mind doing this, but my point is to not argue Mike Gonzalez for Jacobs as a core package or whatever. My point is, we can live without one of the big 4 starters, this includes Dontrelle, if they get some sort of MLB ready CF/RP that is just as or more valuable to the pitcher we trade. Likewise with Jacobs, we have literally no need for him and if he can bring us a piece we need in the bullpen, or CF, or even a young projectable catcher, that's a deal we have to entertain seriously. Rocco Baldelli is really good. He's one of the few centerfielders out there that's worth shaking up the staff.
November 19, 200620 yr We have great pitching depth when looking at 2008 onward, but not so much when you look at 2007. We should wait one or two more seasons to see whether or not JJ is the real deal (and whether or not Anibal and Olsen are also to lesser degrees). And even beyond that, the Marlins will have a better idea whether or not they will sign Dontrelle to a contract extension beyond his arbitration years. If not, they deal him for the CF we need (plus maybe our future catcher) and sign FA CFs like Lofton, Roberts or Payton for the interim period and in the meantime shore up our bullpen with lesser trades/FA signings. And this team is building itself into a contender, don't expect a 15 win jump next season if they keep Johnson and plug CF with Lofton. Roberts is going to get a 3/$15+ type deal, and Payton is looking multi-year as well. Lofton is the only guy I see, besides lowballing Jose Cruz Jr. types and hope they transform back to prior numbers, that is a nice 1 year plug without trading. I really don't mind doing this, but my point is to not argue Mike Gonzalez for Jacobs as a core package or whatever. My point is, we can live without one of the big 4 starters, this includes Dontrelle, if they get some sort of MLB ready CF/RP that is just as or more valuable to the pitcher we trade. Likewise with Jacobs, we have literally no need for him and if he can bring us a piece we need in the bullpen, or CF, or even a young projectable catcher, that's a deal we have to entertain seriously. Rocco Baldelli is really good. He's one of the few centerfielders out there that's worth shaking up the staff. I realize this team is building itself to be a contender. But I think JJ can be one of the leading contributors to this team when they make future playoff runs. With the CF FA situation, signing Roberts or Payton to a multiyear deal doesn't prevent the Marlins trading them once they've outlived their usefulness. Trading JJ, Olsen or Anibal this offseason makes sense only if you believe their trade value will go down from here on out. Personally, barring a major injury, I see all three increasing their value in 2007 with a full season in the Marlins starting rotation under their belt. No matter how much depth we have in the minors, I think it is a mistake to trade off 22-year-old SPs that showed as much promise as these three did during their rookie campaigns in 2006.
November 19, 200620 yr I don't believe in giving up that much for a ninth inning guy. If it were up to me, Chris Resop would be the Marlins closer next year. I agree on the not giving up much for a ninth inning guy but Resop at closer? I'd rather use Petit.
November 19, 200620 yr Call me crazy, but I'd rather part with Johnson than Olsen if it came down to one of the two somehow. Call me crazy, too. This is how I'd list the 5 top to bottom: Olsen Sanchez Willis Johnson NolascoSign me up for that club as well. However, I'd put a pretty large gap between JJ and Nolasco.
November 19, 200620 yr And no, I don't think the closer should be one of the most talented pitchers in the pen. Have you really thought this through? Do you want the pitcher most likely to give up a 2-run HR to the second batter he faces (after walking the first) throwing in the bottom of the ninth with a 1-run lead? The reason most games aren't lost (or won) in the ninth inning is because closers are better than most other relievers. The problem with putting less than your best in the ninth (especially when you're away) is that there is no (or very little) chance to come back if you give them the lead then. Resop as closer would be suicidal.
November 20, 200620 yr Josh Johnson is a bulldog who goes after hitters. I'd much rather trade Nolasco. Seems like Nolasco's value might not be very high but a Nolasco/Petit package could bring us a starting OFer.
November 20, 200620 yr Yes, I've thought it through. Just do a search and you will find my thoughts on this matter. It is not worth my time to rehash them for you right now. Just saying - there's a reason why 7th & 8th inning relievers aren't the most highly regarded of relief pitchers.
November 20, 200620 yr Yes, I've thought it through. Just do a search and you will find my thoughts on this matter. It is not worth my time to rehash them for you right now. Just saying - there's a reason why 7th & 8th inning relievers aren't the most highly regarded of relief pitchers. The chances of a league average pitcher blowing a 3 inning lead in the 9th inning is something like 3 percent.
November 20, 200620 yr And no, I don't think the closer should be one of the most talented pitchers in the pen. Have you really thought this through? Do you want the pitcher most likely to give up a 2-run HR to the second batter he faces (after walking the first) throwing in the bottom of the ninth with a 1-run lead? The reason most games aren't lost (or won) in the ninth inning is because closers are better than most other relievers. The problem with putting less than your best in the ninth (especially when you're away) is that there is no (or very little) chance to come back if you give them the lead then. Resop as closer would be suicidal. The modern bullpen is based upon many misconceptions, most of which are born from inferior stats. An average pitcher will hold a one run lead for one inning most of the time, and a 2 or 3 run inning an overwhelming majority of the time. The best bullpen pitcher should be the guy you go to when the current pitcher is in trouble, not some mythical goal based upon a flawed counting system (aka the "save"). Basically horde your best guys for the jams, and use some average schmuck to 'close.' Best part of the whole deal is that you can sell the 'closer' for far more than he is worth based upon the worthless save stat.
November 20, 200620 yr Ah, I get it. You guys know better than everyone who actually runs a baseball team. The chances of a league average pitcher blowing a 3 inning lead in the 9th inning is something like 3 percent. 3 inning lead in the ninth? Nevermind that - assuming you mean a 3-run lead, what you're saying makes no sense, because "league average" pitchers do not pitch during the ninth. Closers like Mariano Rivera, Trevor Hoffman, and John Papelbon, who are in general, significantly better than league average do. Actually calculate what qualifies as a "league average" relief pitcher and see how often they blow 1, 2, and 3-run leads. Cause I'm willing to bet it's a lot more often than 3%.
November 20, 200620 yr Just do a search. All of your points have been covered. It's impossible to cover the first point because "league average" doesn't describe anyone pitching in the ninth in a save situation. You can't apply any statistics about it because it doesn't happen. If you apply the stats for the "league average" in the ninth, you are talking about "league average" closers, who will be, by design, significantly better than "league average" relievers. You put Chris Resop in as closer in the bottom of the ninth w/ opposing batters hitting .400 off him, you can pretty well expect to lose every close game.
November 20, 200620 yr Yes, I've thought it through. Just do a search and you will find my thoughts on this matter. It is not worth my time to rehash them for you right now. Just saying - there's a reason why 7th & 8th inning relievers aren't the most highly regarded of relief pitchers. "Highly regarded"? By whom? Fans who find comfort in saves? Managers who stave off criticism by adoption to relief roles? General managers who are at the mercy of the wishes of both fans, managers and players and their agents (two other segments which benefit from relief roles and the save statistic)? The media who can establish stars out of these highly-visible players by accenting the difficulty of their jobs and supposedly unique character? Closers are highly regarded because they offer something to these people than other relievers can not. And I assure you it is not their pitching ability.
November 20, 200620 yr Ninth inning save situation is less demanding mentally and talent-wise than inheriting runners on base is. Do a search on that because you are fishing in the wrong place. Closers do on occassion inherit base runners in the ninth as well. Sometimes even in the 8th. It's not as though closers never have to deal with it. "Highly regarded"? By whom? Fans who find comfort in saves? Managers who stave off criticism by adoption to relief roles? General managers who are at the mercy of the wishes of both fans, managers and players and their agents (two other segments which benefit from relief roles and the save statistic)? The media who can establish stars out of these highly-visible players by accenting the difficulty of their jobs and supposedly unique character? Highly regarded by GMs and managers who want to win. Papelbon for example - we all can agree (I hope) that he pitched pretty good in 06. But were they going to save him for the 9th or bring him in for the 7th inning with 2 men on, and then leave the "league average" guy to blow the 2 run lead in the bottom of the ninth?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.