Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Talk About a Tool

Featured Replies

I think Cooperstown is wrong in accepting the ball with an asterisk on it

 

 

they wont accept it, it will be some other museum

Whatever. It's f***ing stupid, but whatever. It's his ball let him do what he wants.

I think Cooperstown is wrong in accepting the ball with an asterisk on it

 

 

they wont accept it, it will be some other museum

So that is why the president said:

 

"We're happy to get it. We're a nonprofit history museum, so this ball wouldn't be coming to Cooperstown without Marc Ecko buying it from the fan who caught it."

 

Agree with it or not, the ball going in with an asterik and being displayed as such shows the culture at the time of the event. The Hall knows this and that is why they want it.

I think Cooperstown is wrong in accepting the ball with an asterisk on it

 

 

they wont accept it, it will be some other museum

So that is why the president said:

 

"We're happy to get it. We're a nonprofit history museum, so this ball wouldn't be coming to Cooperstown without Marc Ecko buying it from the fan who caught it."

 

Agree with it or not, the ball going in with an asterik and being displayed as such shows the culture at the time of the event. The Hall knows this and that is why they want it.

 

from this perspective I have to agree with you

marc ecko really is a clown

he buys an important piece of baseball history for $750,000 with the intention of defacing it, and on top of it holds a fake vote to justify doing so

  • Author

I think Cooperstown is wrong in accepting the ball with an asterisk on it

 

 

they wont accept it, it will be some other museum

So that is why the president said:

 

"We're happy to get it. We're a nonprofit history museum, so this ball wouldn't be coming to Cooperstown without Marc Ecko buying it from the fan who caught it."

 

Agree with it or not, the ball going in with an asterik and being displayed as such shows the culture at the time of the event. The Hall knows this and that is why they want it.

 

So by that logic, no museum should own or possess an Andy Warhol, since the culture at the time of the event didn't overwhelmingly view him as art?

 

Or Picasso?

 

I think time should be allowed to be the judge.

It shows what people felt of the event at the time, which is why the Hall would want it.

 

It's history whether or not you agree with it.

 

I'm glad the Hall doesn't try to gloss over perception or views.

  • Author

It shows what people felt of the event at the time, which is why the Hall would want it.

 

It's history whether or not you agree with it.

 

I'm glad the Hall doesn't try to gloss over perception or views.

 

There's a difference between history, and defacing history.

 

The ball is history, the defacement is not.

Has zero to do with what I said or my original opinion on why the Hall still wants it but I'm glad you got to say what you wanted. :lol

 

FWIW, the 'defacing' of the ball is just as much of it's history now.

  • Author

Has zero to do with what I said or my original opinion on why the Hall still wants it but I'm glad you got to say what you wanted. :lol

 

It has everything to do with what you said. You said that It's history whether or not I agree with it. Your opinion was the Hall of Fame wants it because 'it' is history. The 'it' in question was the ball. And in turn, you said that the hall doesn't gloss anything over.

 

That is absolutely untrue. This is the ONLY defaced item in possession in Cooperstown. Everything else allowed time to be it's only judge, framed in the context of the time. There are no 'n****r' brandings on Jackie Robinson clothes, and surely if they were attempted to be donate, the hall would refuse them. If Baseball has been through many a tumultuous time, why didn't they allow branding of other donated items to accurately reflect the times?

...because the owner of those items didn't deface them?

 

...because there wasn't online voting that had a majority of those that voted wanting it to be defaced?

 

Why do they have racist letters sent to Aaron in the hall, even though in 2007 that isn't how a large group of Americans think or view Aaron. They are in there because they reflect that time.

  • Author

Why do they have racist letters sent to Aaron in the hall, even though in 2007 that isn't how a large group of Americans think or view Aaron.

 

Because that in and of itself is history. That is what he went through at the time. There was no "after market" alteration to the letters. Aaron, or whoever donated them, didn't pour the racial epithets in at a later date.

 

If you actively deface something, it's no longer history. It's you attempting to make yourself part of history. That's reprehensible.

  • Author

...because there wasn't online voting that had a majority of those that voted wanting it to be defaced?

 

So if everyone jumped off a bridge, you would too and find it allowable?

 

Or if there was a newspaper poll in 1947 that wanted Jackie Robinson lynched and Branch Rickey allowed it, that'd be fine?

Why do they have racist letters sent to Aaron in the hall, even though in 2007 that isn't how a large group of Americans think or view Aaron.

 

Because that in and of itself is history. That is what he went through at the time. There was no "after market" alteration to the letters. Aaron, or whoever donated them, didn't pour the racial epithets in at a later date.

 

If you actively deface something, it's no longer history. It's you attempting to make yourself part of history. That's reprehensible.

The ball also won't be altered when it reaches the Hall's hands. That is how they recieved it. Whatever happens to a piece of art, good or bad, or whether it is left like that or is restored is part of it's history no matter your personal feelings on it.

 

...because there wasn't online voting that had a majority of those that voted wanting it to be defaced?

 

So if everyone jumped off a bridge, you would too and find it allowable?

 

Or if there was a newspaper poll in 1947 that wanted Jackie Robinson lynched and Branch Rickey allowed it, that'd be fine?

Do you have any sense of reading comprehension?

 

I'm giving an example of why the Hall is accepting the ball, in it's 'defaced' state because it shows popular opinion and a sort of 'fall-out' from the event. That is why it is a piece that should be displayed in the hall.

 

Shocking you would bring up a black guy getting lynched out of nowhere though to prove a 'point'. :|

Shocking you would bring up a black guy getting lynched out of nowhere though to prove a 'point'. :|

 

 

:lol :lol :lol

It shows what people felt of the event at the time, which is why the Hall would want it.

 

It's history whether or not you agree with it.

 

I'm glad the Hall doesn't try to gloss over perception or views.

 

There's a difference between history, and defacing history.

 

The ball is history, the defacement is not.

 

LeBatard had the VP of the Baseball Hall of Fame on today and he basically said exactly what Fox said. Of course theyd rather have it without any defacement but the ball, no matter what, is history as it broke the all time HR record. He then said that the defacement of the ball shows the views on the subject at the time the record was set which gives further meaning to the ball. Also, the fact that over 10,000,000 people voted shows how important baseball is in our culture.

  • Author

Why do they have racist letters sent to Aaron in the hall, even though in 2007 that isn't how a large group of Americans think or view Aaron.

 

Because that in and of itself is history. That is what he went through at the time. There was no "after market" alteration to the letters. Aaron, or whoever donated them, didn't pour the racial epithets in at a later date.

 

If you actively deface something, it's no longer history. It's you attempting to make yourself part of history. That's reprehensible.

The ball also won't be altered when it reaches the Hall's hands. That is how they recieved it. Whatever happens to a piece of art, good or bad, or whether it is left like that or is restored is part of it's history no matter your personal feelings on it.

 

...because there wasn't online voting that had a majority of those that voted wanting it to be defaced?

 

So if everyone jumped off a bridge, you would too and find it allowable?

 

Or if there was a newspaper poll in 1947 that wanted Jackie Robinson lynched and Branch Rickey allowed it, that'd be fine?

Do you have any sense of reading comprehension?

 

I'm giving an example of why the Hall is accepting the ball, in it's 'defaced' state because it shows popular opinion and a sort of 'fall-out' from the event. That is why it is a piece that should be displayed in the hall.

 

Shocking you would bring up a black guy getting lynched out of nowhere though to prove a 'point'. :|

 

Congrats passion, I think we've hit an all time low. Let's pretend I'm racist to spin the essence of this discussion elsewhere and away from your rapidly crumbling foundation.

 

"Wait, that's not what I said..." "Wait, you lack reading comprehension..."

 

I mean this in a nice way, but that was one of the dumbest things I have ever read, ever. Let's just ignore that I'm defending Barry Bonds here. What's the color of his skin again? Moron.

 

Great, you know what I do agree with you 100% that whatever happens to anything before it reaches a museum is 100% out of the museum's control, but in the essence of "Baseball means so much to our community" the Hall of Fame had the tremendous ability to make a statement and actually stand up for the game it is meant to represent and protect. It allows history to judge the era and it allows visitors to formulate their own opinions upon visiting the displays. There is no blatant advertising, like this, at any display. Even the Pete Rose displays are notably void of any discussion of his action. If it had refused the ball on propagandistic grounds, it would have made a much stronger statement than the asterisk itself.

 

What more, if we continue with 'instantaneous enshrinement' we could very really jump into regrettable actions. In the '40's the fervor of the time would have distorted if not destroyed any and all of Jackie Robinson's legacies. Should we allow overblown fervor to pervert history for future generations? Clearly you think that is allowable, because actions of the time belong not only in the discussion, but as a very part of any and everything that could be preserved for posterity. I sincerely hope you realize how foolish this would be, because it could easily lead to the complete destruction of contemporary achievements that would be of otherwise benefit to the annals of history.

I actually accused you of absolutely nothing, I just thought that was a pretty ridiculous example to throw out there randomly as was your use of n****r earlier. Tons of other things you could have used, I just felt those were extreme. I was slightly joshing you too.

 

Also, I don't think anything in this petty argument had anything to do with being for or against Bonds, at least I don't see it that way.

wow 8 million votes... I wonder why nobody is mentioning the fact that you could of voted more than once. The whole voting process was a joke.

wow 8 million votes... I wonder why nobody is mentioning the fact that you could of voted more than once. The whole voting process was a joke.

 

Still a better voting process than Florida. :mischief

 

I know, it's a played out joke. W/e

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.